← Back to all transcripts

The Economy: What You've Missed

December 31, 2023
Wealth Inequality Enough is Enough Tax Wealth Not Work Economics of Covid Rich get Richer Poor get Poorer Economics Explained Tax the Rich End Austerity Billionaire Poverty
00:00:00

Welcome back to Garys Economics.

00:00:01

Today we are going to bring you up

00:00:03

to speed with everything

00:00:04

that has happened on the economy.

00:00:09

So I've been away for six months.

00:00:10

I want to do a video

00:00:11

to basically

00:00:12

bring you up

00:00:13

to date with everything

00:00:14

that's been happening

00:00:15

in that time on the economy.

00:00:16

The first thing

00:00:17

to say

00:00:17

is that

00:00:18

really, in many ways,

00:00:20

nothing has changed.

00:00:21

Things have continued

00:00:22

to progress

00:00:23

basically in the way

00:00:24

that I expected that it would,

00:00:26

the way that I've been

00:00:26

saying that they will.

00:00:27

And this

00:00:28

is because, in my opinion,

00:00:30

the economy continues

00:00:31

to be dominated

00:00:32

by the enormous amount of money

00:00:34

that was transferred

00:00:35

from government to very

00:00:36

rich individuals during COVID.

00:00:39

Those numbers have

00:00:40

increased slightly,

00:00:41

so I used to speak

00:00:41

a lot about £750 billion

00:00:43

that total

00:00:44

government deficit since COVID

00:00:46

now is £800 billion in the UK.

00:00:48

So that's £16,000

00:00:49

for every adult in the country.

00:00:51

That's the total amount of money

00:00:52

to the rich from the government.

00:00:55

In the US, the number is

00:00:56

$10 trillion,

00:00:57

eyewatering

00:00:58

$10 trillion, which is $80,000

00:01:01

for every US taxpayer.

00:01:02

So enormous amounts of cash

00:01:04

have gone from the government

00:01:05

to the rich.

00:01:05

In my opinion,

00:01:06

those continue to drive

00:01:08

the economy and things

00:01:09

are basically progressing

00:01:10

as I said they would.

00:01:11

And we're going to talk about now

00:01:13

what will happen from now.

00:01:15

So let's go through

00:01:16

the main points one at time.

00:01:17

Number one is inflation.

00:01:19

Inflation is obviously

00:01:20

the big thing,

00:01:21

which has been

00:01:21

hurting people's living

00:01:22

standards in the last few years.

00:01:24

We have seen inflation fall

00:01:26

significantly in basically

00:01:29

every country

00:01:29

in the world in the last year

00:01:31

or so from highs of

00:01:32

in the UK, 10% down

00:01:34

to now, about

00:01:35

4% in the UK

00:01:36

and other countries already

00:01:37

significantly lower.

00:01:38

Now this is

00:01:40

what I predicted.

00:01:41

It's basically

00:01:42

what all economists predicted.

00:01:44

We did a video

00:01:46

maybe about eight or nine months ago

00:01:48

when Rishi Sunak, the Prime Minister,

00:01:50

basically

00:01:51

said he would cut inflation

00:01:53

and at that point

00:01:54

in time

00:01:54

it was already

00:01:55

very obvious that pretty much

00:01:56

everyone that inflation

00:01:57

was going to fall.

00:01:57

So this is not a surprise to anyone.

00:01:59

Now, for me,

00:02:00

this is pretty much in line

00:02:01

with what you would expect

00:02:04

if you

00:02:04

see a one off massive cash gift

00:02:08

from governments to the richest.

00:02:10

The rich accumulate a ton of money.

00:02:11

They spend that money

00:02:13

that pushes prices up.

00:02:14

But because it was a one off

00:02:15

cash gift,

00:02:16

we see a one off

00:02:17

increase in the price level

00:02:18

and then those prices

00:02:19

start to subside.

00:02:21

Some people

00:02:22

think inflation

00:02:22

will come all the way down to 2%,

00:02:24

which is the target.

00:02:25

Some people think it might struggle

00:02:27

And stick around these 4%,

00:02:28

3% levels.

