← Back to all transcripts

Housing - Why is it so expensive?

August 01, 2021
00:00:01

My name is Gary Stevenson former trader and people's economist this is gary's economics

00:00:06

today we're going to talk about housing

00:00:13

okay so there's 5 areas we're going to cover about housing - number 1 why is it so expensive

00:00:20

no.2 is it gonna get more expensive no.3 how that affects people

00:00:27

no.4 who's winning and who's losing and no.5 what can we do about it

00:00:35

so we're gonna go right in with number one why is it so expensive? now a lot of people

00:00:41

tend to believe that the reason housing is expensive is because of the housing

00:00:46

planning policy in the local area - a lot of people here in London believe that

00:00:50

but the expensiveness of housing is not a London specific problem

00:00:54

so i used to work in the city with people from all over the world

00:00:59

people in Sydney, Australia think housing is expensive because of the local planning problems

00:01:03

people in New York think that, people in Los Angeles think that

00:01:07

people in Tokyo think that, people in Shanghai think that, people in Hong Kong think that

00:01:11

people in Vancouver and Toronto think that basically in all of the big cities all over the world

00:01:16

you know i could keep going Mumbai, Rio De Janeiro everybody thinks that housing is expensive

00:01:20

because of the local planning policy in that 1 city once you take a global perspective and you

00:01:25

realize that this is happening in most if not all of the major cities in the whole world we have to

00:01:31

accept that the expensiveness of housing is not because specifically of London planning policy

00:01:38

so it's a global issue housing globally is expensive not in all cities obviously there

00:01:43

are parts of the UK where housing has remained cheaper but in all the major cities it's happening

00:01:49

so why is this happening why is housing in major cities all over the world becoming super expensive

00:01:54

well to understand that we need to take one more broader step back and realize it's not

00:01:59

even just housing that has become expensive in that same period of time the last 13 years since

00:02:05

the financial crisis most stocks and shares have risen 400-500% much more even than housing

00:02:12

land prices have increased significantly gold price has increased significantly even bond prices

00:02:17

have gone up basically the price of all assets has increased significantly over that period

00:02:24

so when we understand this we can see that it's not actually even specific to housing

00:02:30

so first it's not specific to london and secondly it's not even specific to housing

00:02:34

what has happened is there's been a massive increase in basically all long-term assets

00:02:41

all over the world so why has that happened well if you watch my other video 'what is wealth'

00:02:46

and if you haven't watched it yet i recommend you watch it - we talk about wealth inequality

00:02:53

increasing significantly and what that does to the price of housing the price of stocks and shares

00:02:58

so basically in the last 15, 20, 30 years the period where housing has become much less affordable

00:03:04

we've also seen a massive increase in the share of wealth owned by the very wealthiest people

00:03:09

the top 0.1% the extremely wealthy families now when wealthy families own assets

00:03:15

that means they get a lot of income from the rest of us because all of those assets give an income

00:03:21

and they tend not to spend that income they tend to save that income so as inequality has increased

00:03:25

more and more income has gone from ordinary people to the super rich and they use that

00:03:29

to buy assets that means we can expect to see as wealth inequality increases a fall in the prices

00:03:37

of goods and services and wages because that's what ordinary people spend their money on

00:03:42

& an increase in the price of assets, stocks, shares, land, gold, other precious metals and importantly housing

00:03:52

and that's basically what we've seen as we've seen inequality, wealth inequality that is, increase

00:03:57

significantly we've seen a massive increase in basically the price of broadly all assets

00:04:02

and that's because purchasing power has moved away from ordinary people who

00:04:06

buy goods and services which drives your wages and towards very wealthy people who buy assets

00:04:12

so if that's what's happening inequality is pushing the price of assets up including

00:04:16

housing and goods and services down why haven't goods and services prices fallen why

00:04:24

haven't wages fallen well that's because there's basically two effects going on at the same time

00:04:29

firstly increasing inequality pushes house prices up and wages down but secondly at the

00:04:34

same time since 2008 central banks all over the world have been massively increasing the amount

00:04:39

of money in the economy they've been printing huge amounts of money pushing into the economy

00:04:44

i talk about this a lot more in my videos on 'Covid-19 and money printing' and when central banks print

00:04:50

a lot of money that pushes the price of everything up so we've got 2 things happening at the same time

00:04:55

on the one hand increased inequality pushes house prices up & wages down on the other hand

00:05:02

more money in the system pushes the price of everything up the net net balance is

