← Back to all transcripts

I made millions from the financial crisis, Trust me the system is broken. Gary on AE Podcast

August 22, 2020
Gary stevenson gary stevenson garys economics garyseconomics luke cooper zoe williams another europe
00:00:03

[Applause]

00:00:05

[Applause]

00:00:05

[Applause] [Music]

00:00:11

[Music]

00:00:14

[Music]

00:00:14

[Music] he<00:00:14.719> won<00:00:14.880> his<00:00:15.120> job<00:00:15.440> in<00:00:15.599> a<00:00:15.679> card<00:00:15.920> game

00:00:16

he won his job in a card game

00:00:16

he won his job in a card game he<00:00:16.640> made<00:00:16.880> a<00:00:17.039> fortune<00:00:17.680> from<00:00:17.840> the<00:00:18.000> financial

00:00:18

he made a fortune from the financial

00:00:18

he made a fortune from the financial crisis

00:00:19

crisis

00:00:19

crisis now<00:00:19.760> he's<00:00:20.000> warning<00:00:20.400> the<00:00:20.560> world<00:00:21.199> the<00:00:21.439> system

00:00:21

now he's warning the world the system

00:00:21

now he's warning the world the system has<00:00:22.080> to<00:00:22.320> change

00:00:23

has to change

00:00:23

has to change today<00:00:23.680> we<00:00:23.920> hear<00:00:24.160> his<00:00:24.400> story<00:00:25.039> this<00:00:25.359> shutdown<00:00:25.920> is

00:00:26

today we hear his story this shutdown is

00:00:26

today we hear his story this shutdown is creating<00:00:26.560> the

00:00:26

creating the

00:00:26

creating the greatest<00:00:27.599> wealth<00:00:28.000> heist<00:00:28.640> the<00:00:28.800> unemployment

00:00:29

greatest wealth heist the unemployment

00:00:29

greatest wealth heist the unemployment rate<00:00:29.519> has<00:00:29.840> skyrocketed<00:00:30.560> to<00:00:30.720> its<00:00:30.880> highest

00:00:31

rate has skyrocketed to its highest

00:00:31

rate has skyrocketed to its highest level<00:00:31.599> since<00:00:31.840> the<00:00:31.920> great<00:00:32.160> depression

00:00:32

level since the great depression

00:00:32

level since the great depression one<00:00:32.880> of<00:00:32.960> the<00:00:33.120> largest<00:00:33.680> corporate<00:00:34.079> bailouts

00:00:34

one of the largest corporate bailouts

00:00:34

one of the largest corporate bailouts with<00:00:34.960> as<00:00:35.120> few<00:00:35.440> strings<00:00:35.840> as<00:00:36.000> possible

00:00:36

with as few strings as possible

00:00:36

with as few strings as possible in<00:00:36.800> american<00:00:37.760> history<00:00:38.640> welcome<00:00:39.040> to<00:00:39.200> the

00:00:39

in american history welcome to the

00:00:39

in american history welcome to the another<00:00:39.600> europe<00:00:39.920> podcast<00:00:40.480> with<00:00:40.719> me

00:00:41

another europe podcast with me

00:00:41

another europe podcast with me luke<00:00:41.440> cooper<00:00:41.920> and<00:00:42.160> my<00:00:42.399> co-host<00:00:42.960> zoe<00:00:43.360> williams

00:00:44

luke cooper and my co-host zoe williams

00:00:44

luke cooper and my co-host zoe williams today<00:00:44.399> we're<00:00:44.640> joined<00:00:44.879> by<00:00:45.120> gary<00:00:45.520> stevenson<00:00:46.559> a

00:00:46

today we're joined by gary stevenson a

00:00:46

today we're joined by gary stevenson a one-time<00:00:47.280> city<00:00:47.680> trader

00:00:48

one-time city trader

00:00:48

one-time city trader he<00:00:48.480> made<00:00:48.800> a<00:00:48.879> small<00:00:49.360> fortune<00:00:49.920> after<00:00:50.160> the<00:00:50.239> last

00:00:50

he made a small fortune after the last

00:00:50

he made a small fortune after the last financial<00:00:51.199> crisis

00:00:51

financial crisis

00:00:52

financial crisis he<00:00:52.239> successfully<00:00:52.960> predicted<00:00:53.600> that<00:00:53.840> massive

00:00:54

he successfully predicted that massive

00:00:54

he successfully predicted that massive state<00:00:54.719> support<00:00:55.120> to<00:00:55.280> the<00:00:55.360> financial<00:00:56.000> system

00:00:56

state support to the financial system

00:00:56

state support to the financial system would<00:00:57.039> lead<00:00:57.280> to<00:00:57.440> a<00:00:57.600> sharp<00:00:58.079> inflation<00:00:58.800> in<00:00:59.039> asset

00:00:59

would lead to a sharp inflation in asset

00:00:59

would lead to a sharp inflation in asset prices

00:01:00

prices

00:01:00

prices so<00:01:00.559> things<00:01:00.879> like<00:01:01.120> property<00:01:01.680> stocks<00:01:02.160> and

00:01:02

so things like property stocks and

00:01:02

so things like property stocks and shares<00:01:03.120> he<00:01:03.280> was<00:01:03.520> right

00:01:04

shares he was right

00:01:04

shares he was right as<00:01:04.400> the<00:01:04.559> real<00:01:04.799> world<00:01:05.040> economy<00:01:05.519> was<00:01:05.680> barely

00:01:06

as the real world economy was barely

00:01:06

as the real world economy was barely growing<00:01:06.640> there<00:01:06.799> were<00:01:07.040> bull<00:01:07.280> markets<00:01:07.840> in<00:01:08.000> wall

00:01:08

growing there were bull markets in wall

00:01:08

growing there were bull markets in wall street<00:01:08.640> and<00:01:08.720> the<00:01:08.880> city<00:01:09.200> of<00:01:09.360> london

00:01:09

street and the city of london

00:01:09

street and the city of london you'd<00:01:10.080> be<00:01:10.240> forgiven<00:01:10.720> for<00:01:10.880> thinking<00:01:11.360> the<00:01:11.520> rich

00:01:11

you'd be forgiven for thinking the rich

00:01:11

you'd be forgiven for thinking the rich got<00:01:12.080> bailed<00:01:12.400> out<00:01:12.720> and<00:01:12.880> the<00:01:13.040> rest<00:01:13.439> got<00:01:13.680> sold<00:01:14.080> out

00:01:14

got bailed out and the rest got sold out

00:01:14

got bailed out and the rest got sold out gary<00:01:15.119> retired<00:01:15.680> from<00:01:15.840> the<00:01:16.000> city<00:01:16.320> at<00:01:16.400> the<00:01:16.560> age<00:01:16.720> of

00:01:16

gary retired from the city at the age of

00:01:16

gary retired from the city at the age of 27

00:01:17

27 and<00:01:18.000> is<00:01:18.159> now<00:01:18.400> working<00:01:18.799> as<00:01:18.880> an<00:01:18.960> economist

00:01:19

and is now working as an economist

00:01:19

and is now working as an economist warning<00:01:19.920> of<00:01:20.000> the<00:01:20.159> dangers<00:01:20.560> of<00:01:20.640> an<00:01:20.799> economic

00:01:21

warning of the dangers of an economic

00:01:21

warning of the dangers of an economic model<00:01:21.680> with<00:01:21.920> big<00:01:22.159> returns<00:01:22.560> for<00:01:22.799> capital

00:01:23

model with big returns for capital

00:01:23

model with big returns for capital low<00:01:23.840> returns<00:01:24.320> for<00:01:24.479> labour<00:01:25.360> after<00:01:25.680> his

00:01:25

low returns for labour after his

00:01:25

low returns for labour after his dazzling<00:01:26.320> predictions

00:01:27

dazzling predictions

00:01:27

dazzling predictions in<00:01:27.439> the<00:01:27.520> last<00:01:27.840> financial<00:01:28.400> crisis<00:01:28.880> we'll<00:01:29.119> be

00:01:29

in the last financial crisis we'll be

00:01:29

in the last financial crisis we'll be asking<00:01:29.680> him<00:01:29.920> what<00:01:30.079> he<00:01:30.240> makes<00:01:30.560> of<00:01:30.720> the<00:01:30.880> one

00:01:31

asking him what he makes of the one

00:01:31

asking him what he makes of the one we're<00:01:31.439> in

00:01:32

we're in

00:01:32

we're in an<00:01:32.560> even<00:01:32.960> bigger<00:01:33.439> economic<00:01:34.000> collapse<00:01:34.479> brought

00:01:34

an even bigger economic collapse brought

00:01:34

an even bigger economic collapse brought about<00:01:35.200> by<00:01:35.360> the<00:01:35.520> coronavirus<00:01:36.479> pandemic

00:01:37

about by the coronavirus pandemic

00:01:37

about by the coronavirus pandemic he<00:01:38.079> also<00:01:38.400> has<00:01:38.560> a<00:01:38.720> youtube<00:01:39.200> channel<00:01:39.600> gary's

00:01:40

he also has a youtube channel gary's

00:01:40

he also has a youtube channel gary's economics<00:01:40.960> where<00:01:41.119> this<00:01:41.439> podcast<00:01:42.079> will<00:01:42.320> also

00:01:42

economics where this podcast will also

00:01:42

economics where this podcast will also be<00:01:42.799> broadcast

00:01:43

be broadcast

00:01:43

be broadcast he's<00:01:43.840> got<00:01:44.000> some<00:01:44.240> great<00:01:44.479> videos<00:01:44.880> on<00:01:45.040> there<00:01:45.280> so

00:01:45

he's got some great videos on there so

00:01:45

he's got some great videos on there so check<00:01:45.759> it<00:01:45.920> out<00:01:46.560> as<00:01:46.799> usual<00:01:47.200> you<00:01:47.280> can<00:01:47.520> feed<00:01:47.759> back

00:01:47

check it out as usual you can feed back

00:01:48

check it out as usual you can feed back to<00:01:48.159> us<00:01:48.320> on<00:01:48.479> the<00:01:48.640> show

00:01:48

to us on the show

00:01:48

to us on the show and<00:01:49.119> feed<00:01:49.439> in<00:01:49.600> ideas<00:01:50.079> on<00:01:50.159> what<00:01:50.320> you'd<00:01:50.479> like<00:01:50.720> us

00:01:50

and feed in ideas on what you'd like us

00:01:50

and feed in ideas on what you'd like us to<00:01:51.040> cover<00:01:51.280> in<00:01:51.439> the<00:01:51.520> future

00:01:52

to cover in the future

00:01:52

to cover in the future by<00:01:52.479> emailing<00:01:53.119> podcast<00:01:54.159> another<00:01:54.560> europe.org

00:01:55

by emailing podcast another europe.org

00:01:55

by emailing podcast another europe.org you<00:01:55.840> can<00:01:56.000> also<00:01:56.240> support<00:01:56.640> the<00:01:56.719> podcast<00:01:57.280> by

00:01:57

you can also support the podcast by

00:01:57

you can also support the podcast by leaving<00:01:57.759> a<00:01:57.920> rating<00:01:58.320> or<00:01:58.479> review

00:01:59

leaving a rating or review

00:01:59

leaving a rating or review on<00:01:59.280> your<00:01:59.439> podcast<00:02:00.000> platform<00:02:00.880> an<00:02:01.119> extended

00:02:01

on your podcast platform an extended

00:02:01

on your podcast platform an extended version<00:02:02.000> of<00:02:02.079> this<00:02:02.320> podcast<00:02:02.880> is<00:02:02.960> available<00:02:03.439> to

00:02:03

version of this podcast is available to

00:02:03

version of this podcast is available to members<00:02:04.079> of<00:02:04.240> another<00:02:04.640> europe<00:02:04.960> is<00:02:05.200> possible

00:02:05

members of another europe is possible

00:02:05

members of another europe is possible another<00:02:06.320> europe<00:02:06.640> is<00:02:06.799> the<00:02:06.960> home<00:02:07.280> of<00:02:07.360> the

00:02:07

another europe is the home of the

00:02:07

another europe is the home of the european<00:02:08.160> left<00:02:08.479> in<00:02:08.560> britain

00:02:09

european left in britain

00:02:09

european left in britain by<00:02:09.520> joining<00:02:09.920> us<00:02:10.160> you<00:02:10.399> participate<00:02:11.200> in<00:02:11.360> our

00:02:11

by joining us you participate in our

00:02:11

by joining us you participate in our movement<00:02:11.920> building<00:02:12.319> efforts<00:02:12.640> to<00:02:12.800> confront

00:02:13

movement building efforts to confront

00:02:13

movement building efforts to confront injustice

00:02:14

injustice

00:02:14

injustice oppose<00:02:15.120> brexit<00:02:15.680> disaster<00:02:16.400> capitalism<00:02:17.440> and

00:02:17

oppose brexit disaster capitalism and

00:02:17

oppose brexit disaster capitalism and promote<00:02:18.160> grassroots<00:02:19.000> internationalism

00:02:20

promote grassroots internationalism

00:02:20

promote grassroots internationalism to<00:02:20.640> join<00:02:21.200> support<00:02:21.599> our<00:02:21.840> work<00:02:22.160> and<00:02:22.319> gain<00:02:22.640> access

00:02:23

to join support our work and gain access

00:02:23

to join support our work and gain access to<00:02:23.280> an<00:02:23.440> extended<00:02:24.000> version<00:02:24.319> of<00:02:24.400> this<00:02:24.640> podcast

00:02:25

to an extended version of this podcast

00:02:25

to an extended version of this podcast go<00:02:25.760> to<00:02:25.920> another<00:02:26.319> europe.org<00:02:27.440> forward<00:02:27.760> slash

00:02:28

go to another europe.org forward slash

00:02:28

go to another europe.org forward slash join

00:02:35

gary<00:02:35.440> welcome<00:02:35.760> to<00:02:35.840> the<00:02:36.000> show<00:02:36.800> so<00:02:37.200> tell<00:02:37.519> us<00:02:37.760> how

00:02:37

gary welcome to the show so tell us how

00:02:37

gary welcome to the show so tell us how did<00:02:38.080> you<00:02:38.160> come<00:02:38.400> to<00:02:38.480> work<00:02:38.720> as<00:02:38.879> a<00:02:38.959> trader

00:02:39

did you come to work as a trader

00:02:39

did you come to work as a trader and<00:02:39.680> what<00:02:39.840> was<00:02:40.080> it<00:02:40.160> like<00:02:40.879> but<00:02:41.040> it's<00:02:41.200> a<00:02:41.280> funny

00:02:41

and what was it like but it's a funny

00:02:41

and what was it like but it's a funny story<00:02:42.000> actually<00:02:42.400> um<00:02:42.720> i<00:02:42.879> actually<00:02:43.120> won<00:02:43.360> my

00:02:43

story actually um i actually won my

00:02:43

story actually um i actually won my job<00:02:44.640> trading<00:02:45.040> in<00:02:45.120> a<00:02:45.200> card<00:02:45.519> game<00:02:45.680> when<00:02:45.840> i<00:02:45.920> was<00:02:46.080> at

00:02:46

job trading in a card game when i was at

00:02:46

job trading in a card game when i was at university

00:02:47

university

00:02:47

university seems<00:02:47.920> strange<00:02:48.239> but<00:02:48.400> i<00:02:48.480> guess<00:02:48.720> that's<00:02:49.440> how

00:02:49

seems strange but i guess that's how

00:02:49

seems strange but i guess that's how things<00:02:49.920> happen<00:02:50.239> sometimes

00:02:50

things happen sometimes

00:02:50

things happen sometimes pre-financial<00:02:51.599> crisis<00:02:52.080> so<00:02:52.239> i<00:02:52.400> did<00:02:52.560> my

00:02:52

pre-financial crisis so i did my

00:02:52

pre-financial crisis so i did my undergrad<00:02:53.120> at<00:02:53.280> lsc<00:02:53.760> london<00:02:54.000> school<00:02:54.160> of

00:02:54

undergrad at lsc london school of

00:02:54

undergrad at lsc london school of economics

00:02:55

economics

00:02:55

economics i<00:02:55.360> don't<00:02:55.519> know<00:02:55.519> if<00:02:55.599> you<00:02:55.680> know<00:02:55.920> the<00:02:56.000> university

00:02:56

i don't know if you know the university

00:02:56

i don't know if you know the university well<00:02:56.560> but<00:02:56.959> back<00:02:57.200> then<00:02:57.519> i'm<00:02:57.680> guessing<00:02:57.920> it's

00:02:57

well but back then i'm guessing it's

00:02:58

well but back then i'm guessing it's still<00:02:58.239> the<00:02:58.319> same<00:02:58.560> now

00:02:59

still the same now

00:02:59

still the same now it<00:02:59.280> was<00:02:59.360> a<00:02:59.440> bit<00:02:59.599> of<00:02:59.680> a<00:02:59.840> mad<00:03:00.159> place<00:03:00.480> where<00:03:00.959> a<00:03:01.120> lot

00:03:01

it was a bit of a mad place where a lot

00:03:01

it was a bit of a mad place where a lot of<00:03:01.360> people<00:03:01.599> were

00:03:02

of people were

00:03:02

of people were borderline<00:03:02.800> obsessed<00:03:03.120> with<00:03:03.280> getting<00:03:03.599> jobs<00:03:03.840> in

00:03:03

borderline obsessed with getting jobs in

00:03:03

borderline obsessed with getting jobs in investment<00:03:04.319> banking<00:03:04.959> i<00:03:05.120> remember<00:03:05.360> i<00:03:05.440> did<00:03:05.599> my

00:03:05

investment banking i remember i did my

00:03:05

investment banking i remember i did my first<00:03:06.000> year<00:03:06.159> i<00:03:06.239> came<00:03:06.400> back<00:03:06.560> in<00:03:06.720> second<00:03:06.959> year

00:03:07

first year i came back in second year

00:03:07

first year i came back in second year and<00:03:07.280> just<00:03:07.440> suddenly

00:03:08

and just suddenly

00:03:08

and just suddenly everyone<00:03:09.040> was<00:03:09.280> applying<00:03:09.680> for<00:03:09.840> 20<00:03:10.400> 30

00:03:10

everyone was applying for 20 30

00:03:10

everyone was applying for 20 30 different<00:03:11.200> investment<00:03:11.680> banks<00:03:12.159> and

00:03:13

different investment banks and

00:03:13

different investment banks and they're<00:03:13.440> applying<00:03:13.760> to<00:03:13.840> all<00:03:14.000> these<00:03:14.159> different

00:03:14

they're applying to all these different

00:03:14

they're applying to all these different divisions<00:03:14.959> which<00:03:15.280> all<00:03:15.519> seem<00:03:15.680> to<00:03:15.840> have

00:03:16

divisions which all seem to have

00:03:16

divisions which all seem to have acronym<00:03:17.120> names<00:03:17.760> ibd<00:03:18.560> and<00:03:18.959> m<00:03:19.280> a<00:03:19.519> or

00:03:19

acronym names ibd and m a or

00:03:20

acronym names ibd and m a or nbs<00:03:20.640> trading<00:03:21.200> with<00:03:21.519> cds<00:03:22.159> and<00:03:22.480> i<00:03:22.640> really<00:03:22.879> didn't

00:03:23

nbs trading with cds and i really didn't

00:03:23

nbs trading with cds and i really didn't have<00:03:23.200> any<00:03:23.440> idea

00:03:24

have any idea

00:03:24

have any idea what<00:03:24.480> was<00:03:24.560> going<00:03:24.879> on<00:03:25.120> for<00:03:25.280> me<00:03:25.440> it<00:03:25.519> was<00:03:25.680> quite

00:03:26

what was going on for me it was quite

00:03:26

what was going on for me it was quite intimidating<00:03:26.720> really<00:03:27.040> because<00:03:27.200> i

00:03:27

intimidating really because i

00:03:27

intimidating really because i i<00:03:27.680> don't<00:03:27.840> really<00:03:28.000> know<00:03:28.159> anyone<00:03:28.319> who<00:03:28.400> comes<00:03:28.560> to

00:03:28

i don't really know anyone who comes to

00:03:28

i don't really know anyone who comes to that<00:03:28.720> sort<00:03:28.879> of<00:03:28.959> background<00:03:30.000> somewhere<00:03:30.319> from

00:03:30

that sort of background somewhere from

00:03:30

that sort of background somewhere from the<00:03:30.560> year<00:03:30.720> above

00:03:31

the year above

00:03:31

the year above approached<00:03:32.159> me<00:03:32.319> and<00:03:32.480> he<00:03:32.640> was<00:03:32.799> being<00:03:33.040> paid<00:03:33.280> by

00:03:33

approached me and he was being paid by

00:03:33

approached me and he was being paid by citibank<00:03:34.000> he<00:03:34.239> he'd<00:03:34.480> interned<00:03:34.799> at<00:03:34.879> seat<00:03:35.120> bank

00:03:35

citibank he he'd interned at seat bank

00:03:35

citibank he he'd interned at seat bank year<00:03:35.519> before

00:03:36

year before

00:03:36

year before and<00:03:36.319> he<00:03:36.400> was<00:03:36.560> being<00:03:36.799> paid<00:03:36.959> to<00:03:37.120> sort<00:03:37.280> of<00:03:37.360> do<00:03:37.519> some

00:03:37

and he was being paid to sort of do some

00:03:37

and he was being paid to sort of do some sort<00:03:37.840> of<00:03:38.000> talent<00:03:38.400> scouting<00:03:38.879> or<00:03:38.959> something

00:03:39

sort of talent scouting or something

00:03:40

sort of talent scouting or something he<00:03:40.159> approached<00:03:40.560> me<00:03:40.640> and<00:03:40.799> said<00:03:41.040> oh<00:03:41.360> we'll<00:03:41.599> see

00:03:41

he approached me and said oh we'll see

00:03:41

he approached me and said oh we'll see bank<00:03:42.000> high<00:03:42.159> as<00:03:42.239> one<00:03:42.480> trader<00:03:42.720> year<00:03:42.959> through<00:03:43.120> a

00:03:43

bank high as one trader year through a

00:03:43

bank high as one trader year through a maths<00:03:43.519> game

00:03:44

maths game

00:03:44

maths game um<00:03:44.959> i<00:03:45.040> heard<00:03:45.200> you're<00:03:45.360> pretty<00:03:45.519> good<00:03:45.680> at<00:03:45.760> math<00:03:46.000> so

00:03:46

um i heard you're pretty good at math so

00:03:46

um i heard you're pretty good at math so maybe<00:03:46.400> you<00:03:46.480> should<00:03:46.799> try<00:03:47.040> that

00:03:48

maybe you should try that

00:03:48

maybe you should try that so<00:03:48.239> i<00:03:48.319> thought<00:03:48.560> why<00:03:48.720> not<00:03:48.879> i'll<00:03:49.040> give<00:03:49.280> it<00:03:49.360> a<00:03:49.440> go

00:03:50

so i thought why not i'll give it a go

00:03:50

so i thought why not i'll give it a go so<00:03:50.560> i<00:03:50.640> turned<00:03:50.879> up<00:03:50.959> for<00:03:51.120> this<00:03:51.200> math<00:03:51.440> competition

00:03:51

so i turned up for this math competition

00:03:52

so i turned up for this math competition and<00:03:52.159> it<00:03:52.239> was<00:03:52.400> kind<00:03:52.640> of<00:03:52.720> like<00:03:52.879> it<00:03:52.959> was<00:03:53.040> a<00:03:53.120> card

00:03:53

and it was kind of like it was a card

00:03:53

and it was kind of like it was a card game<00:03:53.599> like<00:03:53.760> a<00:03:53.840> sort<00:03:54.000> of

00:03:54

game like a sort of

00:03:54

game like a sort of supposed<00:03:54.720> to<00:03:54.799> be<00:03:54.879> a<00:03:55.040> trading<00:03:55.360> style<00:03:55.680> game<00:03:56.000> you

00:03:56

supposed to be a trading style game you

00:03:56

supposed to be a trading style game you buy<00:03:56.560> and<00:03:56.720> you<00:03:56.879> sell

00:03:57

buy and you sell

00:03:57

buy and you sell but<00:03:58.400> it's<00:03:58.480> hard<00:03:58.959> it<00:03:59.040> was<00:03:59.200> a<00:03:59.280> maths<00:03:59.519> game<00:03:59.920> so<00:04:00.319> i

00:04:00

but it's hard it was a maths game so i

00:04:00

but it's hard it was a maths game so i just<00:04:00.720> ended<00:04:00.959> that<00:04:01.120> game<00:04:01.439> and

00:04:02

just ended that game and

00:04:02

just ended that game and i<00:04:02.400> won<00:04:02.640> the<00:04:02.720> first<00:04:03.040> round<00:04:03.280> i<00:04:03.360> got<00:04:03.519> through<00:04:03.680> to

00:04:03

i won the first round i got through to

00:04:03

i won the first round i got through to the<00:04:03.920> final<00:04:04.239> and<00:04:04.319> then<00:04:04.560> i<00:04:04.720> i<00:04:04.879> studied<00:04:05.280> it<00:04:05.360> a<00:04:05.439> lot

00:04:05

the final and then i i studied it a lot

00:04:05

the final and then i i studied it a lot i<00:04:05.840> went<00:04:06.000> to<00:04:06.159> the<00:04:06.239> final<00:04:06.640> and<00:04:06.879> and<00:04:06.959> i<00:04:07.040> won<00:04:07.280> that

00:04:07

i went to the final and and i won that

00:04:07

i went to the final and and i won that and<00:04:07.519> i<00:04:07.840> got<00:04:08.000> a<00:04:08.080> job

00:04:08

and i got a job

00:04:08

and i got a job i<00:04:09.120> was<00:04:09.599> completely<00:04:10.000> mad<00:04:10.560> yeah<00:04:10.879> it<00:04:10.959> was<00:04:11.200> i<00:04:11.280> was

00:04:11

i was completely mad yeah it was i was

00:04:11

i was completely mad yeah it was i was working<00:04:11.599> at<00:04:11.680> dfs<00:04:12.159> fluffing<00:04:12.480> pillows<00:04:12.799> at<00:04:12.879> the

00:04:12

working at dfs fluffing pillows at the

00:04:12

working at dfs fluffing pillows at the time<00:04:13.200> in<00:04:13.360> weekends<00:04:13.760> and<00:04:13.840> holidays

00:04:14

time in weekends and holidays

00:04:14

time in weekends and holidays getting<00:04:15.120> paid<00:04:15.360> 45<00:04:15.840> pounds<00:04:16.079> a<00:04:16.160> day<00:04:16.720> i<00:04:16.880> don't

00:04:17

getting paid 45 pounds a day i don't

00:04:17

getting paid 45 pounds a day i don't believe<00:04:17.280> you<00:04:17.440> quite<00:04:17.600> believe<00:04:17.840> that<00:04:17.919> i'd

00:04:17

believe you quite believe that i'd

00:04:18

believe you quite believe that i'd manage<00:04:18.239> to<00:04:18.320> get<00:04:18.400> a<00:04:18.479> job<00:04:18.720> in<00:04:18.799> this<00:04:19.040> bizarre

00:04:19

manage to get a job in this bizarre

00:04:19

manage to get a job in this bizarre fashion<00:04:19.759> but

00:04:20

fashion but

00:04:20

fashion but you<00:04:20.320> know<00:04:20.400> i<00:04:20.479> won<00:04:20.639> the<00:04:20.720> game<00:04:21.040> so<00:04:21.199> it's<00:04:21.440> great

00:04:21

you know i won the game so it's great

00:04:21

you know i won the game so it's great and<00:04:21.759> then<00:04:21.919> i<00:04:22.240> turned<00:04:22.560> up

00:04:23

and then i turned up

00:04:23

and then i turned up on<00:04:23.360> the<00:04:23.440> trading<00:04:23.759> floor<00:04:24.080> and<00:04:24.160> i<00:04:24.240> would<00:04:24.400> have

00:04:24

on the trading floor and i would have

00:04:24

on the trading floor and i would have just<00:04:24.639> turned<00:04:24.880> 20.<00:04:25.360> i<00:04:25.520> didn't<00:04:25.759> really<00:04:25.840> know

00:04:25

just turned 20. i didn't really know

00:04:26

just turned 20. i didn't really know what's<00:04:26.160> going<00:04:26.320> on<00:04:26.479> i<00:04:26.560> was<00:04:26.639> just<00:04:26.880> offering<00:04:27.120> to

00:04:27

what's going on i was just offering to

00:04:27

what's going on i was just offering to buy<00:04:27.440> people<00:04:27.759> coffees<00:04:28.080> and<00:04:28.160> go<00:04:28.400> get<00:04:28.560> lunches

00:04:29

buy people coffees and go get lunches

00:04:29

buy people coffees and go get lunches because

00:04:29

because

00:04:29

because that's<00:04:29.759> supposed<00:04:29.919> to<00:04:30.080> do<00:04:30.160> with<00:04:30.240> dfs<00:04:31.919> but<00:04:32.240> yeah

00:04:32

that's supposed to do with dfs but yeah

00:04:32

that's supposed to do with dfs but yeah they<00:04:32.720> they<00:04:32.880> liked<00:04:33.199> me<00:04:33.360> i<00:04:33.759> i<00:04:33.919> didn't<00:04:34.080> know

00:04:34

they they liked me i i didn't know

00:04:34

they they liked me i i didn't know what's<00:04:34.400> going<00:04:34.560> on<00:04:34.720> i<00:04:34.880> don't<00:04:34.960> know<00:04:35.040> if<00:04:35.120> you've

00:04:35

what's going on i don't know if you've

00:04:35

what's going on i don't know if you've been<00:04:35.360> on<00:04:35.440> a<00:04:35.520> trading<00:04:35.759> field<00:04:35.919> but<00:04:36.080> it's<00:04:36.240> a<00:04:36.320> crazy

00:04:36

been on a trading field but it's a crazy

00:04:36

been on a trading field but it's a crazy place

00:04:37

place

00:04:37

place it's<00:04:37.280> a<00:04:37.440> huge<00:04:38.400> huge<00:04:38.720> huge<00:04:39.040> room<00:04:39.360> and

00:04:39

it's a huge huge huge room and

00:04:39

it's a huge huge huge room and everyone's<00:04:40.080> got<00:04:40.240> like<00:04:40.479> six<00:04:40.800> or<00:04:40.880> seven<00:04:41.199> or<00:04:41.280> even

00:04:41

everyone's got like six or seven or even

00:04:41

everyone's got like six or seven or even nine

00:04:42

nine

00:04:42

nine monitors<00:04:42.720> and<00:04:43.199> lots<00:04:43.440> of<00:04:43.520> shouting<00:04:43.919> and<00:04:44.000> lots

00:04:44

monitors and lots of shouting and lots

00:04:44

monitors and lots of shouting and lots of<00:04:44.320> noise<00:04:44.720> and

00:04:45

of noise and

00:04:45

of noise and yeah<00:04:45.840> it<00:04:45.919> took<00:04:46.080> a<00:04:46.160> bit<00:04:46.240> of<00:04:46.400> time<00:04:46.639> to<00:04:47.120> figure<00:04:47.440> out

00:04:47

yeah it took a bit of time to figure out

00:04:47

yeah it took a bit of time to figure out what<00:04:47.680> was<00:04:47.840> happening<00:04:48.639> and<00:04:48.800> what<00:04:49.040> and<00:04:49.120> what

00:04:49

what was happening and what and what

00:04:49

what was happening and what and what year<00:04:49.600> was<00:04:49.759> that<00:04:49.919> was<00:04:50.080> that

00:04:50

year was that was that

00:04:50

year was that was that that<00:04:50.639> must<00:04:50.800> have<00:04:50.880> been<00:04:51.040> before<00:04:51.440> the<00:04:51.759> financial

00:04:52

that must have been before the financial

00:04:52

that must have been before the financial crash<00:04:52.639> right<00:04:52.960> so<00:04:53.120> my<00:04:53.360> internships<00:04:53.840> would<00:04:54.000> have

00:04:54

crash right so my internships would have

00:04:54

crash right so my internships would have been<00:04:54.160> in<00:04:54.240> 2006<00:04:54.960> and<00:04:55.040> 2007

00:04:55

been in 2006 and 2007

00:04:55

been in 2006 and 2007 because<00:04:56.240> i<00:04:56.400> started<00:04:56.880> full<00:04:57.199> time<00:04:57.520> in<00:04:57.680> 2008

00:04:59

because i started full time in 2008

00:04:59

because i started full time in 2008 right<00:05:00.000> right<00:05:00.240> right<00:05:00.479> right<00:05:00.880> so<00:05:01.120> you<00:05:01.280> basically

00:05:01

right right right right so you basically

00:05:01

right right right right so you basically arrived<00:05:02.160> just<00:05:02.400> in<00:05:02.479> time<00:05:02.720> for<00:05:02.880> this

00:05:03

arrived just in time for this

00:05:03

arrived just in time for this unbelievable<00:05:04.160> explosion<00:05:05.440> which<00:05:05.680> must<00:05:05.919> have

00:05:06

unbelievable explosion which must have

00:05:06

unbelievable explosion which must have been<00:05:06.400> an<00:05:06.560> experience

00:05:07

been an experience

00:05:07

been an experience kind<00:05:08.000> of<00:05:08.160> in<00:05:08.320> itself<00:05:09.120> what<00:05:09.360> um<00:05:09.600> what<00:05:09.840> was<00:05:10.080> the

00:05:10

kind of in itself what um what was the

00:05:10

kind of in itself what um what was the atmosphere<00:05:10.639> like<00:05:10.880> then<00:05:11.039> did<00:05:11.199> you

00:05:11

atmosphere like then did you

00:05:12

atmosphere like then did you did<00:05:12.320> did<00:05:12.479> it<00:05:12.639> seem<00:05:12.880> really<00:05:13.199> extreme<00:05:13.680> or

00:05:13

did did it seem really extreme or

00:05:13

did did it seem really extreme or because<00:05:14.160> you'd<00:05:14.320> had<00:05:14.400> nothing<00:05:14.639> to<00:05:14.720> compare<00:05:15.120> it

00:05:15

because you'd had nothing to compare it

00:05:15

because you'd had nothing to compare it to

00:05:15

to did<00:05:16.000> it<00:05:16.080> just<00:05:16.240> seem<00:05:16.400> like<00:05:16.560> they<00:05:16.720> were<00:05:16.800> extreme

00:05:17

did it just seem like they were extreme

00:05:17

did it just seem like they were extreme already<00:05:17.680> i<00:05:17.840> started<00:05:18.160> full<00:05:18.320> time<00:05:18.560> in<00:05:18.639> june<00:05:18.800> 2008

00:05:19

already i started full time in june 2008

00:05:19

already i started full time in june 2008 right<00:05:19.680> so<00:05:19.840> the

00:05:20

right so the

00:05:20

right so the the<00:05:20.320> lima<00:05:20.639> crisis<00:05:20.960> was<00:05:21.280> really<00:05:21.520> soon<00:05:21.840> after<00:05:22.080> i

00:05:22

the lima crisis was really soon after i

00:05:22

the lima crisis was really soon after i began<00:05:22.880> lehman<00:05:23.199> brothers<00:05:23.520> staff<00:05:23.919> arrived<00:05:24.320> at

00:05:24

began lehman brothers staff arrived at

00:05:24

began lehman brothers staff arrived at work<00:05:24.720> in<00:05:24.800> london<00:05:25.199> this<00:05:25.360> morning<00:05:25.600> to<00:05:25.759> be<00:05:25.919> told

00:05:26

work in london this morning to be told

00:05:26

work in london this morning to be told the<00:05:26.240> bank<00:05:26.479> had<00:05:26.639> been<00:05:26.800> put<00:05:27.039> into

00:05:27

the bank had been put into

00:05:27

the bank had been put into administration

00:05:28

administration

00:05:28

administration stocks<00:05:28.960> all<00:05:29.120> around<00:05:29.440> the<00:05:29.520> world<00:05:29.919> are<00:05:30.160> tanking

00:05:30

stocks all around the world are tanking

00:05:30

stocks all around the world are tanking because<00:05:31.360> of<00:05:31.440> the<00:05:31.600> crisis<00:05:32.240> on<00:05:32.479> wall<00:05:32.720> street

00:05:33

because of the crisis on wall street

00:05:33

because of the crisis on wall street at<00:05:33.280> the<00:05:33.440> time<00:05:33.759> i<00:05:33.840> was<00:05:34.240> a<00:05:34.320> bit<00:05:34.560> too

00:05:35

at the time i was a bit too

00:05:35

at the time i was a bit too inexperienced<00:05:35.840> really<00:05:36.160> perhaps<00:05:36.840> to

00:05:38

inexperienced really perhaps to

00:05:38

inexperienced really perhaps to grasp<00:05:38.960> the<00:05:39.039> severity<00:05:39.520> of<00:05:39.680> it<00:05:39.840> but<00:05:40.080> you<00:05:40.160> know

00:05:40

grasp the severity of it but you know

00:05:40

grasp the severity of it but you know the<00:05:40.560> traders<00:05:40.880> let<00:05:41.039> me<00:05:41.120> know

00:05:41

the traders let me know

00:05:41

the traders let me know they<00:05:42.000> said<00:05:42.160> like<00:05:42.320> this<00:05:42.560> is<00:05:42.960> a<00:05:43.120> massive<00:05:43.600> massive

00:05:43

they said like this is a massive massive

00:05:44

they said like this is a massive massive deal<00:05:44.240> here<00:05:44.560> sort<00:05:44.720> of<00:05:44.800> amounts<00:05:45.199> of<00:05:45.280> money<00:05:45.520> being

00:05:45

deal here sort of amounts of money being

00:05:45

deal here sort of amounts of money being made<00:05:46.000> and<00:05:46.080> lost<00:05:46.400> were<00:05:46.560> much<00:05:46.800> much

00:05:47

made and lost were much much

00:05:47

made and lost were much much bigger<00:05:48.479> people<00:05:48.720> were<00:05:48.880> saying<00:05:49.199> you<00:05:49.280> know

00:05:49

bigger people were saying you know

00:05:50

bigger people were saying you know citibank<00:05:50.400> was<00:05:50.560> bowed<00:05:50.880> out<00:05:50.960> by<00:05:51.120> the<00:05:51.280> american

00:05:51

citibank was bowed out by the american

00:05:51

citibank was bowed out by the american government<00:05:52.240> and

00:05:52

government and

00:05:52

government and relatively<00:05:53.600> quickly<00:05:54.000> people<00:05:54.240> realized<00:05:54.639> that

00:05:54

relatively quickly people realized that

00:05:54

relatively quickly people realized that the<00:05:54.880> solvency<00:05:55.360> of<00:05:55.600> the<00:05:55.759> bank

00:05:56

the solvency of the bank

00:05:56

the solvency of the bank was<00:05:57.199> under<00:05:57.440> threat<00:05:57.680> but<00:05:57.840> also<00:05:58.240> that<00:05:58.400> there<00:05:58.560> was

00:05:58

was under threat but also that there was

00:05:58

was under threat but also that there was a<00:05:58.800> sovereignty<00:05:59.199> of<00:05:59.280> basically<00:05:59.600> every<00:05:59.759> bank

00:06:00

a sovereignty of basically every bank

00:06:00

a sovereignty of basically every bank under<00:06:00.639> threat<00:06:01.039> so<00:06:01.520> right<00:06:02.720> they<00:06:02.960> knew<00:06:03.199> it<00:06:03.280> was

00:06:03

under threat so right they knew it was

00:06:03

under threat so right they knew it was serious<00:06:04.560> i<00:06:04.800> knew<00:06:05.039> it<00:06:05.120> was<00:06:05.680> serious<00:06:06.160> without

00:06:06

serious i knew it was serious without

00:06:06

serious i knew it was serious without really

00:06:07

really

00:06:07

really knowing<00:06:07.440> what<00:06:07.680> serious<00:06:08.160> meant<00:06:08.400> if<00:06:08.560> that<00:06:08.720> makes

00:06:08

knowing what serious meant if that makes

00:06:08

knowing what serious meant if that makes sense<00:06:09.280> because<00:06:09.520> i<00:06:09.919> was<00:06:10.080> so<00:06:10.319> young

00:06:10

sense because i was so young

00:06:10

sense because i was so young i<00:06:10.880> was<00:06:11.039> sort<00:06:11.199> of<00:06:11.360> taking<00:06:11.680> it<00:06:12.720> i<00:06:12.800> could<00:06:13.039> see<00:06:13.199> the

00:06:13

i was sort of taking it i could see the

00:06:13

i was sort of taking it i could see the emotion<00:06:13.840> from

00:06:14

emotion from

00:06:14

emotion from the<00:06:14.479> traders<00:06:14.960> at<00:06:15.120> lse<00:06:15.600> everyone's<00:06:15.919> applying

00:06:16

the traders at lse everyone's applying

00:06:16

the traders at lse everyone's applying for<00:06:16.400> 20<00:06:16.639> 30<00:06:16.880> banks<00:06:17.199> it's<00:06:17.360> kind<00:06:17.520> of<00:06:17.600> random<00:06:18.000> what

00:06:18

for 20 30 banks it's kind of random what

00:06:18

for 20 30 banks it's kind of random what banks<00:06:18.400> you<00:06:18.560> end<00:06:18.720> up<00:06:18.880> at<00:06:18.960> you<00:06:19.039> know<00:06:19.199> so<00:06:19.280> i<00:06:19.360> had<00:06:19.440> a

00:06:19

banks you end up at you know so i had a

00:06:19

banks you end up at you know so i had a couple<00:06:19.680> of<00:06:19.840> friends<00:06:20.160> who<00:06:20.319> were<00:06:20.479> at<00:06:20.560> lehman

00:06:21

couple of friends who were at lehman

00:06:21

couple of friends who were at lehman and<00:06:21.680> just<00:06:22.000> you<00:06:22.080> know<00:06:22.240> a<00:06:22.319> couple<00:06:22.560> years<00:06:22.800> into

00:06:22

and just you know a couple years into

00:06:22

and just you know a couple years into their<00:06:23.039> career<00:06:23.360> they<00:06:23.440> suddenly<00:06:23.759> lost<00:06:24.000> their

00:06:24

their career they suddenly lost their

00:06:24

their career they suddenly lost their jobs<00:06:24.400> so

00:06:24

jobs so

00:06:24

jobs so the<00:06:25.120> kind<00:06:25.280> of<00:06:25.440> overall<00:06:25.919> mood<00:06:26.319> did<00:06:26.560> it<00:06:26.880> feel

00:06:27

the kind of overall mood did it feel

00:06:27

the kind of overall mood did it feel like<00:06:27.440> kind<00:06:27.600> of<00:06:27.680> in<00:06:27.840> the<00:06:28.000> eye<00:06:28.160> of<00:06:28.240> the<00:06:28.400> crisis

