← Back to all transcripts

Taxing the Rich = Growing the Government?

June 02, 2024
Wealth Inequality Enough is Enough Tax Wealth Not Work Economics of Covid Rich get Richer Poor get Poorer Economics Explained Tax the Rich End Austerity Billionaire Poverty
00:00:00

Okay. Welcome back to Gary’s Economics.

00:00:02

Today we are going to talk about

00:00:04

giving your money to the government.

00:00:10

All right.

00:00:10

So I wanted to do a quick one addressing

00:00:12

one of the most common questions, criticisms

00:00:14

we get on the channel,

00:00:15

which is why do you want to increase taxes?

00:00:18

All of that money is going to go to government.

00:00:21

Government is full of corrupt idiots.

00:00:23

They're going to steal my money.

00:00:24

They're going to waste my money. It's a waste of time.

00:00:26

Don't do it. Gary, you're a communist.

00:00:30

And

00:00:31

I thought this was an interesting one to talk about.

00:00:33

Because there's a kind of a perception

00:00:36

when I say that I want to tax

00:00:38

the rich more, that I must

00:00:40

necessarily be wanting

00:00:41

to give more money to the government.

00:00:43

I must be wanting to increase the size of government.

00:00:45

And I think this is

00:00:47

a good chance basically to show that

00:00:48

this is not what I'm trying to do.

00:00:50

So when I talk about taxing the rich,

00:00:54

first thing to say is I'm talking

00:00:56

about taxing the very rich.

00:00:58

This is not about taxing,

00:01:01

very likely, not about taxing you, not about your kids.

00:01:03

It's not about taxing lawyers

00:01:05

or even bankers or people

00:01:07

who are making sort of 100, 200 grand a year.

00:01:09

We're talking about taxing

00:01:11

extremely wealthy individuals

00:01:13

with wealth of more than £10 million.

00:01:17

And what we want to do is to tax them

00:01:19

so that we can lower your taxes.

00:01:21

This is not really by increasing

00:01:23

the size of government at all.

00:01:24

What I see is a situation

00:01:28

where ordinary families

00:01:29

are increasingly losing their wealth,

00:01:31

and that wealth is flowing

00:01:34

to the very, very rich.

00:01:36

And I'm trying to see

00:01:37

how is it that we can, number one,

00:01:39

protect your family from losing its wealth?

00:01:41

And number two, help your family get its wealth back?

00:01:44

And I think this is,

00:01:45

it's an interesting thing to talk about,

00:01:47

because what is happening

00:01:48

here is quite counterintuitive.

00:01:50

And when I say

00:01:52

we want to tax

00:01:54

the rich, people think immediately more taxation means,

00:01:58

more taxation for me,

00:02:00

less money for me, less money

00:02:02

and wealth for me and my family.

00:02:04

And instead that money and wealth

00:02:06

go into the government.

00:02:07

And people think that Gary's a big government guy.

00:02:11

Gary is a communist.

00:02:13

But really what this is about

00:02:15

is, is about getting your wealth back.

00:02:17

And I think that's quite a,

00:02:19

it's an interesting concept, right,

00:02:20

that we can increase tax

00:02:22

and then increasing in tax,

00:02:23

we can get your wealth back.

00:02:24

So I wanted to just go through

00:02:28

the basic

00:02:29

logic of how

00:02:30

it can be

00:02:31

that increasing tax can make you richer,

00:02:33

because that is ultimately what I'm trying to do here.

00:02:36

Assuming that you are not a super rich person

00:02:38

and you are from an ordinary family.

00:02:40

I want to increase tax to make you richer

00:02:43

and your family, you as an individual.

00:02:46

So how does this work?

00:02:48

The first

00:02:49

and most obvious way is,

00:02:50

if we increase taxation on the super rich,

00:02:53

we can reduce your taxes.

00:02:56

So at the moment we have a tax system

00:02:57

which taxes working people at a very high rate.

00:03:01

You know, I worked

00:03:02

and I made quite a lot of money

00:03:03

and I was paying more than 50% tax at the time.