00:05:08

wages & shop prices stay about the same and house prices and asset prices go through the roof

00:05:12

so the expensiveness of housing is caused by two things happening at the same time significantly

00:05:17

increased wealth inequality and it's important to understand we're not talking about income

00:05:21

inequality this is not about doctors and lawyers this is about wealth going to the super wealthy

00:05:26

families who own huge amounts of assets and at the same time money printing wealth inequality pushes

00:05:31

house prices up, money printing pushes house prices up, house price goes to the roof but at the same time

00:05:36

wealth inequality pushes wages down so the net effect is house prices go up and your

00:05:40

wages stay the same that is why housing is expensive

00:05:43

number two is housing going to get more expensive?

00:05:46

short answer yes - if you watched my videos on Covid you'll see that it has caused a massive

00:05:51

increase in both wealth inequality and money printing that means we can expect to see housing

00:05:56

get significantly more unaffordable and expensive in years ahead

00:06:00

now number three and number four

00:06:03

how does this affect you and who wins and who loses now economists who often come from rich

00:06:08

families that own property like to think that when house prices go up it benefits the economy

00:06:13

people see the house price rise they feel richer they spend more money homeowners also often

00:06:18

like it when they see the value of their houses go up but who loses out here? well the obvious group is

00:06:23

young people from poor and ordinary families right people from rich families they can often

00:06:29

get significant deposits from their parents but people from ordinary families when the house price

00:06:33

goes up and the wage doesn't it can become very difficult or even impossible to buy a property

00:06:38

that means much longer in rented accommodation which is expensive and if they are able to save

00:06:44

up a deposit then they'll have to take a much bigger mortgage which will mean higher repayment

00:06:49

over a longer period of time so younger people are losing the money every month because of this more

00:06:54

expensive house prices either through having to pay rent or having to pay a bigger mortgage

00:06:59

when this happens they can easily respond by thinking i've got to save up a lot more money

00:07:04

i'll have to spend less and that can actually damage the economy

00:07:09

but let's talk about older people from ordinary families who may already own their own property

00:07:15

right these guys often think that they're winning when house prices go up but the only way that you

00:07:20

can get the money from the house price going up is by selling the property now if you sell your

00:07:26

property and spend the money then that means you can't give your kids money to buy their property

00:07:31

now we've already said that when house prices go up that means kids from rich families can get

00:07:35

deposits from their parents but kids from ordinary families can't and that means often they can't

00:07:40

get property at all so if you're a parent from an ordinary family you own your own property you see

00:07:46

the house prices go up and you think you're richer the only way you can actually get that money is by

00:07:51

selling the property and that's going to mean that your kids and your grandkids will never be able

00:07:55

to own property at all so for ordinary families they find themselves in a bind where they feel

00:08:00

richer because the house price is going up but the only way for them to actually make that money is

00:08:04

to sell the property which will mean their kids and their grandkids will never own property again

00:08:10

i can see this happening with the families around me kids from richer families their parents are

00:08:15

able to remortgage their properties or access the stocks and shares they have to give big deposits

00:08:20

to their kids and help them get onto the property ladder but kids from poorer families their parents

00:08:24

need that money to help them get through retirement and it means that kids from richer

00:08:29

families win and kids from poorer families end up completely losing access to property forever so

00:08:36

the winners here are rich families who have a lot of property big portfolios of stocks

00:08:41

and shares which are also going up and the losers are ordinary families who are losing their houses

00:08:46

so as ordinary families lose their properties and kids from richer families able to buy them

00:08:51

inequality gets even worse driving house prices up further still this creates a worsening spiral

00:08:58

which makes housing increasingly unaffordable to ordinary people that brings us to the last thing

00:09:03

(No.5) how do we fix it?

00:09:05

okay so what do we do? this problem is caused by inequality so the only way to

00:09:10

fix it is by fixing inequality not by taxing ordinary working people but by taxing the super rich

00:09:16

the government doesn't want you to know this because it's run by people with

00:09:20

wealth of £100 million or even sometimes over £1 billion - these people get huge amounts of

00:09:26

cash flows from us ordinary people to them which they use to buy houses that our kids need and

00:09:32

often they do it whilst paying almost no tax this can't continue we have to end it

00:09:38

push for wealth taxes on super rich people, educate yourselves, watch my videos about Covid & Inequality

00:09:44

watch my videos about what is wealth tell your friends, tell your mum, let's make it happen