00:02:29

Personally,

00:02:30

I think we probably will see

00:02:31

inflation fall relatively quickly

00:02:33

and that brings us to number two,

00:02:36

which is interest rates.

00:02:38

Now the Central Bank,

00:02:40

Bank of England

00:02:41

or the Fed,

00:02:41

if you’re in the US,

00:02:42

move interest rates

00:02:44

to try and manage inflation.

00:02:45

So since inflation is falling,

00:02:47

the expectations for interest

00:02:48

rates have also fallen.

00:02:50

Now, if you go back

00:02:51

and look at my predictions earlier

00:02:52

in the year

00:02:53

for interest rates and house prices,

00:02:55

which you'll get on to next,

00:02:57

I said interest rates

00:02:58

will keep rising

00:02:59

and then as inflation

00:02:59

falls, will probably start

00:03:00

to see interest rates flatline.

00:03:02

At this point,

00:03:04

markets are basically

00:03:05

expecting that to happen.

00:03:06

So the Bank of England base

00:03:07

rate is up to 5.25%. Now,

00:03:10

they didn't change it

00:03:10

at the last meeting.

00:03:11

Markets now expect that

00:03:12

that will basically be the top.

00:03:14

It will stay at

00:03:15

5.25%, as inflation

00:03:17

falls, interest rates

00:03:18

will start to fall again.

00:03:19

There's a lot of argument

00:03:20

about how far they will fall.

00:03:22

Markets think that they'll

00:03:24

probably come down

00:03:25

to eventually about 4%.

00:03:26

That might take a couple of years.

00:03:28

Personally, I think that

00:03:29

inflation will fall further

00:03:31

and interest rates will end up

00:03:32

coming down lower than that.

00:03:33

But that would depend

00:03:34

based on government policy,

00:03:35

which will get on

00:03:36

to after we’ve

00:03:36

spoken about the economics.

00:03:39

The next thing is house prices.

00:03:41

Now I was very aggressive

00:03:43

in predicting house price rises

00:03:45

from the very beginning of COVID

00:03:46

and we did see

00:03:47

very aggressive house price rises

00:03:48

at the beginning of COVID.

00:03:50

Since then, interest rates

00:03:51

have risen enormously

00:03:52

from 0% up to 5.25%.

00:03:54

And I think a lot of people

00:03:55

have been surprised

00:03:57

that these aggressive

00:03:58

interest rate increases

00:04:00

have not led to aggressive

00:04:02

house price decreases.

00:04:04

For me, I think this is

00:04:06

quite understandable

00:04:07

when you understand

00:04:08

that an enormous

00:04:09

amount of cash has been

00:04:09

accumulated by the rich.

00:04:11

Now, when interest rates

00:04:12

go up a lot, as they have done.

00:04:14

Many of you will have seen

00:04:14

mortgage rates go up.

00:04:16

It becomes very difficult for,

00:04:17

sort of, middle class people,

00:04:19

especially poorer

00:04:19

people, to buy houses

00:04:21

because they rely on mortgages

00:04:23

and those interest

00:04:23

rates have gone up.

00:04:24

But in the same

00:04:25

time,

00:04:25

the rich have accumulated

00:04:27

an enormous amount of money,

00:04:29

which means that

00:04:29

they are able to buy houses

00:04:32

basically without using a mortgage,

00:04:33

using a very small mortgage.

00:04:35

So I think what we've seen

00:04:37

is two things, basically.

00:04:39

As interest rates have gone up,

00:04:42

rich people have been using their

00:04:43

cash savings,

00:04:44

giving it to their kids,

00:04:45

giving it to their grandkids

00:04:47

to buy houses without mortgages,

00:04:49

which is why house

00:04:50

prices have not fallen

00:04:51

despite these big

00:04:52

increases in interest rates.

00:04:55

And the second thing is that

00:04:58

rich people are able

00:04:59

now to get high interest rates

00:05:01

on their savings accounts.

00:05:02

So they're sort of

00:05:03

sitting on the cash they've got

00:05:05

getting high interest

00:05:06

and using it to buy houses.

