← Back to all transcripts

The first politician on Gary's Economics

September 28, 2025
Wealth Inequality Enough is Enough Tax Wealth Not Work Economics of Covid Rich get Richer Poor get Poorer Economics Explained Tax the Rich End Austerity Billionaire Poverty
00:00:00

Okay so this week

00:00:02

we are going to have our first interview

00:00:05

for this series

00:00:06

and our first ever interview with a politician

00:00:09

on Gary's Economics.

00:00:11

You might remember earlier in the year

00:00:13

I spoke about being approached by Labour

00:00:15

to have politicians on the channel and

00:00:17

we eventually chose not to do it for now

00:00:20

largely because

00:00:22

we need to play a little bit of a game with Labour

00:00:24

for sort of

00:00:25

using what we can to get some influence over them

00:00:27

but also really to be totally honest

00:00:29

one of the reasons we chose not to have politicians

00:00:31

was because I thought most politicians

00:00:35

when they go on TV

00:00:36

when they go on the radio are incredibly boring

00:00:38

they just say their own sort of pat lines

00:00:40

you can tell that

00:00:41

they're just saying what they're supposed to say

00:00:43

and I thought it would be terrible

00:00:44

YouTube basically

00:00:47

but I got contacted by a politician

00:00:49

from another country recently

00:00:51

she reached out to me on Instagram and I was so busy

00:00:55

I forgot to reply and

00:00:57

then last week

00:00:58

I suddenly start getting loads of messages

00:00:59

through loads of channels

00:01:00

from this politician who was saying “listen

00:01:03

I'm an MP in New Zealand

00:01:05

I'm really supportive of wealth taxes

00:01:06

I love the work that you do and I'm here in London

00:01:09

so like please find the time to meet me”.

00:01:12

So I researched a little bit

00:01:13

and I saw that there was

00:01:15

this co leader of the New Zealand Greens

00:01:17

who's been massively supporting wealth

00:01:18

taxes for a long time

00:01:21

I went out and met with her last weekend and she seemed

00:01:24

if I can say honestly like somebody who was not boring

00:01:27

and could talk honestly

00:01:28

and was a little bit thoughtful

00:01:29

about what was happening.

00:01:31

We're here in this space now

00:01:32

where the channel’s growing a lot

00:01:33

and we're starting to figure out,

00:01:35

we'll try and figure out how to influence politicians

00:01:37

how to get involved in politics

00:01:38

how to actually make wealth taxes happen.

00:01:41

So I met with her last weekend and I said

00:01:43

you know what

00:01:43

you seem like a politician who can actually speak

00:01:46

is actually cool

00:01:47

you've flown thousands of miles to be here

00:01:50

we're shooting on Wednesday

00:01:51

why don't you come around and shoot

00:01:53

so this week

00:01:54

our first ever politician on the channel

00:01:56

is gonna be an interview with

00:01:57

Chlöe Swarbrick

00:01:59

co leader of the New Zealand Greens.

00:02:03

Alright so first of all

00:02:03

thank you for flying out here coming such a long way

00:02:06

thank you very much for coming on the channel

00:02:07

it's a pleasure to meet you

00:02:09

some of our viewers won't know who you are

00:02:11

would you be happy to introduce yourself a little bit?

00:02:13

Yeah for sure

00:02:15

My name is Chlöe Swarbrick

00:02:16

I've been involved in politics since I was 23 years old

00:02:19

I guess the long and short of it is that I raged

00:02:21

so hard against the machine

00:02:22

I somehow ended up inside of it.

00:02:24

I'm now 31 years old

00:02:27

and was elected in 2017 as a List MP

00:02:31

so we have something called mixed member proportional

00:02:34

so proportional representation in Aotearoa

00:02:36

New Zealand and then in 2020

00:02:38

I became the MP for Auckland Central

00:02:39

which is the centre of our largest city

00:02:43

which is a city of approximately one and a half,

00:02:44

two million people.

00:02:46

Okay so what made you...

00:02:48

when you first became an MP, is that the right term?

00:02:51

You were, how old were you? 23.

00:02:53

So what made you so

00:02:54

like, keen to get in at such a young age?

00:02:57

I was so angry man

00:02:59

What were you angry about?

