← Back to all transcripts

How Rich is Rich?

September 04, 2022
00:00:01

all right so i want to talk about one of the most common questions we get on the channel  

00:00:07

which is: What is rich?

00:00:16

we get asked this a lot um and uh i think to be  honest often when people ask this the question  

00:00:21

they're really asking is do you want to tax me?  because obviously we talk on the channel a lot  

00:00:25

about we need to tax the rich more, we need to  tax the rich more and people are basically worried  

00:00:29

that it's going to be them that pays more tax so i  think the best way to answer this is basically to  

00:00:35

give a kind of accurate description of the wealth  distribution in this country and sort of where we   

00:00:42

are as a country um yeah with regards to wealth  and how it's distributed um the first point is  

00:00:47

to make you know whenever i talk about taxing  the rich i'm always talking about high wealth  

00:00:52

individuals & high wealth families it's not about   high income individuals or high income families  

00:00:57

who may not be necessarily high wealth um and i think  that's important because we live in a country now  

00:01:03

where housing is very very expensive and that  means that you could be high income you could be  

00:01:10

you know a banker like i was or you could be a  lawyer or you could have you know you could work  

00:01:15

in some industry making 70-80 grand a year which  is which is much higher than the national average  

00:01:19

um and still be actually struggling to  afford a home things like this um and  

00:01:26

i'm not at all looking to tax people you know  what i want to create here is a is a country  

00:01:31

and a world in which ordinary people can get  jobs work hard get paid have nice properties  

00:01:39

have nice lives afford families comfortably um  so when i talk about taxing the rich it's about  

00:01:45

high wealth families high wealth  individuals okay it's not about  

00:01:48

high income individuals who are not high  wealth you know i think it's i think i mean  

00:01:52

if you consider the situation we're in right now  you know i'm i'm not crazy rich and we'll get into  

00:01:57

that but i earnt a lot of money in a short amount  of time and i paid 50% tax on everything i made um  

00:02:03

which was you know a few million pounds um whereas  at the same time the Duke of Westminster earnt  

00:02:10

inherited i think £9,000,000,000 & paid nothing  so we currently live in a system where

00:02:18

people from poor and ordinary backgrounds who  earn decent amounts of money pay very high tax but  

00:02:24

people from very very rich backgrounds can earn  unbelievable crazy amounts of money it's important  

00:02:30

to realize you know this guy made more than a  thousand times what i made and paid less tax  

00:02:34

than me it's pretty crazy right and when you look  at it like that you have to kind of accept that  

00:02:39

we actually have quite basically a class-based tax  system whereas people from my sort of background  

00:02:44

my sort of voice and you know you don't need to  be from London you could be from wherever Glasgow  

00:02:49

or Manchester or Birmingham you know people  from ordinary backgrounds who earn high incomes  

00:02:55

sometimes not even crazy high incomes pay 50  percent but people from very wealthy backgrounds  

00:02:59

can earn billions and pay nothing so we currently  have a system where we're already taxing  

00:03:05

earners but we're not actually taxing these  very wealthy families in many cases at all  

00:03:10

so when i say tax the rich i'm talking about  very very wealthy families but then that still  

00:03:15

leaves us the question of how wealthy is  wealthy okay so the first thing to say is  

00:03:22

this country the uk is actually it has  a reputation as a very unequal country  

00:03:26

but if you look you know from an  international or a historical perspective  

00:03:31

it's not a massively unequal country compared  to where a lot of countries are or or even  

00:03:34

where this country has been in the past so this  country still has a relatively high percentage of  

00:03:42

people or families who own their own home you  know i think that owner occupied percentage is  

00:03:46

something like 78% um and that that's not the case  in a lot of countries right and it wasn't the case  

00:03:50

in this country 100 years ago so what that means  is a lot of people or families do own property  

00:03:56

some somewhere in the family it might not be  you it might be your husband it might be your  

00:04:01

uh your father you know i mean but a lot of  families own property um and that means that  

00:04:07

wealth inequality in this country is not  terribly bad you know if you go to a place like  

00:04:12

India which is very high inequality or  Russia which has very high inequality  

00:04:15

you'll see that ordinary families  often really struggle to own like  

00:04:18

decent properties whereas in this country  there is a lot of property owning people um