00:06:29

like kind of in the eye of the crisis

00:06:29

like kind of in the eye of the crisis did<00:06:29.280> your<00:06:29.520> colleagues<00:06:30.080> seem<00:06:30.639> like<00:06:30.960> they

00:06:31

did your colleagues seem like they

00:06:31

did your colleagues seem like they thought<00:06:31.280> there<00:06:31.440> was<00:06:31.600> a<00:06:31.680> big<00:06:32.000> reckoning<00:06:32.479> coming

00:06:33

thought there was a big reckoning coming

00:06:33

thought there was a big reckoning coming with<00:06:33.520> the<00:06:33.680> way<00:06:34.560> the<00:06:34.720> system<00:06:35.120> worked<00:06:35.440> the<00:06:35.520> way

00:06:35

with the way the system worked the way

00:06:35

with the way the system worked the way the<00:06:35.759> economic<00:06:36.240> model<00:06:36.560> worked<00:06:36.800> the<00:06:36.880> way

00:06:37

the economic model worked the way

00:06:37

the economic model worked the way finance<00:06:37.680> plugged<00:06:38.000> into<00:06:38.240> that

00:06:38

finance plugged into that

00:06:38

finance plugged into that or<00:06:40.400> were<00:06:40.639> people<00:06:40.880> not<00:06:41.120> thinking<00:06:41.600> in<00:06:41.680> that<00:06:41.919> kind

00:06:42

or were people not thinking in that kind

00:06:42

or were people not thinking in that kind of

00:06:42

of way<00:06:43.440> on<00:06:43.520> the<00:06:43.680> trading<00:06:44.080> floor<00:06:44.479> traders<00:06:44.960> are

00:06:45

way on the trading floor traders are

00:06:45

way on the trading floor traders are very<00:06:45.520> very

00:06:46

very very

00:06:46

very very focused<00:06:46.639> on<00:06:46.880> making<00:06:47.280> money<00:06:47.919> they're<00:06:48.080> not

00:06:48

focused on making money they're not

00:06:48

focused on making money they're not really<00:06:48.560> incentivized<00:06:49.360> to<00:06:49.599> think<00:06:49.840> about

00:06:50

really incentivized to think about

00:06:50

really incentivized to think about what's<00:06:51.120> happening<00:06:51.440> with<00:06:51.599> the<00:06:51.759> system

00:06:52

what's happening with the system

00:06:52

what's happening with the system especially<00:06:53.120> not<00:06:53.280> on<00:06:53.440> any<00:06:53.599> sort<00:06:53.759> of

00:06:54

especially not on any sort of

00:06:54

especially not on any sort of moral<00:06:54.639> or<00:06:54.800> human<00:06:55.120> sense<00:06:55.360> they're<00:06:55.520> very

00:06:55

moral or human sense they're very

00:06:55

moral or human sense they're very incentivized<00:06:56.240> to<00:06:56.400> make<00:06:56.639> predictions

00:06:57

incentivized to make predictions

00:06:57

incentivized to make predictions so<00:06:57.680> they<00:06:57.840> might<00:06:58.080> be<00:06:58.160> thinking<00:06:58.479> about<00:06:59.520> for

00:06:59

so they might be thinking about for

00:06:59

so they might be thinking about for example<00:06:59.919> in<00:07:00.000> the<00:07:00.160> area<00:07:00.400> where<00:07:00.639> i<00:07:00.800> worked

00:07:01

example in the area where i worked

00:07:01

example in the area where i worked a<00:07:01.599> big<00:07:01.840> part<00:07:02.000> of<00:07:02.080> what<00:07:02.240> we<00:07:02.639> did<00:07:02.880> and<00:07:02.960> what<00:07:03.120> we

00:07:03

a big part of what we did and what we

00:07:03

a big part of what we did and what we were<00:07:03.360> supposed<00:07:03.680> to<00:07:03.759> do<00:07:04.319> was

00:07:05

were supposed to do was

00:07:05

were supposed to do was predict<00:07:05.599> the<00:07:05.680> strength<00:07:06.000> of<00:07:06.160> the<00:07:06.240> future

00:07:06

predict the strength of the future

00:07:06

predict the strength of the future economy<00:07:06.960> so<00:07:07.599> obviously<00:07:08.080> we<00:07:08.319> have<00:07:08.479> to<00:07:08.560> do<00:07:08.720> a<00:07:08.800> lot

00:07:08

economy so obviously we have to do a lot

00:07:08

economy so obviously we have to do a lot of<00:07:09.039> that<00:07:09.120> you<00:07:09.199> know<00:07:09.360> and<00:07:09.440> there<00:07:09.599> was<00:07:09.680> a<00:07:09.759> guy<00:07:10.000> on

00:07:10

of that you know and there was a guy on

00:07:10

of that you know and there was a guy on my<00:07:10.400> team<00:07:10.639> who

00:07:11

my team who

00:07:11

my team who did<00:07:11.440> really<00:07:11.680> well<00:07:11.919> which<00:07:12.080> was<00:07:12.240> just<00:07:12.319> saying

00:07:12

did really well which was just saying

00:07:12

did really well which was just saying this<00:07:12.639> is<00:07:12.720> going<00:07:12.880> to<00:07:12.960> be<00:07:13.039> a<00:07:13.120> disaster<00:07:13.599> it's

00:07:13

this is going to be a disaster it's

00:07:13

this is going to be a disaster it's going<00:07:13.840> to<00:07:13.919> last<00:07:14.160> a<00:07:14.319> really<00:07:14.479> really<00:07:14.720> long<00:07:14.960> time

00:07:15

going to last a really really long time

00:07:15

going to last a really really long time we're<00:07:15.840> not<00:07:16.000> going<00:07:16.080> to<00:07:16.160> get<00:07:16.319> out<00:07:16.400> of<00:07:16.479> this<00:07:16.560> for

00:07:16

we're not going to get out of this for

00:07:16

we're not going to get out of this for ages<00:07:17.120> and<00:07:17.440> he<00:07:17.520> made<00:07:17.680> a<00:07:17.759> lot<00:07:17.840> of<00:07:17.919> money<00:07:18.240> on<00:07:18.400> that

00:07:18

ages and he made a lot of money on that

00:07:18

ages and he made a lot of money on that but

00:07:19

but

00:07:19

but there's<00:07:20.000> no<00:07:21.120> you're<00:07:21.280> not<00:07:21.440> incentivized<00:07:22.160> to

00:07:23

there's no you're not incentivized to

00:07:23

there's no you're not incentivized to think<00:07:23.919> about<00:07:24.080> what<00:07:24.240> that<00:07:24.479> means<00:07:24.880> really

00:07:25

think about what that means really

00:07:25

think about what that means really you're<00:07:25.360> very<00:07:25.680> very<00:07:25.840> heavily<00:07:26.160> incentivized<00:07:26.720> to

00:07:26

you're very very heavily incentivized to

00:07:26

you're very very heavily incentivized to make

00:07:27

make

00:07:27

make correct<00:07:27.919> predictions<00:07:28.960> so<00:07:29.199> there's<00:07:29.360> not

00:07:29

correct predictions so there's not

00:07:29

correct predictions so there's not really<00:07:29.680> much<00:07:30.000> space<00:07:30.319> for<00:07:30.479> sort<00:07:30.720> of<00:07:30.880> sitting

00:07:31

really much space for sort of sitting

00:07:31

really much space for sort of sitting and<00:07:31.360> pondering

00:07:32

and pondering

00:07:32

and pondering what<00:07:32.479> does<00:07:32.639> this<00:07:32.800> mean<00:07:33.039> for<00:07:33.199> society<00:07:34.080> and<00:07:34.319> so

00:07:34

what does this mean for society and so

00:07:34

what does this mean for society and so when<00:07:35.120> the<00:07:35.360> bailouts<00:07:36.000> happened

00:07:37

when the bailouts happened

00:07:37

when the bailouts happened surely<00:07:37.840> at<00:07:38.080> that<00:07:38.479> moment<00:07:39.520> like<00:07:39.759> the<00:07:40.000> whole

00:07:40

surely at that moment like the whole

00:07:40

surely at that moment like the whole idea

00:07:41

idea

00:07:41

idea that<00:07:41.759> free<00:07:42.080> market<00:07:42.560> economics<00:07:43.280> teaches<00:07:43.759> us

00:07:44

that free market economics teaches us

00:07:44

that free market economics teaches us that<00:07:45.360> if<00:07:45.840> a<00:07:46.000> state<00:07:46.560> provides<00:07:47.199> resources<00:07:47.919> to

00:07:48

that if a state provides resources to

00:07:48

that if a state provides resources to the<00:07:48.240> private<00:07:48.800> sector

00:07:49

the private sector

00:07:49

the private sector then<00:07:49.919> that<00:07:50.160> creates<00:07:50.560> a<00:07:50.639> moral<00:07:50.960> hazard<00:07:51.759> like

00:07:52

then that creates a moral hazard like

00:07:52

then that creates a moral hazard like situation<00:07:52.960> because<00:07:53.280> if<00:07:53.440> the<00:07:53.599> risk

00:07:54

situation because if the risk

00:07:54

situation because if the risk mechanism<00:07:54.960> in<00:07:55.120> the<00:07:55.199> system<00:07:55.599> just<00:07:55.759> won't<00:07:56.080> work

00:07:56

mechanism in the system just won't work

00:07:56

mechanism in the system just won't work in<00:07:56.560> the<00:07:56.720> way<00:07:57.280> that<00:07:57.520> it's<00:07:57.680> meant

00:07:58

in the way that it's meant

00:07:58

in the way that it's meant to<00:07:58.720> work<00:07:59.120> because<00:07:59.440> companies<00:08:00.000> will<00:08:00.160> know<00:08:00.400> that

00:08:00

to work because companies will know that

00:08:00

to work because companies will know that they're<00:08:00.720> getting<00:08:00.960> bailed<00:08:01.440> out

00:08:01

they're getting bailed out

00:08:01

they're getting bailed out at<00:08:02.000> the<00:08:02.160> end<00:08:02.319> of<00:08:02.400> the<00:08:02.560> day<00:08:03.039> was<00:08:03.280> there<00:08:03.440> no<00:08:04.000> so

00:08:04

at the end of the day was there no so

00:08:04

at the end of the day was there no so there's<00:08:04.319> no<00:08:04.639> conversation<00:08:05.599> on<00:08:05.840> the<00:08:06.000> trading

00:08:06

there's no conversation on the trading

00:08:06

there's no conversation on the trading floor

00:08:07

floor

00:08:07

floor really<00:08:08.080> about<00:08:08.400> hang<00:08:08.639> on<00:08:08.720> a<00:08:08.800> minute<00:08:09.120> the<00:08:09.360> whole

00:08:09

really about hang on a minute the whole

00:08:09

really about hang on a minute the whole global<00:08:10.160> financial<00:08:10.800> system

00:08:11

global financial system

00:08:11

global financial system has<00:08:11.759> just<00:08:12.080> been<00:08:12.319> bailed<00:08:12.720> out<00:08:13.280> by<00:08:13.599> the<00:08:13.840> state

00:08:14

has just been bailed out by the state

00:08:14

has just been bailed out by the state but<00:08:14.400> things<00:08:14.639> go<00:08:14.879> on<00:08:15.039> as<00:08:15.199> normal

00:08:16

but things go on as normal

00:08:16

but things go on as normal at<00:08:16.319> the<00:08:16.479> time<00:08:16.720> the<00:08:16.879> bailouts<00:08:17.360> happened<00:08:18.000> there

00:08:18

at the time the bailouts happened there

00:08:18

at the time the bailouts happened there were<00:08:18.400> a<00:08:18.479> couple<00:08:18.720> of<00:08:18.800> people<00:08:19.120> who

00:08:19

were a couple of people who

00:08:19

were a couple of people who would<00:08:19.840> mention<00:08:20.160> this<00:08:20.319> kind<00:08:20.560> of<00:08:20.720> thing<00:08:21.039> on<00:08:21.199> the

00:08:21

would mention this kind of thing on the

00:08:21

would mention this kind of thing on the trading<00:08:21.680> floor<00:08:21.919> there's<00:08:22.319> some<00:08:22.560> huge<00:08:22.800> places

00:08:23

trading floor there's some huge places

00:08:23

trading floor there's some huge places there's<00:08:23.280> hundreds<00:08:23.599> of<00:08:23.680> traders<00:08:24.000> right<00:08:24.240> and

00:08:24

there's hundreds of traders right and

00:08:24

there's hundreds of traders right and i<00:08:24.720> was<00:08:24.879> on<00:08:25.039> interest<00:08:25.360> rates<00:08:25.599> trading<00:08:26.400> people

00:08:26

i was on interest rates trading people

00:08:26

i was on interest rates trading people there<00:08:26.800> would<00:08:26.960> be<00:08:27.039> very<00:08:27.199> willing<00:08:27.440> to<00:08:27.520> say<00:08:27.680> well

00:08:27

there would be very willing to say well

00:08:27

there would be very willing to say well it<00:08:27.919> was<00:08:28.080> the<00:08:28.160> credit<00:08:28.479> traders

00:08:29

it was the credit traders

00:08:29

it was the credit traders that<00:08:29.360> blew<00:08:29.520> the<00:08:29.680> economy<00:08:30.080> up<00:08:30.240> so<00:08:30.400> they<00:08:30.560> sort<00:08:30.720> of

00:08:31

that blew the economy up so they sort of

00:08:31

that blew the economy up so they sort of they<00:08:31.199> washed<00:08:31.440> their<00:08:31.520> hands<00:08:31.759> of<00:08:31.840> it<00:08:31.919> so<00:08:32.080> it<00:08:32.159> was

00:08:32

they washed their hands of it so it was

00:08:32

they washed their hands of it so it was nothing<00:08:32.479> to<00:08:32.560> do<00:08:32.640> with<00:08:32.800> us

00:08:33

nothing to do with us

00:08:33

nothing to do with us kind<00:08:33.360> of<00:08:33.440> thing<00:08:34.159> i<00:08:34.240> think<00:08:34.399> there<00:08:34.560> were<00:08:34.719> some

00:08:34

kind of thing i think there were some

00:08:34

kind of thing i think there were some people<00:08:35.200> who<00:08:35.360> were<00:08:35.599> aware<00:08:36.080> like

00:08:36

people who were aware like

00:08:36

people who were aware like you<00:08:36.959> know<00:08:37.599> it's<00:08:37.839> people<00:08:38.159> on<00:08:38.320> this<00:08:38.479> floor

00:08:38

you know it's people on this floor

00:08:38

you know it's people on this floor who've<00:08:38.959> made<00:08:39.120> a<00:08:39.200> lot<00:08:39.360> of<00:08:39.440> money

00:08:40

who've made a lot of money

00:08:40

who've made a lot of money even<00:08:40.320> if<00:08:40.479> it<00:08:40.560> wasn't<00:08:40.800> people<00:08:41.039> on<00:08:41.120> my<00:08:41.360> team

00:08:41

even if it wasn't people on my team

00:08:41

even if it wasn't people on my team directly<00:08:42.399> and<00:08:42.560> then

00:08:43

directly and then

00:08:43

directly and then when<00:08:43.599> the<00:08:43.680> losses<00:08:44.080> come<00:08:44.240> in<00:08:44.959> the<00:08:45.120> government's

00:08:45

when the losses come in the government's

00:08:45

when the losses come in the government's taking<00:08:45.839> them<00:08:46.160> people<00:08:46.399> were<00:08:46.640> aware

00:08:47

taking them people were aware

00:08:47

taking them people were aware that<00:08:47.440> happened<00:08:48.240> but<00:08:49.680> a<00:08:49.839> trading<00:08:50.240> floor

00:08:50

that happened but a trading floor

00:08:50

that happened but a trading floor is<00:08:50.880> not<00:08:51.440> really<00:08:51.600> much<00:08:51.839> of<00:08:51.920> a<00:08:52.000> place<00:08:52.240> for

00:08:52

is not really much of a place for

00:08:52

is not really much of a place for moralizing<00:08:53.360> just<00:08:53.360> just<00:08:53.760> a<00:08:53.839> couple<00:08:54.000> of<00:08:54.160> years

00:08:54

moralizing just just a couple of years

00:08:54

moralizing just just a couple of years after<00:08:54.640> 2008<00:08:55.360> we<00:08:55.519> used<00:08:55.680> to<00:08:55.760> have<00:08:55.920> once<00:08:56.240> a<00:08:56.320> year

00:08:56

after 2008 we used to have once a year

00:08:56

after 2008 we used to have once a year we<00:08:56.640> had

00:08:56

we had

00:08:56

we had what<00:08:57.040> was<00:08:57.200> called<00:08:57.360> a<00:08:57.440> trading<00:08:57.760> off<00:08:57.920> site<00:08:58.160> where

00:08:58

what was called a trading off site where

00:08:58

what was called a trading off site where all<00:08:58.399> the<00:08:58.560> traders<00:08:58.959> go<00:08:59.440> to<00:08:59.600> some<00:08:59.839> place

00:09:00

all the traders go to some place

00:09:00

all the traders go to some place somewhere<00:09:00.480> and<00:09:00.560> have<00:09:00.720> like<00:09:00.880> a<00:09:00.959> weekend<00:09:01.279> away

00:09:01

somewhere and have like a weekend away

00:09:01

somewhere and have like a weekend away to<00:09:01.680> get<00:09:01.760> to<00:09:01.920> know<00:09:02.080> each<00:09:02.240> other<00:09:02.480> and<00:09:02.640> this<00:09:02.800> kind

00:09:02

to get to know each other and this kind

00:09:02

to get to know each other and this kind of<00:09:03.120> stuff<00:09:03.360> and

00:09:03

of stuff and

00:09:03

of stuff and just<00:09:04.160> two<00:09:04.320> years<00:09:04.560> later<00:09:04.880> in<00:09:05.080> 2010<00:09:06.160> was<00:09:06.320> it<00:09:06.480> or

00:09:06

just two years later in 2010 was it or

00:09:06

just two years later in 2010 was it or 2011<00:09:07.360> at<00:09:07.440> the<00:09:07.600> beginning<00:09:07.920> of<00:09:08.000> the<00:09:08.160> year

00:09:09

2011 at the beginning of the year

00:09:09

2011 at the beginning of the year they<00:09:09.200> took<00:09:09.440> us<00:09:09.600> away<00:09:09.839> and<00:09:09.920> they<00:09:10.080> gave<00:09:10.320> us<00:09:10.399> this

00:09:10

they took us away and they gave us this

00:09:10

they took us away and they gave us this massive<00:09:10.959> speech<00:09:11.360> saying<00:09:11.680> look<00:09:12.000> you're<00:09:12.240> all

00:09:12

massive speech saying look you're all

00:09:12

massive speech saying look you're all great<00:09:12.560> traders<00:09:13.120> we<00:09:13.279> think<00:09:13.519> you<00:09:13.600> should

00:09:13

great traders we think you should

00:09:14

great traders we think you should take<00:09:14.240> more<00:09:14.480> risk<00:09:15.279> and<00:09:15.360> they<00:09:15.519> gave<00:09:15.760> us<00:09:15.920> these

00:09:16

take more risk and they gave us these

00:09:16

take more risk and they gave us these little<00:09:16.720> camo<00:09:17.120> baseball<00:09:17.440> hats<00:09:17.680> we<00:09:17.839> said<00:09:18.000> on<00:09:18.080> the

00:09:18

little camo baseball hats we said on the

00:09:18

little camo baseball hats we said on the front

00:09:18

front

00:09:18

front go<00:09:19.040> big<00:09:19.279> or<00:09:19.360> go<00:09:19.600> home<00:09:20.240> and<00:09:20.320> they<00:09:20.480> said<00:09:20.959> if

00:09:21

go big or go home and they said if

00:09:21

go big or go home and they said if you're<00:09:21.600> comfortable<00:09:22.080> taking<00:09:22.320> a<00:09:22.399> risk<00:09:22.800> in

00:09:23

you're comfortable taking a risk in

00:09:23

you're comfortable taking a risk in in<00:09:23.760> one<00:09:23.920> million<00:09:24.240> dollars<00:09:24.720> why<00:09:24.880> don't<00:09:25.040> you

00:09:25

in one million dollars why don't you

00:09:25

in one million dollars why don't you take<00:09:25.360> it<00:09:25.440> in<00:09:25.600> 10<00:09:25.760> million

00:09:26

take it in 10 million

00:09:26

take it in 10 million and<00:09:27.440> the<00:09:28.399> i<00:09:28.480> mean<00:09:28.640> this<00:09:28.880> is<00:09:29.040> clearly<00:09:29.360> taking

00:09:29

and the i mean this is clearly taking

00:09:29

and the i mean this is clearly taking advantage<00:09:30.160> of

00:09:31

advantage of

00:09:31

advantage of the<00:09:31.360> system<00:09:31.680> that<00:09:31.839> is<00:09:32.000> in<00:09:32.080> place<00:09:32.320> with

00:09:32

the system that is in place with

00:09:32

the system that is in place with investment<00:09:33.279> banks<00:09:33.519> which<00:09:33.600> runs<00:09:33.839> all<00:09:34.000> the<00:09:34.080> way

00:09:34

investment banks which runs all the way

00:09:34

investment banks which runs all the way through

00:09:34

through

00:09:34

through as<00:09:34.880> an<00:09:35.040> individual<00:09:35.440> trader<00:09:36.160> if<00:09:36.320> you<00:09:36.399> make<00:09:36.640> a

00:09:36

as an individual trader if you make a

00:09:36

as an individual trader if you make a lot<00:09:36.800> of<00:09:36.880> money<00:09:37.440> you'll<00:09:37.680> be<00:09:37.839> paid<00:09:38.000> a<00:09:38.080> lot<00:09:38.160> of

00:09:38

lot of money you'll be paid a lot of

00:09:38

lot of money you'll be paid a lot of money

00:09:38

money

00:09:38

money but<00:09:38.959> if<00:09:39.040> you<00:09:39.200> lose<00:09:39.440> a<00:09:39.519> lot<00:09:39.600> of<00:09:39.680> money<00:09:40.000> you<00:09:40.160> might

00:09:40

but if you lose a lot of money you might

00:09:40

but if you lose a lot of money you might get<00:09:40.560> fired<00:09:41.120> but<00:09:41.360> you<00:09:41.519> won't

00:09:41

get fired but you won't

00:09:42

get fired but you won't lose<00:09:42.240> any<00:09:42.480> money<00:09:42.720> personally<00:09:43.519> but<00:09:43.680> the<00:09:43.839> same

00:09:44

lose any money personally but the same

00:09:44

lose any money personally but the same situation<00:09:44.480> exists<00:09:44.800> for<00:09:44.959> your<00:09:45.040> boss

00:09:45

situation exists for your boss

00:09:45

situation exists for your boss and<00:09:45.839> the<00:09:45.920> same<00:09:46.160> situation<00:09:46.560> exists<00:09:46.800> for<00:09:46.959> his

00:09:47

and the same situation exists for his

00:09:47

and the same situation exists for his boss<00:09:47.600> and<00:09:47.760> the<00:09:47.839> same<00:09:48.000> situation<00:09:48.399> exists<00:09:48.720> for

00:09:48

boss and the same situation exists for

00:09:48

boss and the same situation exists for his<00:09:49.040> boss<00:09:49.279> so

00:09:49

his boss so

00:09:49

his boss so there<00:09:49.839> really<00:09:50.080> is<00:09:50.240> an<00:09:50.399> incentive<00:09:50.959> for<00:09:52.480> traders

00:09:52

there really is an incentive for traders

00:09:52

there really is an incentive for traders and

00:09:53

and

00:09:53

and all<00:09:53.920> really<00:09:54.240> through<00:09:54.480> that<00:09:54.880> structure<00:09:55.440> to

00:09:55

all really through that structure to

00:09:55

all really through that structure to encourage<00:09:56.240> greater<00:09:56.560> risk<00:09:56.800> taking

00:09:57

encourage greater risk taking

00:09:57

encourage greater risk taking to<00:09:57.600> the<00:09:57.760> extent<00:09:58.000> that<00:09:58.160> even<00:09:58.320> a<00:09:58.399> couple<00:09:58.640> years

00:09:58

to the extent that even a couple years

00:09:58

to the extent that even a couple years after<00:09:59.040> 2008<00:09:59.839> when

00:10:00

after 2008 when

00:10:00

after 2008 when these<00:10:00.800> banks<00:10:01.120> collectively<00:10:01.680> blew<00:10:01.920> the<00:10:02.000> world

00:10:02

these banks collectively blew the world

00:10:02

these banks collectively blew the world up<00:10:03.360> we<00:10:03.519> would<00:10:03.680> be<00:10:03.760> encouraged<00:10:04.240> just<00:10:04.480> to<00:10:04.720> take

00:10:04

up we would be encouraged just to take

00:10:04

up we would be encouraged just to take much<00:10:05.200> more<00:10:05.360> risk<00:10:05.600> go<00:10:05.760> back<00:10:05.920> and<00:10:06.000> take<00:10:06.240> much

00:10:06

much more risk go back and take much

00:10:06

much more risk go back and take much more<00:10:06.560> risk<00:10:06.800> than<00:10:06.880> you<00:10:06.959> normally<00:10:07.279> would

00:10:07

more risk than you normally would

00:10:08

more risk than you normally would greed<00:10:09.040> fraud<00:10:10.279> dishonesty

00:10:11

greed fraud dishonesty

00:10:11

greed fraud dishonesty and<00:10:12.000> arrogance<00:10:13.440> these<00:10:13.839> are<00:10:14.160> some<00:10:14.399> of<00:10:14.560> the

00:10:14

and arrogance these are some of the

00:10:14

and arrogance these are some of the words

00:10:15

words

00:10:15

words that<00:10:16.160> best<00:10:16.560> describe<00:10:17.680> the<00:10:17.839> reality<00:10:18.640> of<00:10:18.800> wall

00:10:19

that best describe the reality of wall

00:10:19

that best describe the reality of wall street

00:10:19

street

00:10:19

street today<00:10:20.399> the<00:10:20.560> predictions<00:10:21.120> that<00:10:21.360> you<00:10:21.600> made<00:10:21.839> a

00:10:21

today the predictions that you made a

00:10:21

today the predictions that you made a lot<00:10:22.000> of<00:10:22.079> money<00:10:22.399> on<00:10:22.640> what<00:10:22.880> were<00:10:23.040> they

00:10:23

lot of money on what were they

00:10:23

lot of money on what were they on<00:10:23.839> were<00:10:24.000> they<00:10:24.240> on<00:10:24.399> interest<00:10:24.720> rates<00:10:25.920> yeah<00:10:26.240> so

00:10:26

on were they on interest rates yeah so

00:10:26

on were they on interest rates yeah so the<00:10:26.640> way<00:10:26.800> interest<00:10:27.040> rates<00:10:27.279> are<00:10:27.360> supposed<00:10:27.680> to

00:10:27

the way interest rates are supposed to

00:10:27

the way interest rates are supposed to work<00:10:28.079> they're<00:10:28.399> they're<00:10:28.640> fixed<00:10:28.880> by<00:10:29.040> the

00:10:29

work they're they're fixed by the

00:10:29

work they're they're fixed by the central<00:10:29.519> bank<00:10:29.760> so<00:10:29.920> in<00:10:30.000> this<00:10:30.079> country<00:10:30.399> the<00:10:30.480> bank

00:10:30

central bank so in this country the bank

00:10:30

central bank so in this country the bank of<00:10:30.800> england

00:10:31

of england

00:10:31

of england in<00:10:31.600> the<00:10:31.680> us<00:10:31.920> the<00:10:32.000> federal<00:10:32.320> reserve<00:10:33.040> and<00:10:33.519> the

00:10:33

in the us the federal reserve and the

00:10:33

in the us the federal reserve and the idea<00:10:34.000> is<00:10:34.079> actually<00:10:34.320> relatively<00:10:34.800> simple<00:10:35.120> right

00:10:35

idea is actually relatively simple right

00:10:35

idea is actually relatively simple right if<00:10:35.440> they<00:10:35.680> think<00:10:35.920> if<00:10:36.079> the<00:10:36.160> central<00:10:36.480> bank<00:10:36.640> thinks

00:10:36

if they think if the central bank thinks

00:10:36

if they think if the central bank thinks the<00:10:37.040> economy<00:10:37.360> is<00:10:37.519> weak

00:10:38

the economy is weak

00:10:38

the economy is weak and<00:10:38.240> it's<00:10:38.399> stimulating<00:10:39.519> they<00:10:39.680> cut<00:10:39.839> the

00:10:39

and it's stimulating they cut the

00:10:40

and it's stimulating they cut the interest<00:10:40.320> rate<00:10:40.720> and<00:10:40.800> that's<00:10:41.040> supposed<00:10:41.279> to

00:10:41

interest rate and that's supposed to

00:10:41

interest rate and that's supposed to make<00:10:41.600> it<00:10:41.760> cheaper<00:10:42.079> for<00:10:42.320> companies<00:10:42.720> to<00:10:42.880> borrow

00:10:43

make it cheaper for companies to borrow

00:10:43

make it cheaper for companies to borrow and<00:10:43.279> invest

00:10:44

and invest

00:10:44

and invest cheaper<00:10:44.480> for<00:10:44.720> individuals<00:10:45.279> to<00:10:45.360> borrow<00:10:45.680> and

00:10:45

cheaper for individuals to borrow and

00:10:45

cheaper for individuals to borrow and spend<00:10:46.560> it<00:10:46.640> makes<00:10:46.959> it<00:10:47.120> less<00:10:47.360> worthwhile<00:10:47.920> saving

00:10:48

spend it makes it less worthwhile saving

00:10:48

spend it makes it less worthwhile saving and<00:10:48.800> it's<00:10:48.959> supposed<00:10:49.279> to<00:10:49.519> encourage<00:10:50.000> people

00:10:50

and it's supposed to encourage people

00:10:50

and it's supposed to encourage people and<00:10:50.480> companies<00:10:50.880> to<00:10:50.959> get<00:10:51.120> out<00:10:51.279> and<00:10:51.360> spend<00:10:51.680> and

00:10:51

and companies to get out and spend and

00:10:51

and companies to get out and spend and get<00:10:51.920> the<00:10:52.079> economy

00:10:52

get the economy

00:10:52

get the economy going<00:10:53.519> if<00:10:53.600> they<00:10:53.760> think<00:10:53.920> the<00:10:54.000> economy<00:10:54.320> is<00:10:54.480> too

00:10:54

going if they think the economy is too

00:10:54

going if they think the economy is too hot<00:10:55.120> and<00:10:55.360> they're<00:10:55.519> worried<00:10:55.760> about<00:10:55.920> inflation

00:10:56

hot and they're worried about inflation

00:10:56

hot and they're worried about inflation they<00:10:56.399> do<00:10:56.560> the<00:10:56.640> opposite<00:10:56.959> they<00:10:57.040> raise<00:10:57.360> rates

00:10:57

they do the opposite they raise rates

00:10:57

they do the opposite they raise rates and<00:10:57.680> that's<00:10:57.839> supposed<00:10:58.079> to<00:10:58.240> encourage<00:10:58.560> people

00:10:58

and that's supposed to encourage people

00:10:58

and that's supposed to encourage people to

00:10:59

to save<00:11:00.399> so<00:11:00.880> in<00:11:01.040> 2008<00:11:01.839> all<00:11:01.920> those<00:11:02.079> interest<00:11:02.320> rates

00:11:02

save so in 2008 all those interest rates

00:11:02

save so in 2008 all those interest rates collapsed<00:11:02.959> very<00:11:03.200> very<00:11:03.360> quickly<00:11:03.760> to

00:11:04

collapsed very very quickly to

00:11:04

collapsed very very quickly to zero<00:11:04.800> or<00:11:04.959> close<00:11:05.200> to<00:11:05.360> zero<00:11:06.480> previously<00:11:06.959> they've

00:11:07

zero or close to zero previously they've

00:11:07

zero or close to zero previously they've been<00:11:07.360> sort<00:11:07.519> of<00:11:07.600> like<00:11:07.839> five<00:11:08.160> percentage

00:11:08

been sort of like five percentage

00:11:08

been sort of like five percentage depending<00:11:09.040> on<00:11:09.120> the<00:11:09.200> country

00:11:09

depending on the country

00:11:09

depending on the country you're<00:11:10.000> looking<00:11:10.320> at<00:11:11.040> and<00:11:11.200> at<00:11:11.360> the<00:11:11.519> time

00:11:12

you're looking at and at the time

00:11:12

you're looking at and at the time because<00:11:12.720> it<00:11:12.800> was<00:11:12.959> such<00:11:13.120> a<00:11:13.279> huge<00:11:13.680> move<00:11:13.920> in

00:11:14

because it was such a huge move in

00:11:14

because it was such a huge move in interest<00:11:14.399> rates

00:11:14

interest rates

00:11:14

interest rates previously<00:11:15.519> they'd<00:11:15.760> move<00:11:16.000> rates<00:11:16.480> very<00:11:16.640> small

00:11:16

previously they'd move rates very small

00:11:16

previously they'd move rates very small amount<00:11:17.200> like<00:11:17.440> four<00:11:17.600> and<00:11:17.760> a<00:11:17.760> half<00:11:18.000> to<00:11:18.079> four<00:11:18.240> and

00:11:18

amount like four and a half to four and

00:11:18

amount like four and a half to four and a<00:11:18.399> quarter

00:11:19

a quarter

00:11:19

a quarter five<00:11:19.519> and<00:11:19.600> three<00:11:19.760> quarters<00:11:20.000> to<00:11:20.079> five<00:11:20.320> and<00:11:20.399> a

00:11:20

five and three quarters to five and a

00:11:20

five and three quarters to five and a half<00:11:20.720> suddenly<00:11:21.200> everyone<00:11:21.440> was<00:11:21.600> cutting<00:11:21.920> i

00:11:21

half suddenly everyone was cutting i

00:11:22

half suddenly everyone was cutting i think<00:11:22.079> the<00:11:22.160> uk<00:11:22.480> cut<00:11:22.640> from<00:11:22.800> five<00:11:23.040> and<00:11:23.120> a<00:11:23.200> half<00:11:23.440> to

00:11:23

think the uk cut from five and a half to

00:11:23

think the uk cut from five and a half to zero<00:11:23.920> point<00:11:24.079> five

00:11:24

zero point five

00:11:24

zero point five and<00:11:24.880> every<00:11:25.120> country<00:11:25.440> was<00:11:25.600> doing<00:11:25.839> that

00:11:26

and every country was doing that

00:11:26

and every country was doing that everyone<00:11:27.040> expected<00:11:27.680> there<00:11:27.839> to<00:11:27.920> be<00:11:28.000> a<00:11:28.160> really

00:11:28

everyone expected there to be a really

00:11:28

everyone expected there to be a really rapid<00:11:28.640> recovery<00:11:29.200> based<00:11:29.440> on<00:11:29.519> these

00:11:29

rapid recovery based on these

00:11:29

rapid recovery based on these huge<00:11:30.160> moves<00:11:30.399> and<00:11:30.560> interest<00:11:30.880> rates<00:11:32.160> so<00:11:32.320> my<00:11:32.480> job

00:11:32

huge moves and interest rates so my job

00:11:32

huge moves and interest rates so my job was<00:11:32.800> to<00:11:32.959> basically<00:11:33.360> bet<00:11:33.519> what<00:11:33.680> will<00:11:33.839> the

00:11:33

was to basically bet what will the

00:11:33

was to basically bet what will the interest<00:11:34.240> rate<00:11:34.399> be<00:11:34.640> in

00:11:35

interest rate be in

00:11:35

interest rate be in two<00:11:35.279> years<00:11:35.519> time<00:11:35.839> in<00:11:35.920> three<00:11:36.160> years<00:11:36.399> time<00:11:37.200> and

00:11:37

two years time in three years time and

00:11:37

two years time in three years time and based<00:11:37.760> on

00:11:38

based on

00:11:38

based on basically<00:11:38.800> will<00:11:39.279> when<00:11:39.519> will<00:11:39.760> the<00:11:39.839> economy

00:11:40

basically will when will the economy

00:11:40

basically will when will the economy recover

00:11:41

recover

00:11:41

recover if<00:11:41.600> you<00:11:41.680> go<00:11:41.839> back<00:11:42.000> and<00:11:42.079> look<00:11:42.240> at<00:11:42.399> the<00:11:42.480> history

00:11:42

if you go back and look at the history

00:11:42

if you go back and look at the history of<00:11:42.800> this<00:11:42.959> it's<00:11:43.279> really<00:11:43.519> interesting<00:11:44.000> because

00:11:44

of this it's really interesting because

00:11:44

of this it's really interesting because the<00:11:44.720> rates<00:11:44.959> collapsed<00:11:45.279> to<00:11:45.360> zero<00:11:45.600> in<00:11:45.680> 2008<00:11:46.800> and

00:11:47

the rates collapsed to zero in 2008 and

00:11:47

the rates collapsed to zero in 2008 and at<00:11:47.120> the<00:11:47.279> time<00:11:47.600> everyone<00:11:47.920> predicted

00:11:48

at the time everyone predicted

00:11:48

at the time everyone predicted they'll<00:11:48.800> go<00:11:48.959> up<00:11:49.120> in<00:11:49.200> 2009<00:11:50.560> then<00:11:50.720> when<00:11:50.880> 2009

00:11:51

they'll go up in 2009 then when 2009

00:11:51

they'll go up in 2009 then when 2009 came

00:11:52

came

00:11:52

came the<00:11:52.720> economy<00:11:53.040> was<00:11:53.200> still<00:11:53.360> weak<00:11:53.600> those

00:11:53

the economy was still weak those

00:11:53

the economy was still weak those predictions<00:11:54.160> got<00:11:54.320> pushed<00:11:54.480> back<00:11:54.639> to<00:11:54.839> 2010.<00:11:55.920> but

00:11:56

predictions got pushed back to 2010. but

00:11:56

predictions got pushed back to 2010. but in<00:11:56.240> 2010<00:11:56.880> it<00:11:56.959> was<00:11:57.120> 2011<00:11:57.839> 2011<00:11:58.480> it<00:11:58.560> was<00:11:58.639> 2012.

00:11:59

in 2010 it was 2011 2011 it was 2012.

