← Back to all transcripts

Why Energy Price Rises Punish the Poor & Reward the Rich

March 13, 2022
00:00:03

We have to do it about energy prices Sim 

00:00:05

it has to be about energy prices

00:00:08

We were gonna do a video about something else today but we have to do it on energy prices  

00:00:12

because massive things are happening that  are going to affect you and your family  

00:00:16

and you need to understand what's going on

00:00:22

in the last couple of months you'll probably be  aware there have been significant increases in  

00:00:26

energy and food prices in the last couple of weeks  with the escalating crisis in Ukraine there's been  

00:00:32

significant further increases in those prices  i woke up this morning and i saw the oil price  

00:00:37

had hit $140 a barrel for the first time in more  than 10 years the wheat price has increased 45%  

00:00:43

just this week and 65% this month you are not  seeing these prices in your bills or the shops  

00:00:49

yet but you are going to, what that means is on  top of the already significant increases in the  

00:00:54

cost of basic living - bills & food prices  are going to increase significantly more  

00:00:59

this is going to cost an ordinary family  like yours thousands of pounds a year  

00:01:04

in many cases this will be thousands of  pounds a year that that family doesn't have  

00:01:08

that means a large number of families in this  country will not be able to heat their homes to  

00:01:14

feed their kids to pay their mortgages to pay  their rent people are going to become homeless  

00:01:18

millions of people are going to be  in these kinds of situations here

00:01:23

we have to do something about it, the media  and economists are presenting this like  

00:01:29

it's an unavoidable consequence of what's  happening in Ukraine like nothing can be done  

00:01:35

here are some facts you need to know the average billionaire in this country increased 

00:01:40

their wealth by £630million during Covid  the first year of Covid saw the biggest ever  

00:01:48

increase in billionaire and millionaire wealth  ever in the history of this country 

00:01:52

billionaire & millionaire wealth increased by 22%  in just 1 year, ok, this is not a situation where  

00:01:59

everybody's suffering this is a situation where  you and your family are suffering but billionaires  

00:02:04

and millionaires have never ever made more money  in the history of this country okay so when people  

00:02:11

tell you there's nothing that can be done to  help your family pay the bills and heat your home  

00:02:19

i want you to realize make sure you're  aware and the people you know are aware  

00:02:23

there has never been more money in the bank  accounts of the rich and the super rich  

00:02:27

this is not a force of nature  this is a political choice  

00:02:32

okay now for the economics bit, who uses the  most energy? rich people have got bigger houses  

00:02:37

bigger cars and take more flights, in the extreme  cases, they've got luxury yachts and private jets  

00:02:43

they use the most energy, so when energy prices  go up, it should hurt them the most right? wrong!  

00:02:50

rich people might use 10 times as much energy as  you but they'll have 100 times as much income and  

00:02:55

500 times as much wealth so as a fraction of their  income and their wealth the amount they spend on  

00:03:00

energy and food is basically nothing if we look  at disposable income the situation is even more  

00:03:05

extreme right disposable income is your income  after you take away rent, food, mortgage, bills  

00:03:10

a lot of ordinary families have nothing left  that means they have nothing with which to pay  

00:03:15

this extra two-three thousand pounds a year listen  the rich are generally sitting on half a million pound  

00:03:20

a million pound disposable income if their  bills go up ten thousand pound it's not going to  

00:03:24

hurt them at all whereas for ordinary families  they're going to be left with nothing to eat  

00:03:29

when you hear energy prices going up i want you to  understand this is a tax on the poorest in society

00:03:34

poor and ordinary families are going to pay where as rich families are not even going to notice

00:03:39

this way of dealing with the crisis hurts ordinary families the worst

00:03:44

so how should we deal with this?

00:03:47

so how should wedeal with this? we need to use less energy most  families are using just about as much energy as  

00:03:51

they need to heat their homes and get themselves  to work and back whereas the super rich are often  

00:03:55

using way more energy than they need the sensible way to deal with this crisis would be  

00:03:59

to ask the rich and the super rich to reduce their  energy consumption but when prices go up that

00:04:05

doesn't affect the rich's behaviour at all they can  easily afford that it will be ordinary families  

00:04:10

forced to reduce their energy consumption by not heating their home

00:04:14

now economists have been saying for a long time that the best way to reduce energy consumption

00:04:18

is to put a tax on energy use, the problem with this is, as we're seeing in this crisis poor and ordinary

00:04:25

people spend a much higher % of their income &  disposable income on energy than richer people  

00:04:31

so if you tax energy use it pushes the price  of energy up like we're seeing now and that  

00:04:36

massively hurts poor and ordinary families  and does nothing for the rich and super rich  

00:04:41

so is there a better solution how about instead  of taxing people for using energy such that poorer  

00:04:47

people lose a big chunk of their disposable income  we start rewarding people who use less than the  

00:04:52

average amount of energy that would mean that the  majority of families who use less than the average  

00:04:57

would start receiving money every year for the  energy that they save this way the rich who use  

00:05:03

the most energy would be paying money to poor  and ordinary people instead of punishing poor  

00:05:08

and ordinary people for something they did nothing  to cause we can actually reward poor and ordinary  

00:05:13

people for using less energy, look this  isn't just an idea that I made up, this is an  

00:05:18

idea called the carbon dividend and it's been  around for a long time it's a very simple way  

00:05:23

of reducing energy consumption in such a way that  instead of punishing the poor you transfer wealth  

00:05:29

from the rich and the super rich who can afford  to pay it towards the poor and ordinary people  

00:05:34

who are often struggling just to survive it's  very simple you can reduce energy consumption  

00:05:39

on the back of the rich but we're choosing to do  it on the back of the poor why are we doing that?

00:05:47

you know i'm not sure to be honest i'm not  sure why we're not doing that and maybe  

00:05:54

Rishi Sunak who is worth an estimated 200  million pounds and whose father-in-law is  

00:05:59

a billionaire or one of his people can get in  touch with me and explain why we're choosing  

00:06:05

to load this crisis on the back of ordinary people  instead of taxing millionaires and billionaires  

00:06:10

but in the meantime i'm going to have to assume  that Rishi Sunak and the current government  

00:06:15

do not have your best interests at heart  so what is the government actually doing?  

00:06:20

they're gonna have to do something and they're  gonna throw a few schemes together to give a few  

00:06:25

families a couple of hundred pounds, bear in mind  you are losing thousands of pounds during this  

00:06:30

crisis and the super rich are making millions, are  they raising taxes on the super rich? well actually  

00:06:39

they're raising national insurance which  is a tax which specifically hits your wages  

00:06:44

and specifically excludes the incomes  of millionaires and billionaires  

00:06:49

listen what's happening here is serious it's  not funny it's going to hurt millions of poor  

00:06:56

and ordinary families yeah ordinary people  like you are going to suffer in this crisis  

00:07:01

while the rich and the super rich are  making millions even billions of pounds  

00:07:07

it doesn't have to be that way the money  is there we can support ordinary people  

00:07:12

but only if we choose to tax the rich and the  super rich but they're not going to give it to  

00:07:17

us easy we're only going to get that if we come together and push back

00:07:23

keep watching

00:07:33

housing could be so much more affordable wages  could be so much higher and we could have so  

00:07:37

many more options in how we live our lives, some  of them put a lot of money into paying economists  

00:07:42

and think tanks to tell you that inequality  is important for the economy - that is not true!