← Back to all transcripts

The Illusion of Improvement

January 14, 2024
Wealth Inequality Enough is Enough Tax Wealth Not Work Economics of Covid Rich get Richer Poor get Poorer Economics Explained Tax the Rich End Austerity Billionaire Poverty
00:00:00

I wanted to do

00:00:01

a video about a concept

00:00:02

which I’ve been calling the illusion of improvement.

00:00:10

This idea is about a kind of a philosophical question,

00:00:12

which is can it be possible

00:00:14

for every single individual in a society

00:00:17

to be getting richer over time,

00:00:19

and yet for society as a whole and for families as a whole

00:00:23

to be getting poorer over time?

00:00:25

And this is an important concept,

00:00:28

I think, because

00:00:30

in my opinion, definitely people in this country,

00:00:33

the UK and many Western countries

00:00:35

have been getting continually poorer

00:00:36

for at least the last 20 years or so.

00:00:39

And yet if you look at most individuals,

00:00:41

you will find that over time

00:00:43

they do tend to get richer over time.

00:00:44

And that is because in most careers

00:00:47

you get salary rises as you get older

00:00:50

and many people are able

00:00:52

to accumulate a little bit of cash and buy property,

00:00:55

which makes them richer over time.

00:00:56

So how is it possible that these two things

00:01:00

simultaneously are happening,

00:01:02

that individuals are getting richer

00:01:05

and yet society as a whole is getting poorer?

00:01:08

So I think the best way to explain

00:01:10

what's happening here is through a graph.

00:01:12

Now, we don't do many graphs or diagrams of this channel,

00:01:15

but I think this diagram here expands really nicely

00:01:18

what is happening.

00:01:19

So on this graph,

00:01:20

you've got time on the x axis

00:01:22

and you got living standards on the Y axis.

00:01:24

So what you have is four separate generations over time.

00:01:28

And if you look at these four generations, you can see

00:01:30

each generation over time is getting richer,

00:01:34

but their children

00:01:36

are also getting richer over time,

00:01:38

but from a lowest scoring point

00:01:39

and reaching a lower end point.

00:01:41

So each generation over time is getting poorer,

00:01:44

but each individual person is getting richer.

00:01:47

And I think this describes really well

00:01:49

what is happening now.

00:01:50

And the reason I wanted to talk about

00:01:52

this is because another thing

00:01:54

which I've been talking about on the channel

00:01:55

is we have seen in the last

00:01:58

15, 20 well, to be honest,

00:01:59

30 or 40 years a very aggressive increase

00:02:02

in house prices and other asset prices.

00:02:05

And I suspect we will see very aggressive

00:02:07

house prices in the next few years.

00:02:09

Now, what is interesting about this is this

00:02:13

this economic action, the increase of house

00:02:15

prices,

00:02:16

it really bankrupts families over time

00:02:18

because each generation finds it

00:02:19

harder and harder to buy a house.

00:02:21

They have to pay more rent.

00:02:22

They have to pay more interest

00:02:24

because they need bigger mortgages.

00:02:26

But if you look at individual people,

00:02:27

they will normally tell you when house prices rise,

00:02:30

it's good for me.

00:02:32

So we have an action which is impoverishing families.

00:02:34

And yet most individuals within those families

00:02:37

think this is good for me.

00:02:39

So I think it's really important

00:02:41

for people to understand this diagram, essentially.

00:02:44

What is important to understand

00:02:45

is if you want to understand how your family is doing,

00:02:49

how your community is doing, how your society is doing

00:02:52

financially, it's not enough to look at just yourself

00:02:57

and your path over time,

00:02:58

or even you and your kids and your path over time.

00:03:01

What you need to do is compare

00:03:02

your kids to you at their age

00:03:04

and your grandkids at their age.

00:03:06

So if we go back to the graph,

00:03:08

if you look at the living standards for young people,

00:03:11

so I'll put XXXX’s in the graph here,

00:03:12

which marks each generation when they were young,

00:03:15

And you can see that each generation

00:03:17

when they were young is getting poorer over time.

00:03:20

If we do the same thing for middle age again, middle aged

00:03:23

people are getting poorer over time.

00:03:24

The elderly again getting poorer over time,

00:03:27

despite the fact that each individual generation

00:03:29

is getting richer over time.

00:03:30

It's very important that you do this

00:03:33

if you want to understand

00:03:33

the future of your family and your communities,

00:03:36

you need to compare generations

00:03:38

when they were the same age.

00:03:40

So I think

00:03:41

once we understand

00:03:42

this, we can start to sort of

00:03:44

get rid of the division,

00:03:45

which is increasingly happening

00:03:46

between elderly and the young when it comes to voting.

00:03:49

I think elderly people see that

00:03:50

their lives are getting better over time.

00:03:53

They assume their kids lives will get better over time.

00:03:55

And they fail to realise that despite things like

00:03:59

increasing house prices which

00:04:00

benefit them but hurt their kids,

00:04:02

the long term trajectory,

00:04:04

the long term

00:04:05

trajectory for their family, for their kids,

00:04:07

for their community is increased poverty over time.

00:04:11

Now, that raises an interesting question,

00:04:14

which is well,

00:04:16

if all families, or the vast

00:04:17

majority of families are being poorer over time,

00:04:20

but society as a whole is not getting

00:04:22

poorer, GDP is not decreasing,

00:04:24

then where is all of that missing wealth going?

00:04:27

And to explain that, we're going to add

00:04:29

one other line on this graph here,

00:04:31

which is the living standards of the rich over time.

00:04:34

So as ordinary families are getting poorer,

00:04:36

they're losing their wealth,

00:04:37

the rich are getting richer at the fastest rate

00:04:39

ever in history and their living standards

00:04:41

are dramatically increasing.

00:04:43

So what we have

00:04:43

is quite an interesting situation,

00:04:45

which is from a class perspective, ordinary families

00:04:48

are basically being impoverished by the very rich,

00:04:50

but the rich are able to convince ordinary families

00:04:53

that they're getting better

00:04:54

by creating this illusion of improvement,

00:04:56

which is every single generation, year by year,

00:05:00

feels like they're getting richer and every family

00:05:02

generation by generation is being made poorer.

00:05:05

So that's it basically.

00:05:06

This is the illusion of improvement.

00:05:07

It's really important to understand this

00:05:09

because in the next 10, 20 years,

00:05:11

house prices are going to go through the roof,

00:05:13

and especially of older generations

00:05:15

who maybe own property

00:05:16

are going to feel that they're winning

00:05:18

and they're often going to fail to realise

00:05:20

that the consequence is their kids

00:05:21

and their grandkids are being made poorer.

00:05:24

If we can get enough people to recognise this,

00:05:26

then we can get together. We can say we don't accept this.

00:05:28

We don't accept the situation

00:05:30

where wealth flows from ordinary families

00:05:32

to the very rich, where living standards

00:05:34

continue to decrease over time.

00:05:36

If we don't realise this,

00:05:37

then it will happen and we will fall into a situation

00:05:40

where the vast majority of families

00:05:42

fall into poverty over time.

00:05:44

We can reverse it.

00:05:45

The only way to do that

00:05:46

is by making rich people pay their fair share

00:05:48

instead of taxing

00:05:49

everybody who's working hard for their money.

00:05:51

We're going to keep pushing for it. We hope you support us.

00:05:54

Watch this video again.

00:05:55

Share it with your friends, Share it with your family.

00:05:57

Send it to your mum, send it to your nan.

00:05:59

Let's fight back.

00:06:00

Let's not accept poverty for ordinary people. Thank you.