00:11:59

in 2010 it was 2011 2011 it was 2012. in<00:11:59.760> 2012<00:12:00.399> it<00:12:00.480> was<00:12:00.560> 2013.<00:12:01.760> and<00:12:01.920> even<00:12:02.079> if<00:12:02.240> you<00:12:02.399> go

00:12:02

in 2012 it was 2013. and even if you go

00:12:02

in 2012 it was 2013. and even if you go back<00:12:02.800> last<00:12:03.120> year

00:12:03

back last year

00:12:03

back last year people<00:12:04.079> were<00:12:04.160> predicting<00:12:04.560> rises<00:12:04.959> for<00:12:05.120> this

00:12:05

people were predicting rises for this

00:12:05

people were predicting rises for this year<00:12:05.839> so<00:12:06.639> it's

00:12:07

year so it's

00:12:07

year so it's it's<00:12:07.360> really<00:12:07.839> it's<00:12:08.720> it's<00:12:08.959> some<00:12:09.279> it's<00:12:09.360> it's

00:12:10

it's really it's it's some it's it's

00:12:10

it's really it's it's some it's it's really<00:12:10.399> phenomenal<00:12:10.959> to<00:12:11.040> think<00:12:11.200> about<00:12:11.440> it's<00:12:11.600> as

00:12:11

really phenomenal to think about it's as

00:12:11

really phenomenal to think about it's as if<00:12:11.920> you<00:12:12.000> turn<00:12:12.160> on<00:12:12.240> the<00:12:12.320> weather<00:12:12.560> forecast

00:12:13

if you turn on the weather forecast

00:12:13

if you turn on the weather forecast and<00:12:13.279> they<00:12:13.440> were<00:12:13.600> just<00:12:13.760> predicting<00:12:14.800> 37<00:12:15.360> degrees

00:12:15

and they were just predicting 37 degrees

00:12:15

and they were just predicting 37 degrees and<00:12:15.839> sunny<00:12:16.160> every<00:12:16.399> day

00:12:16

and sunny every day

00:12:16

and sunny every day in<00:12:16.880> london<00:12:17.279> or<00:12:17.519> if<00:12:17.680> you<00:12:17.760> watch<00:12:18.000> the<00:12:18.079> penalty

00:12:18

in london or if you watch the penalty

00:12:18

in london or if you watch the penalty shooter<00:12:18.720> and<00:12:18.800> they<00:12:18.959> all<00:12:19.440> hit<00:12:19.680> off<00:12:19.760> for<00:12:19.920> a

00:12:19

shooter and they all hit off for a

00:12:20

shooter and they all hit off for a throw-in

00:12:20

throw-in

00:12:20

throw-in they've<00:12:20.800> just<00:12:20.959> been<00:12:21.120> wrong<00:12:21.440> every<00:12:21.680> single

00:12:21

they've just been wrong every single

00:12:22

they've just been wrong every single year<00:12:22.240> so<00:12:22.720> my<00:12:22.959> job<00:12:23.120> was<00:12:23.279> to<00:12:23.440> bet<00:12:23.680> will<00:12:23.920> this

00:12:24

year so my job was to bet will this

00:12:24

year so my job was to bet will this happen

00:12:24

happen

00:12:24

happen and<00:12:25.040> after<00:12:25.360> seeing<00:12:25.600> the<00:12:25.680> first<00:12:25.920> couple<00:12:26.240> of

00:12:26

and after seeing the first couple of

00:12:26

and after seeing the first couple of years<00:12:26.720> of<00:12:27.200> predicting<00:12:27.680> a<00:12:27.760> recovery<00:12:28.160> that

00:12:28

years of predicting a recovery that

00:12:28

years of predicting a recovery that didn't<00:12:28.480> happen

00:12:29

didn't happen

00:12:29

didn't happen i<00:12:29.600> started<00:12:29.920> to<00:12:30.000> become<00:12:30.959> i<00:12:31.120> started<00:12:31.360> to

00:12:31

i started to become i started to

00:12:31

i started to become i started to question<00:12:31.760> really<00:12:32.000> the<00:12:32.079> ideas<00:12:32.399> i<00:12:32.480> learned<00:12:32.639> at

00:12:32

question really the ideas i learned at

00:12:32

question really the ideas i learned at the<00:12:32.720> university<00:12:33.519> and

00:12:34

the university and

00:12:34

the university and why<00:12:34.639> is<00:12:34.800> the<00:12:34.880> recovery<00:12:35.360> not<00:12:35.440> happening<00:12:35.760> what

00:12:35

why is the recovery not happening what

00:12:36

why is the recovery not happening what is<00:12:36.160> the<00:12:36.240> problem<00:12:36.959> and<00:12:37.120> i<00:12:37.200> developed<00:12:37.760> these

00:12:38

is the problem and i developed these

00:12:38

is the problem and i developed these theories<00:12:38.480> that<00:12:38.639> inequality<00:12:39.200> is<00:12:39.360> much<00:12:39.600> more

00:12:39

theories that inequality is much more

00:12:39

theories that inequality is much more important<00:12:40.320> than<00:12:40.720> most<00:12:41.040> economists<00:12:41.519> to

00:12:41

important than most economists to

00:12:41

important than most economists to realize

00:12:42

realize

00:12:42

realize which<00:12:42.800> means<00:12:43.040> that<00:12:43.200> because<00:12:43.519> we're<00:12:43.680> not

00:12:43

which means that because we're not

00:12:43

which means that because we're not addressing<00:12:44.240> inequality<00:12:45.200> the<00:12:45.440> crisis

00:12:46

addressing inequality the crisis

00:12:46

addressing inequality the crisis will<00:12:46.639> be<00:12:46.800> very<00:12:47.040> very<00:12:47.279> long<00:12:47.519> term<00:12:48.240> because

00:12:48

will be very very long term because

00:12:48

will be very very long term because we're<00:12:48.959> not<00:12:49.120> fixing<00:12:49.440> the<00:12:49.519> underlying<00:12:49.839> problem

00:12:50

we're not fixing the underlying problem

00:12:50

we're not fixing the underlying problem essentially

00:12:50

essentially

00:12:50

essentially so<00:12:51.120> i<00:12:51.279> basically<00:12:51.760> bet<00:12:52.000> that<00:12:52.320> rates<00:12:52.560> will<00:12:52.720> stay

00:12:53

so i basically bet that rates will stay

00:12:53

so i basically bet that rates will stay zero<00:12:53.760> or<00:12:53.920> close<00:12:54.079> to<00:12:54.240> zero<00:12:54.480> for<00:12:54.639> a<00:12:54.720> very<00:12:54.959> long

00:12:55

zero or close to zero for a very long

00:12:55

zero or close to zero for a very long time

00:12:56

time

00:12:56

time and<00:12:56.160> they<00:12:56.320> did<00:12:56.720> is<00:12:56.880> it<00:12:57.040> right<00:12:57.360> to<00:12:57.519> say<00:12:57.920> that<00:12:58.160> if

00:12:58

and they did is it right to say that if

00:12:58

and they did is it right to say that if you're

00:12:59

you're

00:12:59

you're the<00:12:59.360> one<00:12:59.680> trader<00:13:00.560> who's<00:13:01.760> getting<00:13:02.000> the

00:13:02

the one trader who's getting the

00:13:02

the one trader who's getting the predictions<00:13:02.880> right

00:13:03

predictions right

00:13:03

predictions right and<00:13:04.320> everyone<00:13:04.800> else<00:13:05.120> is<00:13:05.279> getting<00:13:05.519> the

00:13:05

and everyone else is getting the

00:13:05

and everyone else is getting the predictions<00:13:06.399> wrong

00:13:07

predictions wrong

00:13:07

predictions wrong that<00:13:07.440> means<00:13:07.680> that<00:13:07.839> you're<00:13:08.000> going<00:13:08.079> to<00:13:08.240> make

00:13:08

that means that you're going to make

00:13:08

that means that you're going to make more<00:13:08.720> money<00:13:09.040> is<00:13:09.120> that<00:13:09.279> a<00:13:09.360> fair<00:13:09.680> assumption

00:13:10

more money is that a fair assumption

00:13:10

more money is that a fair assumption yeah<00:13:11.200> yeah<00:13:11.440> i<00:13:11.519> mean<00:13:11.839> the<00:13:12.320> things<00:13:12.560> have<00:13:12.639> changed

00:13:13

yeah yeah i mean the things have changed

00:13:13

yeah yeah i mean the things have changed a<00:13:13.120> little<00:13:13.200> bit<00:13:13.360> since<00:13:13.600> i<00:13:13.760> was<00:13:13.920> there

00:13:14

a little bit since i was there

00:13:14

a little bit since i was there um<00:13:16.399> but<00:13:16.720> back<00:13:16.959> then<00:13:17.680> you

00:13:17

um but back then you

00:13:18

um but back then you you<00:13:18.240> were<00:13:18.320> expected<00:13:18.800> to<00:13:18.959> make<00:13:19.519> personally<00:13:20.079> a

00:13:20

you were expected to make personally a

00:13:20

you were expected to make personally a percentage<00:13:20.639> of<00:13:20.720> what<00:13:20.800> you<00:13:20.880> made<00:13:21.120> for<00:13:21.279> the<00:13:21.360> bank

00:13:21

percentage of what you made for the bank

00:13:22

percentage of what you made for the bank it<00:13:22.079> was<00:13:22.240> all<00:13:22.399> a<00:13:22.480> little<00:13:22.639> bit<00:13:22.800> murky<00:13:23.279> because

00:13:24

it was all a little bit murky because

00:13:24

it was all a little bit murky because there's<00:13:24.639> no<00:13:24.880> contractual<00:13:25.519> obligation<00:13:26.000> for

00:13:26

there's no contractual obligation for

00:13:26

there's no contractual obligation for the<00:13:26.160> bank<00:13:26.399> to<00:13:26.480> do<00:13:26.720> that<00:13:26.959> so<00:13:27.120> at<00:13:27.200> the<00:13:27.360> end<00:13:27.519> of<00:13:27.600> the

00:13:27

the bank to do that so at the end of the

00:13:27

the bank to do that so at the end of the year<00:13:27.920> you<00:13:28.000> kind<00:13:28.160> of<00:13:28.240> have<00:13:28.399> to<00:13:28.639> hope<00:13:28.880> that<00:13:29.040> they

00:13:29

year you kind of have to hope that they

00:13:29

year you kind of have to hope that they actually

00:13:29

actually

00:13:30

actually pay<00:13:30.240> you<00:13:30.560> which<00:13:30.880> was<00:13:31.120> sort<00:13:31.200> of<00:13:31.360> a<00:13:31.440> strange

00:13:31

pay you which was sort of a strange

00:13:31

pay you which was sort of a strange setup<00:13:32.320> but<00:13:32.639> yeah<00:13:32.880> the<00:13:33.040> idea<00:13:33.519> is<00:13:33.600> that<00:13:33.760> you<00:13:33.920> will

00:13:34

setup but yeah the idea is that you will

00:13:34

setup but yeah the idea is that you will get<00:13:34.240> paid

00:13:34

get paid

00:13:34

get paid more<00:13:35.120> personally<00:13:35.600> if<00:13:35.760> you<00:13:35.839> make<00:13:36.079> more<00:13:36.320> for<00:13:36.480> the

00:13:36

more personally if you make more for the

00:13:36

more personally if you make more for the bank<00:13:37.120> as<00:13:37.279> you<00:13:37.440> had<00:13:37.760> this<00:13:38.000> realization

00:13:38

bank as you had this realization

00:13:38

bank as you had this realization did<00:13:39.120> your<00:13:39.440> politics<00:13:40.000> change<00:13:40.480> as<00:13:40.639> you<00:13:40.800> were

00:13:40

did your politics change as you were

00:13:40

did your politics change as you were doing<00:13:41.040> the<00:13:41.199> economics

00:13:42

doing the economics

00:13:42

doing the economics your<00:13:42.560> personal<00:13:42.959> politics<00:13:43.839> and<00:13:44.000> not<00:13:44.160> at<00:13:44.320> first

00:13:45

your personal politics and not at first

00:13:45

your personal politics and not at first because

00:13:45

because

00:13:45

because you<00:13:45.680> know<00:13:46.079> at<00:13:46.240> the<00:13:46.399> time<00:13:46.959> i<00:13:47.040> was<00:13:47.279> just<00:13:48.079> super

00:13:48

you know at the time i was just super

00:13:48

you know at the time i was just super focused<00:13:48.880> on

00:13:49

focused on

00:13:49

focused on understanding<00:13:50.480> the<00:13:50.880> economy<00:13:51.760> it's<00:13:52.160> it's<00:13:52.320> such

00:13:52

understanding the economy it's it's such

00:13:52

understanding the economy it's it's such an<00:13:52.639> interesting<00:13:53.120> place

00:13:53

an interesting place

00:13:53

an interesting place to<00:13:53.920> work<00:13:54.320> and<00:13:54.480> to<00:13:54.639> sort<00:13:54.800> of<00:13:54.959> be<00:13:55.199> there

00:13:55

to work and to sort of be there

00:13:55

to work and to sort of be there competitively<00:13:56.160> making<00:13:56.480> predictions

00:13:57

competitively making predictions

00:13:57

competitively making predictions trying<00:13:57.680> to<00:13:57.760> make<00:13:57.920> the<00:13:58.000> right<00:13:58.160> predictions<00:13:58.720> i

00:13:58

trying to make the right predictions i

00:13:58

trying to make the right predictions i was<00:13:58.959> really<00:13:59.199> just<00:13:59.360> single-mindedly<00:14:00.160> focused

00:14:00

was really just single-mindedly focused

00:14:00

was really just single-mindedly focused on

00:14:01

on try<00:14:01.279> make<00:14:01.440> the<00:14:01.519> right<00:14:01.680> prediction<00:14:02.079> try<00:14:02.160> and

00:14:02

try make the right prediction try and

00:14:02

try make the right prediction try and make<00:14:02.399> the<00:14:02.480> right<00:14:02.639> prediction<00:14:03.199> now<00:14:03.680> when<00:14:03.839> i

00:14:04

make the right prediction now when i

00:14:04

make the right prediction now when i first<00:14:04.320> came<00:14:04.560> to<00:14:04.720> this

00:14:05

first came to this

00:14:05

first came to this idea<00:14:06.079> that<00:14:06.480> i<00:14:06.639> think<00:14:06.800> inequality<00:14:07.360> is<00:14:07.519> much

00:14:07

idea that i think inequality is much

00:14:07

idea that i think inequality is much much<00:14:08.000> more<00:14:08.160> important<00:14:08.560> than

00:14:09

much more important than

00:14:09

much more important than economists<00:14:10.560> realize<00:14:11.040> or<00:14:11.120> what<00:14:11.279> they<00:14:11.360> teach<00:14:11.600> at

00:14:11

economists realize or what they teach at

00:14:11

economists realize or what they teach at university

00:14:12

university

00:14:12

university at<00:14:13.120> first<00:14:13.360> i<00:14:13.519> wasn't<00:14:13.760> certain<00:14:14.079> of<00:14:14.160> that<00:14:14.480> i<00:14:14.639> was

00:14:14

at first i wasn't certain of that i was

00:14:14

at first i wasn't certain of that i was quite<00:14:15.040> confident<00:14:15.519> because<00:14:15.839> you<00:14:15.920> know<00:14:16.000> i've

00:14:16

quite confident because you know i've

00:14:16

quite confident because you know i've been<00:14:16.240> thinking<00:14:16.560> about<00:14:16.720> these<00:14:16.880> ideas<00:14:17.120> for<00:14:17.199> a

00:14:17

been thinking about these ideas for a

00:14:17

been thinking about these ideas for a couple<00:14:17.440> of<00:14:17.519> years<00:14:17.839> but<00:14:17.920> i<00:14:18.000> wasn't<00:14:18.320> certain

00:14:19

couple of years but i wasn't certain

00:14:19

couple of years but i wasn't certain but<00:14:19.440> i<00:14:19.519> was<00:14:19.600> confident<00:14:19.920> enough<00:14:20.160> to<00:14:20.240> make<00:14:20.320> a<00:14:20.399> big

00:14:20

but i was confident enough to make a big

00:14:20

but i was confident enough to make a big bet<00:14:20.800> on<00:14:20.959> it<00:14:21.839> and<00:14:22.000> then

00:14:22

bet on it and then

00:14:22

bet on it and then yeah<00:14:23.040> when<00:14:23.279> it<00:14:23.440> came<00:14:23.680> back<00:14:24.160> super<00:14:24.480> successful

00:14:24

yeah when it came back super successful

00:14:24

yeah when it came back super successful and<00:14:25.120> it<00:14:25.199> was<00:14:25.440> phenomenally<00:14:26.000> successful<00:14:26.480> that

00:14:26

and it was phenomenally successful that

00:14:26

and it was phenomenally successful that year<00:14:26.800> when<00:14:26.959> i<00:14:27.040> did<00:14:27.199> that<00:14:27.440> 2011

00:14:28

year when i did that 2011

00:14:28

year when i did that 2011 i<00:14:28.639> was<00:14:28.800> the<00:14:28.880> most<00:14:29.040> profitable<00:14:29.440> trader<00:14:29.839> in<00:14:30.000> the

00:14:30

i was the most profitable trader in the

00:14:30

i was the most profitable trader in the bank<00:14:30.399> globally<00:14:31.040> that<00:14:31.199> year<00:14:31.440> on<00:14:31.519> the<00:14:31.600> back<00:14:31.839> of

00:14:31

bank globally that year on the back of

00:14:31

bank globally that year on the back of that

00:14:33

that

00:14:33

that then<00:14:33.680> when<00:14:33.920> that<00:14:34.160> came<00:14:34.399> back<00:14:35.920> at<00:14:36.079> first<00:14:36.320> i<00:14:36.399> just

00:14:36

then when that came back at first i just

00:14:36

then when that came back at first i just wanted<00:14:36.720> to<00:14:36.800> make<00:14:36.959> sure<00:14:37.120> i<00:14:37.199> got<00:14:37.440> paid

00:14:37

wanted to make sure i got paid

00:14:37

wanted to make sure i got paid because<00:14:38.639> this<00:14:38.880> is<00:14:38.959> a<00:14:39.120> weird<00:14:39.360> world<00:14:39.680> and<00:14:39.839> you

00:14:39

because this is a weird world and you

00:14:39

because this is a weird world and you know<00:14:40.320> they<00:14:40.480> might<00:14:40.639> just<00:14:40.880> fire<00:14:41.040> you<00:14:41.199> instead<00:14:41.440> of

00:14:41

know they might just fire you instead of

00:14:41

know they might just fire you instead of paying<00:14:41.839> you<00:14:42.000> and<00:14:42.160> it<00:14:42.240> was<00:14:42.399> a<00:14:42.480> lot<00:14:42.560> of<00:14:42.639> money

00:14:42

paying you and it was a lot of money

00:14:42

paying you and it was a lot of money that<00:14:42.959> was<00:14:43.120> on<00:14:43.199> the<00:14:43.279> line

00:14:44

that was on the line

00:14:44

that was on the line but<00:14:44.240> once<00:14:44.480> that<00:14:44.639> was<00:14:44.800> done<00:14:45.120> i<00:14:45.279> sort<00:14:45.440> of<00:14:45.600> sat

00:14:45

but once that was done i sort of sat

00:14:45

but once that was done i sort of sat back<00:14:46.000> and<00:14:46.160> i<00:14:46.240> thought<00:14:46.560> well<00:14:46.720> that<00:14:46.880> was

00:14:47

back and i thought well that was

00:14:47

back and i thought well that was strange<00:14:48.560> because<00:14:49.839> i<00:14:49.920> mean<00:14:50.160> you<00:14:50.240> might<00:14:50.480> think

00:14:50

strange because i mean you might think

00:14:50

strange because i mean you might think in<00:14:50.959> a<00:14:51.040> civilized<00:14:51.519> society

00:14:52

in a civilized society

00:14:52

in a civilized society if<00:14:52.959> you<00:14:53.519> have<00:14:53.760> been<00:14:53.920> paid<00:14:54.160> a<00:14:54.160> lot<00:14:54.320> of<00:14:54.399> money<00:14:54.720> to

00:14:54

if you have been paid a lot of money to

00:14:54

if you have been paid a lot of money to correctly<00:14:55.199> predict<00:14:55.600> that<00:14:55.680> there's<00:14:56.000> going<00:14:56.079> to

00:14:56

correctly predict that there's going to

00:14:56

correctly predict that there's going to be<00:14:56.320> a<00:14:56.399> long-term

00:14:57

be a long-term

00:14:57

be a long-term economic<00:14:57.680> crisis<00:14:58.240> there<00:14:58.399> might<00:14:58.560> be<00:14:58.639> some<00:14:58.800> sort

00:14:58

economic crisis there might be some sort

00:14:58

economic crisis there might be some sort of<00:14:59.040> like<00:14:59.199> escalation<00:14:59.839> like

00:15:00

of like escalation like

00:15:00

of like escalation like okay<00:15:00.480> you<00:15:00.560> should<00:15:00.720> probably<00:15:00.959> go<00:15:01.199> and<00:15:01.279> talk<00:15:01.440> to

00:15:01

okay you should probably go and talk to

00:15:01

okay you should probably go and talk to the<00:15:01.600> government<00:15:01.920> and<00:15:02.079> explain<00:15:02.720> what's<00:15:02.959> going

00:15:03

the government and explain what's going

00:15:03

the government and explain what's going to<00:15:03.120> happen<00:15:03.440> but

00:15:04

to happen but

00:15:04

to happen but they<00:15:04.399> just<00:15:04.560> said<00:15:04.800> all<00:15:04.959> right<00:15:05.519> that<00:15:05.680> was<00:15:05.920> great

00:15:06

they just said all right that was great

00:15:06

they just said all right that was great we<00:15:06.399> all<00:15:06.480> made<00:15:06.639> money<00:15:06.959> do<00:15:07.199> it<00:15:07.279> again

00:15:07

we all made money do it again

00:15:07

we all made money do it again it<00:15:08.079> was<00:15:08.240> only<00:15:08.560> after<00:15:09.199> it<00:15:09.440> happened<00:15:09.760> it<00:15:09.920> had

00:15:09

it was only after it happened it had

00:15:10

it was only after it happened it had been<00:15:10.160> really<00:15:10.399> successful<00:15:10.880> that<00:15:11.040> i<00:15:11.120> started<00:15:11.360> to

00:15:11

been really successful that i started to

00:15:11

been really successful that i started to think

00:15:12

think

00:15:12

think well<00:15:12.880> that<00:15:13.040> was<00:15:13.920> strange<00:15:14.720> if<00:15:14.800> you're<00:15:15.120> very

00:15:15

well that was strange if you're very

00:15:15

well that was strange if you're very very<00:15:15.440> good<00:15:15.600> at<00:15:15.680> making<00:15:15.839> economic<00:15:16.240> predictions

00:15:17

very good at making economic predictions

00:15:17

very good at making economic predictions you<00:15:17.199> can<00:15:17.279> get<00:15:17.440> paid<00:15:17.760> a<00:15:17.839> lot<00:15:18.959> by<00:15:19.199> bank<00:15:19.600> but

00:15:20

you can get paid a lot by bank but

00:15:20

you can get paid a lot by bank but there's<00:15:20.399> not<00:15:20.480> really<00:15:20.959> many<00:15:21.360> other<00:15:21.519> places<00:15:22.000> i

00:15:22

there's not really many other places i

00:15:22

there's not really many other places i mean

00:15:23

mean

00:15:23

mean that's<00:15:23.440> why<00:15:23.519> i'm<00:15:23.680> here<00:15:23.760> on<00:15:23.839> this<00:15:24.000> podcast

00:15:24

that's why i'm here on this podcast

00:15:24

that's why i'm here on this podcast right<00:15:24.560> to<00:15:24.639> try<00:15:24.720> and<00:15:24.800> tell<00:15:25.040> people<00:15:25.279> right<00:15:25.839> if

00:15:25

right to try and tell people right if

00:15:26

right to try and tell people right if the<00:15:26.160> government's<00:15:26.560> listening<00:15:26.880> give<00:15:27.040> me<00:15:27.120> a

00:15:27

the government's listening give me a

00:15:27

the government's listening give me a shout<00:15:27.440> i'll<00:15:27.519> work<00:15:27.680> for<00:15:27.839> free<00:15:28.079> i'll<00:15:28.240> tell<00:15:28.399> you

00:15:28

shout i'll work for free i'll tell you

00:15:28

shout i'll work for free i'll tell you what's<00:15:28.639> happening

00:15:29

what's happening

00:15:30

what's happening i<00:15:30.160> mean<00:15:30.560> but<00:15:30.880> just<00:15:31.199> that<00:15:31.759> story<00:15:32.560> i<00:15:32.639> mean<00:15:32.800> the

00:15:32

i mean but just that story i mean the

00:15:32

i mean but just that story i mean the story<00:15:33.360> itself

00:15:33

story itself

00:15:33

story itself is<00:15:34.079> just<00:15:34.880> extraordinary<00:15:35.920> because<00:15:36.240> of<00:15:36.320> course

00:15:36

is just extraordinary because of course

00:15:36

is just extraordinary because of course it's<00:15:36.880> just

00:15:37

it's just

00:15:37

it's just so<00:15:37.759> true<00:15:38.160> and<00:15:38.399> so<00:15:39.360> correct

00:15:40

so true and so correct

00:15:40

so true and so correct that<00:15:41.279> if<00:15:41.519> you<00:15:42.320> have<00:15:42.560> something<00:15:42.959> to<00:15:43.199> contribute

00:15:44

that if you have something to contribute

00:15:44

that if you have something to contribute to<00:15:44.399> the<00:15:44.560> structure<00:15:44.959> of<00:15:45.120> society<00:15:46.079> that<00:15:46.320> is<00:15:46.560> hang

00:15:46

to the structure of society that is hang

00:15:46

to the structure of society that is hang on<00:15:46.880> a<00:15:46.959> minute

00:15:47

on a minute

00:15:47

on a minute inequality<00:15:48.720> is<00:15:48.959> unproductive<00:15:50.079> to<00:15:50.320> our

00:15:50

inequality is unproductive to our

00:15:50

inequality is unproductive to our economy

00:15:51

economy

00:15:51

economy the<00:15:51.920> bank<00:15:52.240> has<00:15:52.480> made<00:15:52.880> a<00:15:53.120> massive<00:15:53.440> amount<00:15:53.759> of

00:15:53

the bank has made a massive amount of

00:15:53

the bank has made a massive amount of cash

00:15:54

cash

00:15:54

cash from<00:15:55.199> that<00:15:55.440> prediction<00:15:56.560> you<00:15:57.279> and<00:15:57.440> then<00:15:57.600> they

00:15:57

from that prediction you and then they

00:15:57

from that prediction you and then they say<00:15:58.000> okay<00:15:58.480> fine

00:15:59

say okay fine

00:15:59

say okay fine that's<00:16:00.000> good<00:16:00.240> work<00:16:00.959> go<00:16:01.120> away<00:16:01.519> and<00:16:01.680> do<00:16:01.920> it<00:16:02.000> again

00:16:02

that's good work go away and do it again

00:16:02

that's good work go away and do it again and<00:16:03.120> of<00:16:03.279> course<00:16:03.519> this<00:16:03.759> prediction<00:16:04.320> has<00:16:04.880> really

00:16:05

and of course this prediction has really

00:16:05

and of course this prediction has really a<00:16:05.360> lot<00:16:05.600> of<00:16:05.759> social<00:16:06.240> utility<00:16:06.880> for<00:16:07.040> the<00:16:07.120> rest<00:16:07.360> of

00:16:07

a lot of social utility for the rest of

00:16:07

a lot of social utility for the rest of society

00:16:08

society

00:16:08

society as<00:16:08.240> you<00:16:08.320> say<00:16:08.560> in<00:16:08.720> a<00:16:08.800> civilized<00:16:09.759> country<00:16:10.399> and<00:16:10.639> in

00:16:10

as you say in a civilized country and in

00:16:10

as you say in a civilized country and in a<00:16:10.880> civilized<00:16:11.519> world

00:16:12

a civilized world

00:16:12

a civilized world this<00:16:12.480> would<00:16:12.639> be<00:16:12.800> hang<00:16:13.040> on<00:16:13.120> a<00:16:13.199> minute<00:16:13.519> we<00:16:13.600> need

00:16:13

this would be hang on a minute we need

00:16:13

this would be hang on a minute we need to<00:16:13.920> have<00:16:14.639> significant

00:16:15

to have significant

00:16:15

to have significant macroeconomic<00:16:16.720> change<00:16:17.199> to<00:16:17.360> redress<00:16:18.480> the

00:16:18

macroeconomic change to redress the

00:16:18

macroeconomic change to redress the imbalance<00:16:19.279> between<00:16:19.680> labor<00:16:20.079> and<00:16:20.240> capital

00:16:20

imbalance between labor and capital

00:16:20

imbalance between labor and capital right

00:16:21

right

00:16:21

right i<00:16:21.519> mean<00:16:21.680> what<00:16:21.680> what<00:16:22.000> happened<00:16:22.320> was<00:16:22.959> this<00:16:23.199> sort

00:16:23

i mean what what happened was this sort

00:16:23

i mean what what happened was this sort of<00:16:23.440> problem<00:16:23.759> sort<00:16:23.920> of<00:16:24.000> built<00:16:24.240> up<00:16:24.399> in<00:16:24.480> me

00:16:24

of problem sort of built up in me

00:16:24

of problem sort of built up in me over<00:16:25.120> time<00:16:25.519> eventually<00:16:26.000> i<00:16:26.560> i<00:16:26.880> escalated<00:16:27.360> to

00:16:27

over time eventually i i escalated to

00:16:27

over time eventually i i escalated to management<00:16:27.839> and<00:16:28.000> i<00:16:28.079> said<00:16:28.240> you<00:16:28.320> know<00:16:28.560> i<00:16:28.639> just

00:16:28

management and i said you know i just

00:16:28

management and i said you know i just don't<00:16:28.959> think<00:16:29.120> i<00:16:29.279> can<00:16:29.360> do<00:16:29.519> this<00:16:29.839> anymore

00:16:30

don't think i can do this anymore

00:16:30

don't think i can do this anymore because

00:16:30

because

00:16:30

because i<00:16:31.120> think<00:16:31.519> you<00:16:31.600> know<00:16:32.079> my<00:16:32.320> genuine<00:16:32.720> predictions

00:16:33

i think you know my genuine predictions

00:16:33

i think you know my genuine predictions at<00:16:33.360> the<00:16:33.440> time

00:16:34

at the time

00:16:34

at the time were<00:16:34.399> that<00:16:34.560> the<00:16:34.720> economy<00:16:35.040> was<00:16:35.199> going<00:16:35.360> to<00:16:35.440> be

00:16:35

were that the economy was going to be

00:16:35

were that the economy was going to be really<00:16:36.240> weak<00:16:36.480> for<00:16:36.639> a<00:16:36.720> long<00:16:36.880> time

00:16:37

really weak for a long time

00:16:37

really weak for a long time and<00:16:37.680> they<00:16:37.839> still<00:16:38.160> are<00:16:38.320> they<00:16:38.480> have<00:16:38.639> been<00:16:38.800> ever

00:16:39

and they still are they have been ever

00:16:39

and they still are they have been ever since<00:16:39.360> and<00:16:39.519> the<00:16:39.759> predictions<00:16:40.240> have<00:16:40.320> been<00:16:40.399> very

00:16:40

since and the predictions have been very

00:16:40

since and the predictions have been very successful<00:16:41.199> ever<00:16:41.360> since<00:16:41.600> then

00:16:41

successful ever since then

00:16:42

successful ever since then and<00:16:42.399> you<00:16:42.560> know<00:16:42.720> after<00:16:42.880> about<00:16:43.040> six<00:16:43.279> months

00:16:43

and you know after about six months

00:16:43

and you know after about six months after<00:16:43.759> that<00:16:43.920> i<00:16:44.000> went<00:16:44.160> to<00:16:44.399> management<00:16:44.800> and<00:16:44.800> said

00:16:44

after that i went to management and said

00:16:44

after that i went to management and said yeah<00:16:45.120> i<00:16:45.199> think<00:16:45.279> i<00:16:45.440> need<00:16:45.519> to<00:16:45.600> take<00:16:45.759> some<00:16:45.839> time

00:16:46

yeah i think i need to take some time

00:16:46

yeah i think i need to take some time out<00:16:46.160> and<00:16:46.240> figure<00:16:46.480> out<00:16:46.560> what<00:16:46.639> i<00:16:46.800> can<00:16:46.880> do<00:16:47.120> here

00:16:47

out and figure out what i can do here

00:16:47

out and figure out what i can do here and<00:16:48.000> then<00:16:48.160> they<00:16:48.720> they<00:16:48.880> very<00:16:49.120> strongly

00:16:49

and then they they very strongly

00:16:49

and then they they very strongly encouraged<00:16:49.839> me<00:16:49.920> not<00:16:50.079> to<00:16:50.160> do<00:16:50.320> that<00:16:50.560> and<00:16:50.639> then

00:16:51

encouraged me not to do that and then

00:16:51

encouraged me not to do that and then about<00:16:52.000> a<00:16:52.079> year<00:16:52.240> later<00:16:52.560> i<00:16:52.639> went<00:16:52.800> back<00:16:53.040> and<00:16:53.120> said

00:16:53

about a year later i went back and said

00:16:53

about a year later i went back and said look<00:16:53.519> i<00:16:53.839> i<00:16:54.160> think<00:16:54.399> i<00:16:54.480> need<00:16:54.639> to<00:16:54.720> leave<00:16:54.959> i<00:16:55.040> think<00:16:55.199> i

00:16:55

look i i think i need to leave i think i

00:16:55

look i i think i need to leave i think i need<00:16:55.440> to<00:16:55.519> go<00:16:55.759> and<00:16:55.839> work<00:16:56.079> for<00:16:56.160> a<00:16:56.240> charity

00:16:57

need to go and work for a charity

00:16:57

need to go and work for a charity that's<00:16:57.759> work<00:16:57.920> on<00:16:58.079> inequality<00:16:58.639> because<00:16:59.199> i<00:16:59.360> just

00:16:59

that's work on inequality because i just

00:16:59

that's work on inequality because i just don't<00:16:59.920> think<00:17:00.160> it's<00:17:00.320> right<00:17:00.480> me<00:17:00.639> just<00:17:00.800> sitting

00:17:01

don't think it's right me just sitting

00:17:01

don't think it's right me just sitting here<00:17:01.199> making<00:17:01.440> money<00:17:01.759> on

00:17:02

here making money on

00:17:02

here making money on the<00:17:02.399> world<00:17:02.720> being<00:17:03.199> terrible<00:17:03.680> and<00:17:03.839> um<00:17:04.640> yeah

00:17:05

the world being terrible and um yeah

00:17:05

the world being terrible and um yeah let's<00:17:05.520> just<00:17:05.919> i<00:17:06.240> don't<00:17:06.400> want<00:17:06.480> to<00:17:06.559> go<00:17:06.640> in<00:17:06.720> too

00:17:06

let's just i don't want to go in too

00:17:06

let's just i don't want to go in too much<00:17:07.120> detail<00:17:07.439> on<00:17:07.520> that<00:17:07.679> but<00:17:08.079> let's<00:17:08.319> say<00:17:08.480> the

00:17:08

much detail on that but let's say the

00:17:08

much detail on that but let's say the bank<00:17:08.799> made<00:17:09.039> it<00:17:09.199> very<00:17:09.439> difficult<00:17:09.760> for<00:17:09.919> me<00:17:10.079> to

00:17:10

bank made it very difficult for me to

00:17:10

bank made it very difficult for me to make<00:17:10.400> that<00:17:10.559> decision

00:17:11

make that decision

00:17:11

make that decision of<00:17:11.600> finally<00:17:12.000> leaving<00:17:12.400> and<00:17:12.640> uh<00:17:12.880> talking

00:17:13

of finally leaving and uh talking

00:17:13

of finally leaving and uh talking publicly<00:17:13.600> about<00:17:13.760> inequality<00:17:14.319> so<00:17:14.559> yes

00:17:14

publicly about inequality so yes

00:17:14

publicly about inequality so yes it's<00:17:15.199> a<00:17:15.280> strange<00:17:15.600> world<00:17:15.760> we<00:17:15.839> live<00:17:16.079> in<00:17:16.160> where<00:17:16.400> if

00:17:16

it's a strange world we live in where if

00:17:16

it's a strange world we live in where if you<00:17:16.959> you<00:17:17.039> can<00:17:17.199> get<00:17:17.439> paid

00:17:18

you you can get paid

00:17:18

you you can get paid huge<00:17:18.799> sums<00:17:19.039> of<00:17:19.120> money<00:17:19.600> working<00:17:19.919> for

00:17:20

huge sums of money working for

00:17:20

huge sums of money working for investment<00:17:20.640> banks<00:17:21.039> betting<00:17:21.439> the<00:17:21.520> economy

00:17:21

investment banks betting the economy

00:17:21

investment banks betting the economy will<00:17:22.000> be<00:17:22.079> terrible<00:17:22.400> forever

00:17:23

will be terrible forever

00:17:23

will be terrible forever but<00:17:23.520> i<00:17:23.600> mean<00:17:23.839> after<00:17:24.000> i<00:17:24.079> went<00:17:24.240> to<00:17:24.400> oxford<00:17:24.799> and<00:17:25.039> to

00:17:25

but i mean after i went to oxford and to

00:17:25

but i mean after i went to oxford and to do<00:17:25.360> a<00:17:25.439> master's<00:17:25.760> degree<00:17:25.919> and<00:17:26.079> tried<00:17:26.240> to<00:17:26.319> tell

00:17:26

do a master's degree and tried to tell

00:17:26

do a master's degree and tried to tell the<00:17:26.559> professors<00:17:26.959> and<00:17:27.039> say<00:17:27.199> look<00:17:27.439> economy<00:17:27.760> is

00:17:27

the professors and say look economy is

00:17:27

the professors and say look economy is going<00:17:27.919> to<00:17:28.000> be<00:17:28.079> terrible<00:17:28.400> forever<00:17:28.799> and<00:17:28.880> they

00:17:29

going to be terrible forever and they

00:17:29

going to be terrible forever and they just<00:17:29.280> said<00:17:29.520> well<00:17:29.679> go<00:17:29.840> read<00:17:30.000> this<00:17:30.160> 100<00:17:30.640> page

00:17:30

just said well go read this 100 page

00:17:30

just said well go read this 100 page paper<00:17:31.360> you<00:17:31.440> know<00:17:31.760> they<00:17:31.919> weren't<00:17:32.160> too

00:17:32

paper you know they weren't too

00:17:32

paper you know they weren't too interesting

00:17:34

interesting

00:17:34

interesting i<00:17:34.400> think<00:17:34.559> that's<00:17:34.880> a<00:17:35.039> lot<00:17:35.200> of<00:17:35.360> the<00:17:35.600> journey<00:17:36.080> but

00:17:36

i think that's a lot of the journey but

00:17:36

i think that's a lot of the journey but i<00:17:36.720> mean<00:17:36.960> i<00:17:37.039> should<00:17:37.280> say<00:17:37.520> for<00:17:37.679> podcast

00:17:38

i mean i should say for podcast

00:17:38

i mean i should say for podcast listeners

00:17:38

listeners

00:17:38

listeners i<00:17:39.039> mean<00:17:39.200> you've<00:17:39.360> written<00:17:40.000> some<00:17:40.160> stuff<00:17:40.400> for

00:17:40

i mean you've written some stuff for

00:17:40

i mean you've written some stuff for open<00:17:40.880> democracy

00:17:42

open democracy

00:17:42

open democracy that<00:17:42.320> we<00:17:42.480> will<00:17:42.720> put<00:17:43.039> in<00:17:43.200> the<00:17:43.520> podcast

00:17:44

that we will put in the podcast

00:17:44

that we will put in the podcast description<00:17:45.039> but<00:17:45.200> we<00:17:45.360> came<00:17:45.600> across

00:17:46

description but we came across

00:17:46

description but we came across you<00:17:46.480> through<00:17:47.280> a<00:17:47.600> mutual<00:17:48.000> friend<00:17:48.320> who<00:17:48.480> works

00:17:48

you through a mutual friend who works

00:17:48

you through a mutual friend who works for<00:17:48.880> another<00:17:49.120> europe<00:17:49.520> is<00:17:49.679> possible<00:17:50.080> alina

00:17:50

for another europe is possible alina

00:17:50

for another europe is possible alina ravanava<00:17:51.120> he's<00:17:51.360> a<00:17:51.440> momentum<00:17:51.919> member

00:17:52

ravanava he's a momentum member

00:17:52

ravanava he's a momentum member in<00:17:52.799> tower<00:17:53.120> hamlets<00:17:54.000> so<00:17:54.240> just<00:17:54.559> at<00:17:54.720> this<00:17:54.960> stage

00:17:55

in tower hamlets so just at this stage

00:17:55

in tower hamlets so just at this stage you<00:17:55.840> know<00:17:56.320> you<00:17:56.559> must<00:17:56.880> have<00:17:57.280> in<00:17:57.440> this<00:17:58.000> journey

00:17:58

you know you must have in this journey

00:17:58

you know you must have in this journey through<00:17:59.200> citibank<00:18:00.320> to<00:18:00.559> oxford<00:18:01.520> you<00:18:01.840> ended<00:18:02.160> up

00:18:02

through citibank to oxford you ended up

00:18:02

through citibank to oxford you ended up thinking<00:18:02.799> well<00:18:02.960> hang<00:18:03.120> on<00:18:03.280> a<00:18:03.360> minute

00:18:03

thinking well hang on a minute

00:18:04

thinking well hang on a minute this<00:18:04.320> guy<00:18:05.120> jeremy<00:18:05.600> corbyn<00:18:06.160> momentum<00:18:06.799> they've

00:18:07

this guy jeremy corbyn momentum they've

00:18:07

this guy jeremy corbyn momentum they've actually<00:18:07.360> got<00:18:07.600> a<00:18:07.679> point

00:18:08

actually got a point

00:18:08

actually got a point i<00:18:08.240> mean<00:18:08.400> that's<00:18:08.799> like<00:18:09.440> a<00:18:09.600> quite<00:18:10.080> phenomenal

00:18:11

i mean that's like a quite phenomenal

00:18:11

i mean that's like a quite phenomenal journey<00:18:11.919> in<00:18:12.160> quite<00:18:12.320> a<00:18:12.400> short<00:18:12.720> space<00:18:13.039> of<00:18:13.200> time

00:18:13

journey in quite a short space of time

00:18:13

journey in quite a short space of time it<00:18:13.760> might<00:18:14.000> seem<00:18:14.240> like<00:18:14.400> a<00:18:14.480> big<00:18:14.640> journey<00:18:15.039> really

00:18:15

it might seem like a big journey really

00:18:15

it might seem like a big journey really but

00:18:15

but

00:18:15

but for<00:18:16.000> me<00:18:16.240> i<00:18:16.320> think<00:18:17.520> i<00:18:17.600> don't<00:18:17.760> view<00:18:18.000> myself<00:18:18.400> as<00:18:18.559> a

00:18:18

for me i think i don't view myself as a

00:18:18

for me i think i don't view myself as a hugely<00:18:19.280> political<00:18:19.679> person<00:18:20.080> but<00:18:20.320> you<00:18:20.400> know<00:18:20.880> my

00:18:21

hugely political person but you know my

00:18:21

hugely political person but you know my life<00:18:21.360> has<00:18:21.520> been

00:18:22

life has been

00:18:22

life has been devoted<00:18:22.720> for<00:18:23.039> 15<00:18:23.360> years<00:18:23.600> now<00:18:23.760> to<00:18:23.919> the<00:18:24.080> study<00:18:24.320> of

00:18:24

devoted for 15 years now to the study of

00:18:24

devoted for 15 years now to the study of economics<00:18:25.120> and

00:18:25

economics and

00:18:25

economics and i've<00:18:26.160> been<00:18:26.400> very<00:18:26.640> successful<00:18:27.360> doing<00:18:27.600> that

00:18:27

i've been very successful doing that

00:18:27

i've been very successful doing that i've<00:18:27.919> made<00:18:28.080> a<00:18:28.160> lot<00:18:28.240> of<00:18:28.320> money<00:18:28.559> doing<00:18:28.799> that<00:18:29.039> and

00:18:29

i've made a lot of money doing that and

00:18:29

i've made a lot of money doing that and i<00:18:29.520> think<00:18:29.760> it's<00:18:30.000> because<00:18:30.960> i<00:18:31.200> have<00:18:31.440> understood

00:18:31

i think it's because i have understood

00:18:31

i think it's because i have understood that<00:18:32.000> inequality<00:18:32.480> is<00:18:32.559> phenomenally

00:18:33

that inequality is phenomenally

00:18:33

that inequality is phenomenally important<00:18:34.559> i<00:18:34.640> think<00:18:34.799> if<00:18:34.880> you<00:18:34.960> don't<00:18:35.120> do

00:18:35

important i think if you don't do

00:18:35

important i think if you don't do something<00:18:35.520> about<00:18:35.840> it

00:18:36

something about it

00:18:36

something about it it's<00:18:36.720> not<00:18:36.799> just<00:18:37.039> the<00:18:37.120> moral<00:18:37.440> issue<00:18:37.600> here<00:18:37.760> you

00:18:37

it's not just the moral issue here you

00:18:37

it's not just the moral issue here you know<00:18:38.000> it<00:18:38.160> leads<00:18:38.480> to<00:18:39.120> low<00:18:39.360> wages<00:18:39.919> unaffordable

00:18:40

know it leads to low wages unaffordable

00:18:40

know it leads to low wages unaffordable housing<00:18:40.880> lower<00:18:41.039> living<00:18:41.280> conditions

00:18:41

housing lower living conditions

00:18:42

housing lower living conditions and<00:18:44.240> that's<00:18:44.480> what<00:18:44.559> i<00:18:44.640> think

00:18:45

and that's what i think

00:18:45

and that's what i think happens<00:18:45.600> if<00:18:45.679> you<00:18:45.760> have<00:18:45.840> very<00:18:46.000> high<00:18:46.160> inequality

00:18:46

happens if you have very high inequality

00:18:46

happens if you have very high inequality and<00:18:46.960> i<00:18:47.039> don't<00:18:47.200> think<00:18:47.360> it's<00:18:47.520> really<00:18:47.760> understood

00:18:48

and i don't think it's really understood

00:18:48

and i don't think it's really understood at<00:18:48.160> university<00:18:48.799> i<00:18:48.880> think<00:18:49.039> that's<00:18:49.200> the<00:18:49.280> reason

00:18:49

at university i think that's the reason

00:18:49

at university i think that's the reason why<00:18:49.679> i've<00:18:49.840> been<00:18:50.000> able<00:18:50.240> to

00:18:50

why i've been able to

00:18:50

why i've been able to beat<00:18:50.880> the<00:18:50.960> market<00:18:51.360> year<00:18:51.600> after<00:18:51.840> year<00:18:52.559> so<00:18:53.280> since

