← Back to all transcripts

Capitalism Reflects Wealth Distribution in the Economy

May 07, 2023
Wealth Inequality Enough is Enough Tax Wealth Not Work Economics of Covid Rich get Richer Poor get Poorer Economics Explained Tax the Rich End Austerity Billionaire Poverty
00:00:00

well I've been thinking for a while  we need to do one about Capitalism  

00:00:03

because we get asked it a lot right "Capitalism is the problem!"  

00:00:07

it's a bit frustrating for me because it's like  it's so non-specific it's like okay well... yes...

00:00:20

problem with capitalism is different people have  very very different ideas of what the word means  

00:00:25

all right um so it can become difficult to do  any sort of analysis of it because different  

00:00:30

people have different ideas um so I'm going  to say provide the basic working definition  

00:00:36

which some people disagree with but it's what I'm  going to use for this purpose of this discussion  

00:00:41

which is capitalism is a system which has  a relatively small government relatively  

00:00:45

low taxation people are expected to take  care of themselves with their own money  

00:00:51

um yeah and then there's freedom to trade  freedom to own things basically it's a  

00:00:58

people call it 'laissez-faire' system there's  not a lot of government control people do  

00:01:02

whatever they want everybody's free to do  what they want it's important to realise once  

00:01:06

you use that definition none of us live in fully  capitalist countries right the UK has NHS that's  

00:01:11

not capitalist institution the UK has public fund  education that's not capitalist you know so we're  

00:01:17

not about living a perfect capitalist system but  let's talk about capitalism which is the idea of  

00:01:21

freedom to own freedom to trade and also  means freedom to generate inequality right  

00:01:29

now there's something which is good about  capitalism which is that capitalism rewards  

00:01:36

people for doing things that other people want so  if you can if you're making a lot of paintings and  

00:01:43

nobody wants them you're going to make no money  but if you're making a lot of paintings that  

00:01:46

people want then you are going to make money right  why'd the footballers make money in the capitalist  

00:01:50

system because tons of people are willing to pay  to watch them so in a sense capitalism is good  

00:01:56

because it incentivises all these people to play football and people want to watch football

00:02:00

these kind of things right so there's like a philosophical idea behind it which is that  

00:02:06

because everybody is free then you will get  rewarded if you do things other people want which  

00:02:12

means in theory people should start doing things  that other people want which is good because we're  

00:02:16

all helping each other out this is the this is  this is the idea behind it right the problem is

00:02:24

if you actually look at the outcomes of capitalism  lots of people have things which they really  

00:02:29

really want or even need that they don't get so we  have a capitalist system and a lot of people can't  

00:02:35

afford to feed their kids all right so you know  they want to feed their kids and there's enough  

00:02:39

food for them to feed their kids, well you know, why  are they not feeding their kids? we have people who  

00:02:43

work at jobs for homeless you know of course  they want homes but they're not getting homes  

00:02:47

and what this reveals is there's one key flaw of  capitalism which is that capitalism doesn't reward  

00:02:53

you for doing what people want, capitalism rewards  you for doing what people with money want right  

00:03:00

you know there are people in poor countries  in the world that are blind and they just need  

00:03:05

relatively inexpensive surgery to fix their  blindness but they don't get that because  

00:03:09

they've got no ****ing money right, capitalism  doesn't give back to those people you know  

00:03:15

you know you know you're a dentist right you  will see there are dentists that spend all  

00:03:19

of their days doing expensive cosmetic  surgeries for wealthy people and at the  

00:03:24

same time there's people who are in agony  of toothache who can't get a dentist right  

00:03:28

and this is because capitalism doesn't reward you  for doing what people want capitalism rewards you  

00:03:35

for doing what people with money want, if you  can do something that rich people want you can  

00:03:40

make a ton of money right but if you can do you  know if you want to provide dental work for like  

00:03:45

poor people in Africa or in Southeast Asia you're  not going to make no money for that because they  

00:03:49

don't have any money right so once you understand  this then what you see is inequality is absolute  

00:03:57

cancer at the philosophical root of capitalism  because if you have a broader equal society then  

00:04:04

it works right because everybody has money so you should do the thing which lots of people want  

00:04:10

but once you have inequality then it doesn't  matter if 99% of people hate something  

00:04:15

you know if you do a job which sucks wealth  out of the poorest 99% and gives it to the 1%  

00:04:21

you can get paid a ****ing ton of money for that, I know because I did it right! capitalism works for the  

00:04:27

people with money there's this phrase right which is "Freedom for the Heron is Death to the Fishes" 

00:04:32

right if you allow everybody freedom and what the most powerful wants is to, what the most  