00:05:09

This has meant that

00:05:09

we haven't seen what

00:05:10

a lot of people have predicted,

00:05:11

which is house price falls.

00:05:13

Now, I think

00:05:14

house prices is interesting for me

00:05:16

because I think

00:05:16

probably what we will see

00:05:17

next is interest

00:05:19

rates will start to fall

00:05:20

as inflation starts to fall.

00:05:22

I think once those interest rates

00:05:23

start to fall,

00:05:24

rich people will stop

00:05:25

sitting on these big

00:05:26

piles of cash in the bank

00:05:28

and they will start

00:05:29

to lend the money out

00:05:30

at lower rates for mortgages.

00:05:32

They will start to buy more houses.

00:05:34

And I'm strongly expecting

00:05:36

aggressive house price rises

00:05:38

in the next couple of years

00:05:39

as the interest rates fall down.

00:05:42

So I think this is going to lead to

00:05:44

a while before that.

00:05:45

I want to talk about

00:05:46

the very last thing we've got,

00:05:47

which is living standards.

00:05:49

So inflation

00:05:51

has fallen significantly.

00:05:53

I think people are

00:05:54

starting to realise now

00:05:56

what I was speaking about earlier

00:05:57

on in the year.

00:05:58

When inflation falls,

00:06:00

that doesn't mean prices fall.

00:06:02

So prices

00:06:02

have continued to rise

00:06:04

throughout the year.

00:06:05

Prices have consistently risen

00:06:08

more than wages, which means

00:06:10

even as inflation has fallen,

00:06:13

living standards

00:06:13

have continued to decrease.

00:06:16

The way I see it really is during

00:06:18

the three years of COVID,

00:06:19

we paused the

00:06:20

economy and rapidly

00:06:22

increased inequality.

00:06:24

If you pause the economy

00:06:26

and rapidly increase inequality

00:06:28

when you unpause

00:06:28

the economy is inevitable,

00:06:30

you will see a significant

00:06:31

fall in living standards.

00:06:33

I think that is basically

00:06:36

what we're seeing now.

00:06:38

The question is

00:06:38

what happens from here?

00:06:39

Because I think

00:06:40

the way that the economy is being

00:06:43

presented in the media at the

00:06:44

moment is largely that we are

00:06:46

in a recession.

00:06:47

And I think that

00:06:49

kind of gives the implication

00:06:50

that there is a temporary period

00:06:52

of decreasing

00:06:53

living standards

00:06:54

and then we will have a recovery.

00:06:57

I think if you want to understand

00:06:58

the long term picture,

00:07:00

it's important

00:07:00

to understand basically

00:07:02

the sort of second round effects

00:07:04

of this large amount of money

00:07:05

that has gone to the rich.

00:07:06

So up till now,

00:07:09

the rich, because they'd been

00:07:10

getting higher levels of interest,

00:07:11

have been relatively happy

00:07:13

to just sit on that money

00:07:15

and accumulate the interest.

00:07:17

Now, as inflation starts to fall

00:07:19

and interest rates start to fall,

00:07:21

they will probably look to invest

00:07:24

that money more aggressively,

00:07:25

which means they will start to

00:07:27

essentially

00:07:29

buy houses from the middle class.

00:07:31

So what that means is

00:07:32

we will see house prices go up.

00:07:35

We will see home ownership rates

00:07:38

from young people continue to fall.

00:07:41

What we will also see is

00:07:43

as the rich people

00:07:45

look to use the money

00:07:45

they've accumulated

00:07:46

and what we already are seeing,

00:07:48

significant increases in

00:07:50

rents,

00:07:51

the prices of luxury

00:07:52

goods, the price of holidays.

00:07:53

And that is, again, something

00:07:54

you would expect

00:07:55

when you

00:07:56

see a massive accumulation

00:07:57

of cash from the rich.

00:07:59

That basically means

00:08:00

rents will go up,

00:08:02

house prices will go up,

00:08:03

and the ability of

00:08:04

owning homes will become more

00:08:06

out of reach of ordinary families.