00:18:53

beat the market year after year so since

00:18:53

beat the market year after year so since i<00:18:53.760> think<00:18:54.000> that<00:18:54.480> that's<00:18:54.720> my<00:18:54.880> economic<00:18:55.280> view<00:18:56.080> i

00:18:56

i think that that's my economic view i

00:18:56

i think that that's my economic view i need<00:18:56.559> to<00:18:56.720> find<00:18:56.960> a<00:18:57.039> way

00:18:57

need to find a way

00:18:57

need to find a way to<00:18:57.440> get<00:18:57.600> my<00:18:57.760> voice<00:18:58.080> out<00:18:58.240> basically<00:18:58.640> so<00:18:58.799> i've

00:18:59

to get my voice out basically so i've

00:18:59

to get my voice out basically so i've been<00:18:59.200> looking<00:18:59.360> for<00:18:59.520> the<00:18:59.600> last<00:18:59.840> few<00:19:00.000> years

00:19:00

been looking for the last few years

00:19:00

been looking for the last few years basically

00:19:00

basically

00:19:00

basically just<00:19:00.799> spaces<00:19:01.280> where<00:19:01.440> i<00:19:01.520> can<00:19:01.840> speak<00:19:02.160> about

00:19:02

just spaces where i can speak about

00:19:02

just spaces where i can speak about inequality<00:19:03.039> and<00:19:03.200> its<00:19:03.280> relevance<00:19:03.679> to

00:19:03

inequality and its relevance to

00:19:03

inequality and its relevance to economics<00:19:04.240> so<00:19:04.480> i've<00:19:04.640> been<00:19:04.799> looking<00:19:05.120> through

00:19:05

economics so i've been looking through

00:19:05

economics so i've been looking through loads<00:19:05.919> of<00:19:06.000> different<00:19:06.240> channels<00:19:06.640> i

00:19:06

loads of different channels i

00:19:06

loads of different channels i volunteered<00:19:07.120> at<00:19:07.280> new<00:19:07.440> economics<00:19:07.840> foundation

00:19:08

volunteered at new economics foundation

00:19:08

volunteered at new economics foundation for<00:19:08.480> a<00:19:08.559> bit<00:19:08.799> working<00:19:09.120> with<00:19:09.280> a<00:19:09.360> guy<00:19:09.600> called

00:19:09

for a bit working with a guy called

00:19:09

for a bit working with a guy called james<00:19:10.080> midway

00:19:11

james midway

00:19:11

james midway when<00:19:11.520> momentum<00:19:12.000> popped<00:19:12.240> up<00:19:12.320> but<00:19:12.559> these<00:19:12.720> guys

00:19:12

when momentum popped up but these guys

00:19:12

when momentum popped up but these guys were<00:19:12.960> talking<00:19:13.280> a<00:19:13.280> lot<00:19:13.440> about<00:19:13.600> inequality

00:19:14

were talking a lot about inequality

00:19:14

were talking a lot about inequality and<00:19:14.480> i<00:19:14.559> thought<00:19:14.799> maybe<00:19:15.039> here's<00:19:15.360> a<00:19:15.520> place<00:19:16.240> where

00:19:16

and i thought maybe here's a place where

00:19:16

and i thought maybe here's a place where i<00:19:16.480> can<00:19:16.559> get<00:19:16.720> a<00:19:16.799> bit<00:19:16.880> of<00:19:17.039> a<00:19:17.120> voice

00:19:18

i can get a bit of a voice

00:19:18

i can get a bit of a voice to<00:19:18.320> be<00:19:18.400> honest<00:19:18.640> i've<00:19:18.720> been<00:19:18.880> looking<00:19:19.039> all<00:19:19.200> over

00:19:19

to be honest i've been looking all over

00:19:19

to be honest i've been looking all over the<00:19:19.440> place<00:19:19.600> you<00:19:19.679> know<00:19:19.760> i<00:19:19.840> wrote<00:19:20.000> for<00:19:20.080> the<00:19:20.160> daily

00:19:20

the place you know i wrote for the daily

00:19:20

the place you know i wrote for the daily express

00:19:21

express

00:19:21

express last<00:19:21.440> week<00:19:22.000> yeah<00:19:22.160> it<00:19:22.240> might<00:19:22.480> seem<00:19:22.640> like<00:19:22.799> a<00:19:22.880> long

00:19:23

last week yeah it might seem like a long

00:19:23

last week yeah it might seem like a long journey<00:19:23.280> to<00:19:23.440> be<00:19:23.520> honest<00:19:23.760> but<00:19:24.000> you<00:19:24.080> know

00:19:24

journey to be honest but you know

00:19:24

journey to be honest but you know i<00:19:24.559> look<00:19:24.799> i<00:19:24.880> learned<00:19:25.120> about<00:19:25.280> economics<00:19:25.840> at<00:19:26.320> lsu

00:19:26

i look i learned about economics at lsu

00:19:26

i look i learned about economics at lsu and<00:19:27.200> in<00:19:27.280> the<00:19:27.360> banking<00:19:27.760> sector<00:19:28.160> and

00:19:28

and in the banking sector and

00:19:28

and in the banking sector and the<00:19:29.039> way<00:19:29.280> i<00:19:29.440> see<00:19:29.679> it<00:19:29.840> is<00:19:30.240> if<00:19:30.400> we<00:19:30.480> don't<00:19:30.640> do

00:19:30

the way i see it is if we don't do

00:19:30

the way i see it is if we don't do something<00:19:30.960> about<00:19:31.120> inequality

00:19:32

something about inequality

00:19:32

something about inequality the<00:19:32.320> economy<00:19:32.720> is<00:19:32.799> going<00:19:32.880> to<00:19:32.960> be<00:19:33.039> in<00:19:33.200> a<00:19:33.280> really

00:19:33

the economy is going to be in a really

00:19:33

the economy is going to be in a really really<00:19:34.080> bad<00:19:34.400> way<00:19:34.720> so

00:19:35

really bad way so

00:19:35

really bad way so you<00:19:36.000> know<00:19:37.039> for<00:19:37.200> me<00:19:37.360> it's<00:19:37.440> not<00:19:37.520> a<00:19:37.600> political

00:19:37

you know for me it's not a political

00:19:38

you know for me it's not a political issue<00:19:38.320> do<00:19:38.480> you<00:19:38.559> want<00:19:38.640> an<00:19:38.799> economic<00:19:39.120> disaster

00:19:39

issue do you want an economic disaster

00:19:39

issue do you want an economic disaster or<00:19:39.679> don't<00:19:39.919> you

00:19:46

before<00:19:46.799> we<00:19:46.960> get<00:19:47.200> back<00:19:47.440> to<00:19:47.600> the<00:19:47.679> podcast<00:19:48.320> with

00:19:48

before we get back to the podcast with

00:19:48

before we get back to the podcast with gary<00:19:48.960> and<00:19:49.200> his<00:19:49.520> truly<00:19:49.919> amazing<00:19:50.400> story

00:19:51

gary and his truly amazing story

00:19:51

gary and his truly amazing story a<00:19:51.360> quick<00:19:51.679> shout<00:19:52.000> out<00:19:52.320> for<00:19:52.480> a<00:19:52.559> new<00:19:52.799> series<00:19:53.200> of

00:19:53

a quick shout out for a new series of

00:19:53

a quick shout out for a new series of podcasts<00:19:53.919> i've<00:19:54.080> made<00:19:54.320> for<00:19:54.480> the<00:19:54.559> lse

00:19:55

podcasts i've made for the lse

00:19:55

podcasts i've made for the lse about<00:19:55.600> the<00:19:55.760> causes<00:19:56.240> of<00:19:56.400> war<00:19:56.720> and<00:19:56.799> conflict<00:19:57.440> in

00:19:57

about the causes of war and conflict in

00:19:57

about the causes of war and conflict in the<00:19:57.679> 21st<00:19:58.400> century

00:19:59

the 21st century

00:19:59

the 21st century across<00:19:59.840> six<00:20:00.160> episodes<00:20:00.720> we<00:20:00.960> dig<00:20:01.280> deeper<00:20:01.760> into

00:20:01

across six episodes we dig deeper into

00:20:02

across six episodes we dig deeper into the<00:20:02.159> ideas<00:20:02.640> and<00:20:02.799> theory<00:20:03.280> you<00:20:03.520> need<00:20:03.760> to<00:20:03.919> make

00:20:04

the ideas and theory you need to make

00:20:04

the ideas and theory you need to make sense<00:20:04.480> of<00:20:04.640> society's<00:20:05.360> experiencing

00:20:06

sense of society's experiencing

00:20:06

sense of society's experiencing intractable<00:20:07.440> conflict<00:20:08.320> and<00:20:08.640> organized

00:20:09

intractable conflict and organized

00:20:09

intractable conflict and organized violence

00:20:10

violence

00:20:10

violence we<00:20:10.400> investigate<00:20:11.039> the<00:20:11.200> causes<00:20:11.600> of<00:20:11.760> conflict<00:20:12.320> in

00:20:12

we investigate the causes of conflict in

00:20:12

we investigate the causes of conflict in the<00:20:12.480> horn<00:20:12.799> of<00:20:12.960> africa<00:20:13.440> central<00:20:13.919> africa<00:20:14.400> and

00:20:14

the horn of africa central africa and

00:20:14

the horn of africa central africa and the<00:20:14.640> middle<00:20:15.039> east

00:20:15

the middle east

00:20:15

the middle east expose<00:20:16.320> the<00:20:16.480> networks<00:20:17.120> of<00:20:17.280> dark<00:20:17.679> money

00:20:18

expose the networks of dark money

00:20:18

expose the networks of dark money fueling<00:20:18.880> conflict

00:20:19

fueling conflict

00:20:19

fueling conflict and<00:20:19.919> uncover<00:20:20.400> the<00:20:20.559> positive<00:20:21.120> stories<00:20:21.919> of

00:20:22

and uncover the positive stories of

00:20:22

and uncover the positive stories of democratic<00:20:22.960> civil<00:20:23.360> society<00:20:24.000> resistance

00:20:25

democratic civil society resistance

00:20:25

democratic civil society resistance promoting<00:20:25.679> peace<00:20:26.240> and<00:20:26.559> social<00:20:27.039> justice<00:20:28.000> you

00:20:28

promoting peace and social justice you

00:20:28

promoting peace and social justice you can<00:20:28.400> find<00:20:28.720> them

00:20:29

can find them

00:20:29

can find them by<00:20:29.440> searching<00:20:29.919> for<00:20:30.240> conflict<00:20:30.799> zone<00:20:31.520> from<00:20:31.679> the

00:20:31

by searching for conflict zone from the

00:20:31

by searching for conflict zone from the lse

00:20:32

lse

00:20:32

lse wherever<00:20:33.039> you<00:20:33.200> get<00:20:33.440> your<00:20:33.600> podcasts<00:20:34.480> from

00:20:41

so<00:20:42.080> to<00:20:42.240> move<00:20:42.559> on<00:20:42.640> to<00:20:42.799> that<00:20:43.039> impending<00:20:43.440> disaster

00:20:44

so to move on to that impending disaster

00:20:44

so to move on to that impending disaster or<00:20:44.400> the<00:20:44.559> disaster<00:20:45.039> we're<00:20:45.280> already<00:20:45.679> in

00:20:46

or the disaster we're already in

00:20:46

or the disaster we're already in can<00:20:46.320> you<00:20:46.559> describe<00:20:47.039> how<00:20:47.200> the<00:20:47.280> economic

00:20:47

can you describe how the economic

00:20:47

can you describe how the economic choices<00:20:48.240> made<00:20:48.480> in<00:20:48.559> the<00:20:48.640> financial<00:20:49.200> crash

00:20:49

choices made in the financial crash

00:20:49

choices made in the financial crash produced<00:20:50.320> a<00:20:50.480> sharp<00:20:50.720> increase<00:20:51.039> in<00:20:51.120> global

00:20:51

produced a sharp increase in global

00:20:51

produced a sharp increase in global inequality<00:20:52.159> yeah<00:20:52.320> so<00:20:52.480> when<00:20:52.640> we<00:20:52.720> go<00:20:52.880> back<00:20:53.039> to

00:20:53

inequality yeah so when we go back to

00:20:53

inequality yeah so when we go back to 2008

00:20:54

2008

00:20:54

2008 this<00:20:54.640> is<00:20:55.280> what<00:20:55.520> economists<00:20:56.000> might<00:20:56.240> call<00:20:56.799> a

00:20:56

this is what economists might call a

00:20:56

this is what economists might call a demand<00:20:57.440> crisis<00:20:57.919> right<00:20:58.159> which<00:20:58.320> is<00:20:58.400> worth<00:20:58.640> just

00:20:58

demand crisis right which is worth just

00:20:58

demand crisis right which is worth just talking<00:20:59.039> about<00:20:59.280> just<00:20:59.440> a<00:20:59.520> little<00:20:59.679> bit

00:21:00

talking about just a little bit

00:21:00

talking about just a little bit it's<00:21:00.400> a<00:21:00.480> crisis<00:21:00.880> that<00:21:00.960> happens<00:21:01.280> when<00:21:01.520> suddenly

00:21:02

it's a crisis that happens when suddenly

00:21:02

it's a crisis that happens when suddenly people<00:21:02.559> stop<00:21:02.880> spending

00:21:03

people stop spending

00:21:03

people stop spending and<00:21:03.760> that's<00:21:04.000> an<00:21:04.159> interesting<00:21:04.559> crisis<00:21:04.960> because

00:21:05

and that's an interesting crisis because

00:21:05

and that's an interesting crisis because i<00:21:05.120> think<00:21:05.280> when<00:21:05.520> people<00:21:06.080> think<00:21:06.320> about

00:21:06

i think when people think about

00:21:06

i think when people think about economics

00:21:07

economics

00:21:07

economics they<00:21:07.600> tend<00:21:07.840> to<00:21:07.919> think<00:21:08.080> about<00:21:08.320> the<00:21:08.480> production

00:21:08

they tend to think about the production

00:21:08

they tend to think about the production side<00:21:09.200> of<00:21:09.280> things<00:21:09.679> they<00:21:09.840> think<00:21:10.000> oh<00:21:10.240> we've<00:21:10.400> got<00:21:10.480> a

00:21:10

side of things they think oh we've got a

00:21:10

side of things they think oh we've got a problem<00:21:10.880> because<00:21:11.039> we're<00:21:11.200> not<00:21:11.280> producing

00:21:11

problem because we're not producing

00:21:11

problem because we're not producing enough

00:21:12

enough

00:21:12

enough but<00:21:12.640> 2008<00:21:13.600> and<00:21:14.000> in<00:21:14.159> many<00:21:14.320> ways<00:21:14.640> also<00:21:15.200> this

00:21:15

but 2008 and in many ways also this

00:21:15

but 2008 and in many ways also this crisis<00:21:15.840> now

00:21:17

crisis now

00:21:17

crisis now is<00:21:17.280> coming<00:21:17.520> about<00:21:17.760> because<00:21:18.000> people<00:21:18.240> suddenly

00:21:18

is coming about because people suddenly

00:21:18

is coming about because people suddenly stop<00:21:18.880> spending<00:21:19.280> and<00:21:19.520> that<00:21:19.760> creates<00:21:20.080> a<00:21:20.240> problem

00:21:20

stop spending and that creates a problem

00:21:20

stop spending and that creates a problem because<00:21:20.880> if<00:21:20.960> people<00:21:21.280> stop<00:21:21.520> spending

00:21:22

because if people stop spending

00:21:22

because if people stop spending then<00:21:22.559> companies<00:21:23.200> let<00:21:23.360> off<00:21:23.520> workers<00:21:24.400> they

00:21:24

then companies let off workers they

00:21:24

then companies let off workers they don't<00:21:24.960> invest<00:21:25.280> they<00:21:25.440> don't<00:21:25.679> grow

00:21:26

don't invest they don't grow

00:21:26

don't invest they don't grow and<00:21:26.640> lots<00:21:26.799> of<00:21:26.880> people<00:21:27.120> lose<00:21:27.280> their<00:21:27.440> jobs<00:21:27.919> and

00:21:28

and lots of people lose their jobs and

00:21:28

and lots of people lose their jobs and we<00:21:28.640> get<00:21:28.799> high<00:21:28.960> unemployment<00:21:29.440> people<00:21:29.679> can't

00:21:29

we get high unemployment people can't

00:21:29

we get high unemployment people can't pay<00:21:30.000> their<00:21:30.159> bills<00:21:30.480> so

00:21:31

pay their bills so

00:21:31

pay their bills so in<00:21:31.360> that<00:21:31.520> sense<00:21:31.760> that<00:21:31.919> crisis<00:21:32.400> and<00:21:32.480> this

00:21:32

in that sense that crisis and this

00:21:32

in that sense that crisis and this crisis<00:21:32.880> is<00:21:32.960> now<00:21:33.120> quite<00:21:33.360> similar<00:21:34.000> now

00:21:34

crisis is now quite similar now

00:21:34

crisis is now quite similar now modern<00:21:35.679> mainstream<00:21:36.320> economic<00:21:36.799> thinking<00:21:37.120> like

00:21:37

modern mainstream economic thinking like

00:21:37

modern mainstream economic thinking like you<00:21:37.440> would<00:21:37.520> get<00:21:37.679> at<00:21:37.840> university<00:21:38.400> will

00:21:38

you would get at university will

00:21:38

you would get at university will basically<00:21:38.960> tell<00:21:39.120> you<00:21:39.280> there's<00:21:39.440> two<00:21:39.600> things

00:21:39

basically tell you there's two things

00:21:39

basically tell you there's two things you<00:21:39.919> can<00:21:40.080> do<00:21:40.240> in<00:21:40.320> this<00:21:40.400> kind<00:21:40.559> of<00:21:40.640> situation

00:21:41

you can do in this kind of situation

00:21:41

you can do in this kind of situation one<00:21:41.840> is<00:21:41.919> what<00:21:42.000> they'll<00:21:42.240> call<00:21:42.480> fiscal<00:21:42.880> policy

00:21:43

one is what they'll call fiscal policy

00:21:43

one is what they'll call fiscal policy which<00:21:43.520> is<00:21:43.679> basically<00:21:44.559> governments<00:21:45.039> just<00:21:45.200> come

00:21:45

which is basically governments just come

00:21:45

which is basically governments just come in<00:21:45.520> and<00:21:45.679> directly<00:21:46.240> spend

00:21:46

in and directly spend

00:21:46

in and directly spend so<00:21:47.200> the<00:21:47.280> problem<00:21:47.600> with<00:21:47.679> the<00:21:47.760> economy<00:21:48.080> is<00:21:48.159> not

00:21:48

so the problem with the economy is not

00:21:48

so the problem with the economy is not enough<00:21:48.480> spending<00:21:49.120> so<00:21:49.280> the<00:21:49.360> government<00:21:49.679> comes

00:21:49

enough spending so the government comes

00:21:49

enough spending so the government comes in<00:21:50.080> they<00:21:50.159> spend<00:21:50.480> themselves

00:21:51

in they spend themselves

00:21:51

in they spend themselves and<00:21:51.840> you<00:21:51.919> know<00:21:52.080> it<00:21:52.159> could<00:21:52.320> be<00:21:52.480> on<00:21:52.640> anything

00:21:52

and you know it could be on anything

00:21:52

and you know it could be on anything really<00:21:53.200> but<00:21:53.440> you<00:21:53.520> know<00:21:53.760> obviously<00:21:54.080> there's<00:21:54.240> a

00:21:54

really but you know obviously there's a

00:21:54

really but you know obviously there's a lot<00:21:54.400> of<00:21:54.480> talk<00:21:54.720> this<00:21:54.880> time<00:21:55.039> of<00:21:55.200> a<00:21:55.280> green<00:21:55.440> new

00:21:55

lot of talk this time of a green new

00:21:55

lot of talk this time of a green new deal<00:21:56.080> or<00:21:56.240> you<00:21:56.320> know

00:21:56

deal or you know

00:21:56

deal or you know necessary<00:21:57.440> investments<00:21:58.000> and<00:21:58.159> infrastructure

00:21:58

necessary investments and infrastructure

00:21:58

necessary investments and infrastructure this<00:21:58.960> kind<00:21:59.200> of<00:21:59.280> thing<00:21:59.520> but<00:21:59.679> the<00:21:59.840> idea<00:22:00.240> is<00:22:00.400> we

00:22:00

this kind of thing but the idea is we

00:22:00

this kind of thing but the idea is we don't<00:22:00.720> have<00:22:00.799> enough<00:22:00.960> spending<00:22:01.280> in<00:22:01.360> the

00:22:01

don't have enough spending in the

00:22:01

don't have enough spending in the economy

00:22:02

economy

00:22:02

economy so<00:22:02.240> the<00:22:02.400> government<00:22:02.799> comes<00:22:03.039> in<00:22:03.200> and<00:22:03.360> spends

00:22:04

so the government comes in and spends

00:22:04

so the government comes in and spends that<00:22:04.320> creates<00:22:04.640> the<00:22:04.720> spending

00:22:05

that creates the spending

00:22:05

that creates the spending that<00:22:05.600> creates<00:22:05.919> the<00:22:06.080> jobs<00:22:06.880> that<00:22:07.039> prevents

00:22:07

that creates the jobs that prevents

00:22:07

that creates the jobs that prevents unemployment<00:22:07.840> from<00:22:08.000> going<00:22:08.240> up

00:22:08

unemployment from going up

00:22:08

unemployment from going up uh<00:22:09.039> that's<00:22:09.440> fiscal<00:22:10.320> policy<00:22:10.720> that's<00:22:10.880> one<00:22:11.039> way

00:22:11

uh that's fiscal policy that's one way

00:22:11

uh that's fiscal policy that's one way to<00:22:11.360> deal<00:22:11.520> with<00:22:11.679> it<00:22:11.840> and<00:22:12.000> in<00:22:12.159> 2008

00:22:13

to deal with it and in 2008

00:22:13

to deal with it and in 2008 a<00:22:13.919> decision<00:22:14.400> was<00:22:14.640> kind<00:22:14.880> of<00:22:15.039> made<00:22:15.520> over<00:22:15.760> the

00:22:15

a decision was kind of made over the

00:22:15

a decision was kind of made over the longer<00:22:16.159> term<00:22:16.559> especially<00:22:16.960> by<00:22:17.120> the

00:22:17

longer term especially by the

00:22:17

longer term especially by the conservative

00:22:18

conservative

00:22:18

conservative it<00:22:18.159> was<00:22:18.320> a<00:22:18.400> coalition<00:22:18.799> government<00:22:19.120> after<00:22:19.360> 2010

00:22:20

it was a coalition government after 2010

00:22:20

it was a coalition government after 2010 not<00:22:20.720> to<00:22:20.880> really<00:22:21.280> go<00:22:21.520> for<00:22:21.679> a<00:22:21.760> lot<00:22:21.919> of<00:22:22.159> aggressive

00:22:22

not to really go for a lot of aggressive

00:22:22

not to really go for a lot of aggressive fiscal<00:22:22.960> support<00:22:23.360> not<00:22:23.520> to<00:22:23.600> go<00:22:23.679> for<00:22:23.840> a<00:22:23.840> lot<00:22:23.919> of

00:22:23

fiscal support not to go for a lot of

00:22:24

fiscal support not to go for a lot of government<00:22:24.320> support

00:22:25

government support

00:22:25

government support so<00:22:25.520> that<00:22:25.679> meant<00:22:26.000> instead<00:22:26.720> we<00:22:26.880> went<00:22:27.039> for<00:22:27.200> the

00:22:27

so that meant instead we went for the

00:22:27

so that meant instead we went for the other<00:22:28.159> method<00:22:28.480> of<00:22:28.559> supporting<00:22:28.960> which<00:22:29.200> is

00:22:29

other method of supporting which is

00:22:29

other method of supporting which is what<00:22:29.600> we<00:22:29.760> call<00:22:29.919> monetary<00:22:30.480> policy<00:22:30.880> monetary

00:22:31

what we call monetary policy monetary

00:22:31

what we call monetary policy monetary stimulus<00:22:32.240> and

00:22:32

stimulus and

00:22:32

stimulus and in<00:22:32.799> this<00:22:33.440> mode<00:22:33.760> of<00:22:33.840> supporting<00:22:34.159> an<00:22:34.320> economy

00:22:35

in this mode of supporting an economy

00:22:35

in this mode of supporting an economy the<00:22:35.280> central<00:22:35.679> bank<00:22:36.000> so<00:22:36.159> in<00:22:36.240> this<00:22:36.320> country<00:22:36.640> the

00:22:36

the central bank so in this country the

00:22:36

the central bank so in this country the bank<00:22:36.880> of<00:22:37.039> england

00:22:37

bank of england

00:22:38

bank of england prints<00:22:38.320> a<00:22:38.400> lot<00:22:38.480> of<00:22:38.559> money<00:22:38.960> i<00:22:39.039> think<00:22:39.280> people<00:22:39.440> get

00:22:39

prints a lot of money i think people get

00:22:39

prints a lot of money i think people get confused<00:22:40.000> about<00:22:40.159> that<00:22:40.320> sometimes<00:22:40.720> but<00:22:40.880> you

00:22:40

confused about that sometimes but you

00:22:40

confused about that sometimes but you just<00:22:41.120> need<00:22:41.280> to<00:22:41.360> understand<00:22:41.679> the<00:22:41.840> central<00:22:42.080> bank

00:22:42

just need to understand the central bank

00:22:42

just need to understand the central bank is<00:22:42.559> allowed<00:22:42.880> to<00:22:43.039> create<00:22:43.520> new<00:22:43.760> money

00:22:44

is allowed to create new money

00:22:44

is allowed to create new money electronically

00:22:45

electronically

00:22:45

electronically and<00:22:45.120> then<00:22:45.280> they<00:22:45.520> lend<00:22:45.760> that<00:22:45.919> into<00:22:46.080> the<00:22:46.240> system

00:22:47

and then they lend that into the system

00:22:47

and then they lend that into the system now<00:22:47.440> this<00:22:47.600> is<00:22:47.760> a<00:22:47.840> more<00:22:48.080> interesting<00:22:48.480> way<00:22:48.640> of

00:22:48

now this is a more interesting way of

00:22:48

now this is a more interesting way of stimulating<00:22:49.200> an<00:22:49.360> economy

00:22:50

stimulating an economy

00:22:50

stimulating an economy because<00:22:50.559> it<00:22:50.720> doesn't<00:22:51.120> directly<00:22:51.679> create

00:22:52

because it doesn't directly create

00:22:52

because it doesn't directly create spending<00:22:52.480> it<00:22:52.559> doesn't<00:22:52.720> directly<00:22:53.120> create

00:22:53

spending it doesn't directly create

00:22:53

spending it doesn't directly create demand

00:22:54

demand

00:22:54

demand the<00:22:54.400> people<00:22:54.640> who<00:22:54.799> get<00:22:54.960> lent<00:22:55.200> the<00:22:55.280> money<00:22:55.679> need

00:22:55

the people who get lent the money need

00:22:55

the people who get lent the money need to<00:22:56.000> spend<00:22:56.320> it<00:22:56.720> so

00:22:57

to spend it so

00:22:57

to spend it so what<00:22:57.440> happened<00:22:57.840> in<00:22:57.919> 2008<00:22:58.720> largely<00:22:59.600> the

00:22:59

what happened in 2008 largely the

00:22:59

what happened in 2008 largely the central<00:23:00.080> bank<00:23:00.240> lends<00:23:00.559> loads<00:23:00.720> of<00:23:00.799> money<00:23:01.039> to<00:23:01.120> the

00:23:01

central bank lends loads of money to the

00:23:01

central bank lends loads of money to the commercial<00:23:01.600> banks<00:23:02.000> and<00:23:02.080> then<00:23:02.240> the<00:23:02.320> commercial

00:23:02

commercial banks and then the commercial

00:23:02

commercial banks and then the commercial banks<00:23:02.880> need<00:23:03.039> to<00:23:03.120> lend<00:23:03.360> it<00:23:03.520> on

00:23:04

banks need to lend it on

00:23:04

banks need to lend it on but<00:23:04.400> of<00:23:04.480> course<00:23:04.720> the<00:23:04.880> people<00:23:05.280> who<00:23:05.679> can<00:23:05.919> most

00:23:06

but of course the people who can most

00:23:06

but of course the people who can most easily<00:23:06.640> borrow<00:23:06.880> money<00:23:07.120> from<00:23:07.280> commercial

00:23:07

easily borrow money from commercial

00:23:07

easily borrow money from commercial banks

00:23:08

banks

00:23:08

banks are<00:23:09.039> big<00:23:09.280> investment<00:23:09.760> funds<00:23:10.159> or<00:23:10.480> companies<00:23:11.039> or

00:23:11

are big investment funds or companies or

00:23:11

are big investment funds or companies or richer<00:23:11.600> individuals

00:23:12

richer individuals

00:23:12

richer individuals and<00:23:13.039> what<00:23:13.200> happened<00:23:13.520> in<00:23:13.600> 2008<00:23:14.320> was<00:23:14.799> because

00:23:15

and what happened in 2008 was because

00:23:15

and what happened in 2008 was because there<00:23:15.520> wasn't<00:23:15.840> much

00:23:16

there wasn't much

00:23:16

there wasn't much space<00:23:16.720> for<00:23:16.960> growth<00:23:17.280> because<00:23:17.440> there<00:23:17.520> wasn't

00:23:17

space for growth because there wasn't

00:23:17

space for growth because there wasn't much<00:23:17.919> spending<00:23:18.880> rich<00:23:19.200> individuals<00:23:19.919> and

00:23:20

much spending rich individuals and

00:23:20

much spending rich individuals and investment<00:23:20.720> corporations<00:23:21.280> they<00:23:21.440> borrowed

00:23:21

investment corporations they borrowed

00:23:21

investment corporations they borrowed this

00:23:21

this

00:23:22

this money<00:23:22.559> and<00:23:22.720> rather<00:23:23.039> than<00:23:23.200> investing<00:23:23.679> they

00:23:23

money and rather than investing they

00:23:23

money and rather than investing they just<00:23:24.000> bought<00:23:24.320> existing<00:23:24.720> assets

00:23:25

just bought existing assets

00:23:25

just bought existing assets so<00:23:25.919> if<00:23:26.080> you<00:23:26.159> go<00:23:26.320> back<00:23:26.480> and<00:23:26.559> look<00:23:26.720> at<00:23:26.799> 2008<00:23:27.520> you

00:23:27

so if you go back and look at 2008 you

00:23:27

so if you go back and look at 2008 you can<00:23:27.840> see

00:23:28

can see

00:23:28

can see even<00:23:28.880> though<00:23:29.039> the<00:23:29.200> economy<00:23:29.520> was<00:23:29.760> really<00:23:30.000> weak

00:23:30

even though the economy was really weak

00:23:30

even though the economy was really weak relatively<00:23:31.120> quickly<00:23:31.520> after<00:23:31.760> the<00:23:31.840> crisis

00:23:32

relatively quickly after the crisis

00:23:32

relatively quickly after the crisis asset<00:23:33.039> prices<00:23:33.360> started<00:23:33.760> roaring<00:23:34.159> upwards<00:23:34.559> so

00:23:34

asset prices started roaring upwards so

00:23:34

asset prices started roaring upwards so the<00:23:34.960> first<00:23:35.120> one<00:23:35.280> was<00:23:35.520> gold<00:23:35.520> gold

00:23:36

the first one was gold gold

00:23:36

the first one was gold gold started<00:23:36.400> flying<00:23:36.880> and<00:23:37.440> you<00:23:37.600> might<00:23:37.760> have<00:23:37.840> seen

00:23:38

started flying and you might have seen

00:23:38

started flying and you might have seen just<00:23:38.480> overnight<00:23:38.960> last<00:23:39.280> night<00:23:39.600> gold<00:23:39.919> hit<00:23:40.080> a<00:23:40.159> new

00:23:40

just overnight last night gold hit a new

00:23:40

just overnight last night gold hit a new all-time<00:23:40.720> historic<00:23:41.200> high

00:23:42

all-time historic high

00:23:42

all-time historic high so<00:23:42.320> it's<00:23:42.480> happening<00:23:42.880> again<00:23:43.200> now<00:23:43.679> first<00:23:44.000> gold

00:23:44

so it's happening again now first gold

00:23:44

so it's happening again now first gold started<00:23:44.480> going<00:23:44.799> up

00:23:45

started going up

00:23:45

started going up then<00:23:45.440> relatively<00:23:45.919> quickly<00:23:46.240> stocks<00:23:46.559> started

00:23:46

then relatively quickly stocks started

00:23:46

then relatively quickly stocks started going<00:23:47.120> up<00:23:47.520> and<00:23:47.679> then<00:23:47.840> after<00:23:48.159> a<00:23:48.240> short<00:23:48.480> delay

00:23:48

going up and then after a short delay

00:23:48

going up and then after a short delay house<00:23:49.120> prices<00:23:49.440> started<00:23:49.679> going<00:23:49.919> up

00:23:50

house prices started going up

00:23:50

house prices started going up so<00:23:51.200> what<00:23:51.360> happened<00:23:51.600> in<00:23:51.679> 2008<00:23:52.240> was<00:23:52.480> because

00:23:52

so what happened in 2008 was because

00:23:52

so what happened in 2008 was because they<00:23:53.039> chose<00:23:53.440> just<00:23:53.679> to<00:23:53.760> go<00:23:54.000> with<00:23:54.240> full-on

00:23:54

they chose just to go with full-on

00:23:54

they chose just to go with full-on monetary<00:23:55.200> policy<00:23:55.679> print<00:23:55.840> new<00:23:56.000> money

00:23:56

monetary policy print new money

00:23:56

monetary policy print new money lend<00:23:56.880> it<00:23:56.960> into<00:23:57.200> the<00:23:57.279> economy<00:23:58.400> it<00:23:58.640> tended<00:23:58.960> to

00:23:59

lend it into the economy it tended to

00:23:59

lend it into the economy it tended to benefit<00:23:59.440> rich<00:23:59.760> people

00:24:00

benefit rich people

00:24:00

benefit rich people firstly<00:24:00.880> because<00:24:01.039> they<00:24:01.200> could<00:24:01.360> borrow<00:24:01.600> the

00:24:01

firstly because they could borrow the

00:24:01

firstly because they could borrow the money<00:24:02.320> and<00:24:02.559> secondly<00:24:02.960> because<00:24:03.200> they<00:24:03.440> use<00:24:03.600> that

00:24:03

money and secondly because they use that

00:24:03

money and secondly because they use that to<00:24:03.840> push<00:24:04.159> asset<00:24:04.480> prices<00:24:04.880> up

00:24:05

to push asset prices up

00:24:05

to push asset prices up and<00:24:05.360> when<00:24:05.600> asset<00:24:05.919> prices<00:24:06.320> go<00:24:06.559> up<00:24:06.799> who<00:24:06.960> does

00:24:07

and when asset prices go up who does

00:24:07

and when asset prices go up who does that<00:24:07.279> benefit<00:24:08.000> well<00:24:08.159> of<00:24:08.240> course<00:24:08.480> that

00:24:08

that benefit well of course that

00:24:08

that benefit well of course that benefits<00:24:09.200> the<00:24:09.279> people<00:24:09.520> who<00:24:09.679> own

00:24:09

benefits the people who own

00:24:10

benefits the people who own assets<00:24:10.400> which<00:24:10.559> is<00:24:10.720> rich<00:24:10.960> people<00:24:11.200> again<00:24:12.240> so<00:24:12.480> the

00:24:12

assets which is rich people again so the

00:24:12

assets which is rich people again so the focus<00:24:13.120> on

00:24:13

focus on

00:24:13

focus on monetary<00:24:14.320> policy<00:24:14.720> without<00:24:15.120> any<00:24:15.440> direct

00:24:15

monetary policy without any direct

00:24:15

monetary policy without any direct government<00:24:16.080> intervention<00:24:16.720> led<00:24:16.880> to<00:24:17.120> a<00:24:17.200> huge

00:24:17

government intervention led to a huge

00:24:17

government intervention led to a huge increase

00:24:18

increase

00:24:18

increase in<00:24:18.720> inequality<00:24:19.760> because<00:24:20.080> of<00:24:20.240> greater<00:24:20.559> access

00:24:20

in inequality because of greater access

00:24:20

in inequality because of greater access to<00:24:20.960> money<00:24:21.200> for<00:24:21.360> rich<00:24:21.600> people<00:24:22.000> and<00:24:22.159> also

00:24:22

to money for rich people and also

00:24:22

to money for rich people and also huge<00:24:23.120> increases<00:24:23.600> in<00:24:23.840> asset<00:24:24.080> prices<00:24:24.480> which<00:24:24.640> are

00:24:24

huge increases in asset prices which are

00:24:24

huge increases in asset prices which are owned<00:24:24.880> by<00:24:25.039> rich<00:24:25.279> people

00:24:26

owned by rich people

00:24:26

owned by rich people what<00:24:26.559> would<00:24:26.799> need<00:24:27.120> to<00:24:27.360> happen<00:24:27.760> in<00:24:27.919> society<00:24:29.120> for

00:24:30

what would need to happen in society for

00:24:30

what would need to happen in society for so<00:24:30.559> capitalists<00:24:31.360> aren't<00:24:31.679> investing

00:24:32

so capitalists aren't investing

00:24:32

so capitalists aren't investing productively

00:24:33

productively

00:24:33

productively they're<00:24:33.840> investing<00:24:34.320> in<00:24:34.400> speculation<00:24:35.360> in

00:24:35

they're investing in speculation in

00:24:35

they're investing in speculation in existing<00:24:36.320> assets

00:24:37

existing assets

00:24:37

existing assets what<00:24:37.200> would<00:24:37.440> actually<00:24:37.840> need<00:24:38.080> to<00:24:38.240> happen<00:24:38.559> in

00:24:38

what would actually need to happen in

00:24:38

what would actually need to happen in order<00:24:38.960> to<00:24:39.200> get<00:24:39.520> those<00:24:39.840> capitalists

00:24:40

order to get those capitalists

00:24:40

order to get those capitalists to<00:24:41.200> invest<00:24:41.679> in<00:24:41.919> things<00:24:42.159> like<00:24:42.799> jobs<00:24:43.600> production

00:24:44

to invest in things like jobs production

00:24:44

to invest in things like jobs production manufacturing<00:24:45.440> capacity<00:24:46.480> a<00:24:46.640> green

00:24:46

manufacturing capacity a green

00:24:46

manufacturing capacity a green industrial<00:24:47.520> revolution

00:24:48

industrial revolution

00:24:48

industrial revolution a<00:24:48.480> green<00:24:48.799> new<00:24:49.039> deal<00:24:49.679> it's<00:24:49.840> a<00:24:49.919> tricky<00:24:50.159> one

00:24:50

a green new deal it's a tricky one

00:24:50

a green new deal it's a tricky one really<00:24:50.640> because

00:24:51

really because

00:24:51

really because the<00:24:51.760> reason<00:24:52.080> that<00:24:52.720> the<00:24:52.880> rich<00:24:53.120> are<00:24:53.200> not<00:24:53.360> really

00:24:53

the reason that the rich are not really

00:24:53

the reason that the rich are not really investing<00:24:54.080> in<00:24:54.159> new<00:24:54.320> production<00:24:54.720> at<00:24:54.799> the

00:24:54

investing in new production at the

00:24:54

investing in new production at the moment<00:24:55.200> is<00:24:55.279> because<00:24:55.520> the<00:24:55.600> demand<00:24:56.000> isn't<00:24:56.240> there

00:24:56

moment is because the demand isn't there

00:24:56

moment is because the demand isn't there so<00:24:57.039> it's<00:24:57.440> it's<00:24:57.679> a<00:24:57.840> difficult<00:24:58.400> situation<00:24:58.960> how

00:24:59

so it's it's a difficult situation how

00:24:59

so it's it's a difficult situation how do<00:24:59.200> you<00:24:59.279> encourage<00:24:59.679> these<00:24:59.919> guys

00:25:01

do you encourage these guys

00:25:01

do you encourage these guys i<00:25:01.200> mean<00:25:01.440> basically<00:25:01.840> there's<00:25:02.000> two<00:25:02.240> questions

00:25:02

i mean basically there's two questions

00:25:02

i mean basically there's two questions within<00:25:02.720> your<00:25:02.880> question<00:25:03.360> one<00:25:03.600> is<00:25:03.840> how<00:25:04.080> do<00:25:04.159> you

00:25:04

within your question one is how do you

00:25:04

within your question one is how do you get<00:25:04.320> them<00:25:04.400> to<00:25:04.559> invest<00:25:04.880> in<00:25:05.120> good<00:25:05.360> things

00:25:05

get them to invest in good things

00:25:05

get them to invest in good things as<00:25:05.919> opposed<00:25:06.240> to<00:25:06.720> potentially<00:25:07.279> socially

00:25:07

as opposed to potentially socially

00:25:07

as opposed to potentially socially harmful<00:25:08.000> things<00:25:08.559> but<00:25:08.720> the<00:25:08.880> second<00:25:09.120> question

00:25:09

harmful things but the second question

00:25:09

harmful things but the second question is<00:25:09.520> how<00:25:09.679> do<00:25:09.760> you<00:25:09.840> get<00:25:09.919> them<00:25:10.000> to<00:25:10.159> invest<00:25:10.559> at<00:25:10.720> all

00:25:11

is how do you get them to invest at all

00:25:11

is how do you get them to invest at all because<00:25:11.520> at<00:25:11.679> the<00:25:11.760> moment<00:25:12.480> you<00:25:12.559> know<00:25:12.880> like<00:25:13.120> i

00:25:13

because at the moment you know like i

00:25:13

because at the moment you know like i said<00:25:13.440> gold<00:25:13.679> is<00:25:13.919> a<00:25:14.240> record<00:25:14.640> all-time<00:25:15.039> historic

00:25:15

said gold is a record all-time historic

00:25:15

said gold is a record all-time historic high

00:25:16

high

00:25:16

high rich<00:25:16.400> people<00:25:16.720> buying<00:25:16.960> gold<00:25:17.279> doesn't<00:25:17.520> do<00:25:17.679> much

00:25:18

rich people buying gold doesn't do much

00:25:18

rich people buying gold doesn't do much for<00:25:18.320> the<00:25:18.400> economy<00:25:18.880> obviously

00:25:19

for the economy obviously

00:25:19

for the economy obviously lots<00:25:20.000> of<00:25:20.080> stocks<00:25:20.400> are<00:25:20.480> at<00:25:20.640> all-time<00:25:20.960> highs<00:25:21.200> as