00:02:59

hahaha so I had spent

00:03:03

four and a half years on this little radio station

00:03:05

called 95BFM

00:03:07

number one alternative radio station in Auckland

00:03:09

and I've been interviewing these politicians

00:03:11

and community leaders and researchers and academics

00:03:14

and I'd never really understood why

00:03:16

all of the people who had dedicated their lives

00:03:18

to solving these problems

00:03:19

were saying one thing

00:03:20

and the politicians were saying the other

00:03:22

and in 2016 the local body elections were coming up

00:03:24

and I was interviewing the

00:03:25

kind of top four candidates for the Auckland mayoralty

00:03:28

as prescribed by the mainstream media

00:03:30

and I'm a born and bred Aucklander

00:03:31

we've got a lot of problems as a city

00:03:33

but as far as I

00:03:34

was concerned they were our problems

00:03:36

and we had to kind of stay and fight and fix them

00:03:38

and we're experiencing the brain drain

00:03:40

at that time, a lot of my mates were leaving the country

00:03:43

for you know, greener pastures

00:03:44

for lower cost of living

00:03:45

for better job opportunities and god forbid

00:03:47

functional public transport and a decent nightlife

00:03:51

I was complaining about it to my good mate

00:03:53

and producer at the time and she was like

00:03:55

shut up Chloe

00:03:55

go and do something about it

00:03:56

so I googled how to become the mayor of Auckland

00:03:59

I found you had to be over the age of 18

00:04:00

had to pay 200 bucks for administrative fees

00:04:02

and had to have two people nominate you

00:04:04

so I was like, okay cool

00:04:05

I had absolutely no political experience

00:04:07

no idea what the hell I was doing

00:04:09

had never been involved in a political party

00:04:11

I put myself forwards

00:04:12

and just had this really basic thesis

00:04:15

or idea

00:04:15

I guess that god forbid we put ideas on the table and

00:04:21

you know regular people engage with those ideas

00:04:23

and we work together to try and make things better

00:04:26

and obviously I was so young at the time

00:04:28

a lot of people would go at me because of my age

00:04:30

and I'd kind of go, well

00:04:31

very clearly any politician that stands in front of you

00:04:34

and tells you that they know everything

00:04:35

regardless of their age is either lying

00:04:37

to you or completely lacking self awareness

00:04:39

and I'm not sure which of those is worse

00:04:41

so I'm never pretending to have all of the answers

00:04:44

but I'll be crystal clear about what I believe in

00:04:47

and wanna work with the experts

00:04:48

and the people who do know what the answers are

00:04:50

and let's just try and make something of that

00:04:52

you know?

00:04:53

So I wanna talk to you a little bit about politics

00:04:56

because

00:04:59

obviously this is a YouTube channel

00:05:01

primarily about economics and inequality

00:05:04

but in the last like one year

00:05:05

two years we've grown a lot

00:05:08

and it's reached the point where

00:05:10

I feel we need to start

00:05:12

basically trying to influence politics

00:05:15

we've got a new government that's been in for one year

00:05:18

which is Labour, our centre left

00:05:20

party who

00:05:21

you would imagine

00:05:22

should be doing something about inequality

00:05:23

should in theory be open to wealth taxes, but

00:05:26

they haven't really given us much.

00:05:27

So I wanna know a little bit about

00:05:31

your experience in politics and how

00:05:33

if you can sort of give us any advice

00:05:35

how we can influence politics and politicians

00:05:38

because we're at that sort of level

00:05:39

but before we talk about that

00:05:44

I wanna talk a little bit about

00:05:46

New Zealand and the economy in New Zealand

00:05:48

because it's a long way away

00:05:49

most of our, well actually it's quite international now

00:05:51

but most of our viewers are UK,

00:05:53

US, Europe

00:05:55

they might not know that much about New Zealand

00:05:56

you know, other than Lord of the Rings

00:05:59

this kind of stuff so

00:06:01

could you give us like, summarise

00:06:05

what you think are the most

00:06:06

important things we should know about the country

00:06:09

the economy, the economic situation

00:06:12

just a few ideas

00:06:13

how you think it might be similar to what it's like

00:06:15

here in the UK, Europe

00:06:16

the US, how it might be different.

00:06:17

Yeah for sure

00:06:18

so look

00:06:19

first thing I'll say is I love and adore my country

00:06:22

obviously I wouldn't do what I do if I didn't

00:06:24

and I think that we

00:06:26

like so many other countries

00:06:28

have an amazing pool of phenomenal people

00:06:32

who are incredibly hardworking

00:06:33

incredibly creative and incredibly talented

00:06:36

but the problem is, much like here

00:06:38

they are stymied

00:06:39

or blocked from reaching their full potential

00:06:41

because of the way that the economy is rigged

00:06:43

in favour of those at the top.

00:06:45

So to start unpacking that

00:06:47

we had some research

00:06:49

that was commissioned

00:06:49

actually by the former Labour government in 2023

00:06:53

from the Inland Revenue department

00:06:54

our tax department

00:06:56

and what that showed is that at that point in time

00:06:59

the wealthiest 311 households

00:07:02

had a combined wealth of approximately $85 billion

00:07:05

that was more than the bottom

00:07:06

two and a half million New Zealanders combined

00:07:08

bear in mind this is in a country

00:07:10

this is a country of five million people

00:07:13

so that kind of stratification of wealth right

00:07:16

was exposed not just to be kind of an accident or

00:07:20

you know something that just happened.

00:07:22

It is a direct consequence

00:07:23

of what that report also exposed

00:07:25

which is that we have a tax system that says

00:07:27

those at the top pay an effective tax rate

00:07:29

less than half of that of the average New Zealander

00:07:32

and that goes to the core of what

00:07:33

you're always talking about

00:07:34

which is that those who are at the top

00:07:37

are able to arrange their finances in such a way

00:07:39

cause they have access to accountants and lawyers

00:07:42

and otherwise where wealth just kind of begets wealth

00:07:44

and it accumulates

00:07:45

cause they're able to sit on that pile of treasure

00:07:47

whereas regular

00:07:48

working people are paying income tax as they go

00:07:51

so this is resulting very clearly

00:07:55

in a backsliding of the quality of life

00:07:58

and a massive increase in the cost of living

00:08:00

for regular hard working people

00:08:02

and I think that really contradicts

00:08:06

the egalitarian ideas that we have

00:08:08

not only of other people

00:08:09

projecting onto Aotearoa, New Zealand

00:08:11

but also that we even have of ourselves

00:08:13

right? And I think that

00:08:15

you know, another really important point is that

00:08:18

we are an outlier in the OECD

00:08:21

as the only country in the OECD

00:08:23

that doesn't have a form of wealth tax,

00:08:25

inheritance tax

00:08:26

or even a capital gains tax or stamp duty

00:08:28

None of any of those? None of those

00:08:30

and the political debate is so bloody constrained

00:08:34

it is so frustrating because

00:08:36

whenever we try to talk about fixing those scales right

00:08:40

there's this kind of appeal to like

00:08:43

in some ways

00:08:43

this imported notion of the American dream

00:08:46

or this bizarre reference back to how

00:08:49

you know

00:08:50

in our heads we're egalitarian

00:08:51

whereas very clearly an experience and evidence

00:08:53

we're not.

