← Back to all transcripts

How COVID-19 MAKES the Rich Richer - Gary EXPLAINS the theory

July 14, 2020
economics Cash coronavirus wealth tax covid rich get richer Covid-19 Gary Stevenson QE Quantitative Easing Income Inequality Wealth Inequality Inequality Money Coronavirus GarysEconomics garys Gary's Economics
00:00:00

This video is about Coronavirus and money. Now this is a really important

00:00:06

video, I've been wanting to make it for a long time, because huge, huge, historic things

00:00:10

are happening in the world of money here. Even when I was working as a money trader in

00:00:13

the 2008 crisis nothing ever happened of this speed. Now what's happening in the world

00:00:18

of money here is going to dominate the economy for the next few years

00:00:21

quite possibly even the next few decades. It's going to affect you it's going to affect

00:00:26

your family's financial position, so if you want to understand what's going to

00:00:29

happen in the economy going forward, you've got to watch this video.

00:00:32

Now so far in this crisis, most workers have had their incomes relatively protected. in this country the

00:00:36

In this country, the UK, most workers are still working and getting their regular incomes,

00:00:40

of those who can't work the majority are being supported by government furlough

00:00:43

and self-employment schemes. Now, as many as five and a half million

00:00:47

workers are falling through the gaps of those schemes and are getting almost no

00:00:49

income support. Now those guys already are feeling the pain of this financial crisis,

00:00:53

but what we're going to explain in this video is how even if your income is

00:00:56

being supported, the changes in the world of money, behind the scenes, are

00:01:00

going to affect your financial position going forward. Now we're going to explain how.

00:01:04

Now the biggest changes have been happening in the world of government and central banks,

00:01:07

now this is happening all over the world, but in the UK the central bank, the

00:01:11

Bank of England, has committed to printing 300 billion pounds,

00:01:15

300 billion pounds, it's an enormous amount of money, it's £4,500 for

00:01:19

every single man, woman and child in the country. It's more than three times the

00:01:24

net worth of Jeff Bezos, the world's richest man. Now when such a huge amount

00:01:28

of money gets printed and put into the economy, it's really important you

00:01:31

understand three things about it:

00:01:33

1. How does it work? So we are going to talk about exactly what money printing is.

00:01:37

2. Where does the money go?

00:01:39

3. Where does the money end up.

00:01:42

Now those last two things they may sound similar

00:01:44

but they're actually crucially different, and we're going to explain why.

00:01:47

Okay so number one, how does this new money work. So I think a lot of people are confused by the

00:01:52

concept of money printing. It's important to understand that this 300 billion

00:01:55

pound is brand-new money created by the central bank. Now if that's confusing to you,

00:02:00

you just need to understand that the central bank has the legal right to

00:02:03

print or create brand-new money. Now we say "print money" to give the visual idea

00:02:10

of a printing press printing out new banknotes, but in reality nowadays

00:02:13

most money is electronic, so what that means in practice is that the Bank

00:02:17

of England is allowed to simply credit its own account with new money.

00:02:21

Okay, so this is brand new money, it doesn't come from anyone, it's not raised through taxes

00:02:25

it's simply created by the Bank of England. When that money gets poured into

00:02:29

the system we need to understand who's gonna get it, and the next question: where

00:02:34

does it go? Now most of this money is getting lent from the Bank of England

00:02:38

to the government. Now even though this is brand-newly created money, and the

00:02:42

Bank of England is a government institution, the government still has to

00:02:45

borrow it from the Bank of England. This creates a debt which legally the

00:02:49

government has to pay back. For this reason government debt has increased

00:02:53

hugely already in this crisis and just recently UK government debt has gone

00:02:57

above 100% of GDP for the first time in over 50 years. So what does the

00:03:03

government then do with this money. Well the government gives most of it to

00:03:06

furloughed workers and other workers who can't get their income during the Coronavirus crisis

00:03:10

This brings us to part three: where does the money end up?

00:03:13

now we know the money is being paid to furloughed workers. But if we look at

00:03:17

the actual situation of furloughed workers, they're actually receiving less

00:03:20

income than they were before the crisis happened. This is because, even though

00:03:25

they're receiving government income support

00:03:26

it's only 80 percent of their original wages and their original wages are no

00:03:31

longer coming in. So this creates a mystery. We know that a lot of new money

00:03:35

is coming into the economy, and we know that ultimately it's going to the furloughed

00:03:39

workers, but the furloughed workers are no richer than they were before. So

00:03:43

where's the money going? that brings us to question number three

00:03:47

Where does the money end up? Now we know the money is being paid to the furloughed

00:03:51

workers. But the furloughed workers have less money than they had before the

00:03:55

Coronavirus crisis, because they've lost the wages that they were originally

00:03:58

being paid. If we want to know who ends up with the money we need to find out

00:04:02

who has those wages? Where have the wages gone that used to be paid to the workers?