00:03:07

But it taxes, extremely wealthy families,

00:03:10

extremely wealthy individuals at a rate

00:03:11

often close to 0%.

00:03:14

These guys have an enormous amount of wealth.

00:03:16

They generate enormous amount of income

00:03:18

from that wealth.

00:03:18

They don't pay tax.

00:03:19

If we tax them much more, we can reduce your taxes.

00:03:23

This means more money in your pocket.

00:03:25

This means more money going to you.

00:03:28

Now, I'm not instinctively a big government person,

00:03:30

but we do exist at the moment in this country,

00:03:33

the UK, at the end of 50 years of austerity,

00:03:36

which has really starved

00:03:38

a lot of government services of money,

00:03:40

especially if you look at things like

00:03:42

local government services,

00:03:44

even things like the police, education,

00:03:46

massively starved of money,

00:03:48

things like

00:03:48

the legal system,

00:03:49

the court system, anyone who works

00:03:51

anywhere, especially in local services,

00:03:53

will see massive starvation of money.

00:03:55

So I think at this point

00:03:57

you probably would want to use some of that money

00:03:59

to help fund local services, which are being...

00:04:02

have been decimated the last 15, 20 years.

00:04:06

What this means is

00:04:08

less money for the rich, more money for you

00:04:11

because your taxes are reduced,

00:04:13

more money for local services,

00:04:14

so you won't have to pay for things

00:04:16

which you're currently paying for,

00:04:17

because that would be provided by the government.

00:04:21

You have more money in your pocket.

00:04:23

Local workers around

00:04:24

you will have more money in their pocket

00:04:25

because

00:04:26

government are trying to hire staff,

00:04:28

trying to improve the public services

00:04:30

which have been decimated for a long time.

00:04:32

It means you’ll have more money.

00:04:33

People around you will have more money.

00:04:34

You will be able to spend that money.

00:04:36

People around

00:04:36

you will be able to spend that money,

00:04:37

which means your wages will go up.

00:04:39

So we say, number one, your wages go up.

00:04:41

Number two, your taxes go down.

00:04:43

And that means more wealth in your pocket.

00:04:46

Now there is another channel

00:04:47

by which increasing taxation on the rich

00:04:50

will make you richer.

00:04:52

I think this is also quite

00:04:53

interesting and counterintuitive,

00:04:56

which is if you increase tax

00:04:58

on the very rich people with wealths of £10 million,

00:05:01

£100 million, a billion massively,

00:05:04

you will enforce rich people selling their assets.

00:05:09

If you tax them really, really highly

00:05:10

and to be honest, I think at this point

00:05:13

wealth inequality has become so

00:05:15

large and is growing so quickly.

00:05:17

You really do need to tax

00:05:18

these people really massively.

00:05:20

If you where to tax them a lot,

00:05:22

you could put them in a situation

00:05:23

where they have to sell their assets.

00:05:26

And I think a lot of people

00:05:27

see this instinctively as a bad thing.

00:05:29

It's often an argument that is made.

00:05:33

You shouldn't tax the rich a lot

00:05:34

because maybe they're not that cash rich.

00:05:36

Maybe they're just holding lots of assets.

00:05:38

And if you tax them a lot

00:05:39

they’ll have to sell their assets.

00:05:42

Increasingly, as wealth inequality grows

00:05:47

a bigger and bigger share of the national wealth

00:05:50

of national assets are owned by the very rich.

00:05:54

Now, if you are very rich, say

00:05:55

you have a wealth of £100 million or let's say

00:05:59

£500 million, like Rishi Sunak,

00:06:01

according to the Sunday Times,

00:06:03

you would generate a passive income of £25 million

00:06:06

a year,

00:06:07

£2 million a month.

00:06:11

If the wealth is being held

00:06:13

by people who have a passive income of £2 million

00:06:17

per month,

00:06:19

they will never sell anything.

00:06:21

If you had a large amount of wealth,

00:06:23

you're making £2 million a month.

00:06:25

Why would you ever sell any of your assets?

00:06:27

You're making £2 million a month.

00:06:28

You never need to sell anything.