00:08:55

So you, I mean I think

00:08:56

a lot of British people probably do have that kind of

00:08:58

perception of New Zealand

00:08:59

which is that it's more equal

00:09:02

perhaps that living standards are in some ways better

00:09:05

We've got a lot of nature!

00:09:08

But it's interesting to hear then if you actually...

00:09:12

from what you just described

00:09:13

the tax system of New Zealand is even worse

00:09:16

from an equality perspective

00:09:17

than the tax system of the UK

00:09:18

and my sort of big idea

00:09:20

which I always push here on this channel

00:09:22

is if you don't tax rich people

00:09:25

what will happen is

00:09:26

they will accumulate a lot of money very quickly

00:09:29

and they'll use that to buy the assets

00:09:31

and what you'll start seeing is house prices going up

00:09:34

housing becoming less affordable

00:09:37

So I went on the radio yesterday to like a call in

00:09:41

taking calls

00:09:42

actually on Tom Swarbrick’s show

00:09:43

another Swarbrick, two Swarbrick’s in two days

00:09:45

We're not related as far as I'm aware

00:09:48

And Tom said to me

00:09:49

this is like a quite well known radio host here

00:09:52

he said housing is more affordable in other countries

00:09:54

and I said where and

00:09:55

he didn't say New Zealand

00:09:56

but he said Australia so

00:09:59

you're coming here telling me that the tax

00:10:01

situation in New Zealand is even worse,

00:10:05

what's the housing affordability situation?

00:10:07

It's cooked mate

00:10:08

so on some metrics

00:10:09

we'd have

00:10:10

some of the most unaffordable housing in the world

00:10:12

and part of the reason that right now

00:10:15

house prices are stabilising

00:10:16

despite the current government's best efforts

00:10:18

with giving tax breaks out to landlords

00:10:21

and changing the bright line test by which

00:10:23

you know people end up paying taxes

00:10:26

we are now seeing a stabilising or a slight reduction

00:10:31

but that's despite the government's best efforts

00:10:33

so we've got quite a conservative government

00:10:34

at the moment

00:10:35

some economists have characterised our economy as

00:10:38

more of a housing market with bits tacked on the side

00:10:41

and I think that this kind of is

00:10:42

part and parcel of what we were talking about before

00:10:44

with how this kind of inequality compounds right

00:10:47

people are working so damn hard

00:10:50

so many regular people are working so damn hard

00:10:53

as house prices have escalated before their very eyes

00:10:55

over the last you know

00:10:56

few decades and now

00:10:59

regular people are having to rely on

00:11:00

what's colloquially known as the bank of mum and dad

00:11:03

in order to get into their first house

00:11:05

and that then kind of creates this cultural norm

00:11:08

where nobody wants to create a situation

00:11:11

where it seemed that housing would end up being taxed

00:11:14

so the problem continues to perpetuate

00:11:16

and we end up in this kind of parasitic feedback loop

00:11:19

which is squashing regular

00:11:21

hardworking people. This is really

00:11:23

I mean,

00:11:23

it it reminds me so much of what's happening here

00:11:26

which is you have this situation where

00:11:28

because the rich are not taxed

00:11:30

they're accumulating all this money

00:11:32

and that

00:11:33

all that pushes house prices up in an obvious way

00:11:35

because they can

00:11:36

you are competing with them to buy the houses

00:11:38

you know they don't need to buy them themselves

00:11:40

they can just lend the money for the mortgages

00:11:41

if you have these guys who are sitting on the side

00:11:44

and they're gonna buy anything that has a return of

00:11:46

you know

00:11:46

just over 5% you know

00:11:47

unless the house price is above here

00:11:49

they're gonna buy it

00:11:50

so you have to pay this enormous amount

00:11:52

but then what you

00:11:53

what you get is this kind of perverse reaction

00:11:55

which is

00:11:57

because people know then that unless you own wealth

00:12:01

you're like totally screwed

00:12:03

they then become resistant to the taxation of wealth

00:12:05

and my big challenge here

00:12:07

is to try to communicate to people

00:12:10

if you don't tax the wealth of the very rich

00:12:13

you are the one who's gonna be squeezed out

00:12:14

you're not gonna beat them in that game

00:12:16

one of the reasons why I was keen to have you on is because

00:12:20

here in this country we get a lot of people

00:12:22

leave this country to go to Australia

00:12:24

to go to New Zealand

00:12:26

in this pursuit of better living standards

00:12:30

maybe more equal society maybe more affordable housing

00:12:35

and at the same time as British people say that to me like

00:12:38

like I told you this

00:12:38

I got told this on the radio yesterday

00:12:40

we get people in the comments all the time, Australia

00:12:44

New Zealand, Canada

00:12:45

saying even places like Sweden

00:12:47

oh my God it's so much worse

00:12:48

oh my God

00:12:49

it's so much worse here. So

00:12:50

I was keen to have you on

00:12:52

to perhaps communicate to British people, Europeans

00:12:55

Americans who are watching

00:12:56

this is not a problem that you can run away from

00:12:59

because it is a global problem

00:13:00

it's a worldwide phenomenon

00:13:02

Yeah and again

00:13:03

it's gonna require probably

00:13:05

if we're going to do wealth taxation properly

00:13:08

global coordination. Yeah.