00:04:08

So if you want to understand we have to follow this cash flow back through the system

00:04:12

Now, normally wages get paid to the workers through the companies. But if we look

00:04:18

at the companies, we will find that most of these companies are struggling as well

00:04:21

because customers have simply stopped coming to their stores and stopped

00:04:24

buying this stuff. So we need to follow the cash flow back

00:04:27

one step further, to the customers. Now the customers in this crisis have

00:04:31

dropped their spending massively. For that reason, many of these customers are

00:04:36

holding more money in their pockets. That money is not going to the companies

00:04:39

which means the wages have stopped. So the people who are holding more money,

00:04:44

the net benefitors of the new money being put into the system are actually the

00:04:49

customers. Now when I say that, you're probably thinking "wait a minute I'm a

00:04:55

customer where's my £4,500 per man woman and child?" and that would be a good question.

00:05:01

The reason why you might not be holding £4,500 more than you were

00:05:05

before is because not all customers are created equal. Remember the reason that

00:05:10

customers have more money now than they had before the crisis is because they've

00:05:14

cut their spending. But it's not all spending that has cut here. Spending on

00:05:19

essentials such as rent, mortgage, food and bills still has to be paid. So if

00:05:24

most of your spending is on those essentials, you're spending won't have

00:05:27

fallen by much. The spending that has fallen is on non essentials and luxuries.

00:05:32

So see here, the customers who are saving the most money are the ones who have

00:05:36

very high spending on non essentials and luxuries. Well, you're probably starting

00:05:41

to see where I'm going with this. Who spends a lot of money on luxuries?

00:05:46

The customers who are accumulating money during this crisis are the rich.

00:05:51

Now I wrote an article predicting this back in March, explaining how rich people, because

00:05:55

they would cut their spending would accumulate savings and money during this

00:05:58

crisis. Since then, data has come out from a lot of institutions, including the IPPR

00:06:03

in the UK, demonstrating clearly that rich people have been accumulating money

00:06:08

during this crisis, because their spending has reduced so much. It's

00:06:12

interesting to compare here the situation of a furloughed worker with a

00:06:15

richer person in the economy. Furloughed workers have lost their income, which

00:06:19

comes from services jobs, but they've kept most of their spending, which is

00:06:23

largely on essentials like rent and bills. Richer workers, who tend to work in

00:06:27

office jobs and can work from home, have kept their incomes, whereas their

00:06:31

spending, which is largely on luxuries, has collapsed. It's important to understand

00:06:35

the significance it has on the economy when the rich people stop spending.

00:06:38

Now in normal times, rich people have very

00:06:41

high spending, much higher than ordinary workers. Because that spending goes to

00:06:45

companies, which employ workers, it contributes to wages being paid. This is

00:06:49

really important because ordinary workers have to pay bills, rent, food. When

00:06:55

they pay that money, a lot of that money ends up going to the owners of the

00:06:58

houses and owners of the corporations who are themselves the rich. So as you

00:07:02

can see in this diagram, in a normal situation, the spending of the rich goes

00:07:06

to the workers, and when the workers pay the rent, bills and food, it goes back to

00:07:10

the rich. The money flows around in a circle. So what happens when the rich

00:07:14

suddenly stop spending? Well that money was driving the wages for ordinary

00:07:18

workers. Suddenly, the workers' wages have disappeared. But they still have to pay

00:07:23

the rent, they still have to pay the mortgage, they still have to pay the

00:07:26

bills. How are they gonna do that with no income? It's a massive problem and if

00:07:30

nothing happens some of these guys they could become homeless

00:07:33

they could even not even get food on the table. So it's no surprise that in this

00:07:37

emergency situation the government and the Bank of England stepped in with the

00:07:41

furlough scheme. This provides a substitute income to ordinary workers who have lost

00:07:45

their wages. It's important to realise that at this point, from the perspective

00:07:49

of the worker things actually look quite similar to how they did pre-crisis. They've got an

00:07:54

income, they've got their expenditure. The income's a little bit less, they have to

00:07:57

save a little bit, but from their perspective the situation is largely

00:08:02

unchanged. But look at what is happening outside in the system. Previously the

00:08:06

money was going out in a circle. What's happening now? The money gets printed by

00:08:11

the Bank of England, it goes to the worker, the worker pays their bills,

00:08:15

it goes to the rich, and then... it just stays there! Because the rich are not

00:08:20

spending their money anymore. That means money piles up with the rich and

00:08:24

accumulates, and what happens with the government? They accumulate debt. Okay so

00:08:30

we've learned that during the Covid crisis, most people's financial situation

00:08:34

appears relatively unchanged. However, behind the scenes the government is

00:08:39

accumulating big piles of debt, and the rich are accumulating big piles of money.