00:08:10

What that means for young people

00:08:12

from ordinary

00:08:13

and poorer families is

00:08:14

rent is much more

00:08:15

expensive when you're young

00:08:17

and you

00:08:17

then have to take

00:08:18

out a much bigger

00:08:19

mortgage to buy a house,

00:08:20

so you have to pay

00:08:21

much more in interest.

00:08:23

This increases the flow of rent

00:08:25

from the poor

00:08:26

to the rich

00:08:26

and increases

00:08:27

the flow of interest

00:08:28

from the poor to the rich.

00:08:31

We also have a massively increased

00:08:33

government debt,

00:08:34

which means that the government

00:08:35

is now paying debt,

00:08:37

paying interest to the rich.

00:08:38

You are paying

00:08:38

interest to the rich much

00:08:39

more on your taxes.

00:08:40

So all of

00:08:42

these second round

00:08:43

effects are essentially bad.

00:08:46

When you give cash to the rich,

00:08:48

the rich use that cash

00:08:49

to buy the assets

00:08:50

from the middle class,

00:08:51

to buy the debt of

00:08:52

the middle class, to buy

00:08:53

the government

00:08:54

increased levels of debt, decreased

00:08:56

levels of home ownership means

00:08:59

increased cash flows

00:09:00

from the

00:09:01

middle class to the rich,

00:09:01

and this will continue to

00:09:03

rebound through.

00:09:04

So what that means is

00:09:05

we will continue

00:09:06

to see living standards fall

00:09:09

in the coming year,

00:09:10

the coming two years.

00:09:11

I want to talk a little bit about

00:09:14

how this will

00:09:14

probably play out

00:09:16

politically, because

00:09:17

we obviously have an election

00:09:18

coming up next year in this country.

00:09:20

There's also an election

00:09:20

in the states.

00:09:21

I think

00:09:23

the most important thing

00:09:24

you need to understand

00:09:24

if you want

00:09:25

to understand

00:09:26

the future of the economy,

00:09:29

is that inequality

00:09:30

has greatly increased.

00:09:33

So it is inevitable

00:09:34

that living

00:09:35

standards have to fall further.

00:09:38

I think that will probably dominate

00:09:41

the political environment

00:09:42

for some time to come.

00:09:46

I don't think any mainstream

00:09:47

political parties

00:09:48

at the moment are serious

00:09:51

about reducing inequality,

00:09:52

which means that

00:09:52

inequality will

00:09:54

inevitably continue to increase.

00:09:56

So I think if you want to understand

00:09:58

politics,

00:10:01

the economic framework you

00:10:02

need behind

00:10:03

that is to accept that

00:10:05

from this point,

00:10:06

further significant falls

00:10:08

in living standards are

00:10:09

basically certain,

00:10:12

which means you...

00:10:15

what you see

00:10:15

is continued

00:10:16

dissatisfaction in whichever

00:10:18

political party is in power,

00:10:20

be that Conservatives

00:10:21

or Labour

00:10:22

or Democrats or Republicans.

00:10:25

So I think,

00:10:26

you know,

00:10:27

and I'm

00:10:27

not a professional

00:10:28

political forecaster,

00:10:29

but I'm very confident

00:10:29

my economic forecast,

00:10:31

what you will probably see

00:10:33

is increased demand

00:10:34

for ordinary people,

00:10:35

for some sort

00:10:36

of political alternative.

00:10:38

So it's probably

00:10:41

important

00:10:42

that we understand

00:10:43

what are the likely

00:10:44

political alternatives.

00:10:46

So I'm making this video

00:10:47

very shortly

00:10:48

after the Dutch

00:10:49

election in which for the first time

00:10:50

ever, the Dutch populist

00:10:53

far right party

00:10:54

essentially won the election.

00:10:55

Got the highest number of

00:10:56

seats and votes. And I think

00:11:00

at the

00:11:01

moment we are in a

00:11:01

situation

00:11:02

where living standards

00:11:03

will definitely fall.

00:11:04

They already are falling, clearly,

00:11:06

and people

00:11:07

will start to demand

00:11:08

a political alternative.

00:11:10

And what that means is,

00:11:11

it becomes very important

00:11:12

what the most feasible seeming

00:11:15

political alternative is.