00:13:10

But again you know

00:13:11

as I think you frequently point to

00:13:14

it might be really hard to do

00:13:16

but it is the right thing to do

00:13:17

and it's the only thing, it's the

00:13:19

necessary thing for us to do

00:13:22

if we are to arrest this growing wealth inequality

00:13:24

and this is another thing that I think

00:13:25

it's really important for people to understand

00:13:28

is that poverty doesn't come from nowhere

00:13:31

it is directly caused by this tolerance of

00:13:33

that deep wealth inequality

00:13:35

and this is also where you know

00:13:37

for New Zealanders

00:13:38

and probably around the west of the world

00:13:39

to also understand that

00:13:41

instituting these wealth taxes

00:13:43

is not only about arresting that deeply

00:13:46

and quickly growing wealth inequality

00:13:48

but it's also about

00:13:50

bringing back into the collective pool

00:13:52

the resources necessary

00:13:54

to build the foundations of the society that all of us

00:13:57

bloody live in

00:13:58

which goes to the core of the myth of self made

00:14:01

This is the thing I always,

00:14:02

I don't know if I've emphasized it enough

00:14:04

you know this is not

00:14:05

this is not inequality for inequality’s sake

00:14:08

this is if you allow that inequality to rise

00:14:10

what that also means is you losing your assets!

00:14:14

If the 1% owns 100%

00:14:16

what that means is you own nothing and

00:14:18

and you are being squeezed out

00:14:19

and this is the thing

00:14:20

which I'm constantly trying to think about

00:14:21

how do we communicate

00:14:23

but yeah I was I was keen to have you on talk

00:14:24

to show a little bit that this is not

00:14:27

sometimes people have people ask me

00:14:30

you know how can we do it in the UK alone

00:14:32

and what I always say is, why do it in the UK alone?

00:14:35

If you look at the time when inequality was reduced

00:14:37

after World War 2 it was a big international effort

00:14:39

so I was keen to have you on to show

00:14:41

there are people fighting this fight in other countries

00:14:43

and to be clear we'll get on to this next

00:14:45

you have been supporting wealth taxes

00:14:47

you know I want to have Gabriel Zukman

00:14:48

and Thomas Piketty on, two

00:14:49

of the French economists who've been pushing it

00:14:52

I was over in Norway

00:14:52

talking to Norwegian political parties

00:14:54

there are people all over doing this

00:14:56

but that brings us to the next question

00:14:58

if there are so many people in so many countries

00:15:02

fighting for wealth taxes

00:15:04

and you know, now in the UK

00:15:06

we see the polling

00:15:07

it's overwhelmingly popular with the public

00:15:10

what is stopping us from getting these?

00:15:12

Because you know

00:15:12

you're a politician

00:15:13

you've been in there for a number of years

00:15:16

I'm sure you'll be seeing similar things

00:15:18

in your country

00:15:19

why is it that even centre left political parties

00:15:21

and you can speak

00:15:22

it's also called the Labour Party in New Zealand right?

00:15:24

You can speak for what they've been doing

00:15:27

where is that resistance from

00:15:29

even these traditional centre left coming from and

00:15:32

what do we do and how do we overcome it?

00:15:35

So I think there's a few different things at play

00:15:37

one is very much vested interests

00:15:40

so there are a lot of very wealthy people

00:15:43

who will do absolutely everything that they can

00:15:45

to fan the flames of fear

00:15:47

and to point to division and distraction

00:15:50

and to create division and distraction

00:15:52

amongst regular people so that

00:15:53

you know here

00:15:54

for example it's migrants and our country

00:15:57

I mean definitely

00:15:58

the two more radical right wing parties

00:16:01

are currently falling over themselves

00:16:02

to take credit for a New Zealand values test

00:16:04

that they want to impose on migrants

00:16:05

as well but all of that aside

00:16:08

these very wealthy people own largely

00:16:11

but also influence hugely our media landscape

00:16:14

then I think you know

00:16:15

part and parcel of the unfortunate consequences of this

00:16:19

inequality

00:16:20

is not only that regular people are poorer and poorer

00:16:22

but also that they have less and less time

00:16:25

to engage with the political arena

00:16:27

this has happened simultaneously too

00:16:29

over the last 40 years

00:16:30

very intentional shredding of collective action

00:16:33

of union movements you know

00:16:35

people are living more precarious lives

00:16:37

so the gig economy for example

00:16:39

means that you're less likely to know your coworker

00:16:41

You’re less likely to know your neighbour

00:16:42

because you're less likely to be able to stay in your house

00:16:44

for a long period of time

00:16:46

what that means is that when we see these problems

00:16:49

impacting our day to day lives

00:16:51

we see them as problems with us

00:16:52

not as systemic problems necessarily

00:16:54

so I think

00:16:55

it's also part and parcel of how people perceive

00:16:57

and understand the world. Then it's the media landscape

00:16:59

and the messages that we're getting

00:17:01

about what's actually possible

00:17:02

and feasible. People are intentionally

00:17:05

confused by, you know, again

00:17:07

all of these distractions and all of this division

00:17:10

and that then also bleeds into the vested interests

00:17:13

which influence our politics.

00:17:15

So yeah I think that it really boils down

00:17:19

to put, to flip that on its head

00:17:21

what the solution looks like

00:17:23

is people understanding that

00:17:25

you know, these solutions are not gonna come from vested

00:17:28

interests very clearly

00:17:29

and it's gonna require an understanding that

00:17:33

politics is not as complicated as it's made out

00:17:35

in the same way that

00:17:37

economics is not as complicated as it's made out

00:17:39

you know, I've been in politics now

00:17:40

for the better part of 10 years

00:17:41

politics very simply is just about power

00:17:45

it's about resources

00:17:46

and it's about who gets to make decisions

00:17:48

that saturate and shape our daily lives, right?

00:17:50

That is politics.

00:17:52

Things end up getting complicated

00:17:54

when we throw in all this partisanship

00:17:55

and these political parties

00:17:56

or whatever else

00:17:58

but I think some very clever people

00:18:00

likes of yourself have articulated

00:18:02

you know it is no longer this kind of simplistic

00:18:05

left or right wing thing

00:18:06

it very much is the 1% versus the 99%

00:18:10

and as you've also said before

00:18:12

you know

00:18:12

there's very wealthy people who are looking to protect

00:18:15

their lot or what they perceive is their lot

00:18:17

which I would actually argue

00:18:19

has come at the expense of everybody else

00:18:20

who's working and slogging their guts out.