00:08:43

The next question is... why does that matter? Well the easier part of that

00:08:50

question is to talk about why big government debt could affect you.

00:08:54

Those of you who are old enough to remember 2008 will remember at that time

00:08:57

too, government debt increased, and the government came in and used that to

00:09:01

enforce austerity. Now that impacted a lot of people, it had a lot of effects

00:09:06

in many, many different ways. That could happen again if government debt increases

00:09:11

again. Now I'm not a politician, I'm not political forecaster I'm an

00:09:16

economic forecaster. I can't tell you if austerity will happen again. But what I

00:09:20

want to talk about is those big piles of money stacking up in rich people's bank

00:09:24

accounts. How's that gonna affect you? So what does it mean if the rich get richer?

00:09:31

I mean if they just stack the money in their bank account it's probably not a

00:09:36

problem right? Personally, I worked in the finance industry for a long time, I

00:09:41

managed money for the rich, I've got involved in understanding how they

00:09:44

invest their money. Through that I made some money myself

00:09:47

I got involved in investing myself. I know a little bit about what the rich do

00:09:51

when money starts piling up in their bank account. Number one, they buy houses

00:09:56

but it's not just houses they buy, they buy stocks, they buy shares, they buy

00:10:00

bonds, they buy gold. To be honest, they buy everything. Now let's look at what

00:10:06

happened last time the government used money printing to solve a financial

00:10:10

crisis. We can look back to the 2008 crisis. In many ways, that was similar.

00:10:15

That time, too, the Bank of England printed a huge amount of money to try and deal with an

00:10:19

economic crisis. What happened then? Well within six years stock prices in London

00:10:24

had doubled. Within three years the gold price was up 150%, and within 10 years of

00:10:29

the crisis, London house prices had doubled. What does that mean? Well in the

00:10:35

20 years since 2000, through that period of crisis and rising house prices, the

00:10:42

percentage of young people who've been able to afford a home in this country

00:10:44

has fallen from 65% to 27%. What will it mean if house prices double again? It'll

00:10:52

mean that, realistically, people who are from a family that doesn't have a home

00:10:56

now, will probably never own housing. It means that those people will be locked out of

00:11:02

the housing market forever. It means that young people will find it more difficult to

00:11:07

get the security of a home to raise a family. And at the same

00:11:12

time as that's happening, stock prices are gonna go up, gold price is gonna go

00:11:15

up, the rich are gonna get richer than ever before. But it's not just stocks and

00:11:21

shares and housing that these guys are going to buy. They'll be in the shops too

00:11:24

and they'll have a lot more money to push those prices up. It's very likely that

00:11:29

over the next few years we're going to see the prices of a lot of things

00:11:32

increase. At the same time, what's going to happen to wages? Well we've already

00:11:37

seen the unemployment rate double in this country, and that's in spite of a

00:11:41

furlough scheme encouraging firms to keep jobs on. There's currently nine

00:11:45

million workers on that furlough scheme, and when that starts to be wrapped up a lot

00:11:49

of those workers will probably be pushed into unemployment. With unemployment

00:11:53

going up and up and up, it's very likely that just as house prices and prices in

00:11:58

the shops are rising, wages will stay low. Okay so what can we do? We know that

00:12:04

under the current situation the rich are going to get richer, while wages full

00:12:08

house prices rise and shop prices increase. It's going to make housing

00:12:12

unaffordable and it's going to drop the living conditions for regular people.

00:12:15

Can it be fixed? Well, personally I think that it can. If you go back and look at this

00:12:20

slide explaining the problem, we can see what's happening. Money, currently, is

00:12:23

flowing from the government to the rich, leaving the government with big piles of

00:12:28

debt and the rich with big piles of money. We can actually fix this with one

00:12:32

simple arrow in this diagram. If we start money moving, back round the system, away

00:12:37

from the rich, no more cash piles for the rich, no more debt for the government.

00:12:42

In my opinion we need to find a ways the tax of truly rich in our society, by

00:12:46

taxing wealth rather than just income. This will draw money from the wealthiest

00:12:51

people in our society, the people who get their income from owning assets, rather

00:12:55

than working. Ultimately we need to find a way to make the richest in our society

00:13:00

contribute to fixing this crisis rather than simply profiting from it. Otherwise

00:13:05

financial security is going to move out of the reach of our kids. Thank you for

00:13:10

watching. This is a message which is really important to me. If you think it's

00:13:14

important too, share it with your friends share t with your family. If you want to

00:13:18

know more about me you can see my Twitter and my website in the description

00:13:22

come back here for more videos. Okay, thanks again.