00:04:26

but what is happening is increasingly fewer  and fewer people are able to own property  

00:04:31

and especially if you look at younger  generations when it comes to owning property like  

00:04:34

they need to take really  really really big mortgages  

00:04:39

so what that means is generationally  ordinary families are losing wealth um

00:04:48

and then there's a question of where is that wealth going so when we talk about rich

00:04:51

what is rich? so to be in the top 1% of richest

00:04:57

people in this country you need  about three and a half million pounds  

00:05:01

which is this is quite a lot of money i think you  know three and a half million pounds is a lot um

00:05:08

but one percent of people in this country do  have more than three and a half million pounds um  

00:05:13

so really you know often i suggest okay let's tax  people above that level three and a half million  

00:05:18

pounds um but i think actually the most important  thing is that you hit the people at the very top

00:05:28

and the reason i say that is if you bring in a tax  that effectively taxes people who are three and  

00:05:32

a half million pounds and three and a half million  pounds a lot of money you know if you're worth  

00:05:35

three enough million pounds you can afford to pay  more tax um but if you hit those people but  

00:05:40

you don't hit say the Rishi Sunak, who is worth  apparently about 700 million pounds and his father  

00:05:45

knows worth billions um if you tax people worth  three and a half million pounds and you don't  

00:05:51

tax people are worth 700 million pounds then  ultimately that wealth which is currently held  

00:05:57

by the three and a half million pound families  will end up being owned by Rishi Sunak and then  

00:06:01

other people of that level of wealth you know so i  think really i'm i didn't come into this game as a  

00:06:11

with really a moral ethical perspective i'm an  economist and um what i see is is an economy  

00:06:17

where wealth is draining away from this you know we  we have a middle class in this country we have a  

00:06:22

group of people sort of a middle 50% of people who  can live a comfortable ish life and can accumulate  

00:06:28

assets but it's shrinking and their wealth is  moving to the super rich and i i see this economy  

00:06:33

and i say okay well if that keeps happening  it's inevitable basically they'll be growing  

00:06:37

poverty basically and that's not a good thing and  it's the direction of travel is important right  

00:06:43

so if you don't do anything to reverse that then  what you will see is this middle class and you  

00:06:49

know this might be a lot of people watching who  they own their own property, you know if it's in  

00:06:54

London they're probably like worth a million  pounds you know and maybe they don't have a  

00:06:57

massive mortgage on it or maybe they do a mortgage  on it so there's a lot of people in London who  

00:07:00

might be worth 500 - 700,000 pounds because  their property values have gone up um these  

00:07:07

people will be squeezed out over time and the  way they'll be squeezed out is essentially that

00:07:14

the rich will use their enormous incomes to  buy assets from them um and i think there's  

00:07:19

this problem where increasingly because house  prices are so high people who are not actually  

00:07:24

rich they don't live lives of luxury think of  themselves as rich because they look at their  

00:07:29

net asset their net worth and it's like it could  be a million pounds they could be a millionaire  

00:07:33

right um and don't get me wrong you know you  know if you do have a net worth a million pounds  

00:07:37

you're in the top two percent of the country you  know i mean you are well richer than average um  

00:07:43

but because house prices are going up and up  and up and up and up the only way to access  

00:07:47

that money is to sell your house and i think we're  increasingly seeing this interesting dynamic for  

00:07:53

ordinary families where they feel rich because  their house is worth a lot of money but there's  

00:07:56

no way for them to ever access that money so then  they end up panicking that if i say tax the rich  

00:08:04

i mean tax them but the reality of this situation  is if we don't tax the rich they will get your  

00:08:09

house in the end you know they will get your  house in the end and they'll push the price up  

00:08:12

and up and up and up and up but eventually we'll  not be able to compete with it um so yeah look  

00:08:19

i personally where do i sit in all this you  know i'm i'm probably not in that one percent  

00:08:24

i'm probably not worth three and a half million  pounds you know i don't see it i don't have a  

00:08:27

spreadsheet or anything you know what i mean  um but i would be willing to pay more tax if  

00:08:33

the richest paid it as well you need to hit the  top you know and i've said it before in the news  

00:08:37

i'll pay if Rishi Sunak pays it but um if you don't hit  these super rich then they will use their enormous  