00:18:24

They are going to

00:18:26

do everything to have regular people believe

00:18:28

that they are not worthy

00:18:30

or they do not deserve a fairer society

00:18:34

and I think this just kind of leads us to the conclusion

00:18:37

why the hell would you let the people

00:18:40

who are currently fleecing you

00:18:42

and laughing their way to the bank

00:18:44

tell you what is possible in politics

00:18:49

It’s cooked

00:18:51

Yeah, I have often used the term in the past

00:18:53

the fire engines are not coming.

00:18:55

What I mean when I say that is

00:18:59

people, definitely people in this country

00:19:00

especially more working class people

00:19:02

have kind of had it drilled into them like

00:19:04

you know, it's not your place to deal with that

00:19:06

like that's the job of the politicians

00:19:09

Yeah, and that also

00:19:11

is I think another big problem, is

00:19:13

you've probably heard the adage,

00:19:15

in relationships

00:19:16

that you get the love that you think that you deserve

00:19:18

so a lot of people

00:19:18

stay in a lot of really shitty relationships right?

00:19:21

I think the same goes

00:19:22

we get the politics that we think that we deserve

00:19:25

and after 40 odd years of politicians

00:19:28

promising one thing and then selling regular

00:19:30

hard working people down the river with

00:19:32

you know, everything that they actually do in reality

00:19:35

you know, this

00:19:37

the implications of that are that

00:19:40

people don't believe that politics

00:19:41

is capable of changing or transforming their lives

00:19:43

so you end up with this really negative feedback loop

00:19:46

whereby people don't get the outcomes that they want

00:19:49

from engaging in politics

00:19:50

so why would they engage?

00:19:52

That lack of engagement results in

00:19:54

a lack of representation on the things that they want

00:19:56

which then results in less action

00:19:58

less engagement

00:19:59

less representation and so on and so forth.

00:20:00

So I've got this kind of strategy right

00:20:03

which I've been calling the Murdoch strategy

00:20:05

which is

00:20:06

you know, what does Rupert Murdoch do?

00:20:08

You don't mind me speaking about Rupert Murdoch?

00:20:09

No go hard.

00:20:13

He has a lot of control over the media

00:20:16

but I think that's slipping a little bit

00:20:17

because of the move towards social media

00:20:21

For those who don't know

00:20:21

this is the guy that owns like tons of like news channels

00:20:24

radio stations, newspapers

00:20:27

controls what the public think

00:20:28

and then because of that he can kind of

00:20:31

decide whether a

00:20:32

political party wins or loses an election

00:20:33

and for that reason

00:20:34

the political parties kind of have to do what he says

00:20:37

right? And then I've seen this move towards social media

00:20:41

which I think has opened a lot of space

00:20:43

because a lot of the traditional

00:20:45

power players in politics

00:20:46

the political parties, the big media stations

00:20:48

including the ones owned by Rupert Murdoch have

00:20:51

not been quick enough to move into that space

00:20:53

and then that's meant that there's all of this kind of

00:20:55

power to take

00:20:57

in terms of influencing what the public believe

00:20:59

what the public understand on social media

00:21:02

and if we move in and take that

00:21:04

then we can educate the public and then

00:21:07

we can be trusted by the public

00:21:08

and then we can do what Murdoch has always done

00:21:10

which is go and have a meeting

00:21:12

with the political leaders

00:21:13

before the elections and say, ‘well

00:21:14

what are you gonna offer me?’ basically

00:21:17

But the stumbling block that I've come to

00:21:19

obviously

00:21:19

I'm not as big or as influential as Rupert Murdoch

00:21:21

but this channel is by the standards of like politics

00:21:25

social media it's massive now right?

00:21:27

And we have a Labour Party

00:21:29

which is polling terribly badly

00:21:32

they look like they're gonna lose

00:21:33

really badly in the next election

00:21:37

This channel is very popular

00:21:40

and very influential with the British public

00:21:43

and yet

00:21:43

this phenomenally unpopular Labour Party are extremely

00:21:48

stubbornly resistant to listening to us

00:21:52

so as somebody who's been within politics

00:21:54

and I guess I know

00:21:55

you've been supportive of wealth taxes for a long time

00:21:57

maybe you've had similar experiences yourself

00:22:00

have you got any advice for

00:22:01

like what can we do

00:22:03

what should we do? Should we change our strategy

00:22:06

in trying to influence Labour

00:22:07

should we forget about Labour

00:22:08

and just go straight for the public

00:22:10

have you got any advice about what we should do?

00:22:12

Oh mate

00:22:12

if I had advice to give you

00:22:14

we would have sorted out all our problems right?