00:25:21

lots of stocks are at all-time highs as

00:25:21

lots of stocks are at all-time highs as well<00:25:22.080> so

00:25:22

well so

00:25:22

well so it's<00:25:23.360> difficult<00:25:23.840> to<00:25:24.159> encourage<00:25:24.640> the<00:25:24.799> rich<00:25:25.120> to

00:25:25

it's difficult to encourage the rich to

00:25:25

it's difficult to encourage the rich to invest<00:25:25.840> because<00:25:26.159> ultimately

00:25:26

invest because ultimately

00:25:26

invest because ultimately what<00:25:27.039> they're<00:25:27.120> going<00:25:27.279> to<00:25:27.360> want<00:25:27.520> to<00:25:27.600> invest<00:25:28.000> in

00:25:28

what they're going to want to invest in

00:25:28

what they're going to want to invest in is<00:25:28.320> what's<00:25:28.559> profitable<00:25:29.840> i<00:25:29.919> think<00:25:30.159> you

00:25:30

is what's profitable i think you

00:25:30

is what's profitable i think you probably<00:25:30.640> do<00:25:30.799> need<00:25:30.960> to<00:25:31.039> create<00:25:31.279> the<00:25:31.440> demand

00:25:31

probably do need to create the demand

00:25:31

probably do need to create the demand directly<00:25:32.400> somehow

00:25:33

directly somehow

00:25:33

directly somehow and<00:25:34.480> i<00:25:34.640> think<00:25:34.799> that's<00:25:35.440> that's<00:25:35.679> difficult<00:25:36.080> to

00:25:36

and i think that's that's difficult to

00:25:36

and i think that's that's difficult to do<00:25:36.320> without<00:25:36.720> direct<00:25:37.120> some<00:25:37.360> form<00:25:37.520> of<00:25:37.600> direct

00:25:37

do without direct some form of direct

00:25:37

do without direct some form of direct government<00:25:38.080> intervention

00:25:39

government intervention

00:25:39

government intervention so<00:25:40.480> there's<00:25:40.799> two<00:25:41.039> ways<00:25:41.360> you<00:25:41.520> can<00:25:41.600> get

00:25:42

so there's two ways you can get

00:25:42

so there's two ways you can get the<00:25:42.400> rich<00:25:42.640> to<00:25:42.799> invest<00:25:43.840> you<00:25:44.000> can<00:25:44.159> either

00:25:44

the rich to invest you can either

00:25:44

the rich to invest you can either directly<00:25:45.279> incentivize<00:25:45.919> them<00:25:46.080> or<00:25:46.240> you<00:25:46.320> can

00:25:46

directly incentivize them or you can

00:25:46

directly incentivize them or you can provide<00:25:46.799> the<00:25:46.960> customers

00:25:47

provide the customers

00:25:48

provide the customers but<00:25:48.159> i<00:25:48.240> think<00:25:48.480> the<00:25:48.640> problem<00:25:49.039> is<00:25:49.279> because<00:25:49.600> we

00:25:49

but i think the problem is because we

00:25:49

but i think the problem is because we don't<00:25:49.919> have<00:25:50.080> the<00:25:50.240> spending

00:25:51

don't have the spending

00:25:51

don't have the spending we're<00:25:51.440> not<00:25:51.600> going<00:25:51.679> to<00:25:51.760> get<00:25:51.919> the<00:25:52.080> investment

00:25:52

we're not going to get the investment

00:25:52

we're not going to get the investment from<00:25:52.559> the<00:25:52.640> rich<00:25:52.880> so<00:25:53.039> it's<00:25:53.200> a<00:25:53.279> little<00:25:53.440> bit<00:25:54.080> it's

00:25:54

from the rich so it's a little bit it's

00:25:54

from the rich so it's a little bit it's a<00:25:54.320> little<00:25:54.480> bit<00:25:54.640> of<00:25:54.720> chicken<00:25:54.960> and<00:25:55.120> egg<00:25:55.279> in<00:25:55.360> the

00:25:55

a little bit of chicken and egg in the

00:25:55

a little bit of chicken and egg in the sense<00:25:55.840> you<00:25:56.000> need<00:25:56.159> to<00:25:56.320> get<00:25:56.480> the<00:25:56.640> spending<00:25:57.039> first

00:25:57

sense you need to get the spending first

00:25:57

sense you need to get the spending first of<00:25:57.440> all

00:25:57

of all

00:25:57

of all but<00:25:57.840> it's<00:25:58.000> very<00:25:58.159> difficult<00:25:58.480> to<00:25:58.559> get<00:25:58.720> the

00:25:58

but it's very difficult to get the

00:25:58

but it's very difficult to get the spending<00:25:59.200> when<00:25:59.279> the<00:25:59.360> rich<00:25:59.600> have<00:25:59.760> all<00:25:59.840> the

00:25:59

spending when the rich have all the

00:25:59

spending when the rich have all the money

00:26:00

money

00:26:00

money is<00:26:01.120> there<00:26:01.279> an<00:26:01.440> argument<00:26:02.000> then<00:26:02.240> that<00:26:02.799> the

00:26:03

is there an argument then that the

00:26:03

is there an argument then that the better<00:26:03.360> way<00:26:03.520> for<00:26:03.679> a<00:26:03.840> central<00:26:04.240> bank<00:26:04.480> to<00:26:04.720> use

00:26:05

better way for a central bank to use

00:26:05

better way for a central bank to use those

00:26:05

those

00:26:05

those mechanisms<00:26:06.159> it<00:26:06.320> has<00:26:06.640> is<00:26:07.039> just<00:26:07.279> a<00:26:07.360> kind<00:26:07.520> of

00:26:07

mechanisms it has is just a kind of

00:26:07

mechanisms it has is just a kind of helicopter<00:26:08.159> money<00:26:08.480> scheme<00:26:08.880> where<00:26:09.200> instead<00:26:09.600> of

00:26:10

helicopter money scheme where instead of

00:26:10

helicopter money scheme where instead of putting<00:26:11.279> it's<00:26:11.520> the<00:26:11.679> currency<00:26:12.080> it's<00:26:12.240> created

00:26:12

putting it's the currency it's created

00:26:12

putting it's the currency it's created into<00:26:12.960> the<00:26:13.039> hands<00:26:13.360> of<00:26:13.520> the

00:26:13

into the hands of the

00:26:13

into the hands of the commercial<00:26:14.400> banking<00:26:14.799> sector<00:26:15.200> it<00:26:15.279> just<00:26:15.440> puts

00:26:15

commercial banking sector it just puts

00:26:15

commercial banking sector it just puts them<00:26:15.919> into<00:26:16.159> everybody's<00:26:16.559> bank<00:26:16.799> account<00:26:17.120> i

00:26:17

them into everybody's bank account i

00:26:17

them into everybody's bank account i mean<00:26:17.360> i<00:26:17.440> know<00:26:17.600> they<00:26:17.760> were<00:26:18.000> talking<00:26:18.320> about<00:26:18.480> that

00:26:18

mean i know they were talking about that

00:26:18

mean i know they were talking about that at<00:26:18.720> the<00:26:18.799> beginning<00:26:19.039> of<00:26:19.120> the<00:26:19.200> corona<00:26:19.600> virus

00:26:19

at the beginning of the corona virus

00:26:19

at the beginning of the corona virus crisis

00:26:20

crisis

00:26:20

crisis or<00:26:20.960> rather<00:26:21.520> the<00:26:21.679> government<00:26:22.080> weren't<00:26:22.400> but

00:26:22

or rather the government weren't but

00:26:22

or rather the government weren't but people<00:26:22.960> were<00:26:23.200> i<00:26:23.279> mean<00:26:23.440> it's<00:26:23.600> interesting<00:26:23.919> to

00:26:24

people were i mean it's interesting to

00:26:24

people were i mean it's interesting to say<00:26:24.240> that<00:26:24.400> because

00:26:24

say that because

00:26:24

say that because i<00:26:24.960> mean<00:26:25.279> this<00:26:25.520> crisis<00:26:25.840> is<00:26:25.919> not<00:26:26.080> identical<00:26:26.480> to

00:26:26

i mean this crisis is not identical to

00:26:26

i mean this crisis is not identical to the<00:26:26.640> last<00:26:26.880> crisis<00:26:27.279> and<00:26:27.440> what<00:26:27.600> has<00:26:27.760> happened<00:26:28.000> so

00:26:28

the last crisis and what has happened so

00:26:28

the last crisis and what has happened so far

00:26:28

far

00:26:28

far it<00:26:28.880> is<00:26:29.039> actually<00:26:30.080> quite<00:26:30.400> similar<00:26:30.720> to<00:26:30.799> what<00:26:30.960> you

00:26:31

it is actually quite similar to what you

00:26:31

it is actually quite similar to what you just<00:26:31.200> said<00:26:31.520> essentially

00:26:32

just said essentially

00:26:32

just said essentially um<00:26:32.960> previously<00:26:33.520> most<00:26:33.760> of<00:26:33.840> the<00:26:33.919> newly<00:26:34.240> printed

00:26:34

um previously most of the newly printed

00:26:34

um previously most of the newly printed money<00:26:35.360> that<00:26:35.520> the<00:26:35.600> central<00:26:35.919> bank<00:26:36.159> created

00:26:36

money that the central bank created

00:26:36

money that the central bank created most<00:26:37.120> of<00:26:37.200> it<00:26:37.279> went<00:26:37.520> into<00:26:37.679> the<00:26:37.760> banking<00:26:38.080> system

00:26:38

most of it went into the banking system

00:26:38

most of it went into the banking system first<00:26:38.640> of<00:26:38.799> all<00:26:39.600> some<00:26:39.760> went<00:26:39.919> directly<00:26:40.240> to

00:26:40

first of all some went directly to

00:26:40

first of all some went directly to governments<00:26:40.880> but

00:26:41

governments but

00:26:41

governments but this<00:26:41.520> time<00:26:41.840> a<00:26:42.000> huge<00:26:42.320> amount<00:26:42.640> has<00:26:42.799> gone

00:26:44

this time a huge amount has gone

00:26:44

this time a huge amount has gone to<00:26:44.480> the<00:26:44.640> government<00:26:44.960> essentially<00:26:45.440> and<00:26:45.520> the

00:26:45

to the government essentially and the

00:26:45

to the government essentially and the government<00:26:46.000> has<00:26:46.159> used<00:26:46.480> a<00:26:46.559> lot<00:26:46.720> of<00:26:46.799> that<00:26:46.880> money

00:26:47

government has used a lot of that money

00:26:47

government has used a lot of that money to<00:26:47.279> support

00:26:47

to support

00:26:47

to support for<00:26:48.080> example<00:26:48.480> things<00:26:48.640> like<00:26:48.799> the<00:26:48.880> furlough

00:26:49

for example things like the furlough

00:26:49

for example things like the furlough scheme<00:26:49.440> and<00:26:49.520> the<00:26:49.600> self-employment<00:26:50.240> scheme

00:26:50

scheme and the self-employment scheme

00:26:50

scheme and the self-employment scheme which<00:26:50.960> means<00:26:51.200> that<00:26:51.360> ultimately<00:26:51.760> the<00:26:51.840> newly

00:26:52

which means that ultimately the newly

00:26:52

which means that ultimately the newly printed<00:26:52.480> money

00:26:52

printed money

00:26:52

printed money has<00:26:53.200> gone<00:26:53.520> in<00:26:53.760> to<00:26:53.919> the<00:26:54.000> bank<00:26:54.240> accounts<00:26:55.520> of

00:26:56

has gone in to the bank accounts of

00:26:56

has gone in to the bank accounts of people<00:26:56.320> who<00:26:56.480> are<00:26:56.559> struggling<00:26:56.960> in<00:26:57.039> this<00:26:57.200> crisis

00:26:58

people who are struggling in this crisis

00:26:58

people who are struggling in this crisis so

00:26:59

so in<00:26:59.520> some<00:26:59.760> sense<00:27:00.080> especially<00:27:00.400> because<00:27:00.640> of<00:27:00.720> the

00:27:00

in some sense especially because of the

00:27:00

in some sense especially because of the usage<00:27:01.200> of<00:27:01.279> the<00:27:01.360> furlough<00:27:01.679> scheme

00:27:02

usage of the furlough scheme

00:27:02

usage of the furlough scheme the<00:27:03.600> policy<00:27:04.080> response<00:27:04.480> has<00:27:04.640> been<00:27:04.880> much<00:27:05.200> more

00:27:06

the policy response has been much more

00:27:06

the policy response has been much more egalitarian<00:27:06.960> in<00:27:07.120> a<00:27:07.200> sense<00:27:07.520> be<00:27:07.679> much<00:27:07.840> more

00:27:07

egalitarian in a sense be much more

00:27:08

egalitarian in a sense be much more supportive<00:27:08.480> of<00:27:08.640> ordinary<00:27:09.120> people

00:27:10

supportive of ordinary people

00:27:10

supportive of ordinary people and<00:27:10.400> what<00:27:10.640> that<00:27:10.799> has<00:27:11.039> meant<00:27:11.360> is<00:27:11.600> interestingly

00:27:12

and what that has meant is interestingly

00:27:12

and what that has meant is interestingly so<00:27:12.559> far<00:27:12.720> in<00:27:12.880> this<00:27:13.039> crisis

00:27:13

so far in this crisis

00:27:13

so far in this crisis even<00:27:13.679> though<00:27:14.320> the<00:27:14.559> depths<00:27:14.960> of<00:27:15.120> it<00:27:15.200> if<00:27:15.360> you<00:27:15.440> look

00:27:15

even though the depths of it if you look

00:27:15

even though the depths of it if you look at<00:27:15.679> falls<00:27:16.000> in<00:27:16.080> gdp

00:27:17

at falls in gdp

00:27:17

at falls in gdp much<00:27:17.279> sharper<00:27:17.679> than<00:27:17.760> 2008<00:27:19.120> actually<00:27:19.520> most

00:27:19

much sharper than 2008 actually most

00:27:19

much sharper than 2008 actually most people<00:27:20.000> have<00:27:20.240> not<00:27:20.399> felt<00:27:20.640> anything<00:27:20.960> like<00:27:21.200> the

00:27:21

people have not felt anything like the

00:27:21

people have not felt anything like the kind<00:27:21.520> of<00:27:21.600> economic<00:27:22.159> pain<00:27:22.480> that<00:27:22.720> was<00:27:22.880> felt<00:27:23.120> like

00:27:23

kind of economic pain that was felt like

00:27:23

kind of economic pain that was felt like in<00:27:23.600> 2008<00:27:24.399> yet<00:27:25.360> but<00:27:25.600> what<00:27:25.760> i'm<00:27:26.000> really

00:27:26

in 2008 yet but what i'm really

00:27:26

in 2008 yet but what i'm really concerned<00:27:26.640> about<00:27:26.960> is<00:27:27.120> that

00:27:27

concerned about is that

00:27:27

concerned about is that the<00:27:27.840> furlough<00:27:28.240> scheme<00:27:29.039> firms<00:27:29.360> have<00:27:29.440> to<00:27:29.520> start

00:27:29

the furlough scheme firms have to start

00:27:29

the furlough scheme firms have to start contributing<00:27:30.240> to<00:27:30.320> keep<00:27:30.559> works<00:27:30.880> on<00:27:30.960> furlough

00:27:31

contributing to keep works on furlough

00:27:31

contributing to keep works on furlough from<00:27:31.440> the<00:27:31.600> end<00:27:31.760> of<00:27:31.840> this<00:27:32.000> month<00:27:32.240> which<00:27:32.480> is<00:27:32.559> in

00:27:32

from the end of this month which is in

00:27:32

from the end of this month which is in just<00:27:32.799> a<00:27:32.880> few<00:27:33.120> days<00:27:33.360> now

00:27:33

just a few days now

00:27:34

just a few days now and<00:27:34.640> a<00:27:34.720> lot<00:27:34.880> of<00:27:34.960> workers<00:27:35.279> are<00:27:35.360> going<00:27:35.440> to<00:27:35.520> be

00:27:35

and a lot of workers are going to be

00:27:35

and a lot of workers are going to be left<00:27:36.000> off<00:27:36.080> so<00:27:36.240> i'm<00:27:36.320> worried<00:27:36.720> that

00:27:37

left off so i'm worried that

00:27:37

left off so i'm worried that we've<00:27:37.520> done<00:27:37.760> really<00:27:38.080> well<00:27:38.320> to<00:27:38.480> sort<00:27:38.640> of<00:27:38.799> stave

00:27:39

we've done really well to sort of stave

00:27:39

we've done really well to sort of stave off<00:27:39.360> the<00:27:39.520> worst<00:27:40.240> human<00:27:40.559> disaster<00:27:41.279> so<00:27:41.520> far<00:27:41.760> in

00:27:41

off the worst human disaster so far in

00:27:41

off the worst human disaster so far in this<00:27:42.000> crisis<00:27:42.399> so<00:27:42.559> far

00:27:43

this crisis so far

00:27:43

this crisis so far but<00:27:43.520> it<00:27:43.679> seems<00:27:43.919> like<00:27:44.080> we're<00:27:44.399> just<00:27:44.559> about<00:27:44.799> to

00:27:44

but it seems like we're just about to

00:27:44

but it seems like we're just about to stop<00:27:45.200> doing<00:27:45.440> that<00:27:45.679> and<00:27:45.760> we're<00:27:45.919> just<00:27:46.080> going<00:27:46.159> to

00:27:46

stop doing that and we're just going to

00:27:46

stop doing that and we're just going to let<00:27:46.480> the<00:27:46.640> human

00:27:47

let the human

00:27:47

let the human disaster<00:27:48.080> come<00:27:48.880> in<00:27:49.120> terms<00:27:49.360> of<00:27:49.440> the

00:27:49

disaster come in terms of the

00:27:49

disaster come in terms of the government's<00:27:49.919> wider<00:27:50.240> response<00:27:50.640> to<00:27:50.799> this

00:27:50

government's wider response to this

00:27:50

government's wider response to this crisis

00:27:52

crisis

00:27:52

crisis what<00:27:52.799> do<00:27:52.960> you<00:27:53.360> think<00:27:53.760> that<00:27:53.919> it<00:27:54.159> has<00:27:54.480> been

00:27:55

what do you think that it has been

00:27:55

what do you think that it has been far-sighted<00:27:56.880> in<00:27:57.279> you<00:27:57.440> know<00:27:57.600> in<00:27:57.760> the<00:27:57.919> sense

00:27:58

far-sighted in you know in the sense

00:27:58

far-sighted in you know in the sense that<00:27:58.320> they<00:27:58.399> were<00:27:58.640> putting<00:27:58.880> money<00:27:59.039> into

00:27:59

that they were putting money into

00:27:59

that they were putting money into people's<00:27:59.440> bank<00:27:59.600> accounts<00:28:00.000> rather<00:28:00.240> than<00:28:00.399> into

00:28:00

people's bank accounts rather than into

00:28:00

people's bank accounts rather than into the

00:28:01

the

00:28:01

the bank<00:28:01.279> accounts<00:28:01.520> of<00:28:01.600> commercial<00:28:02.000> banks<00:28:02.320> in<00:28:02.399> the

00:28:02

bank accounts of commercial banks in the

00:28:02

bank accounts of commercial banks in the first<00:28:02.880> instance<00:28:03.360> or<00:28:03.520> do<00:28:03.600> you<00:28:03.679> think<00:28:03.840> that<00:28:03.919> was

00:28:04

first instance or do you think that was

00:28:04

first instance or do you think that was just<00:28:04.240> a<00:28:04.399> kind<00:28:04.480> of<00:28:04.640> knee-jerk

00:28:05

just a kind of knee-jerk

00:28:05

just a kind of knee-jerk what<00:28:06.000> we're<00:28:06.080> going<00:28:06.240> to<00:28:06.320> do<00:28:07.679> which<00:28:08.080> and

00:28:08

what we're going to do which and

00:28:08

what we're going to do which and then<00:28:08.559> and<00:28:08.720> the

00:28:09

then and the

00:28:09

then and the kind<00:28:09.440> of<00:28:09.520> true<00:28:09.760> nature<00:28:10.080> of<00:28:10.159> their<00:28:10.320> response<00:28:10.799> is

00:28:10

kind of true nature of their response is

00:28:10

kind of true nature of their response is coming<00:28:11.200> out<00:28:11.440> now

00:28:12

coming out now

00:28:12

coming out now they<00:28:13.039> had<00:28:13.200> to<00:28:13.279> do<00:28:13.440> it<00:28:13.520> they<00:28:13.679> had<00:28:13.919> they<00:28:14.080> had<00:28:14.240> to

00:28:14

they had to do it they had they had to

00:28:14

they had to do it they had they had to do<00:28:14.880> they<00:28:15.039> had<00:28:15.200> to<00:28:15.360> do<00:28:15.440> it

00:28:16

do they had to do it

00:28:16

do they had to do it if<00:28:16.640> they<00:28:16.799> had<00:28:16.960> not<00:28:17.200> have<00:28:17.279> done<00:28:17.520> that<00:28:18.080> the<00:28:19.120> it

00:28:19

if they had not have done that the it

00:28:19

if they had not have done that the it would<00:28:19.440> have<00:28:19.520> been<00:28:19.679> a<00:28:19.760> humanitarian<00:28:20.480> disaster

00:28:20

would have been a humanitarian disaster

00:28:20

would have been a humanitarian disaster in<00:28:21.039> this<00:28:21.200> country

00:28:22

in this country

00:28:22

in this country if<00:28:22.240> they<00:28:22.399> had<00:28:22.480> not<00:28:22.640> brought<00:28:22.880> in<00:28:22.960> a<00:28:23.039> furlough

00:28:23

if they had not brought in a furlough

00:28:23

if they had not brought in a furlough scheme<00:28:24.159> it<00:28:24.320> would<00:28:24.480> have<00:28:24.559> been<00:28:24.720> a<00:28:24.799> humanitarian

00:28:25

scheme it would have been a humanitarian

00:28:25

scheme it would have been a humanitarian it<00:28:25.600> would<00:28:25.760> have<00:28:25.840> been

00:28:26

it would have been

00:28:26

it would have been it<00:28:27.039> would<00:28:27.200> have<00:28:27.279> been<00:28:27.520> unthinkable<00:28:27.919> how<00:28:28.080> bad

00:28:28

it would have been unthinkable how bad

00:28:28

it would have been unthinkable how bad it<00:28:28.320> would<00:28:28.480> have<00:28:28.559> been<00:28:28.640> had<00:28:28.799> they<00:28:28.880> not<00:28:29.039> done

00:28:29

it would have been had they not done

00:28:29

it would have been had they not done that<00:28:29.600> so

00:28:30

that so

00:28:30

that so as<00:28:30.799> much<00:28:31.039> as<00:28:31.279> it's<00:28:31.440> great<00:28:31.600> that<00:28:31.760> they<00:28:31.919> did<00:28:32.080> do

00:28:32

as much as it's great that they did do

00:28:32

as much as it's great that they did do it<00:28:32.720> i<00:28:32.880> don't<00:28:33.039> want<00:28:33.120> to<00:28:33.200> congratulate<00:28:33.679> them<00:28:33.760> too

00:28:33

it i don't want to congratulate them too

00:28:33

it i don't want to congratulate them too much<00:28:34.080> for<00:28:34.159> doing<00:28:34.399> it<00:28:34.480> because<00:28:34.799> every<00:28:35.039> western

00:28:35

much for doing it because every western

00:28:35

much for doing it because every western country<00:28:35.679> did<00:28:35.840> it<00:28:36.000> because<00:28:36.159> they<00:28:36.320> had<00:28:36.480> to<00:28:36.640> do<00:28:36.799> it

00:28:37

country did it because they had to do it

00:28:37

country did it because they had to do it without<00:28:37.360> doing<00:28:37.520> that<00:28:37.760> it<00:28:37.840> would<00:28:38.000> have<00:28:38.080> been

00:28:38

without doing that it would have been

00:28:38

without doing that it would have been inevitably<00:28:38.960> a<00:28:39.039> disaster<00:28:39.679> so

00:28:40

inevitably a disaster so

00:28:40

inevitably a disaster so i<00:28:40.799> can't<00:28:41.039> say<00:28:41.200> that<00:28:41.360> they're<00:28:41.760> noble<00:28:42.159> people

00:28:42

i can't say that they're noble people

00:28:42

i can't say that they're noble people all<00:28:42.720> i<00:28:42.799> can<00:28:42.960> say<00:28:43.120> is<00:28:43.200> they're<00:28:43.360> not<00:28:43.600> complete

00:28:43

all i can say is they're not complete

00:28:43

all i can say is they're not complete idiots<00:28:44.480> because<00:28:44.640> they<00:28:44.799> had<00:28:44.960> to<00:28:45.120> do<00:28:45.279> that<00:28:45.440> right

00:28:45

idiots because they had to do that right

00:28:46

idiots because they had to do that right they<00:28:46.320> absolutely<00:28:46.720> had<00:28:46.880> to<00:28:46.960> do<00:28:47.120> that<00:28:47.440> i<00:28:47.520> mean

00:28:47

they absolutely had to do that i mean

00:28:47

they absolutely had to do that i mean looking<00:28:48.000> at<00:28:48.159> it<00:28:48.320> unfold

00:28:49

looking at it unfold

00:28:49

looking at it unfold the<00:28:49.279> bbc<00:28:49.760> came<00:28:50.000> out<00:28:50.080> today<00:28:50.399> saying<00:28:50.640> it<00:28:50.720> might

00:28:50

the bbc came out today saying it might

00:28:50

the bbc came out today saying it might take<00:28:51.120> four<00:28:51.360> years<00:28:51.600> for<00:28:51.760> the<00:28:51.840> economy<00:28:52.240> to

00:28:52

take four years for the economy to

00:28:52

take four years for the economy to recover

00:28:52

recover

00:28:52

recover it<00:28:53.039> feels<00:28:53.360> like<00:28:53.520> that's<00:28:53.840> incredibly

00:28:54

it feels like that's incredibly

00:28:54

it feels like that's incredibly optimistic<00:28:55.200> from<00:28:55.840> where<00:28:56.159> i'm<00:28:56.399> sitting<00:28:56.799> but

00:28:56

optimistic from where i'm sitting but

00:28:56

optimistic from where i'm sitting but obviously<00:28:57.279> i'm<00:28:57.520> not<00:28:57.760> i've<00:28:57.919> never<00:28:58.159> made<00:28:58.399> my

00:28:58

obviously i'm not i've never made my

00:28:58

obviously i'm not i've never made my fortune<00:28:58.960> doing<00:28:59.279> economic<00:28:59.679> predictions

00:29:00

fortune doing economic predictions

00:29:00

fortune doing economic predictions they'll<00:29:00.799> be<00:29:00.960> talking<00:29:01.200> about<00:29:01.360> gdp<00:29:01.919> as<00:29:02.000> a<00:29:02.080> whole

00:29:02

they'll be talking about gdp as a whole

00:29:02

they'll be talking about gdp as a whole right<00:29:02.559> gdp<00:29:03.120> could<00:29:03.279> recover<00:29:03.679> in<00:29:03.840> four<00:29:04.000> years

00:29:04

right gdp could recover in four years

00:29:04

right gdp could recover in four years but<00:29:04.799> i<00:29:04.880> mean<00:29:05.520> gdp<00:29:06.000> took<00:29:06.240> its<00:29:06.320> time<00:29:06.480> to<00:29:06.640> recover

00:29:06

but i mean gdp took its time to recover

00:29:06

but i mean gdp took its time to recover after<00:29:07.240> 2008

00:29:08

after 2008

00:29:08

after 2008 and<00:29:09.279> it<00:29:09.440> did<00:29:09.600> eventually<00:29:10.000> recover<00:29:10.720> but<00:29:10.880> by<00:29:11.120> the

00:29:11

and it did eventually recover but by the

00:29:11

and it did eventually recover but by the time<00:29:11.440> it<00:29:11.520> recovered

00:29:11

time it recovered

00:29:12

time it recovered where<00:29:12.240> were<00:29:12.399> house<00:29:12.640> prices<00:29:13.200> compared<00:29:13.520> to

00:29:13

where were house prices compared to

00:29:13

where were house prices compared to wages<00:29:14.799> so

00:29:15

wages so

00:29:15

wages so the<00:29:15.279> gdp<00:29:15.760> recovers<00:29:16.399> but<00:29:16.720> the<00:29:16.960> inequality

00:29:17

the gdp recovers but the inequality

00:29:17

the gdp recovers but the inequality crisis<00:29:18.000> remained

00:29:18

crisis remained

00:29:18

crisis remained and<00:29:19.600> ordinary<00:29:20.080> people<00:29:20.399> felt<00:29:20.640> the<00:29:20.799> effects<00:29:21.120> of

00:29:21

and ordinary people felt the effects of

00:29:21

and ordinary people felt the effects of that<00:29:21.679> and<00:29:21.840> i<00:29:22.000> think

00:29:22

that and i think

00:29:22

that and i think those<00:29:22.880> are<00:29:23.039> the<00:29:23.120> mistakes<00:29:23.520> that<00:29:23.600> we're<00:29:23.760> going

00:29:23

those are the mistakes that we're going

00:29:23

those are the mistakes that we're going to<00:29:24.000> repeat<00:29:24.320> here<00:29:24.799> so<00:29:25.279> i<00:29:25.360> think<00:29:25.520> the<00:29:25.679> photo

00:29:25

to repeat here so i think the photo

00:29:26

to repeat here so i think the photo scheme<00:29:26.240> was

00:29:26

scheme was

00:29:26

scheme was phenomenal<00:29:28.000> absolutely<00:29:28.480> essential<00:29:28.880> and

00:29:29

phenomenal absolutely essential and

00:29:29

phenomenal absolutely essential and vital

00:29:30

vital

00:29:30

vital but<00:29:30.640> i've<00:29:31.120> this<00:29:31.360> i<00:29:31.440> wrote<00:29:31.600> about<00:29:31.840> my<00:29:31.919> open

00:29:32

but i've this i wrote about my open

00:29:32

but i've this i wrote about my open democracy<00:29:32.480> cycles<00:29:32.880> and<00:29:32.960> i<00:29:33.039> put<00:29:33.279> my

00:29:33

democracy cycles and i put my

00:29:33

democracy cycles and i put my video<00:29:34.000> up<00:29:34.159> on<00:29:34.399> youtube<00:29:34.799> gary's<00:29:35.120> economics

00:29:35

video up on youtube gary's economics

00:29:36

video up on youtube gary's economics describing<00:29:36.559> what<00:29:36.640> happens<00:29:36.960> to<00:29:37.039> this<00:29:37.200> money

00:29:37

describing what happens to this money

00:29:37

describing what happens to this money how<00:29:37.760> it's<00:29:37.919> absolutely<00:29:38.320> essential<00:29:38.640> that<00:29:38.799> it

00:29:38

how it's absolutely essential that it

00:29:38

how it's absolutely essential that it comes<00:29:39.120> in

00:29:39

comes in

00:29:39

comes in but<00:29:39.919> ultimately<00:29:40.320> it's<00:29:40.480> filtering<00:29:40.960> up<00:29:41.039> to

00:29:41

but ultimately it's filtering up to

00:29:41

but ultimately it's filtering up to higher<00:29:41.360> income<00:29:41.679> people<00:29:42.159> and<00:29:42.320> it's<00:29:42.480> increasing

00:29:42

higher income people and it's increasing

00:29:42

higher income people and it's increasing inequality<00:29:43.520> just<00:29:43.760> like<00:29:43.919> rapid<00:29:44.240> in<00:29:44.320> 2008

00:29:45

inequality just like rapid in 2008

00:29:45

inequality just like rapid in 2008 and<00:29:45.440> we're<00:29:45.679> already<00:29:46.000> starting<00:29:46.320> to<00:29:46.399> see<00:29:46.559> the

00:29:46

and we're already starting to see the

00:29:46

and we're already starting to see the effect<00:29:46.880> on<00:29:47.039> asset<00:29:47.279> markets<00:29:47.919> the<00:29:48.080> gold<00:29:48.399> price

00:29:48

effect on asset markets the gold price

00:29:48

effect on asset markets the gold price the<00:29:48.799> stock<00:29:49.039> prices

00:29:49

the stock prices

00:29:49

the stock prices there's<00:29:50.000> a<00:29:50.000> lot<00:29:50.159> of<00:29:50.240> news<00:29:50.559> coming<00:29:50.720> in<00:29:50.799> now<00:29:50.960> that

00:29:51

there's a lot of news coming in now that

00:29:51

there's a lot of news coming in now that looks<00:29:51.360> like<00:29:51.520> house<00:29:51.760> prices<00:29:52.080> are<00:29:52.159> moving

00:29:52

looks like house prices are moving

00:29:52

looks like house prices are moving upwards<00:29:53.919> with<00:29:54.240> we're<00:29:54.399> seeing<00:29:54.640> the<00:29:54.720> exact<00:29:55.039> same

00:29:55

upwards with we're seeing the exact same

00:29:55

upwards with we're seeing the exact same things<00:29:55.440> again<00:29:55.679> which<00:29:55.919> is

00:29:57

things again which is

00:29:57

things again which is yes<00:29:57.600> the<00:29:57.919> absolute<00:29:58.399> worst<00:29:58.960> of<00:29:59.039> the

00:29:59

yes the absolute worst of the

00:29:59

yes the absolute worst of the humanitarian<00:29:59.840> disaster<00:30:00.240> seem<00:30:00.399> to<00:30:00.559> be<00:30:00.640> being

00:30:00

humanitarian disaster seem to be being

00:30:00

humanitarian disaster seem to be being prevented<00:30:01.279> we're<00:30:01.440> not

00:30:02

prevented we're not

00:30:02

prevented we're not hopefully<00:30:02.480> we're<00:30:02.720> not<00:30:02.799> going<00:30:02.880> to<00:30:02.960> have

00:30:03

hopefully we're not going to have

00:30:03

hopefully we're not going to have another<00:30:03.440> great<00:30:03.679> depression<00:30:04.159> start<00:30:04.480> absolute

00:30:04

another great depression start absolute

00:30:04

another great depression start absolute collapse

00:30:05

collapse

00:30:05

collapse but<00:30:06.080> we're<00:30:06.240> paying<00:30:06.559> for<00:30:06.640> that<00:30:06.799> with<00:30:07.039> increased

00:30:07

but we're paying for that with increased

00:30:07

but we're paying for that with increased inequality<00:30:08.559> and<00:30:08.799> i<00:30:08.960> predict<00:30:09.279> we'll<00:30:09.440> see

00:30:09

inequality and i predict we'll see

00:30:09

inequality and i predict we'll see another<00:30:09.919> big<00:30:10.080> increase<00:30:10.399> in<00:30:10.480> house<00:30:10.799> prices

00:30:11

another big increase in house prices

00:30:11

another big increase in house prices like<00:30:11.440> we<00:30:11.520> saw<00:30:11.760> last<00:30:12.000> time

00:30:13

like we saw last time

00:30:13

like we saw last time you<00:30:13.600> have<00:30:13.679> to<00:30:13.840> ask<00:30:14.240> what<00:30:14.320> that's<00:30:14.559> going<00:30:14.640> to<00:30:14.720> do

00:30:14

you have to ask what that's going to do

00:30:14

you have to ask what that's going to do you<00:30:15.039> know<00:30:15.120> if<00:30:15.200> house<00:30:15.440> prices<00:30:15.760> double<00:30:16.080> again

00:30:16

you know if house prices double again

00:30:16

you know if house prices double again which<00:30:16.799> is<00:30:16.880> eventually<00:30:17.279> what<00:30:17.440> happened<00:30:18.159> in

00:30:18

which is eventually what happened in

00:30:18

which is eventually what happened in london<00:30:18.799> after<00:30:19.039> the<00:30:19.120> 2008<00:30:19.679> crisis

00:30:20

london after the 2008 crisis

00:30:20

london after the 2008 crisis what<00:30:20.480> does<00:30:20.720> that<00:30:20.799> mean<00:30:21.039> for<00:30:21.200> families<00:30:21.600> that

00:30:21

what does that mean for families that

00:30:21

what does that mean for families that don't<00:30:21.919> own<00:30:22.080> housing<00:30:22.399> now<00:30:22.799> it<00:30:23.120> basically<00:30:23.520> means

00:30:24

don't own housing now it basically means

00:30:24

don't own housing now it basically means they<00:30:24.240> will<00:30:24.480> never<00:30:24.880> ever<00:30:25.200> own<00:30:25.440> housing<00:30:26.000> you're

00:30:26

they will never ever own housing you're

00:30:26

they will never ever own housing you're basically<00:30:26.640> telling

00:30:27

basically telling

00:30:27

basically telling you<00:30:27.279> know<00:30:28.159> the<00:30:28.399> 50<00:30:29.120> of<00:30:29.200> the<00:30:29.279> lowest<00:30:29.600> wealth

00:30:29

you know the 50 of the lowest wealth

00:30:29

you know the 50 of the lowest wealth people

00:30:30

people

00:30:30

people you<00:30:30.559> guys<00:30:30.799> lost<00:30:31.039> capitalism<00:30:31.919> you<00:30:32.080> will<00:30:32.240> never

00:30:32

you guys lost capitalism you will never

00:30:32

you guys lost capitalism you will never get<00:30:32.559> a<00:30:32.640> house<00:30:33.279> you<00:30:33.440> know

00:30:33

get a house you know

00:30:34

get a house you know that<00:30:34.240> that<00:30:34.480> is<00:30:34.840> so<00:30:35.840> you<00:30:36.080> might<00:30:36.240> get<00:30:36.399> a<00:30:36.480> gdp

00:30:36

that that is so you might get a gdp

00:30:36

that that is so you might get a gdp recovery

00:30:37

recovery

00:30:37

recovery but<00:30:37.919> it<00:30:38.000> will<00:30:38.080> be<00:30:38.240> at<00:30:38.320> the<00:30:38.480> cost<00:30:38.799> of<00:30:38.960> basically

00:30:39

but it will be at the cost of basically

00:30:39

but it will be at the cost of basically canceling<00:30:40.000> the<00:30:40.080> bottom<00:30:40.320> half<00:30:40.559> of<00:30:40.640> society<00:30:41.120> and

00:30:41

canceling the bottom half of society and

00:30:41

canceling the bottom half of society and saying<00:30:41.360> these<00:30:41.520> guys<00:30:41.679> will<00:30:41.840> never<00:30:42.000> own<00:30:42.159> housing

00:30:42

saying these guys will never own housing

00:30:42

saying these guys will never own housing ending<00:30:43.039> social<00:30:43.279> mobility<00:30:43.919> so<00:30:45.279> i<00:30:45.360> think<00:30:45.600> we

00:30:45

ending social mobility so i think we

00:30:45

ending social mobility so i think we really<00:30:46.159> need

00:30:46

really need

00:30:46

really need when<00:30:46.720> we<00:30:46.799> talk<00:30:46.960> about<00:30:47.120> being<00:30:47.360> farsighted<00:30:48.320> we

00:30:48

when we talk about being farsighted we

00:30:48

when we talk about being farsighted we need<00:30:48.799> to<00:30:48.960> look<00:30:49.120> at<00:30:49.200> what's<00:30:49.440> happening<00:30:49.679> with

00:30:49

need to look at what's happening with

00:30:49

need to look at what's happening with inequality

00:30:50

inequality

00:30:50

inequality because<00:30:51.200> if<00:30:51.360> we<00:30:51.440> make<00:30:51.679> if<00:30:51.760> we<00:30:51.919> keep<00:30:52.080> making<00:30:52.399> the

00:30:52

because if we make if we keep making the

00:30:52

because if we make if we keep making the same<00:30:52.720> mistake<00:30:53.360> of<00:30:53.520> just<00:30:53.760> allowing<00:30:54.159> inequality

00:30:54

same mistake of just allowing inequality

00:30:54

same mistake of just allowing inequality to<00:30:54.799> ratchet<00:30:55.200> up<00:30:55.360> and<00:30:55.520> up<00:30:55.760> and<00:30:55.919> up<00:30:56.080> and<00:30:56.240> up

00:30:56

to ratchet up and up and up and up

00:30:56

to ratchet up and up and up and up then<00:30:57.760> it's<00:30:57.919> going<00:30:58.080> to<00:30:58.159> be<00:30:58.320> disaster<00:30:58.799> for<00:30:58.960> a<00:30:59.039> lot

00:30:59

then it's going to be disaster for a lot

00:30:59

then it's going to be disaster for a lot of<00:30:59.279> people<00:30:59.679> he's<00:30:59.840> not<00:31:00.159> a<00:31:00.240> conventional

00:31:01

of people he's not a conventional

00:31:01

of people he's not a conventional economist<00:31:01.760> and<00:31:01.919> i'm<00:31:02.000> not<00:31:02.240> even<00:31:02.559> sure<00:31:02.720> if<00:31:02.880> he's

00:31:03

economist and i'm not even sure if he's

00:31:03

economist and i'm not even sure if he's taught<00:31:04.000> on

00:31:05

taught on

00:31:05

taught on university<00:31:05.760> economics<00:31:06.399> degrees<00:31:06.960> but<00:31:07.120> he<00:31:07.279> had

00:31:07

university economics degrees but he had

00:31:07

university economics degrees but he had the<00:31:07.600> very<00:31:07.919> successful<00:31:08.559> book<00:31:08.880> capital<00:31:09.279> in<00:31:09.440> the

00:31:09

the very successful book capital in the

00:31:09

the very successful book capital in the 21st<00:31:10.080> century<00:31:10.480> thomas<00:31:10.880> piketty

00:31:11

21st century thomas piketty

00:31:11

21st century thomas piketty and<00:31:12.880> he<00:31:13.279> he<00:31:13.519> argues<00:31:13.919> that<00:31:14.080> when<00:31:14.240> returns<00:31:14.720> on

00:31:15

and he he argues that when returns on

00:31:15

and he he argues that when returns on capital<00:31:16.080> are<00:31:16.240> high<00:31:16.640> so<00:31:16.799> the<00:31:16.960> asset<00:31:17.360> prices

00:31:17

capital are high so the asset prices

00:31:17

capital are high so the asset prices that<00:31:17.840> you're<00:31:18.080> talking<00:31:18.399> about

00:31:19

that you're talking about

00:31:19

that you're talking about and<00:31:19.440> returns<00:31:19.919> on<00:31:20.080> wages<00:31:20.720> are<00:31:20.880> really<00:31:21.200> low<00:31:21.519> and

00:31:21

and returns on wages are really low and

00:31:21

and returns on wages are really low and depressed

00:31:22

depressed

00:31:22

depressed then<00:31:22.880> the<00:31:23.039> inevitable<00:31:23.919> result<00:31:24.480> is<00:31:24.640> just

00:31:25

then the inevitable result is just

00:31:25

then the inevitable result is just growing

00:31:26

growing

00:31:26

growing inequality<00:31:27.519> you've<00:31:27.840> come<00:31:28.080> to<00:31:28.240> the<00:31:28.320> conclusion

00:31:28

inequality you've come to the conclusion

00:31:28

inequality you've come to the conclusion from<00:31:29.039> the<00:31:29.200> root

00:31:29

from the root

00:31:29

from the root you've<00:31:29.760> described<00:31:30.399> but<00:31:30.559> you<00:31:30.799> do<00:31:30.960> you

00:31:31

you've described but you do you

00:31:31

you've described but you do you basically<00:31:32.080> endorsing

00:31:33

basically endorsing

00:31:33

basically endorsing what<00:31:33.279> pikaty<00:31:34.159> is<00:31:34.320> saying<00:31:34.640> and<00:31:34.799> how<00:31:34.960> he's

00:31:35

what pikaty is saying and how he's

00:31:35

what pikaty is saying and how he's analyzing<00:31:35.840> things

00:31:36

analyzing things

00:31:36

analyzing things i've<00:31:36.559> read<00:31:36.720> piketty's<00:31:37.200> book<00:31:37.440> it's<00:31:37.600> a<00:31:37.679> very

00:31:37

i've read piketty's book it's a very

00:31:37

i've read piketty's book it's a very very<00:31:38.080> big<00:31:38.320> book

00:31:40

very big book

00:31:40

very big book one<00:31:40.480> picket<00:31:40.720> you<00:31:40.799> brought<00:31:40.960> that<00:31:41.039> bouquet<00:31:41.360> was

00:31:41

one picket you brought that bouquet was

00:31:41

one picket you brought that bouquet was great<00:31:41.840> because<00:31:42.240> i've<00:31:42.480> been<00:31:42.720> thinking<00:31:43.039> about

00:31:43

great because i've been thinking about

00:31:43

great because i've been thinking about inequality<00:31:43.840> a<00:31:44.000> lot

00:31:44

inequality a lot

00:31:44

inequality a lot in<00:31:44.559> the<00:31:44.640> previous<00:31:45.120> years<00:31:45.279> coming<00:31:45.519> up<00:31:45.760> i<00:31:45.840> think

00:31:45

in the previous years coming up i think

00:31:45

in the previous years coming up i think that<00:31:46.080> book<00:31:46.240> came<00:31:46.480> out<00:31:46.559> in<00:31:46.840> 2012<00:31:47.919> maybe<00:31:48.240> 2013.