00:11:17

And when I

00:11:18

look around

00:11:19

at voting trends in Europe

00:11:22

and in the

00:11:22

US in trends

00:11:23

of political parties,

00:11:24

it seems to be pretty clear that

00:11:26

at the moment, the most popular

00:11:28

sounding alternative

00:11:29

voice is increased

00:11:32

xenophobia, anti-immigration

00:11:34

and possibly increased racism.

00:11:37

And I think that in the absence of

00:11:40

the creation of a positive

00:11:41

alternative narrative,

00:11:43

it's almost certain that politics

00:11:46

will move this way.

00:11:47

And that is

00:11:48

a direct result of the fact that

00:11:52

it is basically certain

00:11:53

the economy will keep getting worse.

00:11:55

I think

00:11:57

people are aware when

00:11:58

the economy they're in is failing,

00:12:00

especially as that stretches on 10,

00:12:02

20, 30 years.

00:12:04

I think

00:12:04

when you know

00:12:05

that the boat you're on

00:12:06

is sinking,

00:12:07

you know,

00:12:07

you're going to basically jump

00:12:08

on the first lifeboat

00:12:09

that you see.

00:12:10

So I think

00:12:11

what we will see from this point

00:12:14

further decreases

00:12:15

in living standards,

00:12:16

which could become quite fast and

00:12:19

further

00:12:20

demand from ordinary people

00:12:21

for an alternative in politics.

00:12:23

And unless we can create

00:12:26

a positive alternative

00:12:27

which says

00:12:28

let's distribute wealth better,

00:12:29

let's increased living standards,

00:12:31

we're probably likely to

00:12:33

move towards these sort of

00:12:35

far right,

00:12:35

anti-immigration, xenophobic

00:12:37

sentiments over time.

00:12:39

Of course,

00:12:40

those political parties,

00:12:42

they will also fail

00:12:43

to improve the economy

00:12:44

because they will not deal

00:12:45

with the fundamental problem

00:12:46

of inequality,

00:12:48

which means that

00:12:49

unless we

00:12:50

create a positive alternative,

00:12:53

it will probably

00:12:54

simply shift further

00:12:55

and further

00:12:55

to the right and in the search

00:12:57

for something that works. So

00:13:00

that's a relatively

00:13:01

depressing message to be delivering

00:13:02

at the end of the year.

00:13:03

But I think

00:13:05

it also makes it

00:13:06

clear the importance of

00:13:07

what we're doing, which is,

00:13:10

if we make it clear to people

00:13:12

what's happening,

00:13:13

which is that

00:13:14

living standards will

00:13:15

continue to fall,

00:13:17

people will know

00:13:18

that we need an alternative

00:13:21

and we need to make it clear

00:13:24

the fundamental reason for the fall

00:13:25

in living standards,

00:13:26

which is the increase

00:13:27

in inequality.

00:13:28

If we decrease the inequality,

00:13:30

we can improve the living standards.

00:13:31

If we don't

00:13:32

decrease the inequality,

00:13:33

living standards

00:13:34

will continue to decrease

00:13:34

and politics will continue

00:13:37

to move in more extreme directions.

00:13:40

But the most

00:13:40

optimistic thing I can say

00:13:42

is the

00:13:42

massive increase

00:13:43

in inequality mean

00:13:44

that we have massive opportunity

00:13:45

to enormously

00:13:46

increase living standards

00:13:47

If we simply reverse

00:13:48

the increase in

00:13:49

inequality that we see.

00:13:51

So to conclude,

00:13:53

the economy continues

00:13:54

to be driven by inequality.

00:13:55

All the main

00:13:58

economic features inflation, interest

00:14:00

rates continue to be driven by that.

00:14:01

Inequality is increasing

00:14:02

very quickly.

00:14:03

If we don't decrease that,

00:14:04

living standards will fall.

00:14:06

If we take action,

00:14:07

we can make things better.

00:14:07

So support the channel.

00:14:09

We’re making lots

00:14:10

more videos in the New Year.

00:14:12

Thank you for your support.

00:14:13

Good luck.