00:22:16

But I think that this is

00:22:17

kind of exposing the fact that

00:22:19

I've been here now for a few

00:22:20

days and I've been meeting with some phenomenal people

00:22:23

likes of yourself and you know

00:22:24

some of your local politicians and economists and

00:22:27

you know I'm gonna meet with some more

00:22:29

the likes of Piketty and Zucman

00:22:31

and what I am learning

00:22:34

is that nobody has solved this problem

00:22:36

there is no clear answer

00:22:38

which leads me to the conclusion

00:22:41

that we have to get our bloody hands dirty

00:22:43

you know, I am part of so many conversations

00:22:46

with so many smart people

00:22:48

who paralyze themselves by falling over

00:22:50

needing to be right or having all of the perfect plans

00:22:53

before we just start moving on it

00:22:55

and I guess in the most simplistic way

00:22:58

there's kind of two broad spheres

00:23:00

that we can bring about change in

00:23:01

and they're very interconnected

00:23:03

the boundaries between them are really porous and open

00:23:05

and that's kind of

00:23:07

structure, so the structures of society are legislation

00:23:10

regulation, funding

00:23:11

taxation systems, the incentives, subsidies

00:23:14

trade agreements, treaties

00:23:16

procurement processes, contracts

00:23:17

etcetera. That's like the blueprint or the coat hooks

00:23:20

or the social contract

00:23:21

as it's written down in black and white

00:23:23

but that stuff gets its legitimacy from

00:23:25

and can be delegitimised by culture

00:23:28

and this is really important

00:23:29

cause culture here

00:23:30

I'm defining from a design thinking perspective

00:23:33

which is about a shared set of values

00:23:35

and when you understand our culture

00:23:37

as a shared set of values

00:23:39

you can come to understand

00:23:40

how we create this thing called society

00:23:42

which we all live in

00:23:43

with people from all of these different backgrounds

00:23:46

who come together to prioritize

00:23:48

whether it be implicitly not talking about it

00:23:51

or explicitly

00:23:52

intentionally working through that democratically

00:23:54

hopefully what those values actually are

00:23:57

so that's kind of the glue that binds society together

00:23:59

right? And if you think about the different leverage points

00:24:02

for changing culture, so therefore

00:24:04

creating the environment conducive to structural change

00:24:07

to changing politics, to changing our laws

00:24:09

to changing our tax system

00:24:11

it's things like media

00:24:12

which as you've just talked about

00:24:14

is being massively influenced

00:24:16

or undercut now by the social media landscape

00:24:19

it's things like education

00:24:21

which is really important

00:24:22

but it takes a really bloody long time

00:24:24

especially

00:24:24

if you do that through the compulsory education system

00:24:27

but more fundamentally it's about community building

00:24:30

I think

00:24:31

and this is where we have to be honest with ourselves

00:24:33

about the really hard graft

00:24:34

that is obviously

00:24:36

the likes of petition and protest

00:24:37

but more than that, conversation

00:24:40

and regular people feeling confident

00:24:43

and capable enough to talk to each other

00:24:45

about what these problems are.

00:24:47

Understand that they are shared problems

00:24:48

they're not our own individual problems

00:24:50

they're systemic problems

00:24:51

and then work together

00:24:52

organising to try and change that.

00:24:55

So I guess you know

00:24:56

that's a roundabout way of providing the context

00:24:58

to answer your question which is that

00:25:00

if we are to get the critical mass necessary

00:25:03

to make this change politically

00:25:06

then we need more regular

00:25:07

people who know that they are just as bloody entitled

00:25:11

to have an opinion on something

00:25:13

to approach their politician

00:25:14

and to make a political impact

00:25:16

as the Rupert Murdochs of this world.

00:25:17

Yeah this is pretty much in line with

00:25:19

with what I've been saying

00:25:20

which is I think that

00:25:23

I think that there's a there's a lack of compelling

00:25:26

cohesive popular political messages at the moment

00:25:28

I think we've moved into a space of kind of broad

00:25:30

lack of faith of politicians

00:25:32

but I think that provides a lot of opportunity for like,

00:25:37

individuals acting as amplifiers of a message

00:25:40

so like, the popularity of this channel

00:25:42

you know, we've never spent a penny on advertising

00:25:45

it's word of mouth right?

00:25:46

And I keep saying, you know

00:25:47

if everybody convinces one person

00:25:50

then you get everybody and

00:25:51

I do think there's huge space to grow that

00:25:54

through conversations. But on that topic

00:25:57

I can't talk to you today

00:25:58

without bringing up the subject of rising anti

00:26:02

immigrant sentiment

00:26:04

the increased popularity of the far right

00:26:06

There was a huge rally here this weekend

00:26:08

this weekend just gone, by the far right here in London

00:26:12

I think they have really in a sense

00:26:14

done a good job of spreading a message

00:26:16

through social media totally through people

00:26:18

through communities

00:26:20

and they tapped into real anger

00:26:22

Yeah, and when you talk about conversation

00:26:24

I worry a little bit

00:26:27

we're having... it's

00:26:29

making conversations more difficult

00:26:31

because

00:26:31

I feel that this country is moving a little bit more

00:26:33

towards the

00:26:34

kind of

00:26:35

very divided society that you see more so in the US

00:26:38

where you're either on one side or the other side

00:26:40

and people can't really talk

00:26:43

What's the situation like in New Zealand

00:26:45

do you have a rising far right

00:26:47

is it similar, are similar things happening

00:26:49

and what can we do about it?

00:26:52

I mean I don't think

00:26:53

that would be remiss of me to say that

00:26:55

we've got

00:26:56

the most right wing government that we've had

00:26:58

in a generation and they are very intentionally

00:27:03

shredding the social safety net

00:27:04

so they put a hiring freeze in our healthcare system

00:27:08

which is you know

00:27:09

resulting in

00:27:11

people waiting hours and hours in emergency departments

00:27:15

our education system is

00:27:17

falling apart at the seams

00:27:18

and again none of this is for lack of the amazing

00:27:22

people in those systems really trying

00:27:24

but they're burning out

00:27:26

and many of them are then looking offshore

00:27:28

for better opportunities

00:27:29

better quality of life for them and their family

00:27:31

for lower cost of living

00:27:32

and all of those kinds of things

00:27:33

and this is also why I think

00:27:34

it's important that we're talking

00:27:35

and understanding that this is a global phenomenon

00:27:38

right?