00:31:49

that book came out in 2012 maybe 2013.

00:31:49

that book came out in 2012 maybe 2013. what<00:31:49.440> that<00:31:49.600> did<00:31:49.760> was<00:31:50.000> it<00:31:50.080> really<00:31:50.320> brought

00:31:50

what that did was it really brought

00:31:50

what that did was it really brought inequality<00:31:51.120> onto<00:31:51.360> the<00:31:51.440> agenda

00:31:52

inequality onto the agenda

00:31:52

inequality onto the agenda up<00:31:52.640> until<00:31:52.960> then<00:31:53.519> really<00:31:54.080> i<00:31:54.159> mean<00:31:54.720> like<00:31:54.960> i<00:31:55.039> said

00:31:55

up until then really i mean like i said

00:31:55

up until then really i mean like i said i've<00:31:55.519> been<00:31:55.840> five<00:31:56.080> years<00:31:56.320> university<00:31:56.720> studying

00:31:57

i've been five years university studying

00:31:57

i've been five years university studying economics<00:31:57.679> inequalities<00:31:58.399> hardly<00:31:58.799> mentioned

00:31:59

economics inequalities hardly mentioned

00:31:59

economics inequalities hardly mentioned at<00:31:59.519> all<00:32:00.159> so<00:32:01.760> up<00:32:01.919> until<00:32:02.320> pikay<00:32:02.720> brought<00:32:02.880> that

00:32:03

at all so up until pikay brought that

00:32:03

at all so up until pikay brought that book<00:32:03.279> out<00:32:03.440> it<00:32:03.519> wasn't<00:32:03.840> really<00:32:04.080> in<00:32:04.240> them

00:32:04

book out it wasn't really in them

00:32:04

book out it wasn't really in them in<00:32:04.720> the<00:32:04.880> eyes<00:32:05.120> of<00:32:05.200> economies<00:32:05.679> at<00:32:05.840> all<00:32:06.000> and<00:32:06.080> it

00:32:06

in the eyes of economies at all and it

00:32:06

in the eyes of economies at all and it really<00:32:06.399> brought<00:32:06.640> it<00:32:06.720> into<00:32:06.880> the<00:32:06.960> eyes<00:32:07.200> of

00:32:07

really brought it into the eyes of

00:32:07

really brought it into the eyes of economy<00:32:07.600> so<00:32:07.679> i<00:32:07.760> think<00:32:07.919> he's<00:32:08.080> done<00:32:08.240> a<00:32:08.320> really

00:32:08

economy so i think he's done a really

00:32:08

economy so i think he's done a really great<00:32:09.039> service<00:32:09.440> in<00:32:09.519> doing<00:32:09.840> that<00:32:10.480> in<00:32:10.559> terms<00:32:10.799> of

00:32:10

great service in doing that in terms of

00:32:10

great service in doing that in terms of the<00:32:11.039> analysis<00:32:11.600> itself

00:32:12

the analysis itself

00:32:12

the analysis itself it's<00:32:12.559> not<00:32:12.799> really<00:32:13.039> the<00:32:13.120> same<00:32:13.279> kind<00:32:13.440> of<00:32:13.519> thing

00:32:13

it's not really the same kind of thing

00:32:13

it's not really the same kind of thing i'm<00:32:13.840> thinking<00:32:14.240> there's<00:32:14.399> actually<00:32:14.799> a<00:32:14.880> few<00:32:15.200> guys

00:32:15

i'm thinking there's actually a few guys

00:32:15

i'm thinking there's actually a few guys now

00:32:15

now

00:32:16

now some<00:32:16.240> economists<00:32:16.640> called<00:32:16.880> miyan<00:32:17.200> and<00:32:17.360> sufi

00:32:17

some economists called miyan and sufi

00:32:17

some economists called miyan and sufi working<00:32:18.159> with<00:32:18.240> a<00:32:18.320> guy<00:32:18.480> called<00:32:18.720> straub

00:32:19

working with a guy called straub

00:32:19

working with a guy called straub that<00:32:19.519> are<00:32:19.600> really<00:32:19.840> looking<00:32:20.240> at<00:32:20.399> this<00:32:20.640> idea

00:32:20

that are really looking at this idea

00:32:20

that are really looking at this idea that<00:32:21.039> when<00:32:21.279> inequality<00:32:21.919> gets<00:32:22.240> very<00:32:22.559> large

00:32:23

that when inequality gets very large

00:32:23

that when inequality gets very large it<00:32:24.320> creates<00:32:24.799> a<00:32:24.880> situation<00:32:25.600> where<00:32:26.000> all<00:32:26.159> of<00:32:26.240> the

00:32:26

it creates a situation where all of the

00:32:26

it creates a situation where all of the income<00:32:26.640> is<00:32:26.720> going<00:32:26.880> to<00:32:26.960> the<00:32:27.039> rich<00:32:27.279> and<00:32:27.360> they've

00:32:27

income is going to the rich and they've

00:32:27

income is going to the rich and they've got<00:32:27.600> nothing

00:32:28

got nothing

00:32:28

got nothing on<00:32:28.399> which<00:32:28.640> to<00:32:28.799> spend<00:32:29.120> it<00:32:29.679> so<00:32:29.840> they<00:32:30.080> end<00:32:30.240> up

00:32:30

on which to spend it so they end up

00:32:30

on which to spend it so they end up either<00:32:30.799> lending<00:32:31.200> it<00:32:31.279> back<00:32:31.440> to<00:32:31.600> the<00:32:31.679> poor

00:32:32

either lending it back to the poor

00:32:32

either lending it back to the poor or<00:32:32.480> buying<00:32:33.120> houses<00:32:33.600> from<00:32:33.760> the<00:32:33.840> middle<00:32:34.159> class

00:32:34

or buying houses from the middle class

00:32:34

or buying houses from the middle class and<00:32:35.039> it<00:32:35.120> means<00:32:35.360> that<00:32:35.600> inequality<00:32:36.159> leads<00:32:36.320> to

00:32:36

and it means that inequality leads to

00:32:36

and it means that inequality leads to greater<00:32:36.799> inequality

00:32:37

greater inequality

00:32:37

greater inequality because<00:32:38.080> if<00:32:38.320> all<00:32:38.480> the<00:32:38.559> money<00:32:38.799> goes<00:32:38.960> to<00:32:39.120> the

00:32:39

because if all the money goes to the

00:32:39

because if all the money goes to the rich<00:32:39.679> they<00:32:39.840> use<00:32:40.080> that<00:32:40.159> money<00:32:40.399> to<00:32:40.480> buy<00:32:40.640> houses

00:32:41

rich they use that money to buy houses

00:32:41

rich they use that money to buy houses that<00:32:41.600> pushes<00:32:41.919> house<00:32:42.159> prices<00:32:42.559> up<00:32:42.799> which<00:32:43.039> means

00:32:43

that pushes house prices up which means

00:32:43

that pushes house prices up which means maybe<00:32:44.080> ordinary<00:32:44.559> people<00:32:44.799> who<00:32:44.880> might<00:32:45.039> not<00:32:45.200> be

00:32:45

maybe ordinary people who might not be

00:32:45

maybe ordinary people who might not be too<00:32:45.679> well<00:32:45.919> off<00:32:46.159> they<00:32:46.320> think<00:32:46.480> well<00:32:46.640> i'm<00:32:46.720> going

00:32:46

too well off they think well i'm going

00:32:46

too well off they think well i'm going to<00:32:46.880> sell<00:32:47.120> my<00:32:47.200> house<00:32:47.440> because<00:32:47.519> i<00:32:47.600> could<00:32:47.679> have<00:32:47.760> a

00:32:47

to sell my house because i could have a

00:32:47

to sell my house because i could have a really<00:32:48.000> good<00:32:48.240> life

00:32:48

really good life

00:32:48

really good life and<00:32:48.799> the<00:32:48.960> houses<00:32:49.519> transfer<00:32:50.000> up<00:32:50.320> i<00:32:50.399> think<00:32:50.559> we're

00:32:50

and the houses transfer up i think we're

00:32:50

and the houses transfer up i think we're really<00:32:51.039> seeing<00:32:51.279> that<00:32:51.440> in<00:32:51.519> society<00:32:52.000> now

00:32:52

really seeing that in society now

00:32:52

really seeing that in society now you're<00:32:52.640> seeing<00:32:52.880> that<00:32:52.960> as<00:32:53.120> the<00:32:53.200> roots<00:32:53.440> get

00:32:53

you're seeing that as the roots get

00:32:53

you're seeing that as the roots get richer<00:32:54.640> they<00:32:54.880> generate<00:32:55.200> huge<00:32:55.440> amounts<00:32:55.679> of

00:32:55

richer they generate huge amounts of

00:32:55

richer they generate huge amounts of income<00:32:56.080> from<00:32:56.240> their<00:32:56.480> wealth

00:32:57

income from their wealth

00:32:57

income from their wealth they<00:32:57.200> use<00:32:57.440> that<00:32:57.600> wealth<00:32:57.840> to<00:32:58.000> buy<00:32:58.159> the<00:32:58.320> rest<00:32:58.559> of

00:32:58

they use that wealth to buy the rest of

00:32:58

they use that wealth to buy the rest of the<00:32:58.799> wealth<00:32:59.279> which<00:32:59.600> means<00:32:59.840> that

00:33:00

the wealth which means that

00:33:00

the wealth which means that inequality<00:33:01.039> goes<00:33:01.200> up<00:33:01.360> even<00:33:01.519> more<00:33:02.080> so<00:33:02.640> these

00:33:02

inequality goes up even more so these

00:33:02

inequality goes up even more so these guys

00:33:03

guys

00:33:03

guys who<00:33:04.000> are<00:33:04.080> looking<00:33:04.640> at<00:33:04.799> this<00:33:04.960> kind<00:33:05.120> of<00:33:05.200> stuff

00:33:05

who are looking at this kind of stuff

00:33:05

who are looking at this kind of stuff now<00:33:05.679> these<00:33:05.919> guys<00:33:06.159> mian<00:33:06.480> and<00:33:06.640> sufi<00:33:07.039> and<00:33:07.200> straub

00:33:08

now these guys mian and sufi and straub

00:33:08

now these guys mian and sufi and straub that's<00:33:08.559> the<00:33:08.640> kind<00:33:08.799> of<00:33:08.880> analysis<00:33:09.279> i<00:33:09.360> like<00:33:09.519> more

00:33:09

that's the kind of analysis i like more

00:33:10

that's the kind of analysis i like more i<00:33:10.159> was<00:33:10.320> kind<00:33:10.480> of<00:33:10.559> wondering<00:33:10.960> if

00:33:11

i was kind of wondering if

00:33:11

i was kind of wondering if if<00:33:11.360> we're<00:33:11.519> talking<00:33:11.760> about<00:33:11.919> what<00:33:12.080> we<00:33:12.240> should<00:33:12.399> be

00:33:12

if we're talking about what we should be

00:33:12

if we're talking about what we should be campaigning<00:33:13.279> for<00:33:13.679> what<00:33:14.000> economic

00:33:14

campaigning for what economic

00:33:14

campaigning for what economic vision<00:33:15.440> the<00:33:15.679> opposition<00:33:16.159> should<00:33:16.320> be<00:33:16.480> building

00:33:16

vision the opposition should be building

00:33:16

vision the opposition should be building because<00:33:17.039> it<00:33:17.120> does<00:33:17.279> seem<00:33:17.519> to<00:33:17.760> be<00:33:17.919> a

00:33:18

because it does seem to be a

00:33:18

because it does seem to be a time<00:33:18.480> they<00:33:18.640> did<00:33:19.120> do<00:33:19.279> that<00:33:19.919> are<00:33:20.080> we<00:33:20.320> are<00:33:20.399> we

00:33:20

time they did do that are we are we

00:33:20

time they did do that are we are we saying<00:33:20.880> in<00:33:20.960> the<00:33:21.039> first<00:33:21.440> instance

00:33:22

saying in the first instance

00:33:22

saying in the first instance that<00:33:22.480> you<00:33:22.640> have<00:33:22.799> to<00:33:22.960> stop<00:33:23.360> using<00:33:23.760> gdp<00:33:24.320> as<00:33:24.399> a

00:33:24

that you have to stop using gdp as a

00:33:24

that you have to stop using gdp as a measure<00:33:24.799> because<00:33:25.039> i've<00:33:25.200> actually<00:33:25.360> never

00:33:25

measure because i've actually never

00:33:25

measure because i've actually never heard<00:33:25.919> anybody<00:33:26.320> articulate<00:33:26.880> so<00:33:27.120> strongly

00:33:28

heard anybody articulate so strongly

00:33:28

heard anybody articulate so strongly what<00:33:28.640> you<00:33:28.880> just<00:33:29.120> said<00:33:29.440> in<00:33:29.519> terms<00:33:29.840> of<00:33:30.000> how<00:33:31.120> how

00:33:31

what you just said in terms of how how

00:33:31

what you just said in terms of how how ineffective<00:33:32.080> a<00:33:32.240> measure<00:33:32.640> of<00:33:32.799> a<00:33:32.960> nation's

00:33:33

ineffective a measure of a nation's

00:33:33

ineffective a measure of a nation's wealth<00:33:33.679> it<00:33:33.919> is

00:33:34

wealth it is

00:33:34

wealth it is so<00:33:34.559> often<00:33:34.799> people<00:33:35.120> say<00:33:35.519> gdp<00:33:36.000> is<00:33:36.080> no<00:33:36.240> good<00:33:36.399> to

00:33:36

so often people say gdp is no good to

00:33:36

so often people say gdp is no good to measure<00:33:36.799> because<00:33:36.960> it<00:33:37.039> doesn't<00:33:37.279> measure

00:33:37

measure because it doesn't measure

00:33:37

measure because it doesn't measure well-being

00:33:38

well-being

00:33:38

well-being but<00:33:38.880> actually<00:33:39.279> what's<00:33:39.519> wrong<00:33:39.679> with<00:33:39.840> gdp<00:33:40.480> is

00:33:40

but actually what's wrong with gdp is

00:33:40

but actually what's wrong with gdp is that<00:33:41.039> it<00:33:41.279> measures

00:33:42

that it measures

00:33:42

that it measures when<00:33:42.399> you<00:33:42.720> aggregate<00:33:43.279> with<00:33:43.440> the<00:33:43.519> wealth<00:33:43.840> of<00:33:44.000> a

00:33:44

when you aggregate with the wealth of a

00:33:44

when you aggregate with the wealth of a nation<00:33:44.480> you<00:33:44.640> completely<00:33:45.200> erase<00:33:45.600> the

00:33:46

nation you completely erase the

00:33:46

nation you completely erase the the<00:33:46.240> story<00:33:46.480> of<00:33:46.559> the<00:33:46.640> people<00:33:46.880> who<00:33:46.960> don't<00:33:47.200> hold

00:33:47

the story of the people who don't hold

00:33:47

the story of the people who don't hold it<00:33:48.480> so<00:33:48.720> should<00:33:48.960> you<00:33:49.120> in<00:33:49.279> the<00:33:49.360> first<00:33:49.600> instance

00:33:49

it so should you in the first instance

00:33:49

it so should you in the first instance be<00:33:50.080> saying<00:33:50.320> gdp<00:33:50.799> is<00:33:50.880> no<00:33:50.960> longer<00:33:51.279> our<00:33:51.440> thing<00:33:51.919> and

00:33:52

be saying gdp is no longer our thing and

00:33:52

be saying gdp is no longer our thing and not<00:33:52.320> because<00:33:52.640> we<00:33:52.720> want<00:33:52.880> to<00:33:52.960> measure<00:33:53.279> happiness

00:33:53

not because we want to measure happiness

00:33:53

not because we want to measure happiness instead

00:33:55

instead

00:33:55

instead yeah<00:33:55.440> it's<00:33:55.600> a<00:33:55.679> good<00:33:55.840> question<00:33:57.200> i<00:33:57.279> really

00:33:57

yeah it's a good question i really

00:33:57

yeah it's a good question i really remember

00:33:58

remember

00:33:58

remember during<00:33:58.720> the<00:33:58.960> the<00:33:59.120> brexit<00:33:59.519> debates<00:33:59.919> before<00:34:00.159> the

00:34:00

during the the brexit debates before the

00:34:00

during the the brexit debates before the brexit<00:34:00.640> i<00:34:00.640> don't<00:34:00.799> know<00:34:00.799> if<00:34:00.880> it<00:34:00.960> was<00:34:01.120> question

00:34:01

brexit i don't know if it was question

00:34:01

brexit i don't know if it was question time<00:34:01.840> there<00:34:02.080> was<00:34:02.240> some<00:34:02.399> conservative<00:34:02.960> mp<00:34:03.200> it

00:34:03

time there was some conservative mp it

00:34:03

time there was some conservative mp it might<00:34:03.360> have<00:34:03.440> been<00:34:03.600> george<00:34:03.840> osborne

00:34:04

might have been george osborne

00:34:04

might have been george osborne on<00:34:04.720> there<00:34:04.960> and<00:34:05.039> it<00:34:05.760> he<00:34:05.919> was<00:34:06.000> talking<00:34:06.320> about<00:34:06.480> how

00:34:06

on there and it he was talking about how

00:34:06

on there and it he was talking about how gdp<00:34:07.200> has<00:34:07.279> gone<00:34:07.440> up<00:34:07.600> and<00:34:07.760> up<00:34:07.840> and<00:34:08.000> up<00:34:08.240> and

00:34:08

gdp has gone up and up and up and

00:34:08

gdp has gone up and up and up and some<00:34:08.800> i<00:34:08.879> think<00:34:09.040> it<00:34:09.119> was<00:34:09.280> a<00:34:09.359> woman<00:34:09.599> in<00:34:09.679> the<00:34:09.760> crowd

00:34:09

some i think it was a woman in the crowd

00:34:10

some i think it was a woman in the crowd stood<00:34:10.240> up<00:34:10.320> and<00:34:10.399> she<00:34:10.560> shouted<00:34:10.960> out<00:34:11.359> that's<00:34:11.599> your

00:34:11

stood up and she shouted out that's your

00:34:11

stood up and she shouted out that's your gdp

00:34:12

gdp

00:34:12

gdp and<00:34:13.040> i<00:34:13.119> thought<00:34:13.839> good<00:34:14.079> on<00:34:14.240> you<00:34:14.480> because<00:34:14.879> she's

00:34:15

and i thought good on you because she's

00:34:15

and i thought good on you because she's i'm<00:34:16.000> guessing<00:34:16.320> she's<00:34:16.480> not<00:34:16.639> a<00:34:16.639> professional

00:34:17

i'm guessing she's not a professional

00:34:17

i'm guessing she's not a professional economist

00:34:17

economist

00:34:17

economist but<00:34:17.919> she's<00:34:18.320> realized<00:34:18.639> something<00:34:18.960> i<00:34:19.040> think<00:34:19.200> a

00:34:19

but she's realized something i think a

00:34:19

but she's realized something i think a lot<00:34:19.359> of<00:34:19.440> economists<00:34:19.919> probably<00:34:20.240> should

00:34:20

lot of economists probably should

00:34:20

lot of economists probably should realize<00:34:20.800> the<00:34:20.960> problem<00:34:21.200> is

00:34:21

realize the problem is

00:34:21

realize the problem is personally<00:34:22.320> i<00:34:22.399> think<00:34:22.800> from<00:34:22.960> my<00:34:23.119> experience<00:34:23.440> at

00:34:23

personally i think from my experience at

00:34:23

personally i think from my experience at universities<00:34:24.000> a<00:34:24.079> big<00:34:24.240> problem<00:34:24.480> with

00:34:24

universities a big problem with

00:34:24

universities a big problem with economics<00:34:25.119> is

00:34:25

economics is

00:34:25

economics is at<00:34:25.919> the<00:34:26.000> big<00:34:26.240> universities<00:34:26.800> almost<00:34:27.200> everyone

00:34:27

at the big universities almost everyone

00:34:27

at the big universities almost everyone in<00:34:27.919> the<00:34:28.000> department<00:34:28.320> is<00:34:28.480> from<00:34:28.560> a<00:34:28.639> wealthy

00:34:28

in the department is from a wealthy

00:34:28

in the department is from a wealthy background

00:34:29

background

00:34:29

background they<00:34:29.919> don't<00:34:30.159> realize<00:34:30.560> that<00:34:31.119> the<00:34:31.280> economy<00:34:31.599> is

00:34:31

they don't realize that the economy is

00:34:31

they don't realize that the economy is very<00:34:32.000> different<00:34:32.480> for<00:34:32.639> rich<00:34:32.879> people

00:34:33

very different for rich people

00:34:33

very different for rich people as<00:34:33.599> it<00:34:33.760> is<00:34:34.079> from<00:34:34.320> ordinary<00:34:34.800> people<00:34:35.119> and<00:34:35.919> as<00:34:36.159> gdp

00:34:36

as it is from ordinary people and as gdp

00:34:36

as it is from ordinary people and as gdp is<00:34:36.639> going<00:34:36.720> up<00:34:36.879> and<00:34:36.960> up<00:34:37.040> and<00:34:37.200> up<00:34:37.280> i<00:34:37.359> think<00:34:37.520> a<00:34:37.599> lot

00:34:37

is going up and up and up i think a lot

00:34:37

is going up and up and up i think a lot of<00:34:37.919> people<00:34:38.240> are<00:34:38.399> very<00:34:38.720> aware<00:34:39.200> that

00:34:40

of people are very aware that

00:34:40

of people are very aware that lives<00:34:40.879> maybe<00:34:41.119> haven't<00:34:41.359> gotten<00:34:41.599> better<00:34:41.839> for<00:34:42.000> a

00:34:42

lives maybe haven't gotten better for a

00:34:42

lives maybe haven't gotten better for a lot<00:34:42.240> of<00:34:42.320> people<00:34:42.800> maybe<00:34:43.040> a<00:34:43.119> lot<00:34:43.280> of<00:34:43.359> people<00:34:43.599> my

00:34:43

lot of people maybe a lot of people my

00:34:43

lot of people maybe a lot of people my generation<00:34:44.320> younger<00:34:44.639> than<00:34:44.800> me

00:34:45

generation younger than me

00:34:45

generation younger than me might<00:34:46.000> feel<00:34:46.240> that<00:34:46.320> their<00:34:46.480> parents<00:34:46.800> lives<00:34:47.040> were

00:34:47

might feel that their parents lives were

00:34:47

might feel that their parents lives were easier<00:34:47.520> economically<00:34:48.079> than<00:34:48.240> theirs

00:34:48

easier economically than theirs

00:34:48

easier economically than theirs even<00:34:49.200> though<00:34:49.359> gdp<00:34:49.760> goes<00:34:49.919> up<00:34:50.079> and<00:34:50.159> up<00:34:50.240> and<00:34:50.399> up<00:34:50.560> so

00:34:50

even though gdp goes up and up and up so

00:34:50

even though gdp goes up and up and up so i<00:34:50.960> wouldn't<00:34:51.280> say<00:34:51.760> completely<00:34:52.159> throw<00:34:52.480> gdp<00:34:52.960> out

00:34:53

i wouldn't say completely throw gdp out

00:34:53

i wouldn't say completely throw gdp out like<00:34:53.200> it's<00:34:53.280> a<00:34:53.359> completely<00:34:53.760> useless<00:34:54.079> measure

00:34:54

like it's a completely useless measure

00:34:54

like it's a completely useless measure of<00:34:54.720> course<00:34:55.040> it<00:34:55.200> is<00:34:55.359> a<00:34:55.440> useful<00:34:55.839> measure<00:34:56.639> but<00:34:56.960> if

00:34:57

of course it is a useful measure but if

00:34:57

of course it is a useful measure but if gdp<00:34:58.240> is<00:34:58.320> going<00:34:58.560> up<00:34:58.640> and<00:34:58.800> at<00:34:58.960> the<00:34:59.040> same<00:34:59.280> time

00:35:00

gdp is going up and at the same time

00:35:00

gdp is going up and at the same time loads<00:35:00.320> and<00:35:00.400> loads<00:35:00.640> of<00:35:00.720> people<00:35:01.040> are<00:35:01.119> saying<00:35:01.440> my

00:35:01

loads and loads of people are saying my

00:35:01

loads and loads of people are saying my life's<00:35:01.839> getting<00:35:02.079> worse

00:35:02

life's getting worse

00:35:02

life's getting worse listen<00:35:03.200> to<00:35:03.359> that<00:35:03.680> and<00:35:03.920> give<00:35:04.160> it<00:35:04.640> a<00:35:04.800> thought

00:35:05

listen to that and give it a thought

00:35:05

listen to that and give it a thought that<00:35:05.760> maybe<00:35:06.160> something's<00:35:06.480> really<00:35:06.720> happening

00:35:07

that maybe something's really happening

00:35:07

that maybe something's really happening because

00:35:07

because

00:35:07

because we've<00:35:07.839> got<00:35:08.000> a<00:35:08.079> big<00:35:08.240> problem<00:35:08.560> in<00:35:08.640> economics

00:35:09

we've got a big problem in economics

00:35:09

we've got a big problem in economics that<00:35:10.079> very<00:35:10.320> few<00:35:10.480> people<00:35:10.640> with<00:35:10.800> more<00:35:10.880> than<00:35:11.040> any

00:35:11

that very few people with more than any

00:35:11

that very few people with more than any background

00:35:11

background

00:35:11

background are<00:35:11.839> getting<00:35:12.160> into<00:35:12.320> these<00:35:12.480> university

00:35:12

are getting into these university

00:35:12

are getting into these university departments<00:35:13.359> anymore<00:35:13.839> so<00:35:14.000> if<00:35:14.160> ordinary

00:35:14

departments anymore so if ordinary

00:35:14

departments anymore so if ordinary people<00:35:14.720> are<00:35:14.800> coming<00:35:15.040> to<00:35:15.119> you<00:35:15.280> and<00:35:15.359> saying<00:35:15.520> no

00:35:15

people are coming to you and saying no

00:35:15

people are coming to you and saying no things<00:35:16.079> are<00:35:16.160> not<00:35:16.320> good<00:35:16.480> for<00:35:16.720> us

00:35:17

things are not good for us

00:35:17

things are not good for us you<00:35:17.200> have<00:35:17.359> to<00:35:17.520> listen<00:35:17.760> to<00:35:17.920> them<00:35:18.240> i<00:35:18.320> think<00:35:18.640> so

00:35:19

you have to listen to them i think so

00:35:19

you have to listen to them i think so don't<00:35:20.000> completely<00:35:20.400> acknowledge<00:35:20.720> gdp

00:35:21

don't completely acknowledge gdp

00:35:21

don't completely acknowledge gdp but<00:35:23.040> listen<00:35:23.440> also<00:35:23.760> to<00:35:23.920> ordinary<00:35:24.400> people<00:35:24.640> and

00:35:24

but listen also to ordinary people and

00:35:24

but listen also to ordinary people and what<00:35:24.880> they're<00:35:25.040> saying<00:35:25.359> and<00:35:25.520> if<00:35:25.599> they<00:35:25.839> say

00:35:26

what they're saying and if they say

00:35:26

what they're saying and if they say we're<00:35:26.320> not<00:35:26.480> happy<00:35:26.800> with<00:35:27.119> what's<00:35:27.359> happening<00:35:27.760> in

00:35:27

we're not happy with what's happening in

00:35:27

we're not happy with what's happening in the<00:35:27.920> economy<00:35:28.400> ask<00:35:28.640> them<00:35:28.800> why<00:35:29.200> and

00:35:30

the economy ask them why and

00:35:30

the economy ask them why and answer<00:35:30.400> those<00:35:30.560> questions<00:35:30.960> because<00:35:31.760> like<00:35:32.000> i

00:35:32

answer those questions because like i

00:35:32

answer those questions because like i said<00:35:32.240> the<00:35:32.320> last<00:35:32.480> two<00:35:32.640> years<00:35:32.800> i<00:35:32.880> did<00:35:33.040> a<00:35:33.119> masters

00:35:33

said the last two years i did a masters

00:35:33

said the last two years i did a masters at<00:35:33.520> oxford

00:35:34

at oxford

00:35:34

at oxford and<00:35:35.599> i<00:35:35.760> found<00:35:36.000> that<00:35:36.079> the<00:35:36.320> faculty<00:35:36.800> there<00:35:37.119> were

00:35:37

and i found that the faculty there were

00:35:37

and i found that the faculty there were unbelievably<00:35:38.320> disconnected<00:35:38.800> from<00:35:38.960> what<00:35:39.040> was

00:35:39

unbelievably disconnected from what was

00:35:39

unbelievably disconnected from what was happening<00:35:39.440> in<00:35:39.520> the<00:35:39.599> real<00:35:39.760> world<00:35:40.079> and

00:35:40

happening in the real world and

00:35:40

happening in the real world and i<00:35:40.480> spoke<00:35:40.800> to<00:35:40.880> one<00:35:40.960> of<00:35:41.040> the<00:35:41.119> professors<00:35:41.520> i<00:35:41.599> said

00:35:41

i spoke to one of the professors i said

00:35:41

i spoke to one of the professors i said to<00:35:41.920> him<00:35:43.280> you<00:35:43.440> know<00:35:43.760> he<00:35:44.000> asked<00:35:44.160> me<00:35:44.320> why<00:35:44.480> are<00:35:44.480> you

00:35:44

to him you know he asked me why are you

00:35:44

to him you know he asked me why are you so<00:35:45.119> unhappy<00:35:45.440> in<00:35:45.520> the<00:35:45.599> lectures<00:35:46.000> and<00:35:46.079> i<00:35:46.160> said

00:35:46

so unhappy in the lectures and i said

00:35:46

so unhappy in the lectures and i said because<00:35:46.560> you're<00:35:46.640> not<00:35:46.800> talking<00:35:47.040> about<00:35:47.200> what's

00:35:47

because you're not talking about what's

00:35:47

because you're not talking about what's really<00:35:47.520> happening

00:35:47

really happening

00:35:48

really happening why<00:35:48.240> don't<00:35:48.400> you<00:35:48.480> talk<00:35:48.640> about<00:35:48.800> the<00:35:48.880> housing

00:35:49

why don't you talk about the housing

00:35:49

why don't you talk about the housing crisis<00:35:50.079> and<00:35:50.240> he<00:35:50.400> said<00:35:50.560> to<00:35:50.720> me

00:35:51

crisis and he said to me

00:35:51

crisis and he said to me well<00:35:51.520> because<00:35:51.760> the<00:35:51.839> housing<00:35:52.079> crisis<00:35:52.400> is<00:35:52.480> only

00:35:52

well because the housing crisis is only

00:35:52

well because the housing crisis is only in<00:35:52.800> london<00:35:53.920> and<00:35:54.079> i<00:35:54.160> said<00:35:54.320> well<00:35:54.480> the<00:35:54.560> housing

00:35:54

in london and i said well the housing

00:35:54

in london and i said well the housing crisis<00:35:55.119> is<00:35:55.200> only<00:35:55.280> in<00:35:55.359> london<00:35:55.680> because<00:35:55.839> there's

00:35:55

crisis is only in london because there's

00:35:56

crisis is only in london because there's no<00:35:56.160> jobs<00:35:56.480> outside<00:35:56.800> of<00:35:56.880> london

00:35:57

no jobs outside of london

00:35:57

no jobs outside of london and<00:35:57.680> he<00:35:57.839> said<00:35:58.000> to<00:35:58.160> me<00:35:58.720> yes<00:35:58.960> there<00:35:59.119> are<00:35:59.280> jobs

00:35:59

and he said to me yes there are jobs

00:35:59

and he said to me yes there are jobs outside<00:35:59.760> of<00:35:59.839> london<00:36:00.320> i've<00:36:00.640> got<00:36:00.800> a<00:36:00.880> job

00:36:01

outside of london i've got a job

00:36:01

outside of london i've got a job this<00:36:01.839> guy's<00:36:02.079> an<00:36:02.240> economics<00:36:02.880> professor<00:36:03.760> at

00:36:03

this guy's an economics professor at

00:36:03

this guy's an economics professor at oxford<00:36:04.320> university

00:36:05

oxford university

00:36:05

oxford university you<00:36:05.599> know<00:36:05.920> if<00:36:06.000> you're<00:36:06.079> going<00:36:06.240> to<00:36:06.320> tell<00:36:06.560> like

00:36:07

you know if you're going to tell like

00:36:07

you know if you're going to tell like some<00:36:07.359> guy<00:36:07.599> who's<00:36:07.760> lost<00:36:08.000> his<00:36:08.079> job<00:36:08.240> in<00:36:08.400> a<00:36:08.480> factory

00:36:08

some guy who's lost his job in a factory

00:36:08

some guy who's lost his job in a factory in<00:36:08.960> wigan<00:36:09.280> you're<00:36:09.359> going<00:36:09.440> to<00:36:09.520> say

00:36:09

in wigan you're going to say

00:36:09

in wigan you're going to say well<00:36:10.160> actually<00:36:10.800> there's<00:36:10.960> a<00:36:11.040> vacancy<00:36:11.440> at

00:36:11

well actually there's a vacancy at

00:36:11

well actually there's a vacancy at oxford<00:36:11.839> for<00:36:11.920> an<00:36:12.000> economic<00:36:12.400> suppressor<00:36:12.800> why

00:36:13

oxford for an economic suppressor why

00:36:13

oxford for an economic suppressor why don't<00:36:13.200> you<00:36:13.280> go<00:36:13.440> and<00:36:13.520> apply<00:36:13.760> for<00:36:13.920> that<00:36:14.160> like

00:36:14

don't you go and apply for that like

00:36:14

don't you go and apply for that like it's<00:36:15.680> it's<00:36:16.000> boggles<00:36:16.400> the<00:36:16.560> mind<00:36:17.280> how<00:36:17.520> you<00:36:17.680> know

00:36:17

it's it's boggles the mind how you know

00:36:17

it's it's boggles the mind how you know these<00:36:18.160> guys<00:36:18.400> standing<00:36:18.720> there<00:36:18.880> with<00:36:18.960> capes<00:36:19.200> and

00:36:19

these guys standing there with capes and

00:36:19

these guys standing there with capes and bow<00:36:19.520> ties<00:36:19.760> tell<00:36:19.920> him<00:36:20.079> everything's<00:36:20.400> fine

00:36:20

bow ties tell him everything's fine

00:36:20

bow ties tell him everything's fine you're<00:36:20.880> like

00:36:22

you're like

00:36:22

you're like honestly<00:36:22.960> it's<00:36:23.200> it's<00:36:23.440> a<00:36:23.520> massive<00:36:23.920> it's<00:36:24.160> a

00:36:24

honestly it's it's a massive it's a

00:36:24

honestly it's it's a massive it's a massive<00:36:24.800> massive<00:36:25.119> massive<00:36:25.440> problem<00:36:25.680> a<00:36:25.760> lack

00:36:25

massive massive massive problem a lack

00:36:26

massive massive massive problem a lack of<00:36:26.079> representation

00:36:27

of representation

00:36:27

of representation of<00:36:27.280> people<00:36:27.520> from<00:36:27.839> ordinary<00:36:28.640> financial

00:36:29

of people from ordinary financial

00:36:29

of people from ordinary financial positions

00:36:30

positions

00:36:30

positions in<00:36:30.640> these<00:36:31.200> in<00:36:31.280> the<00:36:31.359> world<00:36:31.599> of<00:36:31.760> economics<00:36:32.400> it

00:36:32

in these in the world of economics it

00:36:32

in these in the world of economics it has<00:36:32.800> to<00:36:32.960> be<00:36:33.119> fixed<00:36:33.440> because<00:36:33.680> in<00:36:33.760> the<00:36:33.920> end

00:36:34

has to be fixed because in the end

00:36:34

has to be fixed because in the end you<00:36:34.480> end<00:36:34.560> up<00:36:34.640> with<00:36:34.720> a<00:36:34.800> load<00:36:34.960> of<00:36:35.040> rich<00:36:35.280> people

00:36:35

you end up with a load of rich people

00:36:35

you end up with a load of rich people saying<00:36:36.160> everything's<00:36:36.560> great<00:36:36.800> because<00:36:37.119> for

00:36:37

saying everything's great because for

00:36:37

saying everything's great because for them<00:36:37.520> it's<00:36:37.680> great

00:36:38

them it's great

00:36:38

them it's great we<00:36:38.560> have<00:36:38.640> to<00:36:38.720> fix<00:36:38.960> that<00:36:39.119> and<00:36:39.280> you<00:36:39.440> know<00:36:40.160> part<00:36:40.400> of

00:36:40

we have to fix that and you know part of

00:36:40

we have to fix that and you know part of that<00:36:40.720> is<00:36:40.960> not<00:36:41.280> just<00:36:41.520> fixating<00:36:42.000> on<00:36:42.160> one<00:36:42.400> measure

00:36:42

that is not just fixating on one measure

00:36:42

that is not just fixating on one measure i<00:36:42.720> mean<00:36:42.880> the<00:36:43.040> idea<00:36:43.280> that<00:36:43.440> you<00:36:43.520> could

00:36:44

i mean the idea that you could

00:36:44

i mean the idea that you could reduce<00:36:44.560> boil<00:36:44.800> down<00:36:44.960> the<00:36:45.040> whole<00:36:45.280> economy<00:36:45.680> to<00:36:45.839> a

00:36:45

reduce boil down the whole economy to a

00:36:45

reduce boil down the whole economy to a number<00:36:46.320> 269<00:36:47.280> billion

00:36:47

number 269 billion

00:36:47

number 269 billion or<00:36:47.760> something<00:36:48.000> like<00:36:48.160> this<00:36:49.119> it<00:36:49.200> is<00:36:49.359> absurd

00:36:49

or something like this it is absurd

00:36:49

or something like this it is absurd isn't<00:36:50.000> it<00:36:50.160> and<00:36:50.240> the<00:36:50.400> fact<00:36:50.560> that<00:36:50.640> so<00:36:50.800> many

00:36:50

isn't it and the fact that so many

00:36:50

isn't it and the fact that so many economists<00:36:51.359> have<00:36:51.520> sold<00:36:51.760> themselves<00:36:52.000> to<00:36:52.079> that

00:36:53

economists have sold themselves to that

00:36:53

economists have sold themselves to that perhaps<00:36:53.440> illustrates<00:36:54.560> maybe<00:36:54.880> how

00:36:55

perhaps illustrates maybe how

00:36:55

perhaps illustrates maybe how short-sighted<00:36:55.520> they're<00:36:55.680> being

00:36:56

short-sighted they're being

00:36:56

short-sighted they're being yeah<00:36:57.280> so<00:36:57.520> we've<00:36:57.760> covered<00:36:58.560> really<00:36:59.280> brilliantly

00:37:00

yeah so we've covered really brilliantly

00:37:00

yeah so we've covered really brilliantly the<00:37:00.560> role<00:37:00.960> that<00:37:01.440> if<00:37:01.599> you<00:37:01.760> only<00:37:02.320> look<00:37:02.480> at<00:37:02.640> it<00:37:02.800> in

00:37:02

the role that if you only look at it in

00:37:02

the role that if you only look at it in terms<00:37:03.280> of<00:37:03.440> monetary

00:37:04

terms of monetary

00:37:04

terms of monetary policy<00:37:05.119> then<00:37:05.359> that's<00:37:05.680> a<00:37:05.760> really<00:37:06.079> big<00:37:06.480> factor

00:37:07

policy then that's a really big factor

00:37:07

policy then that's a really big factor in<00:37:07.440> creating

00:37:07

in creating

00:37:08

in creating this<00:37:08.240> high<00:37:08.480> inequality<00:37:09.359> system<00:37:10.240> could<00:37:10.480> we<00:37:10.640> now

00:37:10

this high inequality system could we now

00:37:10

this high inequality system could we now like<00:37:11.119> come<00:37:11.359> on<00:37:11.440> to<00:37:11.599> talk<00:37:11.920> about<00:37:12.160> what<00:37:12.320> the

00:37:12

like come on to talk about what the

00:37:12

like come on to talk about what the alternative

00:37:13

alternative

00:37:13

alternative is<00:37:13.839> and<00:37:13.920> what<00:37:14.079> the<00:37:14.240> government<00:37:14.880> should<00:37:15.119> be

00:37:15

is and what the government should be

00:37:15

is and what the government should be doing<00:37:15.920> because<00:37:16.320> presumably<00:37:17.040> this<00:37:17.359> means