00:08:44

incomes to buy your assets and that is what you're  seeing they'll squeeze you out what we're seeing  

00:08:49

increasingly is the middle class being squeezed  out now i know and i want you to think if you if  

00:08:52

you own a million pound house even if you're  in a 600,000 pound house i want you to think  

00:08:56

what are your kids going to do how are they on you  know regular income is 30-40,000 pounds you know  

00:09:03

how are they going to buy a house when houses  cost 600 000 pounds you know what i mean are they  

00:09:06

all going to live in your house forever you know  you know this is the situation we are in is that  

00:09:14

ordinary people in this country ordinary families  who do have wealth are losing their wealth year  

00:09:20

after year generation after generation to the  rich and if that is allowed to continue and and  

00:09:25

then they are paying higher rates of tax than  the rich do if that is allowed to continue then it  

00:09:29

is inevitable that we will see broad increase and  we will eventually reach a place of mass poverty  

00:09:33

in this country which we within 100 years ago  and you know you know go to India go to Russia  

00:09:38

and look at what really unequal economies look  like they are economies where ordinary families  

00:09:44

live very very difficult lives and  can't own property and if you think  

00:09:48

it can't happen here well it happened here  it was like that here 100 years ago and um

00:09:55

you need to look at the direction of travel of  wealth are ordinary people getting richer or are  

00:09:59

ordinary people getting poorer are the super rich getting richer or the super rich is getting poorer & 

00:10:03

at the moment we live in a time where ordinary  people are very rapidly losing their wealth  

00:10:09

and the rich are very rapidly getting it and you  need to look into the future and say where does  

00:10:12

that lead us as a country where does that leave  my family where does that leave my community  

00:10:15

and um you know we're going to talk  about different ways that that could be  

00:10:20

addressed um i've got some ideas about ways we  can do it to sort of address that balance but  

00:10:26

ultimately if you allow wealth to flow from if you  want our wealth to flow from ordinary families to  

00:10:31

the rich and you have no mechanism to get wealth  back from the rich to ordinary families then it will  

00:10:36

lead to a country of mass poverty and and you  know i've been betting on that happening for 15  

00:10:43

years and i've had millions of pounds doing it  um and i think increasingly it's becoming obvious  

00:10:48

that that's the direction we're going right you  know half the country won't be able to heat their  

00:10:51

homes this winter in 10 years time that would be  70% in 20 years time it will be nearly everyone you  

00:10:56

know that's that that is that is what happens if  you allow the people of a country to have all of  

00:11:02

their assets taken away from them you know you  need assets you need homes you need food and  

00:11:08

if you don't own anything it's going to be very  difficult to get that stuff so um you know i look  

00:11:15

at the world distribution and i look at the travel  of it and and and it leads me to see a very bleak  

00:11:19

future and and the way to push back into that  is tax the super rich and who is rich to be honest  

00:11:26

Rishi Sunak is rich he's worth £700,000,000  listen i'll pay it if he pays it and you know  

00:11:34

i don't want any situation where people who are  not rich are paying *HIGHER* rates of taxes people  

00:11:39

who are really really [ __ ] rich and that's the  world we live in right now you know and i know  

00:11:44

i've made a lot of money and i'm super grateful  but i'm not super rich i don't live a life of luxury  

00:11:49

but i paid 50% everything i earned and there's  billionaires in this country who don't pay that  

00:11:53

there's billionaires in this country  who paid less than me there's billions  

00:11:55

in this country that have paid less  than the people watching this video  

00:11:59

and you know if that's the situation that  we have if that's the world that we live in  

00:12:05

um yeah the future is going to be very dark indeed  but but we can push back and that's what i'm  

00:12:10

trying to do so uh so yeah i would just encourage  people to say look i'm not after i'm not after you  

00:12:14

i'm not after houses um you know i'm a relatively  sort of comfortably wealthy person myself um

00:12:23

but i see the direction of traveling on  me to change it so um i support it and i  

00:12:26

hope other people do too so yeah tax the rich, the really rich (good?)

00:12:38

housing could be so much more affordable wages  could be so much higher and we could have so  

00:12:42

many more options in how we live our lives some  of them put a lot of money into paying economists  

00:12:46

and think tanks to tell you that inequality  is important for the economy that is not true