00:27:38

So while people might move to try and escape these issues

00:27:41

domestically they'll chase them because

00:27:43

you know, the billionaires are coming and

00:27:45

you know Peter Thiel

00:27:45

has citizenship in my country

00:27:47

and is building a bunker

00:27:49

it’s maddening. So I guess again

00:27:52

this is where we need to understand that

00:27:55

in terms of the political analysis

00:27:56

and this polarisation, tepid centrism

00:27:59

that is, you know

00:28:01

centre left parties have been bumbling along

00:28:03

and not meaningfully

00:28:04

addressing the material conditions

00:28:05

of regular working people

00:28:06

for the last 40 years. People are not stupid

00:28:10

they understand

00:28:11

that their day to day lives are deteriorating

00:28:14

that things are getting harder

00:28:15

that they are working longer

00:28:17

and they are angry about that

00:28:19

and they need somewhere to put that anger

00:28:21

and the kind of major proposition from

00:28:25

supposedly left wing parties

00:28:26

or centre left wing parties over the last 40 years

00:28:29

and particularly the last 10 or so years

00:28:31

has effectively been tokenism

00:28:33

has been going well

00:28:34

we're gonna put one person from a structurally

00:28:36

marginalized community into a position of power

00:28:38

not change the power structures

00:28:40

not deal with any of the fundamental issues in society

00:28:43

but we're just gonna

00:28:44

kind of put a gloss on hyper capitalism

00:28:48

and this deeply entrenched inequality

00:28:50

and you know

00:28:51

I think that in turn has meant that

00:28:53

there is a space for the far right to kind of enter

00:28:56

and go, OK

00:28:57

well it's that person who's been placed into that

00:29:00

supposed position of power

00:29:01

this like historically structurally marginalized person

00:29:04

well they're the problem

00:29:05

you know

00:29:06

it's the gays or the migrants or whatever

00:29:08

and this is where I think

00:29:11

to kind of come back down to earth

00:29:12

and to think about how we do

00:29:14

tangibly and realistically

00:29:15

that organizing

00:29:16

that I was alluding to in those conversations

00:29:18

you know, I kinda come back to this really basic point

00:29:20

one of the first things I wanted to do

00:29:22

when I became co leader of the greens

00:29:24

in Aotearoa was to go and talk to the coal miners

00:29:27

because so frequently, obviously

00:29:28

green movements are pitched against working people

00:29:31

particularly working class people in

00:29:33

you know, these industrial areas

00:29:36

so I don't have beef with coal miners

00:29:39

in fact I want them to live good lives

00:29:42

but we obviously need to decarbonize our economy

00:29:45

if we're gonna have a future and a livable planet

00:29:48

so went down to the West coast of the South Island and

00:29:51

I love

00:29:51

nothing more than a challenge of talking to people

00:29:53

who think that they'll hate me

00:29:55

and you know

00:29:56

after talking through some of those initial assumptions

00:29:58

about who I was and what I was there to do

00:30:00

we kind of

00:30:01

then immediately get down to the brass tacks of it

00:30:03

and it's crazy. At the end of the day

00:30:05

all these guys wanted was a decent income

00:30:08

to be able to stay in their community

00:30:09

and feel a sense of pride in what they do

00:30:11

Those are things we can agree on

00:30:13

that is the broadest base unifying thing

00:30:18

that brings together people in my country

00:30:21

people in your country regular people across the world

00:30:25

it's the foundations of Maslow's hierarchy of needs

00:30:28

that is where we will find our solidarity

00:30:30

that is the stuff that we can agree on

00:30:32

so I think that you know

00:30:34

when it comes to

00:30:35

kind of trying to reach across the aisle

00:30:36

and talk to these people

00:30:37

who are in these incredibly angry spaces

00:30:40

and are being co opted

00:30:41

and manipulated by the far right

00:30:44

obviously that's not a role for

00:30:47

particularly

00:30:47

those who are subjected to all of that hatred

00:30:50

but I do think

00:30:51

those of us who have a familiar or family connection

00:30:54

if we can just kind of spend the time and ask people

00:30:57

why they think the way that they do

00:30:58

and how they kind of came to those conclusions

00:31:00

you know people will come to unpack

00:31:02

and when they are talking about

00:31:04

why they think the way that they do

00:31:06

they will start to acknowledge themselves

00:31:08

if they're genuinely being listened to

00:31:10

that maybe there are some gaps in their logic.

00:31:14

I think I think often there's less

00:31:19

between

00:31:20

some of the people who are supporting what we do

00:31:23

who want a wealth tax

00:31:24

and some of the people going on these marches

00:31:26

then you might think and I've seen some guys

00:31:28

there's a guy

00:31:29

there's a youtuber here called Jimmy the giant

00:31:30

I like and I think it was on

00:31:32

he tweeted it, but I think it was on Politics Joe

00:31:34

they went and they spoke to some of these guys

00:31:36

a lot of these guys want wealth taxes

00:31:38

and I think

00:31:41

the situation we have here is

00:31:42

you know everybody hates the Conservatives

00:31:44

it's understandable people are starting to hate Labour

00:31:47

and that's understandable as well

00:31:49

and then Reform our sort of new right

00:31:52

far right party, they

00:31:53

kind of win by being the only voice left in the room

00:31:56

because the left hasn't really been able to

00:31:59

establish a presence in social media

00:32:02

which is where these people are

00:32:03

or in the mainstream media

00:32:04

and I actually think there's a massive space

00:32:10

for a fourth voice

00:32:11

which doesn't have to be on the left, that

00:32:13

that really does anything

00:32:15

that centers living standards, economics

00:32:18

inequality, taxation

00:32:19

which is what I'm trying to be

00:32:22

it sounds like you're trying to do a similar thing here

00:32:24

I should ask you why you're here

00:32:26

you're obviously co leader of the New Zealand Greens

00:32:28

we’ve got a new leader of our British Greens

00:32:31

and he's Zack Polanski for those who don't know

00:32:33

He's great. He seems to be looking to do a similar thing

00:32:36

which is focus a lot on the economy

00:32:38

focus on inequality, be there on social media

00:32:41

be loud, make a voice

00:32:42

any opinions on him?