00:37:17

doing because presumably this means

00:37:17

doing because presumably this means and<00:37:18.000> i<00:37:18.079> think<00:37:18.320> it<00:37:18.400> was<00:37:18.640> implied<00:37:19.040> by<00:37:19.280> what<00:37:19.440> you

00:37:19

and i think it was implied by what you

00:37:19

and i think it was implied by what you said<00:37:20.320> earlier

00:37:21

said earlier

00:37:21

said earlier that<00:37:21.280> the<00:37:21.440> government<00:37:22.000> should<00:37:22.160> be<00:37:22.400> engaging

00:37:23

that the government should be engaging

00:37:23

that the government should be engaging in<00:37:23.680> direct

00:37:24

in direct

00:37:24

in direct job<00:37:25.599> creation<00:37:26.160> in<00:37:26.320> response<00:37:26.800> to<00:37:26.960> the<00:37:27.119> crisis

00:37:27

job creation in response to the crisis

00:37:28

job creation in response to the crisis because<00:37:28.400> you're<00:37:28.720> arguing<00:37:29.200> well<00:37:29.359> look<00:37:29.680> we

00:37:29

because you're arguing well look we

00:37:29

because you're arguing well look we shouldn't<00:37:30.160> really<00:37:30.480> expect

00:37:31

shouldn't really expect

00:37:31

shouldn't really expect the<00:37:31.599> private<00:37:32.079> sector<00:37:33.040> and<00:37:33.359> the<00:37:33.520> very<00:37:33.839> wealthy

00:37:34

the private sector and the very wealthy

00:37:34

the private sector and the very wealthy with<00:37:34.400> all<00:37:34.480> the<00:37:34.640> capital<00:37:35.200> to<00:37:35.359> be<00:37:35.520> investing

00:37:36

with all the capital to be investing

00:37:36

with all the capital to be investing productively<00:37:37.359> at<00:37:37.440> the<00:37:37.520> moment<00:37:38.320> it's<00:37:38.480> going<00:37:38.640> to

00:37:38

productively at the moment it's going to

00:37:38

productively at the moment it's going to be<00:37:39.040> that<00:37:39.200> the<00:37:39.359> government<00:37:39.839> will<00:37:40.079> need

00:37:40

be that the government will need

00:37:40

be that the government will need to<00:37:40.800> take<00:37:41.119> up<00:37:41.359> the<00:37:41.599> slack<00:37:42.400> say<00:37:42.720> is<00:37:42.880> that<00:37:43.200> right

00:37:43

to take up the slack say is that right

00:37:43

to take up the slack say is that right and<00:37:44.240> if<00:37:44.400> it's<00:37:44.640> right<00:37:45.119> how<00:37:45.359> does<00:37:45.520> the

00:37:45

and if it's right how does the

00:37:45

and if it's right how does the government<00:37:46.160> pay<00:37:46.400> for<00:37:46.640> it

00:37:47

government pay for it

00:37:47

government pay for it yeah<00:37:47.680> what<00:37:47.920> i<00:37:47.920> would<00:37:48.079> say<00:37:48.240> first<00:37:48.560> of<00:37:48.640> all<00:37:48.800> is

00:37:49

yeah what i would say first of all is

00:37:49

yeah what i would say first of all is i've<00:37:49.200> spoken<00:37:49.599> quite<00:37:49.760> negatively<00:37:50.240> about

00:37:50

i've spoken quite negatively about

00:37:50

i've spoken quite negatively about monetary<00:37:50.800> policy

00:37:51

monetary policy

00:37:51

monetary policy i<00:37:51.440> just<00:37:51.599> want<00:37:51.680> to<00:37:51.760> be<00:37:51.920> clear<00:37:52.160> i'm<00:37:52.320> not<00:37:52.480> against

00:37:52

i just want to be clear i'm not against

00:37:52

i just want to be clear i'm not against the<00:37:53.040> monetary<00:37:53.440> expansion<00:37:54.000> i<00:37:54.079> don't<00:37:54.320> think<00:37:54.400> the

00:37:54

the monetary expansion i don't think the

00:37:54

the monetary expansion i don't think the monetary<00:37:54.880> expansion<00:37:55.359> is<00:37:55.440> a<00:37:55.520> bad<00:37:55.760> thing<00:37:55.920> in<00:37:56.000> and

00:37:56

monetary expansion is a bad thing in and

00:37:56

monetary expansion is a bad thing in and of<00:37:56.240> itself<00:37:56.560> you<00:37:56.640> know<00:37:56.800> if<00:37:56.880> you<00:37:56.960> go<00:37:57.040> back<00:37:57.200> and

00:37:57

of itself you know if you go back and

00:37:57

of itself you know if you go back and look<00:37:57.440> at<00:37:57.520> the<00:37:57.599> great<00:37:57.839> depression

00:37:58

look at the great depression

00:37:58

look at the great depression back<00:37:58.880> then<00:37:59.040> they<00:37:59.200> didn't<00:37:59.440> expand<00:37:59.760> the

00:37:59

back then they didn't expand the

00:37:59

back then they didn't expand the monetary<00:38:00.240> supply<00:38:00.640> and<00:38:00.720> it<00:38:00.800> was<00:38:01.200> it<00:38:01.280> was

00:38:01

monetary supply and it was it was

00:38:01

monetary supply and it was it was horrendous<00:38:01.920> disaster<00:38:02.480> and

00:38:02

horrendous disaster and

00:38:02

horrendous disaster and probably<00:38:03.920> the<00:38:04.240> money<00:38:04.560> that<00:38:04.640> they've<00:38:04.800> pumped

00:38:05

probably the money that they've pumped

00:38:05

probably the money that they've pumped into<00:38:05.280> their<00:38:05.440> system<00:38:05.920> both<00:38:06.240> now<00:38:06.480> and<00:38:06.640> in<00:38:06.720> 2008

00:38:07

into their system both now and in 2008

00:38:07

into their system both now and in 2008 probably<00:38:08.320> did<00:38:08.560> prevent<00:38:08.960> the<00:38:09.520> kind<00:38:09.680> of

00:38:09

probably did prevent the kind of

00:38:09

probably did prevent the kind of terrible<00:38:10.400> humanitarian<00:38:11.040> disaster<00:38:11.359> that<00:38:11.520> we

00:38:11

terrible humanitarian disaster that we

00:38:11

terrible humanitarian disaster that we saw

00:38:12

saw

00:38:12

saw back<00:38:12.320> in<00:38:12.400> the<00:38:12.480> great<00:38:12.640> depression<00:38:13.440> but<00:38:13.599> it<00:38:13.760> led

00:38:13

back in the great depression but it led

00:38:13

back in the great depression but it led to<00:38:14.079> this<00:38:14.160> huge<00:38:14.400> increase<00:38:14.720> in<00:38:14.800> inequality

00:38:15

to this huge increase in inequality

00:38:15

to this huge increase in inequality and<00:38:16.000> that<00:38:16.240> huge<00:38:16.480> increase<00:38:16.800> in<00:38:16.880> inequality<00:38:17.440> has

00:38:17

and that huge increase in inequality has

00:38:17

and that huge increase in inequality has led<00:38:17.680> to<00:38:17.839> long-term<00:38:18.240> stagnation

00:38:19

led to long-term stagnation

00:38:19

led to long-term stagnation so<00:38:20.320> i<00:38:20.400> don't<00:38:20.560> want<00:38:20.720> to<00:38:20.880> say<00:38:21.040> i'm<00:38:21.119> opposed<00:38:21.440> to

00:38:21

so i don't want to say i'm opposed to

00:38:21

so i don't want to say i'm opposed to monetary<00:38:21.839> policy<00:38:22.160> because<00:38:22.320> i'm<00:38:22.480> not

00:38:22

monetary policy because i'm not

00:38:22

monetary policy because i'm not but<00:38:23.200> we<00:38:23.440> need<00:38:23.680> to<00:38:24.000> then<00:38:24.320> address<00:38:24.720> this

00:38:24

but we need to then address this

00:38:24

but we need to then address this inequality<00:38:25.520> that<00:38:25.680> has<00:38:25.839> been<00:38:26.000> caused

00:38:26

inequality that has been caused

00:38:26

inequality that has been caused because<00:38:26.960> once<00:38:27.200> you<00:38:27.359> then<00:38:27.520> have<00:38:27.680> huge<00:38:27.920> levels

00:38:28

because once you then have huge levels

00:38:28

because once you then have huge levels of<00:38:28.320> inequality<00:38:29.119> then<00:38:29.359> you<00:38:29.520> have<00:38:29.599> the

00:38:29

of inequality then you have the

00:38:29

of inequality then you have the situation<00:38:30.160> where<00:38:30.400> all<00:38:30.480> of<00:38:30.560> the<00:38:30.720> income<00:38:31.040> and

00:38:31

situation where all of the income and

00:38:31

situation where all of the income and all<00:38:31.280> of<00:38:31.359> the<00:38:31.440> wealth<00:38:31.760> is<00:38:31.839> being<00:38:32.000> held<00:38:32.160> by<00:38:32.400> very

00:38:32

all of the wealth is being held by very

00:38:32

all of the wealth is being held by very rich<00:38:32.880> people

00:38:33

rich people

00:38:33

rich people and<00:38:33.520> what<00:38:33.680> we<00:38:33.839> know<00:38:34.000> about<00:38:34.240> very<00:38:34.480> rich<00:38:34.720> people

00:38:35

and what we know about very rich people

00:38:35

and what we know about very rich people is<00:38:35.280> they<00:38:35.520> don't<00:38:35.760> spend<00:38:36.160> a<00:38:36.240> lot<00:38:36.400> of<00:38:36.480> money

00:38:36

is they don't spend a lot of money

00:38:36

is they don't spend a lot of money comparative<00:38:37.520> to<00:38:37.680> how<00:38:37.760> much<00:38:37.920> money<00:38:38.160> they<00:38:38.320> have

00:38:39

comparative to how much money they have

00:38:39

comparative to how much money they have so<00:38:39.200> once<00:38:39.520> all<00:38:39.680> the<00:38:39.760> money<00:38:40.000> gets<00:38:40.240> captured<00:38:40.560> by

00:38:40

so once all the money gets captured by

00:38:40

so once all the money gets captured by the<00:38:40.800> richest

00:38:41

the richest

00:38:41

the richest you<00:38:41.520> end<00:38:41.680> up<00:38:41.760> with<00:38:41.920> this<00:38:42.079> very<00:38:42.320> low<00:38:42.640> demand

00:38:43

you end up with this very low demand

00:38:43

you end up with this very low demand economy<00:38:43.520> because<00:38:44.160> you<00:38:44.240> know<00:38:44.400> it<00:38:44.480> doesn't

00:38:44

economy because you know it doesn't

00:38:44

economy because you know it doesn't matter<00:38:44.960> how

00:38:46

matter how

00:38:46

matter how much<00:38:46.800> money<00:38:47.280> bill<00:38:47.520> gates<00:38:47.760> has<00:38:48.480> if<00:38:48.720> he's<00:38:48.960> a

00:38:49

much money bill gates has if he's a

00:38:49

much money bill gates has if he's a million<00:38:49.359> times<00:38:49.760> richer<00:38:50.079> than<00:38:50.160> an<00:38:50.320> ordinary

00:38:50

million times richer than an ordinary

00:38:50

million times richer than an ordinary person

00:38:51

person

00:38:51

person he's<00:38:51.520> probably<00:38:51.839> more<00:38:52.000> than<00:38:52.160> that<00:38:52.400> times

00:38:52

he's probably more than that times

00:38:52

he's probably more than that times richer<00:38:53.359> he's<00:38:53.599> not<00:38:53.760> gonna

00:38:54

richer he's not gonna

00:38:54

richer he's not gonna he's<00:38:54.720> not<00:38:54.800> gonna<00:38:54.960> eat<00:38:55.200> three<00:38:55.440> million<00:38:55.680> meals<00:38:55.920> a

00:38:55

he's not gonna eat three million meals a

00:38:56

he's not gonna eat three million meals a day<00:38:56.240> he's<00:38:56.480> not<00:38:56.560> gonna<00:38:56.800> spend<00:38:57.040> enough<00:38:57.280> money<00:38:57.440> to

00:38:57

day he's not gonna spend enough money to

00:38:57

day he's not gonna spend enough money to drive<00:38:57.760> the<00:38:57.839> economy

00:38:58

drive the economy

00:38:58

drive the economy so<00:38:58.800> we<00:38:59.040> need<00:38:59.359> to<00:38:59.520> address<00:38:59.839> this<00:39:00.000> inequality

00:39:00

so we need to address this inequality

00:39:00

so we need to address this inequality question<00:39:00.880> so<00:39:01.440> what<00:39:01.599> i<00:39:01.680> would<00:39:01.920> say<00:39:02.160> is

00:39:02

question so what i would say is

00:39:02

question so what i would say is look<00:39:03.359> throw<00:39:03.599> the<00:39:03.680> money<00:39:04.000> in<00:39:04.240> because<00:39:04.400> it's

00:39:04

look throw the money in because it's

00:39:04

look throw the money in because it's helping<00:39:04.880> it's<00:39:05.119> working<00:39:05.440> that<00:39:05.599> has

00:39:05

helping it's working that has

00:39:05

helping it's working that has managed<00:39:06.320> us<00:39:06.400> to<00:39:06.560> get<00:39:07.680> so<00:39:07.920> far<00:39:08.240> in<00:39:08.400> this<00:39:08.560> current

00:39:08

managed us to get so far in this current

00:39:08

managed us to get so far in this current crisis<00:39:09.280> without<00:39:09.599> a<00:39:09.680> disaster

00:39:10

crisis without a disaster

00:39:10

crisis without a disaster but<00:39:11.040> you<00:39:11.200> have<00:39:11.440> to<00:39:11.599> address<00:39:11.839> this<00:39:12.000> inequality

00:39:12

but you have to address this inequality

00:39:12

but you have to address this inequality you<00:39:12.880> have<00:39:13.040> to<00:39:13.200> find<00:39:13.520> a<00:39:13.680> way<00:39:13.839> to<00:39:14.000> address<00:39:14.240> this

00:39:14

you have to find a way to address this

00:39:14

you have to find a way to address this inequality

00:39:15

inequality

00:39:15

inequality and<00:39:15.280> that's<00:39:15.520> why<00:39:15.680> what<00:39:15.839> i've<00:39:16.000> been

00:39:16

and that's why what i've been

00:39:16

and that's why what i've been campaigning<00:39:16.560> for<00:39:16.720> up<00:39:16.800> till<00:39:17.040> now<00:39:17.200> in<00:39:17.280> this

00:39:17

campaigning for up till now in this

00:39:17

campaigning for up till now in this crisis<00:39:17.760> has<00:39:17.839> been<00:39:17.920> a<00:39:18.000> wealth<00:39:18.240> tax

00:39:18

crisis has been a wealth tax

00:39:18

crisis has been a wealth tax and<00:39:18.960> when<00:39:19.119> i<00:39:19.200> say<00:39:19.440> wealth<00:39:19.599> tax<00:39:19.839> i<00:39:19.920> want<00:39:20.000> to<00:39:20.079> make

00:39:20

and when i say wealth tax i want to make

00:39:20

and when i say wealth tax i want to make it<00:39:20.400> clear<00:39:21.200> i'm<00:39:21.359> not<00:39:21.520> talking<00:39:21.839> about

00:39:22

it clear i'm not talking about

00:39:22

it clear i'm not talking about you<00:39:22.720> know<00:39:23.280> doctors<00:39:23.760> and<00:39:23.920> lawyers<00:39:24.400> or<00:39:24.640> nurses

00:39:25

you know doctors and lawyers or nurses

00:39:25

you know doctors and lawyers or nurses and<00:39:25.200> teachers<00:39:25.680> who<00:39:25.760> might<00:39:25.920> be<00:39:26.079> earning<00:39:26.320> higher

00:39:26

and teachers who might be earning higher

00:39:26

and teachers who might be earning higher than<00:39:26.720> average

00:39:27

than average

00:39:27

than average i'm<00:39:27.440> talking<00:39:27.760> about<00:39:28.000> people<00:39:28.320> who<00:39:28.640> own<00:39:29.280> huge

00:39:29

i'm talking about people who own huge

00:39:29

i'm talking about people who own huge amounts<00:39:29.839> of<00:39:30.000> wealth

00:39:30

amounts of wealth

00:39:30

amounts of wealth people<00:39:30.800> who<00:39:30.960> maybe<00:39:31.280> have<00:39:31.440> net<00:39:31.599> wealth<00:39:31.839> of<00:39:32.000> over

00:39:32

people who maybe have net wealth of over

00:39:32

people who maybe have net wealth of over 5<00:39:32.480> million<00:39:33.040> 10<00:39:33.200> million<00:39:33.520> this<00:39:33.680> kind<00:39:33.839> of<00:39:33.920> money

00:39:34

5 million 10 million this kind of money

00:39:34

5 million 10 million this kind of money these<00:39:34.800> guys<00:39:35.040> who<00:39:35.200> are<00:39:35.280> gonna<00:39:35.520> make<00:39:35.839> huge

00:39:36

these guys who are gonna make huge

00:39:36

these guys who are gonna make huge amounts<00:39:36.400> of<00:39:36.400> money<00:39:36.640> in<00:39:36.720> this<00:39:36.960> crisis

00:39:37

amounts of money in this crisis

00:39:37

amounts of money in this crisis just<00:39:37.839> like<00:39:38.000> they<00:39:38.160> did<00:39:38.400> in<00:39:38.480> the<00:39:38.560> last<00:39:38.880> crisis<00:39:39.520> we

00:39:39

just like they did in the last crisis we

00:39:39

just like they did in the last crisis we need<00:39:39.839> to<00:39:39.920> find<00:39:40.160> ways<00:39:40.400> to<00:39:40.480> make<00:39:40.640> these<00:39:40.800> guys

00:39:41

need to find ways to make these guys

00:39:41

need to find ways to make these guys contribute<00:39:41.599> because<00:39:41.839> as<00:39:42.079> it<00:39:42.240> is

00:39:42

contribute because as it is

00:39:42

contribute because as it is they<00:39:42.720> just<00:39:42.880> get<00:39:43.040> richer<00:39:43.359> and<00:39:43.440> richer<00:39:43.760> every

00:39:43

they just get richer and richer every

00:39:44

they just get richer and richer every year<00:39:44.400> they<00:39:44.720> suck<00:39:44.960> the<00:39:45.040> wealth<00:39:45.359> out<00:39:45.520> of<00:39:45.599> the

00:39:45

year they suck the wealth out of the

00:39:45

year they suck the wealth out of the middle<00:39:46.000> class<00:39:46.240> and<00:39:46.320> you<00:39:46.400> can<00:39:46.560> see<00:39:46.800> the

00:39:46

middle class and you can see the

00:39:46

middle class and you can see the shrinking<00:39:47.520> homeownership<00:39:48.160> rates<00:39:48.480> in<00:39:48.640> this

00:39:48

shrinking homeownership rates in this

00:39:48

shrinking homeownership rates in this country

00:39:49

country

00:39:49

country that<00:39:49.599> that<00:39:49.760> wealth<00:39:50.079> is<00:39:50.160> not<00:39:50.320> disappearing

00:39:50

that that wealth is not disappearing

00:39:50

that that wealth is not disappearing it's<00:39:51.040> going<00:39:51.280> up<00:39:51.359> to<00:39:51.520> the<00:39:51.599> very<00:39:51.760> very<00:39:52.000> riches

00:39:52

it's going up to the very very riches

00:39:52

it's going up to the very very riches so<00:39:52.880> i<00:39:52.960> think<00:39:53.200> it's<00:39:53.440> really<00:39:53.680> important<00:39:54.079> that<00:39:54.160> we

00:39:54

so i think it's really important that we

00:39:54

so i think it's really important that we think<00:39:54.960> think<00:39:55.200> about<00:39:55.440> how<00:39:55.599> can<00:39:55.839> we<00:39:55.920> address

00:39:56

think think about how can we address

00:39:56

think think about how can we address this<00:39:56.400> inequality

00:39:57

this inequality

00:39:57

this inequality going<00:39:57.599> forward<00:39:58.240> and<00:39:58.400> for<00:39:58.560> me<00:39:58.800> that<00:39:58.960> has<00:39:59.119> to<00:39:59.280> be

00:39:59

going forward and for me that has to be

00:39:59

going forward and for me that has to be looking<00:39:59.520> at<00:39:59.599> the<00:39:59.680> tax<00:39:59.920> system

00:40:00

looking at the tax system

00:40:00

looking at the tax system my<00:40:00.880> concern<00:40:01.280> is<00:40:01.359> that<00:40:01.440> when<00:40:01.599> we<00:40:01.760> come<00:40:01.920> out<00:40:02.079> of

00:40:02

my concern is that when we come out of

00:40:02

my concern is that when we come out of this<00:40:02.400> people<00:40:02.640> are<00:40:02.720> going<00:40:02.800> to<00:40:02.880> look<00:40:03.119> at<00:40:03.599> how<00:40:03.760> can

00:40:03

this people are going to look at how can

00:40:03

this people are going to look at how can we<00:40:04.079> raise<00:40:04.319> revenues

00:40:05

we raise revenues

00:40:05

we raise revenues and<00:40:05.280> if<00:40:05.440> you<00:40:05.520> look<00:40:05.599> at<00:40:05.680> how<00:40:05.839> to<00:40:05.920> raise<00:40:06.079> revenues

00:40:06

and if you look at how to raise revenues

00:40:06

and if you look at how to raise revenues you're<00:40:06.640> always<00:40:06.800> going<00:40:06.960> to<00:40:07.040> find<00:40:07.280> it's<00:40:07.440> easier

00:40:07

you're always going to find it's easier

00:40:07

you're always going to find it's easier to<00:40:07.920> tax<00:40:08.160> the<00:40:08.240> middle<00:40:08.480> class

00:40:08

to tax the middle class

00:40:08

to tax the middle class and<00:40:09.040> the<00:40:09.200> poor<00:40:09.839> because<00:40:10.079> these<00:40:10.319> guys<00:40:10.480> can't

00:40:10

and the poor because these guys can't

00:40:10

and the poor because these guys can't defend<00:40:10.960> themselves<00:40:11.280> it's<00:40:11.440> difficult<00:40:11.760> to<00:40:11.839> tax

00:40:12

defend themselves it's difficult to tax

00:40:12

defend themselves it's difficult to tax the<00:40:12.160> rich

00:40:12

the rich

00:40:12

the rich but<00:40:12.880> if<00:40:12.960> we<00:40:13.040> do<00:40:13.200> that<00:40:13.359> we're<00:40:13.520> not<00:40:13.599> going<00:40:13.760> to<00:40:13.839> fix

00:40:14

but if we do that we're not going to fix

00:40:14

but if we do that we're not going to fix inequality<00:40:14.560> and<00:40:14.640> we're<00:40:14.720> going<00:40:14.800> to<00:40:14.960> end<00:40:15.119> up

00:40:15

inequality and we're going to end up

00:40:15

inequality and we're going to end up with<00:40:15.359> greater<00:40:15.680> inequality<00:40:16.160> over<00:40:16.319> the<00:40:16.400> long

00:40:16

with greater inequality over the long

00:40:16

with greater inequality over the long term

00:40:17

term

00:40:17

term which<00:40:17.280> is<00:40:17.359> going<00:40:17.440> to<00:40:17.520> lead<00:40:17.760> us<00:40:17.839> to<00:40:18.000> more<00:40:18.160> and

00:40:18

which is going to lead us to more and

00:40:18

which is going to lead us to more and more<00:40:18.480> long-term<00:40:19.280> economic<00:40:19.760> stagnation

00:40:20

more long-term economic stagnation

00:40:20

more long-term economic stagnation so<00:40:20.800> what<00:40:20.960> i'm<00:40:21.040> pushing<00:40:21.280> for<00:40:21.520> at<00:40:21.599> the<00:40:21.680> moment<00:40:22.079> is

00:40:22

so what i'm pushing for at the moment is

00:40:22

so what i'm pushing for at the moment is a<00:40:22.480> wealth<00:40:22.800> tax<00:40:23.200> on<00:40:23.440> very<00:40:23.599> wealthy<00:40:23.920> individuals

00:40:24

a wealth tax on very wealthy individuals

00:40:24

a wealth tax on very wealthy individuals it's<00:40:25.200> not<00:40:25.359> going<00:40:25.440> to<00:40:25.520> be<00:40:25.680> easy<00:40:25.920> to<00:40:26.079> do<00:40:26.319> it<00:40:26.480> needs

00:40:26

it's not going to be easy to do it needs

00:40:26

it's not going to be easy to do it needs to<00:40:26.720> be<00:40:26.880> well<00:40:27.119> planned<00:40:27.520> and<00:40:27.599> well<00:40:27.839> designed

00:40:28

to be well planned and well designed

00:40:28

to be well planned and well designed and<00:40:28.560> it<00:40:28.640> might<00:40:28.800> even<00:40:29.040> require<00:40:29.599> some<00:40:29.839> degree<00:40:30.079> of

00:40:30

and it might even require some degree of

00:40:30

and it might even require some degree of international<00:40:30.720> cooperation

00:40:31

international cooperation

00:40:31

international cooperation now<00:40:31.920> that's<00:40:32.079> not<00:40:32.240> going<00:40:32.319> to<00:40:32.480> be<00:40:32.640> easy<00:40:32.880> but

00:40:33

now that's not going to be easy but

00:40:33

now that's not going to be easy but right<00:40:33.359> now<00:40:33.680> every<00:40:34.000> single<00:40:34.319> country<00:40:34.640> in<00:40:34.720> the

00:40:34

right now every single country in the

00:40:34

right now every single country in the world<00:40:34.960> has<00:40:35.200> the<00:40:35.280> same<00:40:35.520> problem

00:40:36

world has the same problem

00:40:36

world has the same problem so<00:40:36.319> this<00:40:36.560> is<00:40:36.720> an<00:40:36.960> unbelievable<00:40:37.520> opportunity

00:40:38

so this is an unbelievable opportunity

00:40:38

so this is an unbelievable opportunity for<00:40:38.240> us<00:40:38.319> to<00:40:38.480> fix<00:40:38.720> this<00:40:38.880> problem<00:40:39.280> and<00:40:39.440> if<00:40:39.599> we

00:40:39

for us to fix this problem and if we

00:40:39

for us to fix this problem and if we don't<00:40:39.920> fix<00:40:40.240> it

00:40:40

don't fix it

00:40:40

don't fix it it's<00:40:40.880> just<00:40:41.040> going<00:40:41.200> to<00:40:41.280> get<00:40:41.440> worse<00:40:41.839> inequality

00:40:42

it's just going to get worse inequality

00:40:42

it's just going to get worse inequality will<00:40:42.480> get<00:40:42.640> bigger<00:40:42.880> and<00:40:42.960> bigger<00:40:43.520> house<00:40:43.839> prices

00:40:44

will get bigger and bigger house prices

00:40:44

will get bigger and bigger house prices will<00:40:44.240> go<00:40:44.400> up<00:40:44.480> and<00:40:44.640> up<00:40:44.720> and<00:40:44.880> up

00:40:45

will go up and up and up

00:40:45

will go up and up and up and<00:40:45.920> accumulating<00:40:46.720> any<00:40:46.960> sort<00:40:47.200> of<00:40:47.359> financial

00:40:47

and accumulating any sort of financial

00:40:47

and accumulating any sort of financial stability<00:40:48.240> will<00:40:48.400> become<00:40:48.640> increasingly

00:40:49

stability will become increasingly

00:40:49

stability will become increasingly impossible<00:40:49.760> for<00:40:49.920> ordinary<00:40:50.319> people

00:40:50

impossible for ordinary people

00:40:50

impossible for ordinary people so<00:40:51.040> what<00:40:51.280> i'm<00:40:51.359> pushing<00:40:51.599> for<00:40:51.760> at<00:40:51.760> the<00:40:51.839> moment<00:40:52.160> is

00:40:52

so what i'm pushing for at the moment is

00:40:52

so what i'm pushing for at the moment is a<00:40:52.319> wealth<00:40:52.640> tax<00:40:53.359> it's<00:40:53.440> not<00:40:53.599> going<00:40:53.760> to<00:40:53.839> be<00:40:54.000> quick

00:40:54

a wealth tax it's not going to be quick

00:40:54

a wealth tax it's not going to be quick it's<00:40:54.319> not<00:40:54.480> going<00:40:54.560> to<00:40:54.640> be<00:40:54.800> easy<00:40:55.200> but<00:40:55.440> it's<00:40:55.680> i

00:40:55

it's not going to be easy but it's i

00:40:55

it's not going to be easy but it's i think<00:40:56.000> it's<00:40:56.160> vital<00:40:56.480> if<00:40:56.560> you<00:40:56.640> want<00:40:56.800> to<00:40:56.880> avoid

00:40:57

think it's vital if you want to avoid

00:40:57

think it's vital if you want to avoid long-term<00:40:57.839> economic<00:40:58.160> stagnation<00:40:58.720> i'm

00:40:58

long-term economic stagnation i'm

00:40:58

long-term economic stagnation i'm talking<00:40:59.119> about<00:40:59.280> decades

00:41:04

that<00:41:04.960> concludes<00:41:05.520> this<00:41:05.760> episode<00:41:06.240> for<00:41:06.400> those

00:41:06

that concludes this episode for those

00:41:06

that concludes this episode for those listening<00:41:07.119> on<00:41:07.200> the<00:41:07.359> podcast

00:41:08

listening on the podcast

00:41:08

listening on the podcast platforms<00:41:08.880> this<00:41:09.200> podcast<00:41:09.760> was<00:41:09.920> produced<00:41:10.480> as

00:41:10

platforms this podcast was produced as

00:41:10

platforms this podcast was produced as part<00:41:10.960> of<00:41:11.119> a<00:41:11.200> collaboration

00:41:12

part of a collaboration

00:41:12

part of a collaboration with<00:41:12.400> the<00:41:12.480> friedrich<00:41:13.040> herbert<00:41:13.440> stifton<00:41:14.400> for

00:41:14

with the friedrich herbert stifton for

00:41:14

with the friedrich herbert stifton for more<00:41:14.800> information<00:41:15.359> on<00:41:15.520> their<00:41:15.680> work<00:41:16.000> on

00:41:16

more information on their work on

00:41:16

more information on their work on building<00:41:16.640> progressive<00:41:17.200> dialogues<00:41:17.760> between

00:41:18

building progressive dialogues between

00:41:18

building progressive dialogues between germany<00:41:18.640> and<00:41:18.720> britain

00:41:19

germany and britain

00:41:19

germany and britain go<00:41:19.680> to<00:41:20.079> fes<00:41:21.119> hyphen<00:41:22.040> london.org

00:41:23

go to fes hyphen london.org

00:41:23

go to fes hyphen london.org an<00:41:23.760> extended<00:41:24.319> version<00:41:24.720> of<00:41:24.880> this<00:41:25.119> podcast<00:41:25.680> is

00:41:25

an extended version of this podcast is

00:41:25

an extended version of this podcast is available<00:41:26.319> to<00:41:26.560> members<00:41:27.040> of<00:41:27.200> another<00:41:27.599> europe

00:41:27

available to members of another europe

00:41:28

available to members of another europe as<00:41:28.160> possible

00:41:29

as possible

00:41:29

as possible in<00:41:29.359> this<00:41:29.680> week's<00:41:30.000> extra<00:41:30.400> time<00:41:30.960> we<00:41:31.200> asked<00:41:31.520> gary

00:41:31

in this week's extra time we asked gary

00:41:32

in this week's extra time we asked gary for<00:41:32.160> his<00:41:32.400> thoughts<00:41:32.720> on<00:41:32.880> whether<00:41:33.200> the<00:41:33.359> system

00:41:33

for his thoughts on whether the system

00:41:33

for his thoughts on whether the system of<00:41:33.920> global<00:41:34.319> inequality

00:41:35

of global inequality

00:41:35

of global inequality is<00:41:35.680> driving<00:41:36.240> support<00:41:37.119> for<00:41:37.359> political

00:41:37

is driving support for political

00:41:37

is driving support for political nationalism

00:41:39

nationalism

00:41:39

nationalism another<00:41:39.839> europe<00:41:40.160> is<00:41:40.319> the<00:41:40.480> home<00:41:40.880> of<00:41:40.960> the

00:41:41

another europe is the home of the

00:41:41

another europe is the home of the european<00:41:41.760> left<00:41:42.079> in<00:41:42.240> britain

00:41:43

european left in britain

00:41:43

european left in britain to<00:41:43.280> join<00:41:43.599> our<00:41:43.760> people-powered<00:41:44.720> movement<00:41:45.440> go

00:41:45

to join our people-powered movement go

00:41:45

to join our people-powered movement go to<00:41:46.359> anothereurope.org

00:41:47

to anothereurope.org

00:41:47

to anothereurope.org forward<00:41:48.000> slash<00:41:48.640> join

00:41:53

[Music]

00:41:55

[Music]

00:41:55

[Music] you've<00:41:56.079> said<00:41:56.319> that<00:41:56.960> your<00:41:57.200> game<00:41:57.520> is<00:41:57.680> economic

00:41:58

you've said that your game is economic

00:41:58

you've said that your game is economic predictions<00:41:58.880> not<00:41:59.040> political<00:41:59.520> ones

00:42:00

predictions not political ones

00:42:00

predictions not political ones so<00:42:00.560> with<00:42:00.800> that<00:42:01.119> massive<00:42:01.520> caveat<00:42:02.079> aside<00:42:02.960> can<00:42:03.200> i

00:42:03

so with that massive caveat aside can i

00:42:03

so with that massive caveat aside can i take<00:42:03.599> the<00:42:03.760> liberty<00:42:04.240> of<00:42:04.400> asking<00:42:04.800> you

00:42:05

take the liberty of asking you

00:42:05

take the liberty of asking you whether<00:42:05.680> you<00:42:05.839> think<00:42:06.160> that<00:42:06.319> there's<00:42:06.720> a<00:42:06.960> link

00:42:07

whether you think that there's a link

00:42:07

whether you think that there's a link between<00:42:07.760> global<00:42:08.240> inequality<00:42:08.880> and<00:42:08.960> the

00:42:09

between global inequality and the

00:42:09

between global inequality and the economic<00:42:09.680> choices

00:42:10

economic choices

00:42:10

economic choices made<00:42:10.800> since<00:42:11.079> 2008<00:42:12.400> and<00:42:12.720> the<00:42:12.880> type<00:42:13.280> of<00:42:13.520> politics

00:42:14

made since 2008 and the type of politics

00:42:14

made since 2008 and the type of politics we've<00:42:14.960> got<00:42:15.440> since<00:42:15.800> 2008<00:42:17.119> which<00:42:17.520> with<00:42:17.760> a<00:42:17.920> few

00:42:18

we've got since 2008 which with a few

00:42:18

we've got since 2008 which with a few exceptions

00:42:19

exceptions

00:42:19

exceptions here<00:42:20.000> and<00:42:20.160> there<00:42:20.960> does<00:42:21.280> seem<00:42:21.599> to<00:42:21.760> see<00:42:22.400> across

00:42:22

here and there does seem to see across

00:42:22

here and there does seem to see across the<00:42:22.960> globe<00:42:23.359> and<00:42:23.440> it

00:42:23

the globe and it

00:42:23

the globe and it not<00:42:24.079> just<00:42:24.400> in<00:42:24.560> europe<00:42:25.280> the<00:42:25.520> rise<00:42:26.000> of<00:42:26.240> quite

00:42:26

not just in europe the rise of quite

00:42:26

not just in europe the rise of quite nasty<00:42:27.599> strong<00:42:28.079> man<00:42:28.720> and<00:42:28.800> they<00:42:29.040> are<00:42:29.440> men

00:42:30

nasty strong man and they are men

00:42:30

nasty strong man and they are men ethnic<00:42:31.359> nationalists<00:42:32.240> from<00:42:32.480> modi<00:42:32.880> in<00:42:33.040> india

00:42:33

ethnic nationalists from modi in india

00:42:33

ethnic nationalists from modi in india that<00:42:33.520> we<00:42:33.599> did<00:42:33.760> a<00:42:33.920> podcast<00:42:34.640> on

00:42:35

that we did a podcast on

00:42:35

that we did a podcast on to<00:42:35.359> trump<00:42:35.680> in<00:42:35.839> the<00:42:35.920> united<00:42:36.480> states<00:42:37.359> and<00:42:37.839> you

00:42:37

to trump in the united states and you

00:42:37

to trump in the united states and you know<00:42:38.079> trump<00:42:38.480> to<00:42:38.640> use<00:42:38.800> trump<00:42:39.119> as<00:42:39.280> an<00:42:39.440> example<00:42:40.000> i

00:42:40

know trump to use trump as an example i

00:42:40

know trump to use trump as an example i mean<00:42:40.240> he<00:42:40.480> actually

00:42:41

mean he actually

00:42:41

mean he actually i<00:42:41.520> would<00:42:41.760> say<00:42:43.040> didn't<00:42:43.520> answer

00:42:44

i would say didn't answer

00:42:44

i would say didn't answer the<00:42:44.960> conditions<00:42:45.599> that<00:42:45.760> you're<00:42:46.000> talking<00:42:46.240> about

00:42:46

the conditions that you're talking about

00:42:46

the conditions that you're talking about he<00:42:46.640> certainly<00:42:47.040> hasn't<00:42:47.280> proposed<00:42:47.760> anything

00:42:48

he certainly hasn't proposed anything

00:42:48

he certainly hasn't proposed anything that<00:42:48.240> would<00:42:48.400> really<00:42:48.720> address

00:42:49

that would really address

00:42:49

that would really address a<00:42:49.680> global<00:42:50.079> economic<00:42:50.640> inequality<00:42:51.359> and<00:42:51.520> far

00:42:51

a global economic inequality and far

00:42:51

a global economic inequality and far from<00:42:51.920> a<00:42:52.000> wealth<00:42:52.240> tax<00:42:52.640> has<00:42:52.880> cut

00:42:53

from a wealth tax has cut

00:42:53

from a wealth tax has cut a<00:42:53.280> huge<00:42:53.520> tax<00:42:53.839> cuts<00:42:54.079> for<00:42:54.240> the<00:42:54.319> rich<00:42:54.960> but

00:42:55

a huge tax cuts for the rich but

00:42:55

a huge tax cuts for the rich but nonetheless<00:42:55.760> in<00:42:55.839> terms<00:42:56.079> of<00:42:56.160> the

00:42:56

nonetheless in terms of the

00:42:56

nonetheless in terms of the political<00:42:57.440> language<00:42:58.000> he<00:42:58.240> used<00:42:58.720> to<00:42:58.880> take<00:42:59.280> power

00:42:59

political language he used to take power

00:43:00

political language he used to take power back<00:43:00.240> in<00:43:00.520> 2016<00:43:01.839> it<00:43:01.920> was<00:43:02.319> very<00:43:02.800> very

00:43:03

back in 2016 it was very very

00:43:03

back in 2016 it was very very strongly<00:43:03.920> motivated<00:43:04.800> and<00:43:04.960> involved<00:43:05.440> to<00:43:05.599> this

00:43:05

strongly motivated and involved to this

00:43:05

strongly motivated and involved to this kind<00:43:06.160> of

00:43:06

kind of

00:43:06

kind of critique<00:43:07.200> of<00:43:07.400> globalization<00:43:08.480> a<00:43:08.640> system<00:43:09.040> that

00:43:09

critique of globalization a system that

00:43:09

critique of globalization a system that isn't<00:43:09.520> working<00:43:09.920> for<00:43:10.160> people

00:43:10

isn't working for people

00:43:10

isn't working for people and<00:43:10.960> it<00:43:11.119> seems<00:43:11.520> that<00:43:11.520> that<00:43:12.720> argument<00:43:13.599> has<00:43:13.920> been

00:43:14

and it seems that that argument has been

00:43:14

and it seems that that argument has been occupied

00:43:15

occupied

00:43:15

occupied by<00:43:16.560> the<00:43:16.720> far<00:43:17.119> right<00:43:17.599> globally<00:43:18.160> generally

00:43:18

by the far right globally generally

00:43:18

by the far right globally generally and<00:43:18.880> not<00:43:19.119> the<00:43:19.280> left<00:43:19.599> so<00:43:19.839> is<00:43:20.000> there<00:43:20.160> a<00:43:20.319> link

00:43:20

and not the left so is there a link

00:43:20

and not the left so is there a link between<00:43:21.119> this<00:43:21.440> rise<00:43:21.760> of<00:43:21.920> nationalism<00:43:22.560> and

00:43:22

between this rise of nationalism and

00:43:22

between this rise of nationalism and authoritarianism<00:43:23.839> and<00:43:24.000> those<00:43:24.240> economic

00:43:24

authoritarianism and those economic

00:43:24

authoritarianism and those economic choices<00:43:25.280> yeah<00:43:25.520> that's<00:43:25.760> a<00:43:25.839> good<00:43:26.079> question

00:43:26

choices yeah that's a good question

00:43:26

choices yeah that's a good question i<00:43:26.800> mean<00:43:27.040> i'll<00:43:27.280> stress<00:43:27.599> before<00:43:27.839> i<00:43:28.000> answer<00:43:28.240> that

00:43:28

i mean i'll stress before i answer that

00:43:28

i mean i'll stress before i answer that that<00:43:28.560> obviously<00:43:29.280> economics<00:43:29.839> my<00:43:30.000> own

00:43:30

that obviously economics my own

00:43:30

that obviously economics my own expertise

00:43:31

expertise

00:43:31

expertise so<00:43:31.520> politics<00:43:32.480> of<00:43:32.640> course<00:43:32.880> i've<00:43:32.960> got<00:43:33.119> opinions

00:43:33

so politics of course i've got opinions

00:43:33

so politics of course i've got opinions like<00:43:33.680> everyone<00:43:34.000> but<00:43:34.160> you<00:43:34.240> know<00:43:34.400> take<00:43:34.560> what<00:43:34.640> i

00:43:34

like everyone but you know take what i

00:43:34

like everyone but you know take what i say<00:43:34.880> with<00:43:35.040> a<00:43:35.119> pinch<00:43:35.359> of<00:43:35.440> salt

00:43:36

say with a pinch of salt

00:43:36

say with a pinch of salt what<00:43:36.480> i'll<00:43:36.640> say<00:43:36.880> is<00:43:37.760> i<00:43:37.920> come<00:43:38.160> from<00:43:38.640> quite<00:43:38.800> a

00:43:38

what i'll say is i come from quite a

00:43:38

what i'll say is i come from quite a poor<00:43:39.119> background<00:43:39.839> and