00:06:31

So increasingly,

00:06:33

we are in a situation where the assets are owned

00:06:37

by people who never have to sell any assets.

00:06:41

If that is the situation,

00:06:43

obviously, working people like you,

00:06:46

like your kids, like a parent

00:06:48

will never be able to afford assets.

00:06:51

If you want working people

00:06:53

to be able to afford assets like housing,

00:06:57

it is essential that the current owners of assets

00:07:01

at some point sell their assets.

00:07:04

If you give all the assets

00:07:06

to people

00:07:06

that never sell assets,

00:07:08

it will be impossible

00:07:09

for working people without assets to buy assets.

00:07:13

This is how things work.

00:07:15

It's impossible to buy a thing if nobody said a thing.

00:07:19

It is vital in order to get things

00:07:21

like housing back

00:07:23

into the hands of ordinary working families,

00:07:25

that the owners of assets sell their assets.

00:07:28

At the moment,

00:07:29

the superrich have enormous passive incomes,

00:07:32

they never sell anything.

00:07:33

We need them to sell their assets.

00:07:36

So for me,

00:07:38

taxing the super rich is not about growing government.

00:07:41

It's definitely not about moving us

00:07:43

to a communist state.

00:07:44

Taxing the rich is about rebalancing

00:07:47

essentially power and ownership in our society.

00:07:50

At the moment,

00:07:51

both government

00:07:52

and the middle class are losing

00:07:54

their wealth rapidly to the rich.

00:07:56

The only way to get that back is through taxation.

00:07:59

If we tax them more, we can tax you less.

00:08:02

You'll have more money.

00:08:03

The rich will be selling assets.

00:08:05

That means you and your kids can have assets.

00:08:08

You can own things. You can be rich.

00:08:11

We're not going to get assets

00:08:12

into the hands of ordinary working people

00:08:15

unless we take them out of the hands

00:08:17

of the people who own everything.

00:08:19

And the only way to do that is through taxation.

00:08:20

So for me,

00:08:22

taxation is about growing the assets

00:08:24

and the wealth of ordinary working people.

00:08:26

And I would like to sort of

00:08:29

get you to see taxation in a new light.

00:08:31

Taxation has been given a terrible brand,

00:08:34

largely by rich people,

00:08:35

because they don't want to pay it.

00:08:37

Taxation is how you define yourself.

00:08:39

Taxation is how you get wealth back from the group

00:08:42

that is taking your wealth.

00:08:43

And I kind of want increasingly, for you

00:08:45

to see taxation as kind of a tool you can use

00:08:49

in essentially a war.

00:08:51

Now, when you have a war,

00:08:51

when you have an invading army,

00:08:54

why do people invade countries?

00:08:55

Why do people start wars?

00:08:57

Because they want to take the assets.

00:09:00

And what is happening in your country?

00:09:02

Assets that used to be owned by the middle class,

00:09:04

that used to be owned

00:09:05

by the government

00:09:06

are, over time, being owned by the rich

00:09:09

and the super rich.

00:09:11

That is what war is. War is about taking assets.

00:09:15

Your assets will not be owned by your kids

00:09:17

or grandkids.

00:09:18

They'll be owned by the kids

00:09:19

and the grandkids of the superrich.

00:09:21

They are an invading army.

00:09:22

The only tool you have to defend yourself is taxation.

00:09:26

So if you tax the rich,

00:09:29

we can get money in your pocket.

00:09:30

We can get assets, to your kids and your grandkids.

00:09:33

If you don't tax

00:09:33

the rich, inequality will grow more and more

00:09:36

and your grandkids will be poor.

00:09:37

So taxation for the rich is about reducing your taxes.

00:09:43

It's not about growing the state.

00:09:44

It's about protecting your kids from poverty.

00:09:49

The government not going to do it.

00:09:51

They're full of extremely wealthy people.

00:09:53

You have to fight back.

00:09:54

You have to use the only tool that you have,

00:09:57

which is taxation.

00:09:58

It's the only way to protect yourself from the rich.

00:10:01

We're going to keep campaigning for it.

00:10:04

Please share the videos. Help us grow this message.

00:10:07

Thank you.