00:32:45

Oh yeah

00:32:45

no Zack and I met a few days ago and he's awesome

00:32:48

I think that he has an incredible opportunity to yeah

00:32:53

work with people, to have them realise

00:32:55

that all of these problems are so deeply interconnected

00:32:58

right? I mean

00:32:59

it's really funny because our name is Green

00:33:01

and our colour is green

00:33:02

of course we care about the environment

00:33:03

we care about saving the bats and our native species

00:33:06

and all of those other things

00:33:07

but we also care about all life on earth

00:33:09

you know, and it's really

00:33:11

bloody hard to get people to care about the end of the planet

00:33:14

or the end of life on earth as we know it

00:33:16

if they can't put food on the table

00:33:17

for the end of the week. So

00:33:19

any program that is focused on centering

00:33:23

kind of our ecological needs

00:33:25

or our planetary limits needs to bear in mind that

00:33:28

in order to change public policy

00:33:30

to get to that place we need to ensure that everybody

00:33:33

has their basic needs met

00:33:35

so I think it really is that simple

00:33:37

it's about understanding

00:33:37

the same system that is exploiting our planet

00:33:41

is exploiting and exhausting people

00:33:43

and that's where we kind of

00:33:44

come back down to this really basic proposition that

00:33:48

what the hell are we all working so hard for

00:33:51

if not

00:33:52

to have a society that caters to our basic needs

00:33:56

I mean I hope it works

00:33:57

I hope it works

00:33:59

I sometimes feel that I'm sort of

00:34:01

the only guy pushing progressive voice on social media

00:34:03

and I know I'm not

00:34:04

I know there's lots of other people doing it

00:34:06

but I look at what Zack's doing

00:34:08

focusing on inequality, focusing on taxation

00:34:10

focusing on social media

00:34:13

and I hope it works cause

00:34:14

then I could go on holiday and feel like someone else

00:34:16

is doing it

00:34:17

He's got a really clear,

00:34:19

he's got a really clear message

00:34:20

and I mean this is kind of always my call to action

00:34:23

to anybody who, you know

00:34:25

is maybe sitting there at home and going

00:34:27

she doesn't know what the hell she's talking about

00:34:29

well get involved!

00:34:30

Then get your hands dirty

00:34:31

I will take critique from anybody

00:34:34

who is willing to bloody try

00:34:37

You know if enough of us try

00:34:39

then we'll win, I always say that

00:34:40

but let's not, let's not fight in the background right

00:34:43

let's bloody do it

00:34:45

I see too many circular firing squads

00:34:47

but I know you gotta go soon

00:34:48

before you go

00:34:49

I get criticized a lot for being quite pessimistic

00:34:52

because I am quite pessimistic

00:34:54

and given you know

00:34:55

the mood in this country at the moment

00:34:56

is quite pessimistic

00:34:59

I try my best to finish on messages of hope

00:35:01

so I would like to ask you before we finish

00:35:03

do you feel hopeful for the future

00:35:05

is there something you feel hopeful about

00:35:06

what gives you hope?

00:35:07

I feel incredibly hopeful about the future

00:35:09

I wouldn't be able to do what I do if I don't

00:35:11

you know I travel around my country

00:35:13

and obviously been on the other side of the planet

00:35:15

for the first time in several years

00:35:18

And whenever I feel a sense of pessimism or despondency

00:35:22

or whatever you wanna characterize it as

00:35:25

just look for the helpers

00:35:26

and you will find abundant people

00:35:28

who are doing their best day in and day out

00:35:31

in ways big and small to make the world a better place

00:35:35

and if we start connecting the dots

00:35:36

between all of those actions

00:35:37

and those practices of people living their values

00:35:40

and doing the right thing

00:35:41

and we scale that up

00:35:43

then we've kind of changed the world overnight

00:35:45

you know, so yeah

00:35:46

I feel an incredible sense of hope

00:35:49

and I think that it's about people realizing

00:35:52

and this is my kind of classic

00:35:54

go to

00:35:55

that inspiration

00:35:56

is not a reason to put somebody on a pedestal

00:35:58

and go

00:35:59

that person's gonna solve all of the world's problems

00:36:01

clearly they're not you know

00:36:03

if you look at

00:36:03

all of the amazing things that human beings

00:36:06

have been able to achieve

00:36:07

in the arc of history, civil rights

00:36:10

gay rights, women's rights

00:36:11

whatever, it has always been

00:36:14

regular people working together at scale

00:36:17

to change our politics up against some of the most

00:36:20

heinous and difficult barriers

00:36:22

that you can possibly conceptualize

00:36:24

and imagine. So inspiration is a mirror

00:36:27

it is you seeing in somebody else

00:36:28

actually something that you admire about yourself

00:36:31

and that is an invitation to participate

00:36:33

and to be part of something bigger

00:36:35

and the kind of co benefit

00:36:37

or the other really awesome thing about that is

00:36:40

our mental health will be so much better for it.

00:36:43

I hope so, I hope so

00:36:46

I think we can make it better

00:36:48

I think we can and I think that we have to

00:36:50

and I think that in the process of trying

00:36:52

we need to have some fucking fun

00:36:54

I'll try my best, that's never been a specialty of mine

00:36:57

but thank you very much

00:36:59

first ever politician on the channel

00:37:00

thanks for coming all the way over and yeah

00:37:02

good luck

00:37:03

nice to meet you, Chlöe Swarbrick. You too mate