00:43:40

poor background and

00:43:40

poor background and i<00:43:40.400> think<00:43:40.560> that<00:43:41.119> people<00:43:41.520> that<00:43:41.839> i<00:43:42.000> grew<00:43:42.240> up<00:43:42.319> with

00:43:43

i think that people that i grew up with

00:43:43

i think that people that i grew up with they<00:43:43.520> feel<00:43:43.680> that<00:43:43.839> things<00:43:44.079> are<00:43:44.160> not<00:43:44.240> getting

00:43:44

they feel that things are not getting

00:43:44

they feel that things are not getting better

00:43:45

better

00:43:45

better they<00:43:45.280> feel<00:43:45.520> things<00:43:45.680> are<00:43:45.760> getting<00:43:46.000> more

00:43:46

they feel things are getting more

00:43:46

they feel things are getting more difficult<00:43:47.359> and<00:43:47.680> i<00:43:47.760> think<00:43:47.920> they<00:43:48.079> feel<00:43:48.319> ignored

00:43:49

difficult and i think they feel ignored

00:43:49

difficult and i think they feel ignored i<00:43:49.119> think<00:43:49.280> they<00:43:49.440> feel<00:43:49.599> that<00:43:49.680> nobody's

00:43:50

i think they feel that nobody's

00:43:50

i think they feel that nobody's listening<00:43:50.720> nobody's<00:43:51.359> addressing

00:43:52

listening nobody's addressing

00:43:52

listening nobody's addressing what's<00:43:52.640> happening<00:43:53.040> to<00:43:53.200> them<00:43:53.440> you<00:43:53.599> know<00:43:53.680> i

00:43:53

what's happening to them you know i

00:43:53

what's happening to them you know i think<00:43:53.839> they<00:43:54.000> just<00:43:54.160> feel<00:43:54.400> like

00:43:55

think they just feel like

00:43:55

think they just feel like it<00:43:55.599> doesn't<00:43:55.920> matter<00:43:56.079> who<00:43:56.240> they<00:43:56.400> vote<00:43:56.720> for

00:43:57

it doesn't matter who they vote for

00:43:57

it doesn't matter who they vote for things<00:43:57.520> don't<00:43:57.760> get

00:43:58

things don't get

00:43:58

things don't get better<00:43:58.880> you<00:43:58.960> know<00:43:59.359> that<00:43:59.520> that's<00:43:59.920> that's<00:44:00.160> the

00:44:00

better you know that that's that's the

00:44:00

better you know that that's that's the sense<00:44:00.560> that<00:44:00.640> i<00:44:00.800> get<00:44:01.040> you<00:44:01.119> know<00:44:01.359> from

00:44:02

sense that i get you know from

00:44:02

sense that i get you know from from<00:44:02.800> people<00:44:03.040> i<00:44:03.119> grew<00:44:03.280> up<00:44:03.359> with<00:44:03.839> people<00:44:04.079> in<00:44:04.160> my

00:44:04

from people i grew up with people in my

00:44:04

from people i grew up with people in my family<00:44:04.960> people<00:44:05.200> i<00:44:05.359> speak<00:44:05.599> to

00:44:06

family people i speak to

00:44:06

family people i speak to i<00:44:06.720> i<00:44:06.880> think<00:44:07.040> a<00:44:07.119> lot<00:44:07.200> of<00:44:07.280> that<00:44:07.440> you<00:44:07.599> know<00:44:07.839> i'm

00:44:07

i i think a lot of that you know i'm

00:44:08

i i think a lot of that you know i'm sure<00:44:08.160> it's<00:44:08.240> not<00:44:08.400> 100<00:44:08.960> economic<00:44:09.359> but<00:44:09.520> i<00:44:09.520> think<00:44:09.680> a

00:44:09

sure it's not 100 economic but i think a

00:44:09

sure it's not 100 economic but i think a lot<00:44:09.839> of<00:44:09.920> that<00:44:10.079> is<00:44:10.160> economic

00:44:10

lot of that is economic

00:44:10

lot of that is economic people<00:44:11.200> just<00:44:11.440> feel<00:44:11.680> you<00:44:11.760> know<00:44:12.000> like<00:44:13.040> you<00:44:13.119> know

00:44:13

people just feel you know like you know

00:44:13

people just feel you know like you know my<00:44:13.599> dad<00:44:13.839> he<00:44:13.920> never<00:44:14.079> went<00:44:14.240> to<00:44:14.400> university<00:44:15.040> you

00:44:15

my dad he never went to university you

00:44:15

my dad he never went to university you know<00:44:15.359> he<00:44:15.440> just<00:44:15.599> worked<00:44:15.839> for<00:44:15.920> the<00:44:16.000> post<00:44:16.240> office

00:44:16

know he just worked for the post office

00:44:16

know he just worked for the post office his<00:44:16.560> whole<00:44:16.800> life<00:44:17.040> but<00:44:17.280> he's<00:44:17.359> got<00:44:17.520> a<00:44:17.599> house<00:44:18.000> he

00:44:18

his whole life but he's got a house he

00:44:18

his whole life but he's got a house he raised

00:44:19

raised

00:44:19

raised three<00:44:19.280> kids<00:44:19.520> on<00:44:19.599> that<00:44:19.760> you<00:44:19.839> know<00:44:20.079> we<00:44:20.560> never<00:44:20.800> had

00:44:20

three kids on that you know we never had

00:44:20

three kids on that you know we never had a<00:44:20.960> lot<00:44:21.040> of<00:44:21.119> money<00:44:21.359> but

00:44:22

a lot of money but

00:44:22

a lot of money but we<00:44:22.800> were<00:44:23.040> we<00:44:23.200> were<00:44:23.359> secure<00:44:24.319> nowadays<00:44:25.040> you'd

00:44:25

we were we were secure nowadays you'd

00:44:25

we were we were secure nowadays you'd struggle<00:44:25.680> to<00:44:25.839> live

00:44:26

struggle to live

00:44:26

struggle to live on<00:44:26.880> you<00:44:27.040> know<00:44:27.520> just<00:44:27.839> going<00:44:28.079> to<00:44:28.160> get<00:44:28.240> a<00:44:28.319> job<00:44:28.480> at<00:44:28.560> a

00:44:28

on you know just going to get a job at a

00:44:28

on you know just going to get a job at a post<00:44:28.880> office<00:44:29.119> you<00:44:29.200> know

00:44:29

post office you know

00:44:29

post office you know with<00:44:29.680> just<00:44:29.839> one<00:44:30.000> parent<00:44:30.319> working<00:44:31.440> so<00:44:31.599> i<00:44:31.680> think

00:44:31

with just one parent working so i think

00:44:31

with just one parent working so i think people<00:44:32.240> feel<00:44:32.400> that<00:44:32.560> things<00:44:32.720> are<00:44:32.880> not<00:44:32.960> getting

00:44:33

people feel that things are not getting

00:44:33

people feel that things are not getting better<00:44:33.359> for<00:44:33.520> them

00:44:33

better for them

00:44:33

better for them and<00:44:34.000> i<00:44:34.079> think<00:44:34.240> people<00:44:34.560> feel<00:44:34.800> that<00:44:35.200> mainstream

00:44:35

and i think people feel that mainstream

00:44:35

and i think people feel that mainstream politicians<00:44:36.160> are<00:44:36.240> not<00:44:36.400> answering<00:44:36.800> that

00:44:36

politicians are not answering that

00:44:36

politicians are not answering that question<00:44:37.359> you<00:44:37.440> know<00:44:37.599> i<00:44:37.680> think<00:44:37.839> they've

00:44:38

question you know i think they've

00:44:38

question you know i think they've they've<00:44:38.319> lost<00:44:38.560> faith<00:44:38.880> in<00:44:38.960> politicians<00:44:39.520> and

00:44:39

they've lost faith in politicians and

00:44:39

they've lost faith in politicians and you<00:44:39.760> know<00:44:40.640> i<00:44:40.720> mean<00:44:40.880> i<00:44:41.119> i've<00:44:41.359> lost<00:44:41.599> faith<00:44:41.839> in

00:44:41

you know i mean i i've lost faith in

00:44:41

you know i mean i i've lost faith in politicians<00:44:42.480> i've<00:44:42.720> lost<00:44:42.880> faith<00:44:43.119> in

00:44:43

politicians i've lost faith in

00:44:43

politicians i've lost faith in economists<00:44:43.920> to<00:44:44.079> be<00:44:44.240> honest<00:44:44.480> you<00:44:44.640> know

00:44:44

economists to be honest you know

00:44:44

economists to be honest you know i<00:44:45.119> mean<00:44:45.280> people<00:44:45.599> also<00:44:46.319> just<00:44:46.480> like<00:44:46.640> i<00:44:46.720> said

00:44:46

i mean people also just like i said

00:44:46

i mean people also just like i said economists<00:44:47.359> have<00:44:47.440> been<00:44:47.680> predicting

00:44:48

economists have been predicting

00:44:48

economists have been predicting the<00:44:48.720> recession<00:44:49.119> would<00:44:49.280> end<00:44:49.440> next<00:44:49.680> year<00:44:50.000> for<00:44:50.160> 12

00:44:50

the recession would end next year for 12

00:44:50

the recession would end next year for 12 years<00:44:51.119> you<00:44:51.200> know

00:44:51

years you know

00:44:51

years you know people<00:44:52.160> hear<00:44:52.319> that<00:44:52.720> they<00:44:52.880> get<00:44:53.119> the<00:44:53.280> idea<00:44:53.599> that

00:44:53

people hear that they get the idea that

00:44:53

people hear that they get the idea that the<00:44:53.839> people<00:44:54.160> in<00:44:54.240> charge<00:44:54.560> have<00:44:54.640> got<00:44:54.720> no<00:44:54.880> idea

00:44:55

the people in charge have got no idea

00:44:55

the people in charge have got no idea what's<00:44:55.200> going<00:44:55.440> on

00:44:55

what's going on

00:44:55

what's going on so<00:44:56.319> if<00:44:56.480> that's<00:44:56.720> what<00:44:56.880> everybody<00:44:57.280> thinks<00:44:58.240> then

00:44:58

so if that's what everybody thinks then

00:44:58

so if that's what everybody thinks then if<00:44:58.560> some<00:44:58.720> new<00:44:58.960> guy<00:44:59.119> turns<00:44:59.440> up<00:44:59.599> and<00:44:59.760> says<00:44:59.920> that

00:45:00

if some new guy turns up and says that

00:45:00

if some new guy turns up and says that i'm<00:45:00.240> one<00:45:00.400> of<00:45:00.560> you

00:45:00

i'm one of you

00:45:00

i'm one of you i'm<00:45:01.119> with<00:45:01.359> you<00:45:01.520> guys<00:45:02.319> i'll<00:45:02.560> lead<00:45:02.800> you<00:45:02.960> out<00:45:03.119> of

00:45:03

i'm with you guys i'll lead you out of

00:45:03

i'm with you guys i'll lead you out of this<00:45:03.920> you<00:45:04.000> know

00:45:04

this you know

00:45:04

this you know and<00:45:04.720> he<00:45:04.800> goes<00:45:04.960> and<00:45:05.119> have<00:45:05.200> a<00:45:05.359> as<00:45:05.520> a<00:45:05.599> point<00:45:05.839> in<00:45:05.920> the

00:45:05

and he goes and have a as a point in the

00:45:06

and he goes and have a as a point in the pub<00:45:06.400> with<00:45:06.640> them

00:45:07

pub with them

00:45:07

pub with them they'll<00:45:07.839> be<00:45:08.000> down<00:45:08.319> because<00:45:09.040> you<00:45:09.119> know<00:45:09.520> they

00:45:10

they'll be down because you know they

00:45:10

they'll be down because you know they these<00:45:10.400> guys<00:45:10.560> need<00:45:10.720> help<00:45:10.880> and<00:45:11.040> they're<00:45:11.119> not

00:45:11

these guys need help and they're not

00:45:11

these guys need help and they're not getting<00:45:11.520> it<00:45:11.680> and<00:45:11.760> they<00:45:11.920> feel<00:45:12.079> that<00:45:12.160> they<00:45:12.319> don't

00:45:12

getting it and they feel that they don't

00:45:12

getting it and they feel that they don't listen<00:45:12.720> to

00:45:13

listen to

00:45:13

listen to so<00:45:13.920> you<00:45:14.079> know<00:45:14.240> like<00:45:14.400> i<00:45:14.480> said<00:45:14.640> i'm<00:45:14.800> not<00:45:14.880> a

00:45:14

so you know like i said i'm not a

00:45:14

so you know like i said i'm not a political<00:45:15.359> expert<00:45:15.920> you<00:45:16.000> know

00:45:16

political expert you know

00:45:16

political expert you know but<00:45:16.720> i<00:45:16.880> think<00:45:17.040> the<00:45:17.200> economic<00:45:17.760> situation<00:45:18.240> for<00:45:18.400> a

00:45:18

but i think the economic situation for a

00:45:18

but i think the economic situation for a lot<00:45:18.560> of<00:45:18.640> people<00:45:18.800> is<00:45:18.960> not<00:45:19.040> good<00:45:19.280> they<00:45:19.440> can't<00:45:19.599> get

00:45:19

lot of people is not good they can't get

00:45:19

lot of people is not good they can't get financial<00:45:20.160> security

00:45:20

financial security

00:45:20

financial security it's<00:45:21.119> not<00:45:21.280> getting<00:45:21.520> better<00:45:22.319> they<00:45:22.480> want

00:45:22

it's not getting better they want

00:45:22

it's not getting better they want answers<00:45:23.359> and

00:45:24

answers and

00:45:24

answers and you<00:45:24.560> know<00:45:24.640> if<00:45:24.720> the<00:45:24.880> mainstream<00:45:25.280> political

00:45:25

you know if the mainstream political

00:45:25

you know if the mainstream political parties<00:45:26.079> are<00:45:26.160> not<00:45:26.319> able<00:45:26.480> to<00:45:26.640> offer<00:45:26.960> it

00:45:27

parties are not able to offer it

00:45:28

parties are not able to offer it then<00:45:28.160> they'll<00:45:28.319> look<00:45:28.480> for<00:45:28.640> alternatives<00:45:29.359> so<00:45:29.520> i

00:45:29

then they'll look for alternatives so i

00:45:29

then they'll look for alternatives so i think<00:45:30.640> all<00:45:30.800> of<00:45:30.960> us

00:45:31

think all of us

00:45:31

think all of us you<00:45:31.359> know<00:45:31.680> especially<00:45:32.079> if<00:45:32.160> we're<00:45:32.319> from<00:45:32.560> more

00:45:32

you know especially if we're from more

00:45:32

you know especially if we're from more privileged<00:45:33.119> financial<00:45:33.520> situations<00:45:34.160> i<00:45:34.240> don't

00:45:34

privileged financial situations i don't

00:45:34

privileged financial situations i don't come<00:45:34.720> from<00:45:34.880> that<00:45:35.040> background<00:45:35.359> but<00:45:35.520> i<00:45:35.599> know<00:45:35.680> i'm

00:45:35

come from that background but i know i'm

00:45:35

come from that background but i know i'm in<00:45:35.920> that<00:45:36.000> situation<00:45:36.480> now

00:45:37

in that situation now

00:45:37

in that situation now we<00:45:37.280> need<00:45:37.359> to<00:45:37.440> take<00:45:37.599> it<00:45:37.680> upon<00:45:38.000> ourselves<00:45:38.400> to

00:45:38

we need to take it upon ourselves to

00:45:38

we need to take it upon ourselves to engage<00:45:39.040> with<00:45:39.200> people<00:45:39.440> who<00:45:39.599> are<00:45:39.680> not<00:45:39.839> as

00:45:39

engage with people who are not as

00:45:40

engage with people who are not as financially<00:45:40.480> secure

00:45:41

financially secure

00:45:41

financially secure and<00:45:41.359> ask<00:45:41.599> them<00:45:41.680> why<00:45:41.839> are<00:45:41.920> you<00:45:42.079> unhappy<00:45:42.480> what's

00:45:42

and ask them why are you unhappy what's

00:45:42

and ask them why are you unhappy what's wrong<00:45:42.880> you<00:45:43.040> know<00:45:43.520> we<00:45:43.680> need<00:45:43.839> to<00:45:43.920> bring<00:45:44.079> them

00:45:44

wrong you know we need to bring them

00:45:44

wrong you know we need to bring them into<00:45:44.400> the<00:45:44.480> political<00:45:44.800> process<00:45:45.200> because<00:45:45.440> if<00:45:45.520> we

00:45:45

into the political process because if we

00:45:45

into the political process because if we don't

00:45:46

don't

00:45:46

don't then<00:45:46.240> they're<00:45:46.480> easy<00:45:46.720> game<00:45:46.960> for<00:45:47.040> anyone<00:45:47.359> who

00:45:47

then they're easy game for anyone who

00:45:47

then they're easy game for anyone who turns<00:45:47.760> up<00:45:48.000> you<00:45:48.079> know<00:45:48.240> and<00:45:48.400> i<00:45:48.480> think<00:45:48.560> that's<00:45:48.720> a

00:45:48

turns up you know and i think that's a

00:45:48

turns up you know and i think that's a little<00:45:48.960> bit<00:45:49.040> what<00:45:49.119> we're<00:45:49.280> seeing

00:45:50

little bit what we're seeing

00:45:50

little bit what we're seeing yeah<00:45:50.319> i<00:45:50.480> completely<00:45:50.960> agree<00:45:51.359> one<00:45:51.520> of<00:45:51.599> the

00:45:51

yeah i completely agree one of the

00:45:51

yeah i completely agree one of the research<00:45:52.160> projects<00:45:52.560> we<00:45:52.720> do<00:45:52.880> at<00:45:53.040> the<00:45:53.119> lsc<00:45:53.680> has

00:45:53

research projects we do at the lsc has

00:45:53

research projects we do at the lsc has been<00:45:54.000> on<00:45:54.160> brexit

00:45:54

been on brexit

00:45:54

been on brexit and<00:45:55.760> quote<00:45:56.160> unquote<00:45:56.640> the<00:45:56.800> left<00:45:57.119> behind<00:45:57.599> places

00:45:58

and quote unquote the left behind places

00:45:58

and quote unquote the left behind places in<00:45:58.319> britain

00:45:58

in britain

00:45:58

in britain i<00:45:59.040> mean<00:45:59.359> interestingly<00:45:59.760> enough<00:46:00.000> where<00:46:00.160> you

00:46:00

i mean interestingly enough where you

00:46:00

i mean interestingly enough where you grew<00:46:00.560> up<00:46:00.720> tower<00:46:01.040> hamlets<00:46:01.599> is<00:46:01.680> not

00:46:01

grew up tower hamlets is not

00:46:02

grew up tower hamlets is not classic<00:46:02.560> center<00:46:03.200> of<00:46:03.839> the<00:46:04.359> stereotype

00:46:05

classic center of the stereotype

00:46:05

classic center of the stereotype of<00:46:05.680> the<00:46:05.839> brexit<00:46:06.560> vote<00:46:06.880> of<00:46:06.960> course<00:46:07.359> you<00:46:07.440> know

00:46:07

of the brexit vote of course you know

00:46:07

of the brexit vote of course you know it's<00:46:07.760> a<00:46:08.240> deprived<00:46:08.880> area

00:46:09

it's a deprived area

00:46:09

it's a deprived area but<00:46:09.680> your<00:46:09.880> stereotypical<00:46:11.040> brexit<00:46:11.680> voting

00:46:12

but your stereotypical brexit voting

00:46:12

but your stereotypical brexit voting area<00:46:13.119> is<00:46:13.280> somewhere<00:46:13.680> like<00:46:14.000> mansfield<00:46:15.119> and

00:46:15

area is somewhere like mansfield and

00:46:15

area is somewhere like mansfield and there

00:46:16

there

00:46:16

there you<00:46:16.319> find<00:46:16.880> a<00:46:17.040> really<00:46:17.440> strong<00:46:17.920> sense<00:46:18.400> that

00:46:18

you find a really strong sense that

00:46:18

you find a really strong sense that we're<00:46:18.800> not<00:46:19.040> being<00:46:19.280> listened<00:46:19.760> to

00:46:20

we're not being listened to

00:46:20

we're not being listened to that<00:46:20.560> the<00:46:20.800> system<00:46:21.200> isn't<00:46:21.520> working<00:46:21.920> for<00:46:22.160> us

00:46:22

that the system isn't working for us

00:46:22

that the system isn't working for us that<00:46:22.960> it<00:46:23.200> in<00:46:23.280> terms<00:46:23.599> of<00:46:23.760> its<00:46:23.920> economic<00:46:24.560> profile

00:46:25

that it in terms of its economic profile

00:46:25

that it in terms of its economic profile it<00:46:25.680> tends<00:46:26.000> to<00:46:26.160> have<00:46:26.960> very<00:46:27.280> low<00:46:27.599> wages

00:46:28

it tends to have very low wages

00:46:28

it tends to have very low wages but<00:46:29.040> fairly<00:46:29.599> reasonably<00:46:30.319> high<00:46:31.040> levels<00:46:31.520> of

00:46:31

but fairly reasonably high levels of

00:46:31

but fairly reasonably high levels of home<00:46:32.000> ownership

00:46:32

home ownership

00:46:32

home ownership and<00:46:33.839> low<00:46:34.079> house<00:46:34.400> prices<00:46:34.960> house<00:46:35.280> prices<00:46:35.760> being

00:46:36

and low house prices house prices being

00:46:36

and low house prices house prices being obviously<00:46:36.560> as<00:46:36.720> you<00:46:36.880> would<00:46:37.119> argue

00:46:37

obviously as you would argue

00:46:37

obviously as you would argue a<00:46:38.000> proxy<00:46:38.480> for<00:46:38.640> whether<00:46:38.880> people<00:46:39.119> want<00:46:39.359> to<00:46:39.440> live

00:46:39

a proxy for whether people want to live

00:46:39

a proxy for whether people want to live there<00:46:39.839> a<00:46:39.920> proxy<00:46:40.240> for<00:46:40.400> demand<00:46:40.960> right

00:46:41

there a proxy for demand right

00:46:41

there a proxy for demand right so<00:46:41.839> you<00:46:42.079> get<00:46:42.240> this<00:46:42.480> profile<00:46:43.040> of<00:46:43.200> quite<00:46:43.520> middle

00:46:43

so you get this profile of quite middle

00:46:43

so you get this profile of quite middle of<00:46:44.000> the<00:46:44.240> road

00:46:45

of the road

00:46:45

of the road towns<00:46:46.480> and<00:46:46.960> there<00:46:47.280> i<00:46:47.359> guess<00:46:47.599> it<00:46:47.760> leads<00:46:48.079> me<00:46:48.319> on

00:46:48

towns and there i guess it leads me on

00:46:48

towns and there i guess it leads me on to<00:46:48.720> an<00:46:48.880> economics<00:46:49.680> question<00:46:50.240> because<00:46:50.560> one<00:46:50.720> of

00:46:50

to an economics question because one of

00:46:50

to an economics question because one of the<00:46:51.040> things<00:46:51.440> that

00:46:52

the things that

00:46:52

the things that you<00:46:52.319> see<00:46:52.560> in<00:46:52.640> mansfield<00:46:53.280> is<00:46:53.440> the<00:46:53.920> the<00:46:54.240> whole

00:46:54

you see in mansfield is the the whole

00:46:54

you see in mansfield is the the whole economy<00:46:55.119> is<00:46:55.280> structured<00:46:55.839> around<00:46:56.160> these

00:46:56

economy is structured around these

00:46:56

economy is structured around these horrendous<00:46:57.280> warehouses

00:46:58

horrendous warehouses

00:46:58

horrendous warehouses sports<00:46:59.119> direct<00:46:59.599> has<00:46:59.839> won<00:47:00.240> infamously<00:47:01.440> where

00:47:01

sports direct has won infamously where

00:47:01

sports direct has won infamously where the<00:47:01.839> labor

00:47:02

the labor

00:47:02

the labor market<00:47:03.040> conditions<00:47:03.680> and<00:47:03.839> labor<00:47:04.240> rights<00:47:04.560> are

00:47:04

market conditions and labor rights are

00:47:04

market conditions and labor rights are just<00:47:04.960> really<00:47:05.440> poor

00:47:05

just really poor

00:47:06

just really poor so<00:47:06.160> one<00:47:06.400> of<00:47:06.480> the<00:47:06.560> things<00:47:06.880> that<00:47:06.960> we've

00:47:07

so one of the things that we've

00:47:07

so one of the things that we've emphasized<00:47:08.000> on<00:47:08.400> in<00:47:08.480> this<00:47:08.720> discussion<00:47:09.280> so<00:47:09.520> far

00:47:09

emphasized on in this discussion so far

00:47:10

emphasized on in this discussion so far is<00:47:10.400> the<00:47:10.640> role<00:47:10.880> of<00:47:10.960> the<00:47:11.200> state<00:47:12.160> in<00:47:12.400> raising

00:47:13

is the role of the state in raising

00:47:13

is the role of the state in raising and<00:47:13.520> re<00:47:13.839> in<00:47:14.000> delivering<00:47:14.480> redistribution<00:47:15.839> i

00:47:15

and re in delivering redistribution i

00:47:16

and re in delivering redistribution i suppose<00:47:16.319> there's<00:47:16.480> another

00:47:17

suppose there's another

00:47:17

suppose there's another way<00:47:17.359> that<00:47:17.599> it<00:47:17.680> could<00:47:17.839> be<00:47:18.000> done<00:47:18.319> and<00:47:18.480> i<00:47:18.560> guess

00:47:18

way that it could be done and i guess

00:47:18

way that it could be done and i guess this<00:47:18.960> is<00:47:19.040> the<00:47:19.280> question<00:47:20.079> it<00:47:20.160> would<00:47:20.480> be<00:47:20.720> raising

00:47:21

this is the question it would be raising

00:47:21

this is the question it would be raising workers<00:47:21.839> rights<00:47:22.319> giving<00:47:22.640> workers<00:47:23.119> more

00:47:23

workers rights giving workers more

00:47:23

workers rights giving workers more rights

00:47:24

rights

00:47:24

rights more<00:47:24.400> access<00:47:24.800> to<00:47:25.040> trade<00:47:25.280> union

00:47:25

more access to trade union

00:47:25

more access to trade union representation

00:47:27

representation

00:47:27

representation stronger<00:47:27.599> trade<00:47:27.920> unions<00:47:28.720> that<00:47:28.960> presumably<00:47:29.599> is

00:47:29

stronger trade unions that presumably is

00:47:29

stronger trade unions that presumably is another<00:47:30.160> way

00:47:30

another way

00:47:30

another way of<00:47:30.880> ensuring<00:47:31.440> that<00:47:31.680> labour<00:47:32.079> has<00:47:32.960> more<00:47:33.200> of<00:47:33.440> a

00:47:33

of ensuring that labour has more of a

00:47:33

of ensuring that labour has more of a stake

00:47:34

stake

00:47:34

stake in<00:47:34.319> this<00:47:34.559> system<00:47:34.960> than<00:47:35.200> it<00:47:35.280> does<00:47:35.520> at<00:47:35.680> the

00:47:35

in this system than it does at the

00:47:35

in this system than it does at the moment<00:47:36.240> vis-a-vis<00:47:36.800> capital

00:47:37

moment vis-a-vis capital

00:47:37

moment vis-a-vis capital yeah<00:47:37.920> i<00:47:38.000> think<00:47:39.119> this<00:47:39.359> is<00:47:39.680> these<00:47:39.920> are<00:47:40.000> all

00:47:40

yeah i think this is these are all

00:47:40

yeah i think this is these are all important<00:47:40.400> things<00:47:40.640> to<00:47:40.720> do<00:47:40.880> you<00:47:40.960> know<00:47:41.119> you<00:47:41.359> need

00:47:41

important things to do you know you need

00:47:41

important things to do you know you need to<00:47:41.680> give<00:47:41.920> people

00:47:42

to give people

00:47:42

to give people ordinary<00:47:43.280> working<00:47:43.520> people<00:47:43.760> more<00:47:43.920> power<00:47:44.400> but

00:47:44

ordinary working people more power but

00:47:44

ordinary working people more power but obviously<00:47:45.359> my<00:47:45.520> focus<00:47:45.839> is<00:47:45.920> always<00:47:46.240> on

00:47:46

obviously my focus is always on

00:47:46

obviously my focus is always on wealth<00:47:46.720> distribution<00:47:47.200> and<00:47:47.280> wealth

00:47:47

wealth distribution and wealth

00:47:47

wealth distribution and wealth inequality<00:47:48.240> so<00:47:49.359> as<00:47:49.520> much<00:47:49.760> as<00:47:49.839> you<00:47:50.000> need<00:47:50.079> to

00:47:50

inequality so as much as you need to

00:47:50

inequality so as much as you need to give<00:47:50.319> these<00:47:50.559> people

00:47:50

give these people

00:47:50

give these people more<00:47:51.440> organizational<00:47:52.079> power<00:47:52.480> i<00:47:52.559> think<00:47:53.359> you

00:47:53

more organizational power i think you

00:47:53

more organizational power i think you also<00:47:53.839> need<00:47:54.079> they<00:47:54.240> also<00:47:54.480> need<00:47:54.640> to<00:47:54.720> get<00:47:54.960> more

00:47:55

also need they also need to get more

00:47:55

also need they also need to get more wealth<00:47:55.599> and<00:47:55.760> more<00:47:56.000> money

00:47:57

wealth and more money

00:47:57

wealth and more money and<00:47:57.200> i<00:47:57.359> don't<00:47:57.520> think<00:47:57.680> we<00:47:57.760> can<00:47:57.920> do<00:47:58.079> that<00:47:58.319> unless

00:47:58

and i don't think we can do that unless

00:47:58

and i don't think we can do that unless we<00:47:58.880> extract<00:47:59.359> some<00:47:59.520> demand<00:47:59.839> from<00:48:00.000> the<00:48:00.079> rich<00:48:00.319> i

00:48:00

we extract some demand from the rich i

00:48:00

we extract some demand from the rich i mean

00:48:00

mean

00:48:00

mean when<00:48:00.880> i<00:48:00.960> think<00:48:01.119> about<00:48:01.280> these<00:48:01.440> areas<00:48:01.760> like

00:48:02

when i think about these areas like

00:48:02

when i think about these areas like mansfield<00:48:02.640> i've<00:48:02.880> never<00:48:03.119> been<00:48:03.280> to<00:48:03.359> manchester

00:48:04

mansfield i've never been to manchester

00:48:04

mansfield i've never been to manchester so<00:48:04.800> but<00:48:05.760> i'll<00:48:05.920> put<00:48:06.079> this<00:48:06.240> on<00:48:06.319> my<00:48:06.480> website<00:48:07.040> um

00:48:07

so but i'll put this on my website um

00:48:07

so but i'll put this on my website um when<00:48:08.000> i<00:48:08.079> talk<00:48:08.240> about<00:48:08.400> the<00:48:08.480> effects<00:48:08.720> of

00:48:08

when i talk about the effects of

00:48:08

when i talk about the effects of inequality<00:48:09.200> on<00:48:09.359> an<00:48:09.440> economy<00:48:09.839> and<00:48:09.920> my<00:48:10.079> website

00:48:10

inequality on an economy and my website

00:48:10

inequality on an economy and my website my<00:48:10.640> website<00:48:10.880> is<00:48:11.079> wealtheconomics.org

00:48:12

my website is wealtheconomics.org

00:48:12

my website is wealtheconomics.org i<00:48:12.640> talk<00:48:12.800> about<00:48:13.040> if<00:48:13.119> you<00:48:13.200> have<00:48:13.280> a<00:48:13.359> very<00:48:13.599> unequal

00:48:13

i talk about if you have a very unequal

00:48:14

i talk about if you have a very unequal economy<00:48:15.040> then<00:48:15.280> all<00:48:15.359> of<00:48:15.520> the<00:48:15.599> wealth<00:48:15.839> is<00:48:15.920> held

00:48:16

economy then all of the wealth is held

00:48:16

economy then all of the wealth is held by<00:48:16.240> a<00:48:16.319> small<00:48:16.640> group

00:48:17

by a small group

00:48:17

by a small group of<00:48:17.680> course<00:48:18.000> all<00:48:18.160> of<00:48:18.240> the<00:48:18.319> jobs<00:48:18.559> are<00:48:18.640> going<00:48:18.800> to

00:48:18

of course all of the jobs are going to

00:48:18

of course all of the jobs are going to be<00:48:18.960> where<00:48:19.119> those<00:48:19.359> people<00:48:19.680> are<00:48:20.400> and<00:48:20.559> if<00:48:20.640> you

00:48:20

be where those people are and if you

00:48:20

be where those people are and if you look<00:48:20.880> at<00:48:20.960> the<00:48:21.119> places

00:48:21

look at the places

00:48:22

look at the places where<00:48:23.119> housing<00:48:23.520> is<00:48:23.680> expensive<00:48:24.240> now<00:48:24.640> it's<00:48:24.800> not

00:48:25

where housing is expensive now it's not

00:48:25

where housing is expensive now it's not just

00:48:25

just

00:48:25

just big<00:48:25.599> cities<00:48:25.920> like<00:48:26.079> london<00:48:26.800> it's<00:48:26.960> also<00:48:27.680> little

00:48:27

big cities like london it's also little

00:48:27

big cities like london it's also little cities<00:48:28.160> like<00:48:28.319> oxford

00:48:28

cities like oxford

00:48:28

cities like oxford and<00:48:28.960> cambridge<00:48:30.079> and<00:48:30.640> ski<00:48:30.880> villages<00:48:31.440> but

00:48:31

and cambridge and ski villages but

00:48:31

and cambridge and ski villages but what<00:48:32.079> do<00:48:32.240> these<00:48:32.559> places<00:48:32.880> have<00:48:33.040> in<00:48:33.119> common<00:48:33.680> it's

00:48:33

what do these places have in common it's

00:48:33

what do these places have in common it's where<00:48:34.160> rich<00:48:34.400> people<00:48:34.800> spend<00:48:35.040> their<00:48:35.280> time

00:48:35

where rich people spend their time

00:48:35

where rich people spend their time the<00:48:36.000> place<00:48:36.240> where<00:48:36.400> rich<00:48:36.640> people<00:48:36.960> study<00:48:37.280> are

00:48:37

the place where rich people study are

00:48:37

the place where rich people study are expensive<00:48:38.000> the<00:48:38.160> place<00:48:38.400> where<00:48:38.640> rich<00:48:38.800> people<00:48:38.960> go

00:48:39

expensive the place where rich people go

00:48:39

expensive the place where rich people go on<00:48:39.200> holiday<00:48:39.599> are<00:48:39.760> expensive

00:48:40

on holiday are expensive

00:48:40

on holiday are expensive because<00:48:40.720> if<00:48:40.800> you<00:48:40.880> give<00:48:41.119> all<00:48:41.200> of<00:48:41.359> the<00:48:41.440> money<00:48:41.680> to

00:48:41

because if you give all of the money to

00:48:41

because if you give all of the money to rich<00:48:42.079> people<00:48:42.720> then<00:48:42.960> ordinary<00:48:43.440> people<00:48:43.680> can

00:48:43

rich people then ordinary people can

00:48:43

rich people then ordinary people can only<00:48:44.079> get<00:48:44.240> a<00:48:44.319> job

00:48:44

only get a job

00:48:44

only get a job if<00:48:44.880> they're<00:48:45.119> near<00:48:45.280> the<00:48:45.440> rich<00:48:45.680> people<00:48:45.920> if<00:48:46.079> they

00:48:46

if they're near the rich people if they

00:48:46

if they're near the rich people if they can<00:48:46.319> serve<00:48:46.559> the<00:48:46.640> rich<00:48:46.800> people<00:48:47.119> somehow<00:48:47.520> so<00:48:47.760> it

00:48:48

can serve the rich people somehow so it

00:48:48

can serve the rich people somehow so it obviously<00:48:48.559> leads<00:48:48.880> to<00:48:49.040> a<00:48:49.119> situation

00:48:50

obviously leads to a situation

00:48:50

obviously leads to a situation where<00:48:50.880> you<00:48:51.200> gut<00:48:51.440> the<00:48:51.599> rest<00:48:51.760> of<00:48:51.920> the<00:48:52.000> country

00:48:53

where you gut the rest of the country

00:48:53

where you gut the rest of the country because<00:48:53.440> you<00:48:53.520> know<00:48:53.680> rich<00:48:53.920> people

00:48:54

because you know rich people

00:48:54

because you know rich people they<00:48:55.040> probably<00:48:55.359> don't<00:48:55.520> spend<00:48:55.760> time<00:48:56.000> in

00:48:56

they probably don't spend time in

00:48:56

they probably don't spend time in mansfield<00:48:56.559> nothing<00:48:56.880> against<00:48:57.200> mansfield<00:48:57.680> but

00:48:58

mansfield nothing against mansfield but

00:48:58

mansfield nothing against mansfield but they<00:48:58.240> probably<00:48:58.559> don't<00:48:58.960> right<00:48:59.839> and<00:49:00.240> you<00:49:00.319> know

00:49:00

they probably don't right and you know

00:49:00

they probably don't right and you know if<00:49:00.640> you<00:49:00.720> don't<00:49:00.880> redistribute<00:49:01.440> wealth

00:49:02

if you don't redistribute wealth

00:49:02

if you don't redistribute wealth then<00:49:02.400> you<00:49:02.559> will<00:49:02.720> have<00:49:02.960> a<00:49:03.119> very<00:49:03.440> geographically

00:49:04

then you will have a very geographically

00:49:04

then you will have a very geographically concentrated<00:49:04.640> economy<00:49:05.119> if<00:49:05.200> you<00:49:05.280> concentrate

00:49:05

concentrated economy if you concentrate

00:49:05

concentrated economy if you concentrate the<00:49:05.839> wealth<00:49:06.079> you<00:49:06.160> will<00:49:06.240> concentrate<00:49:06.640> the

00:49:06

the wealth you will concentrate the

00:49:06

the wealth you will concentrate the activity<00:49:07.119> geographically<00:49:07.760> as<00:49:07.839> well

00:49:08

activity geographically as well

00:49:08

activity geographically as well so<00:49:09.280> i'm<00:49:09.440> not<00:49:09.599> an<00:49:09.680> expert<00:49:09.920> on<00:49:10.000> workers<00:49:10.319> rights

00:49:10

so i'm not an expert on workers rights

00:49:10

so i'm not an expert on workers rights and<00:49:10.640> unions<00:49:11.200> so<00:49:11.359> i<00:49:11.440> don't<00:49:11.599> want<00:49:11.680> to

00:49:12

and unions so i don't want to

00:49:12

and unions so i don't want to say<00:49:12.400> too<00:49:12.559> much<00:49:12.800> on<00:49:13.280> lots<00:49:13.440> of<00:49:13.520> people<00:49:13.760> i'm<00:49:13.839> sure

00:49:14

say too much on lots of people i'm sure

00:49:14

say too much on lots of people i'm sure have<00:49:14.319> more<00:49:14.559> informed<00:49:14.880> opinions<00:49:15.200> than<00:49:15.359> me<00:49:15.839> but

00:49:15

have more informed opinions than me but

00:49:16

have more informed opinions than me but what<00:49:16.160> i<00:49:16.240> want<00:49:16.319> to<00:49:16.400> say<00:49:16.640> is

00:49:17

what i want to say is

00:49:17

what i want to say is it's<00:49:18.000> important<00:49:18.319> that<00:49:18.480> we<00:49:18.720> protect<00:49:19.119> the

00:49:19

it's important that we protect the

00:49:19

it's important that we protect the wealth<00:49:19.680> of<00:49:19.839> people<00:49:20.160> as<00:49:20.240> well

00:49:20

wealth of people as well

00:49:20

wealth of people as well their<00:49:21.040> ability<00:49:21.359> to<00:49:21.520> own<00:49:22.000> assets<00:49:22.319> the<00:49:22.480> ability

00:49:22

their ability to own assets the ability

00:49:22

their ability to own assets the ability to<00:49:22.880> own<00:49:23.119> houses<00:49:23.599> because

00:49:24

to own houses because

00:49:24

to own houses because people<00:49:24.640> are<00:49:24.720> losing<00:49:25.040> that<00:49:25.200> right<00:49:25.359> now<00:49:25.440> and<00:49:25.520> i

00:49:25

people are losing that right now and i

00:49:25

people are losing that right now and i don't<00:49:25.680> want<00:49:25.760> to<00:49:25.839> lose<00:49:26.000> sight<00:49:26.160> of<00:49:26.319> that<00:49:26.480> and<00:49:26.640> if

00:49:26

don't want to lose sight of that and if

00:49:26

don't want to lose sight of that and if we<00:49:26.880> have<00:49:27.040> a<00:49:27.119> more<00:49:27.280> equal<00:49:27.520> distribution

00:49:28

we have a more equal distribution

00:49:28

we have a more equal distribution then<00:49:28.720> the<00:49:28.800> people<00:49:29.119> in<00:49:29.200> mansfield<00:49:29.680> can<00:49:29.839> work

00:49:29

then the people in mansfield can work

00:49:30

then the people in mansfield can work for<00:49:30.160> each<00:49:30.400> other<00:49:31.040> and<00:49:31.119> they<00:49:31.280> can<00:49:31.440> pay<00:49:31.599> each

00:49:31

for each other and they can pay each

00:49:31

for each other and they can pay each other<00:49:31.920> and<00:49:32.079> they<00:49:32.160> can<00:49:32.319> get<00:49:32.559> good<00:49:32.800> wages<00:49:33.200> like

00:49:33

other and they can get good wages like

00:49:33

other and they can get good wages like that

00:49:34

that

00:49:34

that but<00:49:34.240> if<00:49:34.319> we<00:49:34.480> give<00:49:34.640> all<00:49:34.800> the<00:49:34.880> money<00:49:35.200> to<00:49:35.359> you<00:49:35.440> know

00:49:35

but if we give all the money to you know

00:49:35

but if we give all the money to you know 100<00:49:35.920> families<00:49:36.319> in<00:49:36.400> london<00:49:36.880> it's<00:49:37.040> always<00:49:37.280> going

00:49:37

100 families in london it's always going

00:49:37

100 families in london it's always going to<00:49:37.440> be<00:49:37.520> difficult<00:49:37.839> for<00:49:38.000> them<00:49:38.160> people

00:49:38

to be difficult for them people

00:49:38

to be difficult for them people in<00:49:39.280> in<00:49:39.440> all<00:49:39.520> the<00:49:39.599> rest<00:49:39.760> of<00:49:39.839> the<00:49:39.920> country<00:49:40.240> to

00:49:40

in in all the rest of the country to

00:49:40

in in all the rest of the country to find<00:49:40.559> good<00:49:42.839> work

00:49:47

[Music]

00:49:59

you