00:04:38

powerful people want is to take everything from  everyone else then that's that's freedom right  

00:04:42

that is freedom the problem is capitalism  is great when you have a broad distribution  

00:04:50

and even then it's not necessarily great  right if you look at for example the US  

00:04:54

the US is a very capitalistic economy for a long  period of time right and it has a lot of resources  

00:04:58

so it did provide a great standard of living for a lot of people, not if you're black right  

00:05:04

if there's groups of people that don't have any  wealth, then they will not get well served under  

00:05:09

capitalism and then if you make it really unequal  then that can be 90-95% of people that don't get  

00:05:16

served under capitalism you see what I'm saying  so capitalism works philosophically & theoretically  

00:05:22

when everybody has money, when everybody has  wealth, but we're moving towards the situation  

00:05:27

that is why capitalism works relatively well  in Western Europe and did for the last 70 years  

00:05:31

because lots of people have wealth so everybody...  capitalism is democracy but one pound = one vote  

00:05:37

you see what I'm saying so if everybody has an  equal amount of money then everybody will get a  

00:05:42

decent amount of what they want, but once you move towards extreme inequality then capitalism   

00:05:46

will only serve the rich of course it will why would  capitalism give you anything if you have nothing  

00:05:51

to offer for it? it's about freedom of trade  and if these people have all the power then  

00:05:56

they will get all the stuff and what you start  to see is capitalism is so dynamic it creates  

00:06:01

the physical infrastructure to perfectly mirror  the distribution of wealth because capitalism  

00:06:06

serves the people with wealth so if you have  a broad wealth holding society then capitalism  

00:06:12

will produce lots of middle-class houses and middle class cars and middle class appliances  

00:06:16

and middle class services and middle class theatres  and middle class cinemas right but if you have ex.. 

00:06:22

an economy where all of the world is with the very  rich then capitalism will give you extreme luxury  

00:06:27

and poverty it will give you a extremely wealthy town centre surrounded by impoverished slums which  

00:06:34

is what the case in Mumbai, which is the case in  Johannesburg, the case in Sao Paulo, is the case  

00:06:38

in every unequal country in the world and is  becoming the case here in London as well right  

00:06:44

so the way I see capitalism (sorry I've  hit my mic) the way I see my capitalism  

00:06:49

the way I see capitalism is it produces  good outcomes when everybody has wealth  

00:06:57

when you are in a very unequal Society  It generally produces terrible outcomes  

00:07:02

so you need to protect the wealth distribution  you need to protect the wealth distribution and  

00:07:08

the problem you have is that capitalism tends  to destroy the wealth distribution so I'm not  

00:07:13

saying I'm anti-capitalist that to me I think you  bring me a car and the car's not working I'm not  

00:07:19

going to tell you I'm anti-cars you know I I have  studied this system it is broken in a specific way  

00:07:24

that I think is fixable I know there will be people out there saying 'ah no capitalism is broken' 

00:07:29

you need to destroy everything to bring it in okay that's fine show me the blueprint for the  

00:07:32

new society I'll have a look at the moment I do want to prevent this disaster from happening and  

00:07:37

it's the problem that they have right now is what  is most frustrating is the problem is so fixable  

00:07:41

the problem is so fixable, it is a problem with the  wealth distribution we fix the world distribution  

00:07:49

we fix the problem we can see a massive increase  in living standards a massive increase in living  

00:07:53

standards you don't fix the wealth distribution  you won't fix the living standard so for me

00:08:01

you need to protect the distribution  the system and we're not doing it  

00:08:05

um and you know like if people want to have a  discussion about what is the ideal system you  

00:08:11

know is capitalism the best system could we have  other systems we can have that discussion but at  

00:08:16

the moment the system that we have is falling  off of a cliff and I would prefer to prevent  

00:08:21

that disaster from happening first because if we don't do anything about what's happening now  

00:08:28

it's going to be real real bad, it's going to be real real bad and um I there's this phrase you know 

00:08:35

'don't let the perfect be the enemy of the good' you know we're in a situation but I would say  

00:08:38

don't let the perfect be the enemy of preventing the collapse of society at this point cos that's what  

00:08:43

we're looking at, that's what we're looking at, so listen let's let's fix the problem that we have  

00:08:49

and then we can talk about is there a better way  to do this is there a better way to do this but  

00:08:52

listen I'm not, I'm not a philosopher you know um I just don't want things to be really really ****

00:08:58

and they're gonna be and we can stop them If we fix the distribution

00:09:08

housing could be so much more affordable, wages  could be so much higher and we could have so  

00:09:13

many more options in how we live our lives some of them put a lot of money into paying 

00:09:17

economists and think thanks to tell you that inequality  is important for the economy that is not true